A Faith to Live By, Part 7: Democracy (continued)

Howard Thurman · Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples · Fellowship Church, San Francisco, California · Preached October 26, 1952

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

1:26 The role of the king among the people was to some extent an absolute role. Now there was a little man in the kingdom who had a vineyard. and he had spent much time cultivating that vineyard. It was his vineyard,

2:00 inherited from his father and his father's father and his father's father. Ahab wanted the vintage. So he said, I want it. and if it's necessary I'll give you something for it I don't want to steal it but of course the king can't steal he takes but I'll we'll work out something But Ahab said, I don't want to give it up. it's mine it's my father's father's father's and this is an extinction of myself and all of the meaning of my little life is wrapped up here in some magical and mysterious manner.

3:00 my sense of security is here so you can have it Now get the feeling of this, because I want you to hold it in mind as we work this out. The king, the absolute monarch, sees a little patch of land owned by a little man. And the king says, I want it, and the little man says, you can't have it. Can you think of the implications of that? And they have. was powerless to take it, apparently. and then his wife, Jezebel.

4:12 helped him work out the scheme. And the rest of the story is full of disaster. And the meaning of the story is that there was something inviolate in the life of the little man that even a king who had absolute power dare not trespass upon.

4:50 Now there it is. I put over against that. The significance of the ordinary man, all that I'll say, and in Greek philosophy, and I mention it not for any purposes that may seem to be full of exhibitionism, but the have influenced us so much and are so wrapped up in almost everything we think that if you took the Greeks out of our civilization, I mean their influence and their ideas, we'd be pretty barren. Of course, we don't have to recognize it as such, but there it is. So let's look at it for a moment. You remember Antigone last year when we gave Antigone in the Arts Festival and the role that the Greek chorus played. Now the central figures in the play Antigone were kings and and queens, and bloodied stock, as it were.

6:13 You know, whose blood was royal, whatever kind of blood that is. But they were royal, and then they had the center of the stage. All the issues turned on that. They were involved in the meaningful experiences. And what role did the little man play? What role did the ordinary man, man in the street as we would say today, just a little man, what role did he play? He was the chorus. standing over here not involved in the traffic you see not involved in the meaningful operations he didn't count he could only echo something you see Mr. and Mrs. Anonymous but the people who really were it the king, the queen the people who rate it.

7:24 Now we see that same thing reflected in Plato. who has influences profoundly. The really significant people are the people within certain classes. The business people and the philosophers and the warriors. But the rank and file of the people existed only as they guaranteed the life of this privileged few. now Aristotle went even further than that Aristotle cut out everybody but but the philosopher if you if you're a warrior that's alright but you didn't really conquer much unless you were a philosopher now if you were a philosopher then the greatest service that the ordinary man can render life is to keep you going you know work for you take care of you and sustain you and support you because you were the spearhead of the forward movement of the human race and that's a wonderful feeling I imagine In Egypt?

9:06 The ordinary man was the dust of the earth. The king is the grave. When I was an India. In Hyderabad, the Nizam of Hyderabad... put one of his 25 or 30 automobiles at our disposal, and he assigned us a Muslim chauffeur who would carry us everywhere we went for four days. Every time we came out he was there with the car waiting to do whatever we wanted. For three and a half days I tried to get some conversation out of this Muslim.

10:08 He spoke English, but he didn't speak any English to me. He was silent, sphinx-like. The last day. when we were being driven to the railway station, I found out the quality of his voice, for I heard it for the first time. And what did he say as we were riding along? Apropos of nothing, Only God is interested in a poor man. Now he is reflecting this whole thing.

11:08 why is this radical difference in the story with which I began and the other recital of the the events, that here is an ordinary man who defies the king?

11:33 Now, let's examine it because the basis of the democratic genius is wrapped up in this explanation I think. There was an assumption that the individual man had a covenant, an agreement with God. Which covenant, which agreement... was binding on him and on God. This covenant, stated in the language, that kind of language, this covenant was the basis, the root, the core of the individual's sense of worth.

12:46 he had a covenant with God he rated having a covenant with God the covenant which he had with God was binding upon God as God was related to him This covenant, which was the basis of his freedom and the meaning of his life, took precedence over any other relationship,

13:36 and if standing within the context of the meaning of the covenant which he had with God, he was required to do anything by any person that did violence to this covenant. then he was under moral obligation to defy that power, that force, whoever it was. To me that is very amazing, very amazing, very interesting and very terrifying. Now do you get the picture that the covenant with God... which relates in a moral sense the individual to God and God to the individual.

14:47 So even Ahab, the king, has no right. to put any kind of pressure upon me, the little man. said Naboth if that pressure does violence to this covenant.

15:20 Now there it is. Now, it is for this reason, as it would seem to me, that when you say that logically, the next step, that all of the people who are related to you in terms of culture, now what's this very carefully. The people, if you say, quite logically, is the next step. That the people who are related to you by culture, by social pattern, by religion, by national origin, and so forth, that they, therefore, in a way that is unique as far as you're concerned, They are bound by the same sort of covenant.

16:24 They are related to the creator of life in the same way as you are. Therefore, they become... uniquely related to you And the things that you are under obligation to do... with them, for them, on their behalf. are identical with the things that the covenant dictates to you.

16:59 Now on that basis, what starts out as the genius of democracy in the life of the individual becomes quite consistently in its social implications the basis for a group pride and a group arrogance. Let me say that again. I feel a vacuum. Let's try it again because I hope I can get it. Now here we are, the individual has the covenant with God, that's the theory and the experience as is seen here in the story there.

18:02 And it is this covenant with God that is unique in the sense that it is mine. Now you have one too, but I'm not talking about yours. mine. And it binds God morally to me and binds me morally to him. On the basis of that covenant, the whole pattern of my behavior is dictated and determined. Now, when I look at you and I find that you speak the same language as I do, you're part of my same culture, we're all here together, then very quickly I I assume that the covenant that binds me in a unique manner binds you.

18:46 Because we are one in all these other ways, you see. Language, culture, religion, and so forth. But when I lift up my eyes and see someone way over there, who speaks another language, whose culture is different, whose whole orientation is radically different from mine, then it is quite reasonable, is it not, for me to assume that the limitations of the covenant and the ethical implication thereof are limitations that are bounded by... common culture common language common religion so that which starts out in me as the basis for my own self-esteem and self-estimate... and moves to you as the basis of your self-esteem and self-estimate because you and I are of the same language, the same culture, the same background, may become something that is fundamentally divisive, that makes for separateness, as I look out upon people whose language, culture, and so forth may be different from mine.

20:12 so that the problem then in the movement of the democratic experience in the history of mankind has been a problem which has centered around the urgency and the necessity constantly to redefine the boundaries of the group

20:41 Because if I do not define the boundaries of the group increasingly so... so as to include more and more diversity, more and more differences, more and more radically alien backgrounds and orientations, then the genius of democracy itself, rooted in this spiritual relationship, becomes a device that makes for group arrogance and group superiority. Do you see what I'm talking about? Therefore, therefore...

21:27 Therefore, the peril of the democratic experience in its very essence is rooted in the fact that the the human spirit can never come to a place of rest with reference to the boundary. Now you can see the kind of conflict that precipitates in modern life, because there are all sorts of other interests that emerge. Now let me illustrate it if I can. I realize it's 12 o'clock, but that's all right. You'll have three weeks to rest. Let us look at the history of our own country in this regard, and you will see what I mean.

22:29 We started out. In America, in a revolution, you will remember that, that we were born in a revolution, a revolution against the king, against a certain way of life, and so forth and so on and on along it goes. So that there is something in the genius, in the very throb of American life that relates itself almost instinctively, a sort of collective instinctive feeling, to all of the people anywhere in the world who are wrestling with the same thing, who who are part of the same respiration that caused us to come to life, whether it's in Asia or Africa or Canada or wherever it is.

23:50 to the pulse beat of people who are in the throes of the agonies that gave birth. birth to us. That's what I'm trying to say. and the meaning then of the democratic notion, experience, insight. as far as one aspect of our common life is concerned, is to push the boundaries.

24:41 And we've been responsive in that way. But along right beside that, there has grown up another kind of responsibility. we stand where where the king stood We have position and power in the world that we didn't ask for. We have it for all these reasons, some of which I mentioned last Sunday. We are the central or among the central figures on the world stage.

25:32 And that relationship carries with it its own etiquette and morality. Because it is a position of power. And power has its own etiquette, its own morality, its own scale of values. And it may not be at at all related to this other thing that that gave birth to us and it constantly feeds us and gives us a sense of human dignity and worth and all those things. So on the one hand, we feel One. with all the people in Indochina this morning who are in the throes of the kind of agony... that gave birth to us.

26:29 On the other hand, we feel as a people under very great obligation to sustain the French government in Indochina as a part of the etiquette of our position over here in the center of the stage as one of the world powers.

26:58 So when we talk about democracy, when we deal with democracy within our common life. our problem is acute because at one time we deal with it as if it were not rooted in this thing about which I've been talking for the last 25 minutes, but rather that it's rooted in the central political power of political arrangements. And so we feel that the only way by which you can hold the established order, the only way by which you can guarantee the perpetuation of the established order... and therefore live up to the integrity of the power position which is ours.

27:59 is to strangle, strangle all of the prerogatives of the Naboth, the little man. So. on the one hand We believe in freedom of speech. That's over here. That's the Naboth dimension of the American democracy. Freedom of speech. Over here, in the power end of it, if it has bearing on disturbance of the delicate balance of power in the world, then you've got to strangle it over here.

29:00 Now, between those two things... you and I move and live and function so if I ask you this morning in which one of these dimensions of our relatedness to the democratic dogma you believe, what would you say to me? Would it depend upon what your position in society is? Would it depend upon the degree of your social or economic insecurity or security?

29:52 Or would you dare let your sense of the meaning of democracy as the basis of your faith in today and tomorrow? be rooted in the primacy of the individual's relationship to God. and what that relationship in and of itself may lead a man to say and to do. Now... There is hope as long as men keep alive in themselves the kind of faith about which I've been talking. Now you may not use the old-fashioned language that you have a covenant with God.

30:52 I don't care what the language is that you use. every man once more than anything else in the world. to be sure. that as a human being, he has an importance and a value that is not related to the ups and downs of the standards, the whims, the fears, the anxieties of the society in which he's living. Every man, more than anything else in the world, wants to know for himself.

31:55 that his significance, his value, is in some wonderfully mysterious, perhaps, but wonderfully exciting manner. more important than anything he can do, a value that operates at a level in him that cannot be touched by whether he's a good man or a bad man, whether he's evil or righteous, whether he's holy or unholy. Every man must know at last that cannot be destroyed by any of these things. Therefore I sing the hymn, the hymn of the conquered. The hymn of the low and the humble, whose youth bore no flowers on their branches.

33:07 whose hopes burned in ashes away. from whose hands slipped the prize they had grasped, that who stood at the dying of day with the wreck of their lives all about them, unheeded, unpityed, alone, with death swooping down o'er their failure. and all but their faith overthrown. and if that's active in you No tyranny can destroy it. and no madness in the mind of man.

Machine translated from the source

Howard Thurman Digital Archive, Pitts Theology Library, Emory University · CC BY-NC 4.0