Can You Blame Peter?

Dave Dwyer · Busted Halo · St. Paul the Apostle Church · Published March 5, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

0:00 Well, can you blame Peter, really, for him suggesting that they just stay there? Like, wow, this is cool. We're on the top of a mountain. We've got Jesus, other two OT celebrities. OT, Old Testament, theology talk. Look at that. Who could want anything better than this?

0:23 And Jesus didn't take everybody there. This wasn't the crowd that was gathered for the loaves and fishes. This wasn't even the full 12. This was the VIPs. Peter, James, and John, they were getting like, you know, the suite at the basketball game with the buffet and stuff. Like, these are the good seats, yeah. If you've ever had an experience like that, you might be familiar with Peter's notion. Can we just stay here? Can we watch every basketball game right here? This would be great. And yet, what we learn about this, particularly in the context of the first reading, the OT reading, about Abram, is that this wasn't just a perk for the inner circle. this was encouragement it was a glimpse of the divine a glimpse of the resurrection but for a purpose

1:30 So maybe you've had experiences like this, whether they be VIP tickets or even something that we might call religiously a mountaintop experience. We use that term usually from these that we hear. Moses had a big one, of course, big commandments. He's present at this one as well. In scripture that when we're on a mountain, oftentimes that's where God reveals himself. himself. We use that sometimes to refer to as a powerful spiritual experience, a mountaintop. I know I had one when I had my call to the priesthood in the midst of some mountains in Colorado. Colorado.

2:14 And that is, at first, our human reaction, what Peter said. This is so good. wish I could just stay here forever. Let's build houses for you and Moses and Elijah. And Jesus didn't take him up on that. He let God the Father take over from the big, bright, shiny cloud. All right guys, sounds like a great idea, but listen to what Jesus has to say. And we don't have it explicitly described here, but we know from this and the other parallel accounts in the Gospels that right after this, they didn't spend a lot of time there. They then went down the mountain.

2:59 And we know what the ultimate destination was. Jesus knew. Because right after this, here in Matthew, chapter 17, he begins to predict more specifically how he will suffer and die. He knew that this moment was not to last. Now here at our community at St. Paul the Apostle, this might seem like a little carved out time of the week. With wonderful music that lifts us high as if we're on a mountain. People that we believe support us no matter where we are, where we're coming from, who we are.

3:41 Quite frankly, what we have for this hour on Sundays is a dislike. much of what we experience out there when we go down those steps, down the mountain, into the real world. And maybe there's some temptation on a Sunday night. I know that Martin, our maintenance guy, definitely experiences this. When we're like hanging around a little too long, he's like, okay, come on, let's go. Got to pick up all the bulletins, make sure everything's tidy for Monday. And we're like, yada, yada, yada in the back, right? Because like Peter, we just want to hold on to this. This is, for many of you, you've told us, a mountaintop experience in your week. Now the danger of these, just like with Peter, James, and John, is that they can... tempt us to be isolated from reality. And Jesus knew that. So immediately he said, all right, we've got this little snapshot of the divine.

4:41 Now let's go, guys. Let's go. Let's go down the mountain. Let's get back to reality. And for Jesus, it was, let's start moving towards Jerusalem. And Jesus knew they didn't yet know, but Jesus knew that in Jerusalem is where he would suffer and die. And he knew that it's where they would have their faith tested. He also knew that two out of these three would be the first to the tomb and be among the first to start spreading the news, to start building this new movement that becomes the church. He knew that there was a lot of work to be done.

5:23 So sometimes, like Peter, James, and John, and like for us on Sunday nights, we get these little sort of beautiful glimpses of the kingdom of God. When here we are gathered together, where all of our differences fall away, and we are truly one body in Christ, and we have this for an hour. But then Jesus says, just like he says to them, it's time to go down the steps out into the real world. Even though the temptation might be to just block everything else out. There's a lot of work to be done. Jesus knew that then. He knew that they would have a huge, difficult road ahead of them in terms of... how the political and religious leaders at the time would be against them, how they're proclaiming the gospel and Jesus as Messiah would not be popular, that they would be thrown in jail.

6:27 He knew all that was coming. So he gives them this glimpse. His divine presence. Something that we as Catholics believe we experience every time we come to this altar. That we really have Jesus present among us as intimately, as miraculously, as he was dazzling white in front of Peter, James, and John. We have that.

6:57 And the reason we have that is not because it's a perk, not because we're the VIPs, but so that we can go down those steps, go back into the real world and face a world, a culture that seems every day, we don't have to go back very many days this week to realize how antithetical to God's kingdom so much of what surrounds us is. that we begin to normalize violence, oppression, and judgment of others. There's so much that needs to be done that it feels great to come here, to have this little dazzlingly shiny white experience of our Lord and the kingdom of heaven. And that's great.

7:54 And Jesus knows we need that because if we had to go too many weeks without this, it would be even harder. But I think the challenge for us, for me too, because I would rather stay in this little enclave. Sometimes I do because I actually live there and don't have to go outside. So if it's really snowing, like it was earlier in the week, it's a great temptation.

8:15 But we are spiritually tempted with that as well, even if you don't live in the building. to just kind of block out how our faith needs to be lived out in the world. In a few days, we're having our parish retreat. And the theme is, what is God asking me to do?

8:39 Our Lord asked Peter, James, and John not to make tents and just be on a cool retreat with him. He said, now it's time to go. And I'm charging you guys, once the resurrection happens, then you get to start telling this and get to work. That gradually became clear to them. Sometimes it's not all that clear to us. So I encourage you, if you've got some time, it's not like a retreat where you have to go away for a week. It's just a couple of things here at the church. It's a carved out good part of a Saturday morning. To really kind of open all of our hearts up to that question.

9:19 Certainly part of it is what is God asking me to do here within this community. And we're grateful for all the people that help out around here. But perhaps even more importantly, what is God asking you to do once you go down the mountain, down those front steps, onto Ninth Avenue and back to wherever? What is God asking me to do that isn't all that fun? That isn't like being in the VIP suite, hanging with the celebrities. That it feels a lot more like work, or a lot more like not being popular because... everybody else seems to be going in one direction and it sounds like God is calling me to push back against that, whatever that is. So what is God asking me to do? Even if you can't make that particular time, and if you can rearrange some things, I think it would be pretty good if you did, but if you can't, let's make that a question that we're actively asking this Lent of ourselves and listening, carving out a little more time, a little space to listen a little more. How is God asking me to not just bask in his glory, take in some of that, get strengthened and nourished, but then go down the mountain towards the cross, towards Jerusalem, towards being potentially ostracized, the apostles thrown in jail.

10:43 Not easy, but Lent is probably a time that God is asking each of us to make some kind of sacrifice and not just kind of soak in the great divine light, but to use that for a purpose. Jesus brought them up there, not just to give them a break or a retreat or a vacation, but so that they would be strengthened to do the hard stuff. There's a lot of hard stuff that needs to be done. in this city, at your workplaces, in your families, in our country, around the world. what is God asking me to do this Lent that I can be nourished for, energized by Jesus and his presence here on the St. Paul's mountaintop, but then to go down the steps and get to the hard work of the Christian life.

Machine translated from the source