Howard Thurman · Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples · Fellowship Church, San Francisco, California · Preached October 19, 1952
0:09 We've come almost to the end of our series on faith for living. We have one more for next Sunday and we will conclude the series. Today we are thinking together about democracy as one of the... one of the elements, one of the crucial elements in our faith for living. It is very difficult to talk about this. because almost everything that anyone has to say about the meaning of the democratic dogma sounds like an old, frayed story that we've heard many times.
1:25 But nevertheless, even at the risk that is involved there, I do want to think as creatively as possible with you about it because... The point at which democracy lives or dies... is in the human heart, in the human spirit.
2:01 And however accurate and technically consistent may be the political and the economic structure. or blueprints. may be.
2:33 The implementation of the dogma has much to do with the faith of the people. So I'd like to ask you a question this morning.
2:56 Do you believe in democracy? Do you? I remember hearing Reinhold Niebuhr say one day that he believed very much in democracy when he was functioning in his capacity as a professor in the Union Theological Seminary. But when he was functioning in his capacity as a member of the Board of Trustees of the Eden Theological Seminary, he didn't believe very much in democracy. It depends, I suppose. While you are posing that question in your own mind and against the context of your own private living, explore with me what seems to me to be the subsoil, the ground, and the technical sense upon which the whole democratic dream and hope and dogma rests.
3:54 There are two or three fundamental things which I'd call your attention. And the first is that... that either this is a world, a world, a universe, in which... it is a reasonable thing to have purposes. to have gold. dreams that sort of thing or it is not For if in its very structure Life is finished, is complete, is rounded out, whole.
5:05 or in its very structure life is fluid, dynamic, unfinished incomplete
5:29 Now, if it be true that life is finished, complete, rounded out, then all hope about life and its meaning, either private or public, personal or impersonal,
5:53 which is not a definition of life as it is, is futile hope. For it means, you see, that you can't basically do anything about anything if the thing is fixed. Finish. The only thing you can do is wait. I remember once I went over to British Columbia, to Toronto I guess it was, and from there I went way up 150 miles, 200 miles north to a Canadian student conference. While I was there, two young people were taken ill with polio, and we didn't know it. It kept it very quiet, and so I came down to Toronto on Saturday morning and stayed with a friend until Sunday evening.
7:01 And when I finished my work Sunday evening, I got a train and came back to New York and then on to Washington, where I was living. I'd been in the house about a couple of hours on that particular Monday morning when the telephone rang and the telephone, the person on the other telephone said, this is the United States Department of Health. We have been informed by the Department of Health of Ontario that you have had a primary exposure to polio and that you escaped across the border without being quarantined. Well, I didn't know anything about it. So I said, well, now, under such a circumstance, what does one do? He said, one simply waits. And if you get a something, nose irritation, some sort of head and spine, then you call me day or night.
8:08 Of course, for 24 hours I had the worst head. It's almost a terrifying thing to wait when you know that the thing is going to fall. You know what it is. that's even more terrifying if you don't know.
8:45 So that if, you see, life is finished, then fundamentally the human spirit is stripped of all options. except those that bear directly on that which is. You see? But if it isn't, if the nature of life is of such that life is dynamic, is fluid, is essentially creative. Then, purposes, aspirations, utopias, if you please, may take irrelevancy, may take on relevancy to life and where it's going. And to have dreams and hopes and aspirations, purposes, goals, not only then becomes a possibility for the human spirit, but it becomes mandatory.
10:06 Now, democracy, one of the basic presuppositions upon which it rests, a metaphysical presupposition, is that this is the kind of world that is grounded in creativity, that it is essentially dynamic. That's... their potentials are an important part of any present consideration or predicament. See what that means? It means that life then and time are both on the side of that which is unfulfilled, that which is on the make.
11:15 that which has not arrived. So when the human spirit... broods over the stubborn and sometimes unyielding and recalcitrant aspects... of chaotic human relations It does it with confidence that it is possible for the raw materials of experience and of living to be fashioned and refashioned, shaped and reshaped in accordance with the law of with great aspiring and great hoping and great dreaming.
12:27 Now that is one of the basic pillars upon which the whole democratic experience of the race rests. Now, you see what that means when you begin to apply it. For democracy, you see, that you can arrive at a sense of direction. a sense of goal, a collective sense of direction, a collective sense of goal. And if you can establish in your relatedness to people, if you can get a sense of a group, experienced by individuals in the group.
13:33 then there will become increasingly available to the group and therefore to the individuals who participate in the group experience. A wisdom and an insight that no one of them working alone. could gather unto himself or herself. So, we hear a great deal about the democratic process, and sometimes it's quite a nuisance, because it takes time. And often, you don't have the time. That is, you don't think you have the time. I remember once when When our younger daughter was just five years old, we were living in Rochester, New York for the winter, and I wanted to get a train at 45 minutes from that time, and I had to finish a chapter from a book that I'd borrowed from the library.
14:50 And she came rushing into the room wanting me to do something. I don't remember what it was, but something was very urgent. And I said, but I can't do it. You see, I'm reading here. I'm studying. I've got to do this before the taxi comes to take me to the railway station. And she said, but I want you to do this now, Danny. And I said, but don't you see I can't do it? You're wasting my time. And she kept insisting. So I just, I closed the book for a minute and then I put a new rumble in my voice and just surrounded her with a general climate of violence. I didn't, I didn't do anything but that and she bristled, being a mother's daughter, and stood her ground and finally rushed out of the room.
15:58 Your back just like that. Now I thought about it on the train. I could have worked the democratic process. It was all there. All the raw materials were there. I could have first established a sense of community in another dimension with a little imagination. I could have put myself in her place and looked out through her eyes as I remain myself, you see, in my place. And then I could have taken her by the hand and put her in my place so she could look out through my eyes and keep breaking it down all the time until she could see it.
16:57 And then maybe we would have arrived at a sympathetic understanding of what was involved and a collective decision privately arrived at would have been unanimous. But that would have taken about two hours. And I had only about 35, 40 minutes.
17:22 Now, that is why, that is why confidence in the integrity of democracy is so hard to maintain. Now let's jump way into another dimension to see exactly what I'm talking about, because and bear in mind that the fundamental point that I'm making is that this democracy is grounded in this dynamic, this creative thing that is inherent in life and that and therefore it is possible to shape ends, to set up goals, to move towards them, and to bring to bear that kind of commitment and conviction the complete resources of one's personality, and to hold one's plan or goal at dead center over the raw materials in a chaotic society, until at last those raw materials begin to take on the objective manifestation of the inner hope.
18:36 During times of war, what happens in our own democratic process? We tend to suspend the democratic process in times of social crisis. It's very interesting that we do that. During the Depression in 1932 when Mr. Roosevelt became President of the United States, and the banks closed and a lot of other things happened, not because he became President, but they closed. And Congress did what? Day after day, we were living in Washington at the time, we'd just moved to Washington. Day after day, Congress merely just put a rubber stamp on paper after paper that came from the White House.
19:40 Why? Because everybody was scared to death. And they couldn't risk the democratic process. because the time interval that was involved was one that tended to undermine confidence in the integrity of the proposal and the experience itself. So in time of war, we did it. We had a man, Jimmy Burns, down in South Carolina, who was the czar of something during czar of defense or czar of something. One man, and they even dubbed him a czar And nobody thought anything about it because everybody was scared.
20:25 So you couldn't trust that the time is against you when the emergency is on you. unless in your mind there is fixed in a very definitive and clear-cut and invasive fashion. that time is always on the side of that which has not matured. Now that's the first thing.
21:04 Now there's a second thing, and I won't do the third thing. that Democracy is rooted in, not only in this metaphysical thing about the nature of life and its creative carry, so that in developing processes and so forth, there's always the predisposition the side that deep within the individuals or deep within the group there is the wisdom. which is needful in order that the group might move in the direction that is creative and sound. Now, the second thing is what it has to say about the attitude towards people, that human beings are ends in themselves, that, I don't quite know how to put this, that you remember last Sunday, I mentioned the fact that in the religious insight that man is a child of God, that spelled out in practical terms man sees himself as being one of a person.
22:42 of infinite value. Now I'd like to pick that idea up and put it here. for all of the insistence in democracy about equality has nothing really to do with equality of gifts, with equality of talents, with equality of abilities. with equality even of superficial position.
23:31 But what fundamentally the genius of democracy insists upon in its notion about equality is this, that the only authentic equality that there is is the equality of infinite ways. Thank you. I am not better than you or you are not better than I am. Those categories mean nothing.
24:11 But this says that I know that I myself, as far as my little me is concerned, there is nothing in the heavens above or the earth beneath. That can. equal what I think my little life is worth to me.
24:53 I may not be worth anything to you. So the equality is an equality of quality rather than an equality of quantity. Therefore, it is the insistence when democracy begins to express itself in behavior patterns, it is insistence that human beings should never be used as means to other ends, that human beings should never be tails to other kites. but that a human being is an end in himself and that's why if there's a conflict between human values and property values democracy insists that human values should take precedent precedence over property values and on and on we could go.
25:54 therefore as long as human beings regard themselves as being of infinite worth. However long it may take them to project that sense of infinite value in terms of social forms and political and economic behavior patterns, but as long as men feel that they are of infinite weight. The democratic ideal and dream are a source of inspiration and hope in times when the social process seems to be out of joint. Now, I'd like to say just one little word about America in this regard. I think often about America.
27:00 Strange country. But it seems to me, and I hope this will not sound to you as if I'm talking on the 4th of July and some sort of chauvinistic rallying point. But this is a part of the faith. I'd like to take time to say it to you. Radha Soami. I thank God. through the instrumentality of life and the life process, is always at work on the revelation and the demonstration of creative purpose.
28:06 That's the basic proposition. It is no accident, for instance, that in the period between the 8th century B.C. and the 2nd century A.D., every single basic, philosophic, and ethical insight known to modern man... emerged just in that little period of a thousand years. Everyone, all the great religions, all the great ethical insights, the philosophers. Just in that period, between the 8th century BC and about the 2nd century AD. Which seems to suggest, you see, that life was trying to get a backlog of social insight, of ethical and religious insight, as a part of the heritage of the race before.
29:14 the secrets of nature became available to the minds of men. And we are alarmed now because we wonder whether or not there is enough character in modern man. to structure the tremendous power that is his as a result of the way in which he has discovered the secrets of nature. What would be our alarm and amazement if that discovery antedated this thousand years? So I think life is alive with a sense of moral incentive and purpose. And that's an illustration of it. Now I think that the same thing applies in America.
30:09 Is it an accident? that between these two oceans... I want you to hear what I want to say about this, even though it's after 12 o'clock. between these two oceans. People. from the ends of the earth. Think of it. From the ends of the earth came In a climate that is ideal for the most part, with natural resources, that in some ways seemed to be boundless and limitless.
31:14 And not only that, but the one place in which from the beginning of the country itself Certain political and ethical ideals were a part of the immediate climate. Isolated. force to experiment effectively with neighborliness or not survive. exposed in the intensity of the isolation to a far-reaching and radical political and ethical theory expressed in the democratic dogma and in the Christian ethic.
32:16 As if life said, somewhere on the planet, I must set up a laboratory against the time when time and space would be reduced to zero. Now if time and space are annihilated, and men have not had a chance to develop a sense of naveliness, then they will quickly, in self-defense, destroy each other. But if somewhere on the planet a laboratory can be set up so that men can experiment creatively and effectively in relatedness, in enableness and so forth.
33:22 than it may be possible. that when time and space are annihilated through the secrets of nature being revealed to the mind of man, that the sense of the family, of the human race, will step into the vacuum created thereby and make the world a safe and a decent place for all the people who haven't had a chance or time or opportunity. to experiment with neighborliness.
34:12 I'll be speaking a language that the rest of us didn't understand. One generation, two generations, three, four, five, removed, that's all. I have somebody who calls attention to the meaning of this. so as to keep alive The focal point. of the purpose of the impersonal forces of life through which God is operating. Well, suppose we had atomic, knew about atomic energy. and there had been nowhere on this planet.
35:09 I want you to hear this and think about it. Whether you agree or disagree offhand, it doesn't matter. But suppose that all of the development of atomic energy... was available to man with the result in the annihilation of time and space, reducing of those to zero.
35:33 Suppose all that had taken place on this planet, and nowhere on the planet there existed or had existed for any length of time the things we take for granted in American life. But what would be the result? And therefore I say to you that I don't think that we are in a position of leadership in the world because we are rich. or because we have industrial know-how, I think all those are incidental, accidental, incidental rather, I'll put it that way.
36:28 But I think that we, that we are in the faithful position. of being the only nation on this planet that has had 300 years of primary exposure to something like the democratic ethic and the Judeo-Christian ethic in an environment so isolated that it could be relatively under control and with the richest cross-section of human beings collected anywhere else in the world.
37:19 And who are we that such a privilege could be given to us in order that we might construct and throw our weight around to dominate the earth. No, that isn't the meaning of it. the meaning of it is that we have been given this we have been sent to school by life by God to develop confidence and faith, technique, methodologies. for implementing
Machine translated from the source