Dave Pivonka · Franciscan University of Steubenville · Steubenville Conferences · Published February 12, 2025
0:05 Again, as I said at the beginning, I'm not sure, yeah, where you come from, what you're expecting, what you're hoping for, what your desire is, but let's just let the Lord be the Lord. Amen. Just pray honestly for yourself. that your hearts would be open. it really doesn't matter what I say, but what matters most is what God does. Amen? Maybe just to start just on that point, actually, maybe I'm getting older. I'm definitely getting older.
0:52 But there's a part of me that just wants to talk less and just be and be present more. You know, just letting God do what God wants to do. And I think God wants to do great things. Amen? Yesterday, underline that word yesterday, I was in Assisi.
1:16 Yes. Yes. And I had an opportunity to take a pilgrimage, do a pilgrimage with some of the students from Franciscan University. and what we decided to do or what I got conned into doing honestly was we we did a pilgrimage where we walked actually there's a lot of question about how far we actually walked we started in Spoleto which is about midway between Rome and Assisi and we did what's called the Via Francesco it's the way of St. Francis generally you go the opposite direction but we wanted to finish in Assisi so it's three and a half days of walking now everybody had a different mode of trying to figure out how far we were walking. Some people had Fitbit, some people had Garmin, some people used their phones. So I go with the number that was the highest, all right? And each time I tell this story, it gets about five miles further than it actually was. So we walked about 700 miles in four days. But you know, it was really funny because some of the people, some of the reactions was funny. Some of the students says, is Father Dave going to walk in his Birkenstocks? It's like, no, Father Dave is not going to walk in his Birkenstocks. And somebody was like, well, how old is Father Dave? Like, is this a good idea? One of the faculty members say, just make sure he comes home alive, right? So one of the students was wondering on, you know, whether or not I would do all right. And somebody who knew that, some of you may know, I walked the Camino de Santiago. So I walked 500 miles. So this was going to be honestly a short walk. It ended up being about 45. And somebody said, well, that'll be easy for Father Dave. He walked 500 miles.
2:55 And I restored it. That was also 18 years ago, right? You lose a lot in 18 years of being able to walk. It was funny. I was talking with a young couple that I married, and I was telling them that I was going to do this. And I got a text message the day before I left. And I know this was supposed to be sweet, and she thought it was sweet. I'm not sure what I thought about it. She goes, seriously, Father Dave, I hope in 25 years when I'm your age, I have the confidence and or ability to take a 45-mile walk in three days through mountains. I'll actually be praying for you.
3:36 So I know that was really, really sweet, and she was wanting to make me feel better, but it did make me feel a lot better. But it really was. It was just a great blessing to be able to kind of be away from everything and just to be present to the Lord. But obviously it invited me to think and reflect more on Francis and St. Francis. And some of you may know, but we're coming up on Francis's 800th anniversary. So this year we celebrate his 800th anniversary of the stigmata. And in two years we'll be able to celebrate the 800th anniversary of Francis and at the death of Francis. Outside of Christ, there are probably few figures that have impacted the church and the world more than Francis.
4:20 Now, obviously, he's been called the Seraphic Father. One of the images that I love is they call Francis the mirror of Christ. The mirror of Christ, that when you look at Francis, you see Jesus. But I just had the opportunity to be able to, as I was walking and praying and thinking is, what was it about him that was so different or so unique that caused him to be totally profoundly free? A freedom that I desire. Amen? A way of life that I desire. So I found myself as I was walking, remembering a couple of musicals, oddly enough, a couple of musicals and some hymns and musicals. I was raised on musicals. My mother would be listening to all of the musicals while she was cooking. So growing up, we would walk into the kitchen.
5:13 Mother would be listening to Paint Your Wagon. Some of you have no idea what I'm talking about. And I love this, all right? I love this. Oklahoma. Yes, West Side Story, of course. Fiddler on the Roof, a classic, right? A classic. Over the years, I've been able to go with mom and dad and I. We'd go to musicals. We saw West Side Story. we've seen Les Mis at Obelis, a beautiful, beautiful musical, a couple of times. We saw one of the days, this was great, a mom was a big fan of Regis and Kelly. Again, some of you have no idea what I'm talking about, and I love this, all right? So we went to New York City. We got up early in the morning. We went to Regis and Kelly. Then we went to Mass at St. Patrick's. We went to lunch. We saw an afternoon show. The producers went to dinner at the ESPN Zone, and they went to a night show of Lion King. That was our day. That's not a bad day in New York City, right? So over the years, realizing that my mom has kind of lost touch with some of the musicals, recently I've watched a couple of musicals, and one of the ones we watched was Hamilton, right? Now some of you are saying, okay, I've heard of that, right? So there's this one scene, this one kind of recurring theme in Hamilton, and it's Eliza, not Eliza, Angelica and Hamilton, they're the song back and forth, but the gist of the song is, you'll never be satisfied. You know, taking a look at Hamilton, who had this great zeal and desire and hopes and dreams and wanting to build this new nation, it's really a powerful, actually, I enjoyed the musical very much, but I was just kind of found myself, literally as I was walking, knowing that I was going to be speaking tonight, was just kind of haunted with that idea of he would never be satisfied.
6:57 you ever met anybody like that Right? Never be satisfied. It's somewhat haunting, right? The other musical that I showed Mom just when I was home last time was The Greatest Showman. there's a younger population here who know that is. There's an older population who have no idea what that is, right? So we're really cutting through here. One of the really cool songs in that is this woman, she's a singer from England. She comes to the United States, and she sings, and the gist of the song is Never Enough. She kind of has this love interest with this individual, and she says that it'll never be enough without you. Like my knife, you have to be in my life.
7:47 Same question. That sense of never enough, not enough. Can be filled, we can have, but never enough. One of the most beautiful, I think in contrast this to Francis, one of the most beautiful moving lines of St. Francis in my life over the last many years that I prayed over by the hour. It's really, really simple. Francis said, oh God, you are enough for me. Oh God, you are enough for me. Just do me a favor. Close your eyes for a minute. Take a breath. Oh God, you are enough for me.
8:33 Francis had a desire to be respected, to be loved, to be honored, to be influential. Many of you know the story. He becomes a knight and doesn't go very well and ends up in being in prison and he has this dream in prison about who is it better to serve? Is it God or is it man? Obviously, it's God. This dream that he had of being a knight is taken away from him. If we pay attention to the life of Francis, you see that's the case in many situations, that he desires something, and ultimately it's taken away from him. He can't acquire it. And it all builds to this crescendo of Francis being alone, being still, and being quiet, and he just simply says, Oh God, you are enough for me. when I reflect about what made Francis so free. And so, I mean, if you've ever been to Assisi, if you've ever been there and experienced that there's something about that place, I believe actually there, like there's something about this place.
9:36 It's just anointed. And you go there and you can literally feel in your bones that there's a peace and there's a presence. And how is it that over 800 years later, the people can come to Assisi and it's still one of the largest pilgrimage places in the world, and they encounter something, they encounter someone there. And it's because, and I would suggest that Francis was able to say, you are enough for me. But I get it. I mean, that in itself is a pretty crazy statement. That a danger that we have is when we say, oh God, you are enough. We feel like that it's everything. And that almost frightens us. But I love the fact that Francis didn't say you are everything. Amen? I mean, I've met people who have everything and it's not enough. And I've been places where people have had nothing except, except Jesus.
10:36 And it's enough. I want to suggest that unless we can come to the place where we can say, honestly, Jesus, you're enough for me, we're not going to know the true freedom of God. We're not going to know the true victory that there is in Christ until he becomes not just our everything, but he comes enough for us. and the danger, I think, and the frustration and the care and the concern that I have is that oftentimes we place things instead of him. We make these idols in our life. Then we can't imagine a life as Francis couldn't imagine a life that wasn't powerful or influential or wealth and all of that. And as that all got away, he came to understand what it was that God was asking. And it was there that he found freedom. It was there that he found peace, hope, joy, all these things that we associate to Francis.
11:43 So the last couple of days, I've been praying about this sense of idols. So do me a favor again, just take a breath. How is it that we get trapped into the feeling of not being satisfied? it's like a hamster on a wheel that we continue to go and we continue to look for and we continue to search and we continue to long for and we open this door and we open that door and we go on this path and we continue wanting to find this peace and this presence and it's never satisfying. Brothers and sisters, that can be one of the most frustrating things to never be fully satisfied. Francis was satisfied because God was enough for him.
12:34 This desire to have more or to acquire, again, it's a hamster on a wheel. It's a dog chasing his tail. It's opening the door and always finding it empty. what we've done is we've replaced this place where God belongs. We've placed idols there. And the first idol, we're going to actually pray about some of this in just a minute. But I want you to just think about this and pray about this. And if something stirs in your heart, we're going to have an opportunity to pray that the Lord would take these away from us. But the first idol, and it was actually the idol for Francis, is yourself. is that if we're honest, we're filled with ourself. Our desires become more important. Our wants become more important.
13:27 Security. Comfort. I mean, think about what we do just to always be comfortable. And the thought of being uncomfortable, the thought of going without, the thought of suffering or difficulty or struggle. It's just, we do everything we can to try to move away from that. We want a life that's comfortable and it becomes an idol. We begin it, all of our work and our efforts becomes to try to create this world that's comfortable. and it's an illusion.
14:03 We try to create this world for ourselves or for those that you love, that's safe, that's secure. It's a fallacy. how is it that we place ourselves in the center of our life that our preferences become our gods? And we get frustrated that people don't prefer the same thing we prefer or the same wants that we want. Or my desire or my will or my opinion becomes the opinion that everybody, and when anyone has an opinion contrary to ours, we find ourselves offended by that. We live in a world that everything is offensive. how is it that you have placed, that we have placed ourselves in the center of our own lives?
15:01 Well, for Francis, Francis was, he pushed God to the side, and he made it really clear that he just pushed God to the side. It wasn't that God was out of the picture, but he just pushed him to the side. And it was himself that was in the middle of his life. It was himself that he created himself. And the whole world created and was surrounded around him.
15:23 How have you, how have we made ourselves idols? Do we get frustrated when we don't get our way? Any of you who are married that get frustrated that you don't get your way? Anyone? One person, two people raised their hand. These two people are honest. some other idols.
15:51 The reality is I think we put other people and we make them idols. Their opinions or their thoughts about us. And I think this is a danger within marriages. I've had so many experiences over the years where couples, one or the other is experiencing conversion, but they're anxious about sharing that because they're not sure what the other will think? Will they accept it? Will they celebrate it? Will they fight it?
16:23 I think we put other people's opinions about ourself, and we're worried about that. It causes us what the world thinks of us. It causes us anxiety, fear, trepidation. What about my reputation? What are people going to think? I love Sister Ann Shields, who Pete's a good friend with as well. She said one time, the only one that's concerned about a reputation is the evil one. What we need to be concerned about is being faithful. Being faithful to Jesus.
16:58 What else do we put in front of these idols as far as other people? I think we put relationships there. You put spouses there. I think one of the most, again, from the outside looking in, One of the most difficult things of a relationship, of a marriage, is that you don't allow your wife or your husband to be your idol.
17:18 That they're not more important than him. That they don't become more important than Jesus. That their opinion of you doesn't matter more than Jesus' opinion of you. And we place them in the middle. And it's not fair to them. We place expectations on them that they can never satisfy. This desire that says, you need to satisfy me. as we hear in Hamilton, they will never be able to satisfy. Or your children. Or your grandchildren. They need to satisfy this emptiness and this longing and these dreams and these hopes. And it's not fair to them. I remember praying with a woman. She had three kids. And she was just like, she had these plans for each one of them. And what they were going to do, she had planned out what their spouses were going to look like, this whole situation, how this was all going to work.
18:15 I mean, that simply isn't fair to them. This dream that she had, which may or may not have been his dream. who are these people in your life that you put in the center of your life that control you, that don't allow you to be free, that you think are going to ultimately satisfy those deepest longing of your heart?
18:41 Only one can satisfy. I think we have a danger, particularly in our culture, of expecting politicians to fill this emptiness, this void. At least this year we know that's not going to happen. but we see it in religious circles too it's been really fascinating over the last 10 or 12 years to watch the relationship we have with our popes you know there were people 25 years ago who loved Pope Francis and Pope John Paul a number of times people said if the pope says it that settles it I would suffice it to say that those people who were saying that 25 years ago were not saying that today 25 years ago they were called cafeteria Catholics now it's something different we make our popes and believe me the Holy Father just came out with a document today on papal infallibility which I think will be really important to read but we make our popes more than they're supposed to be I love in the scriptures when we see after Jesus' resurrection these people encounter Peter and Paul and they're just kind of going crazy and they want to like make them gods.
19:53 And Peter says, I'm flesh just like you. I'm broken, right? I doubt it. I wandered away. But we have a tendency. We desire naturally an inclination in each one of us is we desire to have a God and we desire to have somebody that we can worship. But unfortunately, we place people there and sometimes we place the Pope. And I love the Pope. I love, you know, it's funny. Sometimes it's, I feel nervous about saying that I love Pope Francis. I don't love everything that he said. I don't love everything he's written, but he's my Pope. He's my Holy Father, right? And he's not God. And if we worship him, if we worship any Pope as if there were God, we will never be satisfied. Give him the credit he deserves, but don't give him more than he deserves. We cannot place people thinking that they're going to. They cannot be our idols.
20:48 And we do that with celebrities or we do that with YouTube. We do in the church all the time with YouTube personalities. I loved when I was teaching. I'm a big fan of EWTN. I'm a fan of Mother Angelica, but I remember when I was teaching here at the university one time, and I said something and somebody said to me, well, Mother Angelica said, I love Mother Angelica, amen? But you can have two people that could have a different opinion on something. But we have a danger, I think, of taking whoever speaks the loudest, whoever has the most views, whoever has the most crazy comments on YouTube, we begin to elevate them. And we listen to their voice more than we listen to his voice. And what we begin to do is we begin to see these competing voices and who's going to be the voice that I listen to, right?
21:36 A couple of years ago, Charlotte Buff, he was an entertainer, he's a movie person. He was converted and became a Catholic. Let's rejoice in that, amen? That's fantastic. Amen. But I must say, I got a little frustrated soon after where people were saying to me, well, yeah, but Shia LaBeouf says. I appreciate that. And I'm glad he's Catholic and I'm glad he's converted. But just because Shia LaBeouf says it doesn't mean that it's true or it doesn't mean that we all have to believe it. Amen?
22:06 There are so many YouTube personalities that want it. And part of their existence is us clicking them and liking them and supporting them. And what I'm finding is that we're beginning to compare. It's like, well, I know that pick the personality. But he says, but Jesus, I mean, there's one voice that we listen to. There's one voice that's going to satisfy. There's one voice that's going to fill this longing. And we need to come to us, just be honest with ourselves. And who are those idols or who are those voices that we listen to more than we listen to Jesus? and I suggest that if you come up with anyone, you need to push them off to the side and place him in the center. Amen?
22:50 A couple more. And this is, I want to be really delicate here. is that I think we have a danger of making spirituality or devotions our idols. We are an incarnational church. The church has taught us that for 2,000 years, which is a great blessing, which means that God uses stuff and things and people to not allow us to encounter him, right? So we have smoke, we have incense, and we have bells and all of these kinds of things. They're wonderful. They're beautiful. But they are not the end. The end is Jesus. All of these things, they're supposed to lead us to Jesus. And I think if we're honest, there are many, many people who is actually, it's the devotion itself, which is their idol.
23:46 They're more concerned about their devotion or they're more concerned about the way this group prays, the way that group doesn't pray, than actually encountering Jesus. to encountering Jesus of the Gospels, the Jesus of power and strength and authority, the Jesus of victory. But unfortunately, and it's the danger, it's why some of the Protestants, when they began to break from the church, they got rid of all images because they feel all images would become idols. Now, that's not what we want. That's not what we do as Catholics. We believe that God can use these things for a reason. And the reason is these things should lead us to Jesus. But I'm afraid that all too often, what we do if we're honest is we stop there. I remember I was giving a talk one time. Can we all agree we love the Blessed Mother? Amen?
24:37 Amen, everybody? We love the Blessed Mother. We're a fan. Yay, Mary. We're a fan, okay? We're fine. We're a fan with that. I gave a talk one time, and I said that Mary wasn't God. And this woman approached me at the end of the talk, and she was livid. And she said, how could you say that? I said, well, what do you mean? She goes, how could you say it's so disrespectful? I said, please, what did I say that was disrespectful? She said, you said that Mary wasn't even a little bit God. Forgive me, Mary, right? if the end of our devotion doesn't ultimately lead us to Jesus, we're doing something wrong. And I think we have to be honest, you guys, is that oftentimes the devotion becomes the focus. The devotion becomes our idol. I do adoration just about every day of my life, right? For the last decades, right?
25:32 The focus of my adoration is not adoration. It's Jesus. I celebrate Mass every day. I've celebrated Mass every day for the last 28 years. The focus is Jesus. And a concern I have is that oftentimes what we do is we let the externals, which are beautiful and good and wonderful, but they become the end. They become the idol. So a danger is this. A danger is this right here. The idol becomes the Franciscan University Conference. and I'm going to go get my fix because I love these conferences. I'm really glad you're here. Amen. We hear that, right? But if you walk away and you just had a good fix and you don't know Jesus more, we have failed. We feel this is just a great high, a great weekend. We have a danger that these become or the new movement.
26:24 You know, I've been around long enough. There's Theophastic and then there's Unbound and now there's Encounter and then there was the Renewal and all wonderful things. But if they, the movement, or the individuals in the movement are the end, we will never be satisfied. It will never be enough. It has got to be Jesus. If the end is incense, or a type of music, or a type of celebrating the liturgy, we will never be satisfied. It will never be enough.
27:00 These idols that we create, and I think if we're honest, oftentimes, not always, oftentimes our devotion becomes the end rather than Jesus. And I'm a person who loves the rosary and prays these in devotions. I'm not very good, to be honest. I'm not very good at novenas, but the other stuff I go for.
27:22 I'm just not good at that. What are these things that have a tendency to become our idols? A particular spirituality, a particular way of praying. Do me a favor, take a breath. What does this look like? in Mark 10, we've got a beautiful story. Rich young man, Jesus is leaving Jericho. This guy's heard about Jesus. He's got to talk to him. Says Jesus is on his way of town. He runs up to Jesus and he kneels down before him and he says, good teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life? This is fantastic. This guy literally wants to be in heaven. I mean, this is what his full soul purpose is. Jesus says, why do you call me good?
28:14 Only God is good. And he goes on and says, you know the commandments. You should not kill. You should not commit adultery. You shall not steal. You should not bear false witness. You shall not defraud. You shall honor your father and your mother. He replied, teacher, I've done all of these things. Who of us can say we've followed all of the commandments, right? He's made, in one sense, this idol of the commandments, right? If I just follow the commandments, I'm going to go to heaven. This idol that he has has become the commandments. I just do this, X, Y, Z. No, no, no. He says, there's only one thing you have to do. Sell everything you have and follow me. This is a tragic story because he walks away from Jesus sad.
28:54 What is that thing that Jesus is asking of you? That thing that he says, I want to go to heaven. I want to inherit the kingdom of God. And Jesus is going to say to you, okay, this is your idol. this is the thing that's going to ultimately keep you out of the kingdom of God. For him, it was possessions. For you, it's your phone, your comfort, luxury, status, sports, hobbies, comfort,
29:27 devotions, those things that don't lead us to Jesus. What is that thing that keeps us? that thing that will never satisfy, the thing that will always cause us to continue to long for and experience more. Jesus is inviting us tonight to be enough. Do me a favor, close your eyes and take your breath. Is Jesus enough for you? Can you say, Jesus, you are enough for me? And I think a fear that we have is that if we say that, there's this kind of weird twisted idea that if we say that God is enough, then everything else, like we're gonna lose everything. Remember the God who is enough is also the God of a hundredfold. Right? He's the God of a hundredfold, and he's the God who's enough. The one who will satisfy.
30:21 that Jesus has got to be in the center of my life. And I think of my own life and my own experiences, those opportunities that I've had to be able to say yes to Jesus once again. I remember when I did walk the Camino. The first night of walking the Camino, I was sitting in this small chapel, and I said this scary prayer. I said, Jesus, I give you permission to take away everything in my life that is not of you. and I'll be honest, that prayer scared the crap out of me and it still scares me a little bit. Jesus, I just want you. And what I desire and I think what the Lord wants to move in our life is he wants to have an intimacy with us. That so oftentimes, I think honestly, Catholics, we suffer with ADD, all right? We're trying to keep our eyes on Jesus and the next shiny thing that comes along, we just go running after that. It's like a squirrel and then we go running, right?
31:17 It's got to be Jesus. and Jesus has to be the center of my heart. And I think what he desires and it scares us so oftentimes is an intimacy with him. And I think honestly, what we often do is Jesus is kind of out there and we go out there looking for Jesus. But the reality, brothers and sisters, is the spirit of God has been poured forth into my heart and that I find Jesus here. If I can't find Jesus in an intimacy, and there's some of you that probably that freaks them out, that idea of intimacy with Jesus. I mean, what does that mean? That word intimacy, that's what I desire. That Jesus is the consumer of my heart. He just consumes my heart. And that he's present. And when everything crazy going on around me, I can be quiet and I can still and I can encounter the one that ultimately satisfies. I remember sitting outside the hospital in the car the day before my father died and just weeping there and finding Jesus satisfying in the midst of the brokenness, in the midst of the fear, Jesus satisfying, about to lose the closest relationship I've ever had in my life, but knowing that Jesus was not for a moment did I ever feel orphaned.
32:31 Not for a moment did I ever feel fatherless because Jesus was in the depths of my heart. And this is what he desires for us is that we're looking for Jesus. You're not going to find Jesus out there if we don't find him in the silence and in the stillness and in the quiet. Jesus has got to be enough. And the fear that we have is that he's going to take away everything, right? And it's a scary prayer, but, and I know this is a heavy lift, but what in your life is more important than him? I mean, I want to be at this place that, Jesus, you are enough. You will satisfy. You are my everything. And I really do want to allow you to take away everything that's not of you. That you stir in my heart a presence, an intimacy, a vulnerability, and honesty.
33:31 And I think when we talk about idols, we just have to be honest. I mean, it's embarrassing in 2024 to say, I've got idols. I mean, that's stuff of the Old Testament age. There was no way we'll experience the victory of Jesus, the power of Jesus, the love of Jesus, until we move aside those things that are not of him or those things that distract us from him and allow him to be the center of my life. Amen? Amen.
34:04 Do me a favor, take a breath. and just repeat after me come Lord Jesus Come, Holy Spirit. I just invite you, at least at this time, just to be honest with the Lord for a moment. Lord, what are those idols that we have in our life? those things which vie for our attention. that we give more attention than you, that we give them more power, more value than they should have.
35:11 That voice that we listen to, that we give more credence than your voice. Jesus, bring down, break down the idols in our life. So just repeat after me, Lord Jesus, come with your Holy Spirit.
35:35 Jesus, I want...
Machine translated from the source