A Holy Encounter

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published January 18, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Luke 5:3-11 0:49
3Jesus got into the boat belonging to Simon and asked him to put out a little from shore. And sitting down, He taught the people from the boat. 4When Jesus had finished speaking, He said to Simon, “Put out into deep water and let down your nets for a catch.” 5“Master,” Simon replied, “we have worked hard all night without catching anything. But because You say so, I will let down the nets.” 6When they had done so, they caught such a large number of fish that their nets began to tear. 7So they signaled to their partners in the other boat to come and help them, and they came and filled both boats so full that they began to sink. 8When Simon Peter saw this, he fell at Jesus’ knees. “Go away from me, Lord,” he said, “for I am a sinful man.” 9For he and his companions were astonished at the catch of fish they had taken, 10and so were his partners James and John, the sons of Zebedee. “Do not be afraid,” Jesus said to Simon. “From now on you will catch men.” 11And when they had brought their boats ashore, they left everything and followed Him.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:18 Thanks, Mirabel, very much for reading that passage for us. Well, we're continuing in our sermon series in Luke's Gospel, which we've called Encountering Jesus. And as we've been going through these first couple of sermons in this series, we've been saying that the call of these early chapters of Luke's Gospel is to kind of ditch our plastic Jesus and instead to engage with the real Jesus. That is not work with a caricatured view of who we tend to think Jesus is, but instead let the real Jesus on the pages of Luke's Gospel kind of stand up and reveal to us what he's really like. And one of the things we've seen so far is that Jesus is not one who fits easy categorization. Just as the nets kind of bulged to breaking point this morning, So we'll see that Jesus stretches our categories and that if we try to diminish him and shrink him down to size, then it's one of the clearest signs that we're not actually letting Jesus be Jesus.

3:24 No, the first century, the true and authentic Jesus, the one who's alive still today by his risen power, is one who defies simplistic categorization, who frequently surprises us and contradicts us, and one who is not quite as domesticated as we might easily like him, one who is far greater than we can imagine. And in the passage this morning, we particularly see as he encounters Peter, or rather as Peter encounters him, that the way that we normally think we should relate to Jesus, and the way that we think in general that religion or spirituality goes is not the way that Jesus relates to us. So we're going to see that in two distinctive ways in this passage. First of all, we're going to see that knowing Jesus is not about sincere obedience. Knowing Jesus is not about sincere obedience. And secondly, instead, knowing Jesus is about him shaking your world. So let's see where we're going with it. First of all, knowing Jesus is not about sincere obedience. Now, we start a new kind of small section in Luke's gospel this morning in the wider section of his early ministry in Galilee. And Luke's quite helpful because he signposts shifts in the text. So you can see that it's coming up. And he does this by these little bookmarks that he puts in. We had one at the end of our passage last week. Luke chapter 4 verse 44 is one of them. And he, that is Jesus, kept on preaching in the synagogues of Judea.

4:48 And then if you were to flick over to Luke chapter 7 verse 1, we get a similar bookmark. When Jesus had finished saying all this to the people who were listening, he entered Capernaum. So you get these kind of bookmarks that give you an idea that Luke is changing the key focus of his narrative. And what happens in between in chapters five and six is we get an emphasis on words like law and lawful and sin and being sinful. And in chapter six, we get Jesus' key teaching on what it means to understand the values of the kingdom. So this is really about how Jesus relates to what we normally think of being moral, observing the law, the Jews would think of keeping the Torah, And how we are to understand terms like what it means to be sinful. and sin and how Jesus relates to our moral failures as well. And the first thing that we see is that relating to Jesus is not about sincere obedience. Now pick up with me on the passage in chapter 5 verse 1.

5:45 So here's the scene. Peter and his friends have been out fishing overnight, Which is the time to go fishing in case you're not a fisherman? because that's when the fish rise to the surface because they're not worried about the sun exposing them. And so that's the best time. And so it's mostly a nocturnal existence for fishermen like Peter. And he's been laboring hard all night. And as we'll find out later on, they've caught virtually nothing. So they're packing up by the shore side and Jesus is there and he's teaching the crowds, as was his want. Clearly the crowd seems to swell because at a certain point, Jesus realizes he can no longer be heard just by standing there on the beach side and speaking to the crowd. So he jumps into Peter's boat and it pushes it out from shore. And usually using the natural acoustics of the shoreline, he can now address the crowd more easily as the water kind of carries his voice. And at the end of it, or sorry, right, during it, Peter is listening to what Jesus is saying. And so he's hearing Jesus' teaching. And at the end of it, Peter is finishing packing up his nets.

6:46 And verse four, when Jesus had finished speaking, he said to Simon, that is Peter, put out into deep water and let down the nets for a catch. Now pause for a moment. Put yourself in Peter's shoes. He's had a hard night's work. He's packed everything up. He's washed the nets. He's folded the nets away. Everything is packed up and he's exhausted and he's ready to go home to bed. And Jesus out of the blue tells him to go back out to unpack everything and to go fishing again. Now, what would you expect from Peter at this point? Do you respect Jesus? You're a carpenter. I'm a fisherman. You don't understand how these things work. I'm going home to bed. There's going to be no fish in the sun, right? That would be a normal response. But fair play to Peter. Look at how he responds. Master, verse five, we've worked hard all night and haven't caught anything. But because you say so, I will let down the nets.

7:40 I think this is a remarkable response. Notice how deferential he is to Jesus. He calls him master, a term of respect for an established moral teacher. He doesn't get rude with him or tell him to kind of get lost. You don't know what you're talking about. He doesn't particularly moan. He must be biting down on a lot of confusion and frustration, but he does what we would expect is the best he can do. He sincerely obeys Jesus, even though he doesn't want to. Respect, obedience, and the point is, isn't this what you think religion is all about? You know, sometimes in the religious spiritual life, a God or a religious leader is going to ask you to do something you don't want to do. And in those moments, this is what it's about, right? Obedience, duty, do the right thing. You get out what you put in. Do it respectfully, bite down on things that you disagree with. Just follow the rules and eventually you'll get the benefit.

8:35 That's how most of us think of religion in general and following Jesus in particular. And yet notice, when Peter does this, nothing changes. How would you describe his emotional state in these early verses? Dry, dutiful, begrudging obedience. And yet isn't this what most of us think spirituality and following Jesus is all about? And the whole point of this passage is Peter's got... Jesus and the spiritual life completely wrong. Why? What has Peter got wrong? Well, the point is there's not about rules, it's about relationship. Think of it this way. Imagine that you saw me relating to my children and all you saw in the way that they relate to me was dry, begrudging obedience, but no relationship. By the way, some of you who've struggled to get your children out of the house this morning, you're thinking that doesn't sound too bad right now. But you know, if you were to watch on an ongoing basis, if there's no relationship there, if the child doesn't kind of run to the parent and speak to the parent and hug the parent and there's no intimacy and affection and emotions actually sometimes being up and down.

9:40 They might not be easy, but they show that the child is vulnerable and open with you. If you just see a child kind of standing to attention and nodding and saying, yes, I'll do what you say. Yes, sir, no, sir, three bags, four, sir. You'll have to tell me afterwards if you don't understand that. That's an English phrase. Then you'd be worried, right? Because as a parent, you want intimacy. You want relationship. What do you think God wants from his creatures? Do you think he just wants you to say yes and no and dry, dutiful obedience? Is that the peak of the spiritual life? Is that what Jesus came to earth to establish? More rules, more things for you to do, and you better be respectful and call him master when you do it. For many of you, this characterizes your spiritual walk. The idea of joy in the New Testament is ubiquitous, and yet for so many Christians, it's an alien concept.

10:37 Intimacy with God, how do I be intimate with someone who I've never seen? Affection and relationship with God, no, just tell me what I've got to do, Peter, let's move on. Not so with Jesus. He won't have it with Peter, and he doesn't want it for you. It's about relationship first, not rules. God did not give his one and only begotten son that you might follow rules. He gave him that you might have a relationship with him. I wonder if you've even opened your heart up to that possibility. Not only that, but when we seek to relate to God on the basis of sincere obedience primarily, it makes us proud or despairing. Proud or despairing. Blaise Pascal was one of history's great thinkers, and he wrote his meditations or reflections or pensées as they are in French, and in the seventh section of that, he talks about ethics and morality and legalism, the problem of legalism. And one of the things he unpacks in that is that if we try to relate to God on the basis of rule keeping and sincere obedience, then it will do one of two things with the pathology of the human heart. It will either elevate us and make us proud and dismissive of other people, or will crush us and make us deeply low and despairing and down on ourselves and unable to contribute properly to community. He says this, he says, if people try to relate to God this way, they could not escape either pride or despair. The two sources, he says, of all vices. For if people know the excellence of humanity, they become ignorant of his corruption. So they easily avoid despair, but fall into pride. And if they recognize the weakness of our nature, the fact that we don't keep God's rules well. They become ignorant of his dignity, and so they easily avoid pride, but they fall into despair. He then opens up and says, who then can save humanity from these twin vices? You see what he's saying? He's saying, look, if you think it's about keeping the rules and sincere obedience, then one of two things is going to happen. You either think you're doing it, and if you're doing it, then you think, well, why don't I? I'm doing it. And you start to feel

12:45 very self-assured and very self-confident, and you start to notice that you're doing pretty well. And then you see other people who aren't doing. And you look down your nose at them. And you become puffed up with pride. And you think that God owes you because you've kept his rules. And so your prayers start to become entitled. And when you don't get what you want from God or from other people, you shake your fist and you die a hundred deaths, which you inflict on other people. On the other hand some of you try to do sincere obedience and you're aware that you cannot keep God's standards. Or you have a very strong sense of truth and justice, and you're aware that you do not hit the ideals. And so you feel down on yourself and low, and you shrink into your own skin. And you therefore don't feel like you've got anything to contribute. Woe is me, but the irony is, is that a person who is so down on themselves sucks the oxygen out of community, because everything is about them and their lowly view of themselves. Neither of those is a well-formed human being. Is this what you think Jesus has come to bring about? Moral deformation of pride or despair. Gerardus Voss was one of the great New Testament scholars in the first part of the 20th century, taught at Princeton Seminary, and he said a very striking statement where he said, the essence of legalism is to divorce the law of God from the person of God. In other words, when we try to relate to God on the base of his rules, but not relationship first, we're separating the rules and the law of God, which do matter, but they're not the primary way we relate to God, from the person of God. And it's him that matters. This is the mistake that Peter's making.

14:26 And ever since, it's the mistake that many, many believers who claim to follow Christ are still making today. Knowing Jesus is not about sincere obedience. So what is it about then? Well, it's what happens in verses six and following. Knowing Jesus is about him shaking your world. I wonder, has he shaken your world? So Peter and his co-workers go out and they do what Jesus asks. They go through all this rigmarole and then look at verse six. When they had done so, they caught such a large number of fish that their nets began to break. So they signal to their partners in the other boats to come and help them. And they came out in their boats and filled both boats so full that the boats began to sink. When Simon Peter saw this, he fell on his knees and said, go away from me, Lord. I am a sinful man. And what a strange response, isn't it? Not, that's incredible. How did you know? Not, could you give me future fishing advice? Then I'm going to be really wealthy. Not fantastic. I don't need to fish for a week or a month.

15:31 none of those reactions. Something else is going on for Peter. His attention is not drawn to the size of the fish. His attention is drawn to the enormity of the person standing in front of him, Jesus Christ. What's going on here? Throughout Scripture, when God comes into contact with people, something profound happens. We're frequently told that the very earth shakes. It's as if God is so mighty, so awesome, so holy that the very creation can't withstand the full weight of his majesty and glory. And so when God touches down on earth with his people, everything shakes. And people shake too.

16:17 It's what theologians sometimes call a theophany, an appearing of God. It happens in Exodus chapter 19 when God has redeemed his people from Egypt. and he covenants himself to them at Mount Sinai. and we're told this in the text. On the morning of the third day, there was thunder and lightning with a thick cloud over the mountain and a very loud trumpet blast. Everyone in the camp trembled. Mount Sinai was covered with smoke because the Lord descended on it in fire. The smoke billowed up from it like smoke from a furnace. and the whole mountain trembled violently. When God comes in power, in glory, in holiness, the very mountain shakes and the people tremble too. In Isaiah chapter 6, as Isaiah is commissioned as being one of the great prophets, we're told this,

in the year the king Uzziah died, Isaiah saw the Lord high and exalted, seated on a throne, and the train of his robe filled the temple. Above him were seraphim, each with six wings. With two wings they covered their faces, with two they covered their feet, and with two they flew. And they were calling to one another, holy, holy, holy is the Lord God Almighty. The whole earth is full of his glory. At the sound of their voices, the doorposts and thresholds of the temple shook and was filled with smoke. Woe to me, Isaiah cried. I am ruined, for I am a man of unclean lips, and I live amongst a people of unclean lips, and my eyes have seen the King, the Lord Almighty.

17:45 The temple shakes. Isaiah is a shaken man, never the same again. In Haggai chapter 2, This is what the Lord Almighty says. In a little while again, I will once more shake the heavens and the earth, the sea and the dry land. I will shake all nations and what is desired by all nations will come and I will fill this house with glory, says the Lord Almighty. Haggai looks ahead to a day when the Lord will come again in the person of his son and once more he will shake the earth.

18:17 Knowing God, relating to God is not about sincere obedience. It's about having your world shaken. Has he shaken your world? Well, what do I mean by that? Look, notice how Peter changes how he refers to Jesus. He's moved from master to what does he say to him? Get away from me, Lord, verse eight. I'm a sinful man. Lord is a term that in the first century, people would use to refer to God. His view of Jesus suddenly changed, no longer referring to him as a religious, moral authority, but now seeing him as he truly is, God himself in human form. And when you see God as he truly is in your life, for the first moment, you start to see yourself as you truly are. Peter says, get away from me, Lord, I am a sinful man.

19:07 You know, T.S. Eliot wrote in one of his poems, Burnt Norton, humankind cannot bear very much reality. Humankind cannot bear very much reality. Oh, how true that is. You know, we long as a culture today for authenticity. It's one of the great values we seek in others and in ourselves and in our leaders. But authenticity is tough because we can't bear too much reality. Just a little authenticity, but not too much. Not so much that it starts to sting or hurt or really pull back the curtain on the true me, the real me. So many of us, when we come to any gathering like this, we enter in and we put on our best clothes or at least our smarter clothes. and we put on our makeup, maybe some of us, and we come and we smile and behind the smile, there's a thousand realities we don't want anyone to ask about because it would be too painful. The realities of our weak, the shame we carry with us, the guilt we feel for the gap between the real and the ideal, for we are a generation with high ideals, make no mistakes, but we are acutely aware of our fallen realities.

20:14 And so the gap between that is so huge that the inauthenticity in our lives is like a gaping chasm, and we ache with the dissonance of it. Sometimes the reality only comes to us late at night when we can't sleep, and the world seems quiet for a moment. And in those moments, we replay over the failures and the way we've let not only ourselves down, but other people down. No, we know how we should live, and we long to better people. We have a strong sense of the ideal, the better me, the true me, the authentic me, the me that I long to be. But every day we enter into the new week and the new day and we try again and we fail pretty early. We give in to our temper, to our vanity, to our obsession with self, to our inner demons. And so this yawning chasm between the ideal and the real goes on in our lives, never to be reconciled. We might try and therapize it away or get some counseling to help us a little bit. That might bridge the gap a bit, but it's never enough. We tell ourselves that the guilt feelings are just that. They're just feelings, but we never deal with the real objective guilt. We tell ourselves that the shame we feel is other people's problems, that they're not looking at me right, but we know that there's actually real objective shame as well.

21:30 Notice what Jesus does here with Peter. When Peter says to him, get away from me, Lord, Lord, I'm a sinful man. He does neither of the two things we normally do. He neither condemns him nor does he condone his sin. He neither condemns him. He neither says to him, yes, you are sinful and you're shameful and I can have no part with you. You're not up to my standard. Leave me. Depart from me. He doesn't do that. No cancel culture here. No shaming until you've learned your lesson. Nor does he condone it. Nor does he sweep it away with some counselling ease. Oh, you're not that bad. It's just a broken world. We all make mistakes. No, he affirms there is real objective guilt and every man, woman carries it. And therefore, there's a consequence of that, that he does not deserve to be in the presence of Jesus Christ. And yet Jesus looks on him with such compassion that he restores him. Verse 10, don't be afraid. From now on, you will fish for people. So they pulled their boats up on shore, left everything and followed him. In other words, he shakes up his categories. He says it's not about being good enough for me and you can never be bad enough that I won't have any part with you. If you would just come and confess your sin to me. that is, be authentic, perhaps for the first time in your life, that there is a gap between the real and the ideal, then I will restore you and redeem you and draw you into a relationship with me.

22:54 George Whitefield was one of the greatest preachers of church history, one of the great evangelists of history. It's no exaggeration to say that his ministry in both the United Kingdom and in the United States in the 18th century left such indelible marks on both cultures that neither have been the same again. He led thousands, if not tens of thousands of people to Christ, both here on the East Coast particularly, and also back in England. When he started out life, he was at college at University of Oxford, and at that time, pretty much everyone in the prevailing culture would see themselves as a Christian. And so when George Whitefield went up to Oxford, he had a strong sense that he wanted to be a good person, so much so that he joined an unlikely club, but one which was popular at the time, called the Holy Club. And they were committed to trying to do good deeds. And so Whitefield plowed himself into every good deed he could with the utmost zeal, and yet his soul had no peace. He would go and visit the local prison, which was pretty rough in those days, and there he would read the Bible to the prisoners, thinking that was a good deed to do. But he felt no joy, no happiness, no peace, no relief. Try as he might throughout the whole of his first year of college. Towards the end of his first year, one day he was walking across Magdalene Bridge and a lady that he recognized as being the wives of one of the inmates of the prison was coming the other day, and she was soaking wet. And he asked her what had happened. She had tried to die by suicide by casting herself off the bridge, but someone had dived in afterwards and rescued her. And there she was, you know, realizing what a sinful wretch, as she put it, she was. And she suddenly saw Mr. Whitfield and recognizing him, she confessed all that she'd done to him and asked him how she could be saved.

24:40 Whitfield, recognizing her, said, join me tonight with your husband in the prison. But he didn't know how to be saved. He thought it was all by good works. He got to the prison later on that evening and there he opened up John's gospel and he started to read John chapter 3 to them both. He was reading to them about their encounter, about Nicodemus' encounter with Jesus, where Jesus explains to Nicodemus about the new birth that everybody needs to have if they're to follow Christ. On hearing the gospel, we're told in this biography, they both were overcome with joy and exclaimed, I believe, I believe, I shall not perish because I believe in him now, I'm born again, I'm saved. Whitfield was deeply confused by her response. The next moment, her husband also proclaimed, I see it too. I'm saved. Oh joy, joy, joy. Wycliffe returned to his lodgings. He felt no joy. He was just confused. How is it that they had the one thing he wanted, joy and happiness, and yet it was elusive to him? How did they come to it so quickly when he was trying to do all these good works and could not get it? About a month later, he was sitting in his room and he was thirsty. And so he reached out and took a drink of water, but it didn't quench his thirst.

25:52 And then, as Pollock recounts in his biography, it struck Whitfield that when Christ had cried out, I thirst, his sufferings were nearly at an end. Whitfield threw himself on the bed and called out, I thirst, I thirst, his first ever cry of utter helplessness. All previous prayer had been a conspicuous attempt to merit God's favor. He returned to his desk, and he became aware that he was happy as he had not been happy for all his life. Instinctively, he knew why. He had thrown himself at long last, blindfolded, without reserve, without struggle or claim into God's almighty hands. And someone unseen but real had slaked his thirst, had removed his burden and replaced it with himself. George, this other seemed to say to him, George, you have now what you asked. You ceased to struggle. You simply believed and have been born again. The sheer simplicity, the almost absurdity of being saved by such a prayer made George Whitefield laugh. At that laugh, the floodgates burst. Joy, joy unspeakable, joy that's full of big glory came to him.

27:09 Many of you here hear something like that and you wonder, is that just a historical, anachronistic account or could that be a reality for you? That reality is possible in different ways for anyone here this morning, whether you've been claiming to follow Christ for decades or whether you're just investigating today. And it comes not by sincere obedience, but it comes by Jesus shaking your world as you see who he truly is. And in that moment, seeing his holiness, seeing his perfection, seeing his utter goodness, you suddenly see yourself as you truly are. And when you see that, if you will stop the act, if you will put away the mask, if you will take away the filters, and if you'll be that rarest of thing for one moment, authentic, and say, Lord, I am not the man or woman I should be. And I'm not the man or woman I could be. But by your grace, if you will have me. I am what I am. He does not just want your obedience. He wants everything from you.

28:04 He wants your all. And if you will but give it to him, you will find that his stewardship is utter joy. He will restore you. He will draw you into a relationship, and you will never be the same again. It changed the course of Peter's life, and the only reason we're talking about him now, 2,000 years later, is because of this encounter. The form will change in the ways we do it and accomplishing in our lives. But if we will give ourselves wholly to Jesus Christ and throw ourselves on his mercy by confessing our sin to him, he will restore us and we'll never be the same again. As the words of the hymn put it, who else could rescue me from my failing? Who else could offer his only son? Who else invites me to call him father? Only a holy God. Only my Holy God, is he yours? Let me lead us in a prayer. Heavenly Father, thank you for this passage.

28:57 Certainly wasn't what Peter was expecting. Maybe not what we're expecting either. Thank you that you want far more than just sincere obedience from us. You don't want us to relate to you by rules. You gave your only son, that we might relate to you with intimacy, with love, with affection, with authenticity. Lord, forgive us our sins. Helps to see you as you truly are. help us to see ourselves as we really are. And may we see Jesus Christ dying for us on a cross, bridging that chasm that we might be saved. Give us the joy that Peter experienced, that George Whitford experienced, that you long for all of your sons and daughters to experience. We ask it for Jesus' sake. Amen.

Machine translated from the source