Choosing God's King

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published September 21, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: 1 Samuel 16:1-13 0:25
1Now the LORD said to Samuel, “How long are you going to mourn for Saul, since I have rejected him as king over Israel? Fill your horn with oil and go. I am sending you to Jesse of Bethlehem, for I have selected from his sons a king for Myself.” 2“How can I go?” Samuel asked. “Saul will hear of it and kill me!” The LORD answered, “Take a heifer with you and say, ‘I have come to sacrifice to the LORD.’ 3Then invite Jesse to the sacrifice, and I will show you what you are to do. You are to anoint for Me the one I indicate.” 4So Samuel did what the LORD had said and went to Bethlehem. When the elders of the town met him, they trembled and asked, “Do you come in peace?” 5“In peace,” he replied. “I have come to sacrifice to the LORD. Consecrate yourselves and come with me to the sacrifice.” Then he consecrated Jesse and his sons and invited them to the sacrifice. 6When they arrived, Samuel saw Eliab and said, “Surely here before the LORD is His anointed.” 7But the LORD said to Samuel, “Do not consider his appearance or height, for I have rejected him; the LORD does not see as man does. For man sees the outward appearance, but the LORD sees the heart.” 8Then Jesse called Abinadab and presented him to Samuel, who said, “The LORD has not chosen this one either.” 9Next Jesse presented Shammah, but Samuel said, “The LORD has not chosen this one either.” 10Thus Jesse made seven of his sons pass before Samuel, but Samuel told him, “The LORD has not chosen any of these.” 11And Samuel asked him, “Are these all the sons you have?” “There is still the youngest,” Jesse replied, “but he is tending the sheep.” “Send for him,” Samuel replied. “For we will not sit down to eat until he arrives.” 12So Jesse sent for his youngest son and brought him in. He was ruddy, with beautiful eyes and a handsome appearance. And the LORD said, “Rise and anoint him, for he is the one.” 13So Samuel took the horn of oil and anointed him in the presence of his brothers, and the Spirit of the LORD rushed upon David from that day forward. Then Samuel set out and went to Ramah.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

3:09 Thanks, Sarah, for reading that for us. Well, we're returning to our sermon series in 1 and 2 Samuel, where we're looking at the life of King David. And this is a pretty famous passage. Chance, even if you've not read the Bible, you might have heard bits of this passage about man looking at the outside, but God looking at the inside. And as we come to it, we're calling this whole sermon series after God's heart, because David is described in 1 Samuel 13 as being uniquely a man who is after God's heart. But that's kind of enigmatic. What does that exactly mean? And in this passage, we really see what that means and also why it's so important. So let's dive into this passage together as we think about it in three ways. First of all, we're going to learn the problem of focusing on outward things. The problem of focusing on outward things. Then secondly, we're going to look at the priority of a heart for God and try and understand what that means. And then thirdly, we're going to think very carefully in our application about how our hearts can actually be changed.

4:05 So the problem of focusing on outward things, the priority of a heart after God, and then how can we actually be changed to have a heart after God? That's where we're going. Let's think first of all about the problem of focusing on outward things. Now in verse 1, we pick up the story and we need to do a bit of a catch-up because we started all the way back in chapter 1 with the prayers of Hannah as she was praying, both for her own situation, but also for the life of the nation to experience some renewal. And that led to chapter 8, where the people asked God for a king, which, whilst it might sound like a pretty benign thing, there's a flaw in their motivations. They're asking God for a king so that they can be like the other nations. And of course, Israel was supposed to be different to all the other nations in that it had God as a king, God as their guide, God as their protector. Nonetheless, God is gracious, and he's all sovereign. That is, he's in control. And so he does give them a king, and Saul is installed as king.

5:00 And Saul initially seems to be doing so well. He has all the trappings of what in the ancient world you would think would make for a good king. In fact, many of them probably would make for a good leader today. First, we're told in chapter 9, verse 1, that he's from a family that has standing. His father, Kish, is a man of standing. In other words, he's well-known, well-respected, got power and prestige in his kind of blood, as it were. Secondly, we're told that Saul is tall and handsome. In other words, he looks the part, but also in the ancient world where so much of combat was settled hand-to-hand with a longsword, being taller gave you an advantage with your reach. And so frequently, prominent warriors were disproportionately tall. Saul's got that in his locker as well. And then we also see as it goes on in the chapters that Saul is a very shrewd politician. He knows how to garner support.

5:55 He knows how to solidify his power base. And he quickly becomes a very powerful figure in the life of Israel. But as we'll see, Saul does not follow God and does not obey God. And so prior to this chapter, Saul has been rejected by God as the king and been told that the kingdom has been taken away from him. But you'll notice that Saul has not given up his throne, which shows where Saul's priorities are. He wants to hold on to power. And so in verse 1, we get this question from the Lord to Samuel, How long will you mourn for Saul? I've rejected him as king over Israel. Fill your horn with oil, that is, get ready to anoint a new king. I'm sending you to Jesse of Bethlehem. I've chosen one of his sons to be king. But Samuel is worried, how can I go if Saul hears about it? He will kill me. In other words, Saul is now using all of these great abilities he's got. His ability to garner his power base, his outward appearance, his competence.

6:52 He's using it all to stay in power, not to follow God. And here we see highlighted the problem of focusing on outward things. Now, of course, we live in a city where this is ubiquitous. It wouldn't have escaped your notice. I wonder, even if you were walking to church this morning, you might have gone past numerous billboards. And of course, what are they plugging to you? Outward appearances look beautiful, look young, look fashionable, make it, get ahead. So much about this city is focused on the external factors, the strength of your resume, how you're doing, how much money you earn, the power and prestige you can garner. It's not only the city. I mean, York's kind of often been like that, but it's also our particular social moment, isn't it? We've gone from Facebook, notice the words, not inside heart book, is it? It's looking at the faces of people, to Instagram, where whether or not you choose a filter, you can have filters now which don't even look like filters so that you can present your more than better appearance to the world and garner support. So much of our moment is about external things. Even when it comes to our leaders in different spheres of life, I remember a time not so long ago, and many of you remember it too, when if there was a major moral failure in a leader, in a key institution, be it a bank or a business or a charity or politics, they would step down because they had disqualified themselves by the major moral failure.

8:18 Now it's not only that they don't step down, but actually we don't really care. I mean, after all, we want a winner, not a choir boy, right? You know, this is the problem. We focus on external things, how competent, how good, how powerful, what your resume is, what you can do, your ability to garner support, and we care little, if any, about the heart. Now you may say, well, what's the problem with that? I mean, after all, we don't want incompetent people in leadership, do we? Well, David is certainly not incompetent as we'll see, but he has one thing Saul does not have. He has a heart after God's. Let me highlight at least two problems I think there are if we prioritize competence and outward things over character and what's going on inside in our hearts. First of all, we need to think about the fact that every competence has a shadow side to it. Every gift, every ability has a shadow side to it.

9:13 And if you don't have a character that is strong enough, that is well-formed enough, you'll never confront the shadows of your competence. So someone, I don't know, is popular, charismatic, good at connecting with people. The shadow side of that is that once they play that out, they realize they can bend people to their will and they quickly become inauthentic, presenting a picture of themselves as not entirely true, and manipulative, constantly trying to get support from other people, no matter the truth of the matter. Maybe someone's really intelligent or a great strategist, and they're good at thinking things through, but then they start to overplay their strength, and they don't realize that in their shadow side, they no longer consult people, no longer act like they need anybody else. They become a one-man, one-woman band, and then their blind spot catches them out. Maybe someone's a good speaker. That's the danger with preachers, right? You stand up and you speak and people seem swayed by your words, but then of course you become a slave to your words. And so you defend and distance yourself using your words to get away with your sin. That's the shadow side of it.

10:20 Maybe someone's very attractive, very beautiful, or very handsome and said they've always noticed from an early age that people would do what they want with just a flick of their eyes or a flick of their hair. And then over time, as they do that too much, they become shallow and become a kind of caricature, a parody of themselves. Every competence has a shadow side. And without godliness of character, without a deep-rooted formation, we'll never confront the shadow side. We'll just get caught up with the dazzling bright lights of our competence until it becomes, like Saul too late. That's the first problem. The second problem is that if we're very competent, then we will use our competence to hide and to disguise our character flaws. I mean, think about this. This is how magicians and illusionists work, right? They're very good at this. So they use dazzling or distraction so that they can get away with the trick. And so many of us dazzle with our gifts, distract with our competence, all the while we're hiding our sin under the table.

11:30 Don't want anyone to pull it out of the hat. And so it is. Think of Adam in the Garden of Eden with Eve. He's the first person who after he sins, what does he do? He hides. No one had hidden before. That's very inventive. But all of humanity has been hiding ever since. When we're caught out in our sin, we hide. We dazzle. We distract. We don't want to admit our failures. We use our competence to hide our character flaws, but of course that means that we can never change. Because we're constantly trying to hide our failures, we can never actually deal with our failures, and so we become slaves to our failures. Now, focusing on the outward things may seem attractive initially, but it leads us down a difficult path where we become embedded in our problems and unable to change. And so it was with Saul. It started well, but you see where he is now? Trying to kill a prophet as he rejects God's word to him. That's the dark path of focusing on the external things.

12:36 And so that brings us then, secondly, to the priority of a heart for God, the priority of a hard after God because God sends Samuel to a very different person. And this whole kind of rigmarole that goes on with the parading of seven of Jesse's sons in front of Samuel, and each one, Samuel misunderstanding and misperceiving and getting things wrong, is meant to be an object lesson in us. Not that we roll our eyes at Samuel and think, well, how could you? But in how easily we're duped because we don't look at the inside. There's a deep irony here, by the way, because Samuel as a prophet would have been known or is sometimes called a seer. The idea being that to be a spokesperson for God should give you some particular insight into the way things are. But do you notice how Samuel hasn't yet been able to see things clearly? And so he makes the same mistake that he made with Saul. He focuses too much on the outside. So we get verse 5.

13:36 Samuel replies, he's coming in peace. I've come to sacrifice to the Lord. And then he goes to Jesse and asks him to bring his sons and invite them to the sacrifice. This is Samuel's way of avoiding the problem of saying actually, obviously and externally, that he's going to anoint a new king, which would get Saul's displeasure and potentially bring an army down on Jesse's territory. And so he masks his true intentions with the calling of a sacrifice. But then as the sons are paraded before Samuel, notice what happens first when he sees Eliab. Verse six, when they arrived, Samuel saw Eliab, who's the oldest, by the way, and he thought, surely the Lord's anointed, the king stands here before the Lord. But the Lord said to Samuel, don't consider his appearance or his height, for I've rejected him. When it says rejected, it means I'm not choosing him. Now, why would Samuel be drawn to his height and his appearance?

14:31 For the same reasons he was drawn to Saul's height and appearance. Here is a person with all the trappings. He's the firstborn. Therefore, he would be the one naturally put forward in society. He's taller. He's going to be good in a battle. He's handsome as well. But it's a trick. Or rather, focus on his outward appearance is a trick. He's not this one. And then one by one, the other six sons are paraded, and none of them are the people that God is choosing. until eventually Samuel says, well, is there anybody else? And then David is revealed. And David, God says, is a man after my own heart. Now, what does that mean? In verse 7, when the Lord says, do not consider his appearance or his height, I've rejected him. The Lord does not look at things people look at. People look at the outward appearance. The Lord looks at the heart. What does it mean to be a person after God's own heart? Well, at least two things. First of all, we have to realize that our hearts truly shape who we are.

15:28 Our hearts truly shape who we are. We tend to think of ourselves in lots of different ways. We might think of ourselves as rational beings. You know, if you watch Star Trek, you might think you're a bit more Vulcan. You know, you've got the kind of capacity for reason, and you make your reasons, you know, very clear to people. But how many times have you gone against your own good reasons? Or think of a friend, if it's easier. How many times have you tried to persuade them of good reasons why they shouldn't be doing what they're doing, even though it might be destructive or harmful, and yet they do it anyway? Why? Well, we're not sub-rational, but we are not primarily rational. We are not primarily driven by reason. We're driven by our heart. Or you might think of yourself, well, I'm a volitional being. I'm driven by my will. I've got a strong will, maybe a will to succeed. I want to do good things.

16:20 And so it's my will that defines me. But how often do you really want something, and yet you end up doing something completely different? You might talk about it beforehand. You might lay out the objective to get it. You might say, I'm going to do it. But the spirit might be willing. But the reality of your will is it's very weak because you do what you want to do. You follow your heart. The heart isn't in the Bible really your emotions, so it includes your emotions. It's more your desires. It's more deep-seated. It's the things you love. God is love. And to be made in the image of God is to be people of love. We're drawn to what we love. Our deepest desires shape us, form us, and mold us. So to say that David is a man after God's own heart is to say he's shaped by what he loves. And then secondly, it is to say that what David loves above all things at his best is God. He has a radical God-centeredness.

17:18 Now, for many people today, when they hear that, they might think that that sounds almost fanatical. I mean, how can you be so God-centered? Are you really saying we should put God first? I remember when I first became a Christian and started following Jesus, age 22, and I realized that was what it meant. When I tried to explain to my friends, they kind of stepped back a little bit and said, oh, you're one of those Christians. I let you really take it seriously. Okay, Pete's gone overboard, you know, type thing. And so we can see this kind of devotion to God as being like, religion's fine if it's one amongst many, but don't make God the main thing. There's a scene in one of my favorite films, Chariots of Fire, when Eric Liddell is contemplating that the Paris Olympic Games in 1924 would require him to run in the heats on a Sunday. And as a devoted follower of Christ in those days, he thought it was wrong to be doing sport on a Sunday. And there's a British aristocrat who's trying to persuade him otherwise and says, well, in my day, it was queen and country first and God second. And another aristocrat quips, yes, and the war to end all wars shows us where that leads. The danger is, if you put anything above God, you'll claw and you'll fight and you'll go to war for it. Only God should be first in our heart because only God has made all things? And should not the one who's made all things be prioritized above all things? David shows this remarkably through his life. His God-centeredness time and time again is what sets him apart. We're going to see this spoiler alert in next week in chapter 17 when he goes to face Goliath. And as he goes out to face Goliath, why does he go to fight? Is it because he wants fame or glory? Is he because he thinks this will secure him the crown and get it off Saul's head?

19:09 No, we hear in chapter 17, David says, who is this uncircumcised Philistine that he should defy the armies of the living God? Is David's zeal for the Lord that means he gets an otherworldly courage to face a giant? If you want otherworldly courage, is God first in your heart? Or think about David when he's being horrendously treated by Saul, who is clinging onto the throne and is trying to kill him at every step. And David finds himself in a situation at the cave of En Gedi, when Saul has gone into the cave and he's vulnerable, and David happens to be, just by God's sovereignty, in that cave, with weapons and his men at his side, and he could kill Saul in a heartbeat. Wouldn't that be reasonable? Wouldn't David be able to say, well, it was providential, I was just following the Lord's leading?

20:03 But David knows God's will, and so he doesn't kill him. And when he's explaining why, he says this, The Lord forbid that I should do such a thing to the Lord's anointed, or lay my hand on him, for he is the anointed of the Lord. Lord. It is David's faith in God and his centrality of God in his heart that gives him an otherworldly patience and grace and perseverance under fire. Even when David sins, it is his centrality of God in his heart that restores him. In Psalm 51, when David is praying through his repentance and his forgiveness, he says these remarkable words. He knows he sinned against Bathsheba. He knows he sinned against her husband Uriah, who he puts to death. He knows he's sinned against the nation who he's let down and he's abused the power that they've invested in him. But he says these words, against you, you only, Lord, have I sinned and done what is evil in your sight. It is his God-centeredness that actually paves the path of restoration and redemption for him. So I don't know, you want courage this morning? You want patience and compassion of dealing with difficult situations this morning? You want to know the path of redemption and restoration when you failed? May I ask you, is God central to your heart?

21:27 This is what it means to be a man after, a woman after God's own heart, is to say, God, you are everything to me. Whom have I in heaven but you, and whom do I desire on earth besides you? My heart and my flesh may fail, but you are my strength and my portion forever. It is to say, I'm gonna put you first, God, and everything else will fall into order with you as the center, as the apple of my eye.

21:52 But that then leads us thirdly to a pretty tricky question as we apply this. how can our hearts be changed? You know, there's a subtle temptation with a passage like this. You see the centrality of God in David's heart. You hear these beautiful words, man looks at the outside and God looks at the inside. And particularly if you're a younger sibling, you think how reassuring. Finally, someone who sees me, sees the good within me. But the danger is with a passage like this, if we try to go straight from that passage to us, is just going to put a huge burden on our shoulders. If I was to stand here this morning and say, go, be like David, put God first, you might go out with an initial enthusiasm, you'd feel a kind of rally cry perhaps, and then I guarantee lunchtime, Sunday evening, your first, your second, your third, your 31st failure is kicking in, and it's just a burden on your shoulders that's crushing you under the weight of an expectation you will never be able to fulfill.

22:52 Now, the application of this passage cannot be go and be like David primarily. Why? Well, for two good reasons. Number one, the Bible fundamentally is not about humanity. It's fundamentally a book about God and what God is like. And only once we put God central can we start to see ourselves in a clearer light. And secondly, because if we go from here and think, well, I must try harder to put God first, then two things are going to happen. One, we're either going to be crushed under the weight of our failures, if we're honest with ourselves, or number two, we're going to become proud and unbearable when we think we're doing it and we realize other people around us aren't doing such a good job and will become self-righteous and obnoxious. And neither of those is going to be helpful. Think of it a little bit like this. A couple of years ago, we had an eclipse coming down the kind of eastern seaboard. And so a number of us who were in New York at that time or on the eastern coast, you know, kind of went out around midday, I remember me and a bunch of other people went out to Bryant Park and we went to see the eclipse. But all of us knew not to look directly at the sun, right? Because if we looked directly at the sun to see the eclipse, we wouldn't be able to see the eclipse anyway. We'd just see a kind of fuzzy blur. But number two, we'd risk doing damage to our eyes. So how did we view the eclipse?

24:08 Well, we had to see the eclipse mediated. We had to either pull out our phones and some of us turn down the brightness on our phones and videoed the eclipse and looked at the screens on our phones, and we could then see it very clearly. Others put strong sunglasses on. Others, maybe children, had made those kind of cardboard boxes of, you know, the eclipse cameras and were kind of squinting through a little hole. Can you see it yet? Not quite. Anyway, the point is we all had to mediate the sun so that we could actually see it properly and not be damaged by it. God's holiness in the Bible, and his call to be more like him, to be God-centered, is just like that. If we try and look straight at God unmediated, then we won't see him clearly, and we will actually do damage to ourselves. We need mediation. We need something, or rather someone, who's going to stand between us and God, which is why this passage is not ultimately about David. David does fail. He is not consistently a man after God's own heart. But this passage is not primarily about David, remember, or us. It's primarily about God and how he reveals us to himself through his son, Jesus Christ. Which is why at the end of the passage, we get this repetition of the word anointed. Verse 12, the Lord said, rise and anoint him, this is the one. And verse 13, means that Samuel took the horn of oil and anointed him in the presence of his brothers.

25:40 The word for anointing in Hebrew is Mashiach, which is where we get the word Messiah from, the anointed one. This is pointing us towards great David's greater son, the true king, who was anointed, the one who uniquely and fully was a man after God's own heart. You know, sometimes performance under pressure reveals what's really going on in your heart. Well, think of Jesus when he's most under pressure. The night before he goes to the cross, he's praying in the Garden of Gethsemane. And this remarkable God-man, who had not even shown a hint of his heartbeat being raised when a storm that terrifies seasoned sailors rages. This man who faced down a legion of demons with poise and peace. This man who has never flapped, who is never anxious, suddenly at that moment, the night before he goes to the cross, he's on his knees. He's weeping in the Garden of Gethsemane. And the pressure is so enormous on him at the prospect of the cross that we're told that blood is starting to burst out of his capillaries and sweat blood. Such the pressure he's under. And in that moment, where does his heart go? He prays, Lord, if it's possible, take this cup from me. Yet not my will, but your will be done. Under the most immense pressure, the Lord Jesus Christ is radically God-centered. He says, I do nothing apart from what my Father wants me to do. He is the perfect person after God's own heart. He is the one who uniquely and perfectly fulfills this. He is the great anointed one who shows us what it looks like to follow God the Father faithfully all the days of his life. David fails. David ultimately is rejected. It can't be him. Jesus Christ never fails, even under the greatest duress. And that's why, as well, do you notice that there's a foreshadowing here in this passage of the Lord Jesus Christ? Because

27:46 after Samuel takes the horn of oil and anoints David in the verse of 13, in the presence of his brothers, from that day on we're told the Spirit of the Lord comes powerfully upon David. And so what's the first thing that David does? He goes to battle. In chapter 17, as we'll see next week, come back please, he goes to fight the Lord's enemies, Goliath. And so it is with the Lord Jesus Christ. When he rises up out of the water of his baptism, the Spirit descends on him like a love and we hear the divine voice of the Father coming from heaven saying, this is my Son whom I love, with him I am well pleased. And now anointed by the Spirit, Jesus goes to do battle, not with a physical giant, not with flesh and blood, but with the real giants that we face. Sin, our own internal appetite for destruction and turning away from God. Death, the great shadow that is cast over all the world and our own godlessness. Jesus goes to do battle with those things, proclaiming forgiveness, proclaiming restoration, proclaiming an end to the devil's kingdom, rolling back the forces of death until he dies on the cross. And when he dies on the cross, he, the one who is perfectly after God's own heart, dies for all of the ways that we have prioritized in our hearts other things.

29:07 He, the one who has an undivided heart because God is at the center of his heart, God the Father, he dies for all of the ways that our hearts are so twisted and distorted and turned in on themselves, constantly with good intentions and fallen realities, prioritizing other things, our own popularity, our own prestige, our own career, the things that we must have, that we elevate above God. and when we do that, they enslave us and become dumb idols. Jesus dies on the cross. His heart of integrity is broken in two for all of the ways our hearts have turned away from God. As the words of the great hymn put it, oh, to see the pain written on your face, bearing the awesome weight of sin, every bit of thought, every evil deed, crowning your bloodstained brow, This, the power of the cross.

30:03 Verse seven could be the most terrifying verse you ever read, that God sees your heart. But here's the wonderful reality as I close. If you know Jesus Christ, if he has washed your heart clean by the cross and by the sending of his spirit, if he has given you a new heart, then verse seven can be the most comforting verse in the whole of scripture. As you pause now and think about that verse, Where does it land for you? Does it terrify you that someone really sees you? Every bit of thought, every evil deed you've done, not the you you project, not the you that you put out on Instagram, but you, the real you, the you behind the mask, the you behind the dazzling and the distraction. God sees you. Does that terrify you? Without Jesus Christ, it really should. but with Jesus Christ to know that God sees you, the real you and at that moment has sent his son to die for you and to restore you and has sent his spirit to cleanse you and to renew you that can be the most amazing verse the source of the greatest rejoicing that your heart is washed clean and you can stand before the throne of heaven and say by God's grace I'm forgiven I have a heart washed clean I am a sinner but I am restored Lord, and now, Lord, you see my heart. May that change us, may that renew us, and may God's grace be to us. Let me pray for us. Heavenly Father, thank you for the life of David. Thank you that he shows us in his best moments that yearning to be after your own heart. But thank you as well that he points beyond himself and even his great failures, as we'll see, to the Lord Jesus Christ, the one who uniquely and fully is a man after your own heart. May his life lived for us and his death died for us and his resurrection wrought for us. Cleanse us, renew us in the power of the Spirit so that our hearts might be washed clean and so we might stand before you cleansed and

32:09 forgiven and confident. We ask it for Jesus' sake. Amen.

Machine translated from the source