Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published November 23, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
6:08 Thanks, Mirabel, for reading that passage for us. We're continuing in our sermon series, In the Life of David. As we've been going through seeing David as a man after God's heart, so far we've seen lots of high points. We've seen David's anointing, the unlikely chosen one from his brothers. We've seen David's defeat of Goliath, the moment when he steps in and acts courageous when all others are scared. We've seen his restraint as he's had the opportunity to kill Saul but doesn't, not once but twice. We've seen David's ascent to the throne as he starts to see seemingly become the king that Israel needs and the king that we would love to see ruling. And then we've also seen the ark brought into the center of Jerusalem as David restores the very presence of God at the heart of God's people. So many highs, and yet here it all gets undone. It's as if the thread on David's life is pulled and unraveled so quickly.
7:05 His fall is as great and as infamous, if not more so, than his ascent. And yet, David says in Psalm 32, probably almost certainly reflecting on this episode, that he wants to instruct us and teach us about this episode. Now, how can he be so proud? For a man who is so chastened with such a fall, how can he possibly say that he wants to instruct us? Has he not learned from his mistakes? No, David has learned. David is a chastened man, but when he's writing Psalm 32, he wants us to know two things. First of all, his fall is so great that he wants to warn us about how it happened so that we might not experience such a fall. And secondly, the grace shown to him by God in this passage is so utterly stunning and surprising that he wants to reassure us that no matter how big a mess we've made of any area or all areas of our lives, restoration is never beyond the grace of God. So we're going to see that in the passage as we come to it. We're going to see three things, David's fall, God's judgment, and God's grace. David's fall, God's judgment, and God's grace. We're going to spend almost all of our point on the first part on David's fall, but we will end with God's grace.
8:16 So come with me to the passage as we look at, first of all, David's fall. And as we look at it, I want to draw out three aspects that stand out from the fall. The first one is that the enemy is not without, the enemy is within. Look at chapter 11, verse 1. We're going to cover the whole passage. We could only read sections of it as you got the broad story, but chances are you know it anyway. But look with me at verse 1 of chapter 11. It starts enigmatically, but dropping a powerful hint that we should note. In the springtime, at the time when kings go off to war, David sent Joab out with the king's men and the whole Israelite army. They destroyed the Ammonites and besieged Rabbah, but David remained in Jerusalem. How much has changed for David? There is definitely something we're intended to draw from this opening phrase. In the springtime, when other kings are going out for war, David is not going out for war. He is instead lolling around the palace, lounging around the palace, enjoying the trappings of his power and his prestige.
9:15 each. And this is to teach us that the enemy is within. You see, think of David, where he starts in 1 and 2 Samuel. David is the man of authenticity and integrity. When all other people are afraid of the fight, David rises to fame because he takes the fight in the power of the Lord to Goliath. When others refuse to step in and do the right thing, David is the man of integrity who time and time again does the right thing. And we're intended to see a contrast here with Uriah later on, Uriah, when he is brought home by David, when David's trying to cover up his sin, Uriah, the man of integrity, refuses to go into home because his men are on the front line. They're not his men, really. They're David's men. But David has lost such integrity. The man that he was is not the man that he has become. And we're intended to see here how far he has slipped from his own standards, from the standards that God put before him, how much he has changed. But not just that.
10:12 Notice what it is that brings down the kingdom. It is not the threat of the Philistines or the Ammonites. It's not the enemy at the gate that brings this kingdom down. It's the enemy within. It's the battle that David is not fighting in his own heart that brings him down and brings the kingdom down. How many times has this parable been reenacted throughout history? We look externally to the problems without, but it's the enemy within. that is the real threat. The enemy is not at the gates. The enemy is in David's heart. We're intended to see that he's not fighting that battle anymore, just as he's not fighting the king's battles anymore. You know, in the 20th century, as Christian values and Christian kind of view of the world started to wane from society, there was a big shift in how we started to view what the big problems in society were. In that period, there was a rise of psychoanalytics and Freud's teaching. Freud teaching that primarily our problems come about from adverse childhood experiences and the way that they impact the interactions between the ego and the id and the superego and ultimately therefore an externalization of your problems, the things that have happened to you in the past and the way they resonate in the present. At the same time we had the rise of socialism and the teaching of Marx that the problems aren't within, the problems are out there in power dynamics in society. Those who wield power and oppress the vulnerable with their power and we need to change those power dynamics in order to bring about healing in society.
11:44 And if you want to look at the history of Europe to understand where that led, then you can. Either way, both of those have a certain explanatory power. There is some truth to them, but neither go deep enough. Because both externalize the problems. The problems in power dynamics. The problems in adverse childhood experiences. And again, whilst there might be some truth in them, they both deflect from the real problem, which is the enemy is within. sin. The enemy is not at the gates here. The enemy is in David's heart. This is what the Bible calls sin, and far from being an outdated concept, it couldn't be more relevant or more contemporary. Sin is not some way of dismissing other people. You're a sinner and I'm a righteous person. It's not that. Sin is not something a little bit naughty but quite nice, like the seven deadly sins we might indulge in to have a bit of fun. Sin is none of those. Sin is a highly sophisticated concept. It's about our internal distortion in our desires that moves us away from the good that we want and away from the good that is God. Why are we so often strangers to ourselves? Why often do we so often bring about the end to our dreams with the things that we do? We can try to externalize or push it out there or point the finger at other things, but when we look in the mirror, we realize that painful truth that the enemy is within. So it was for David.
13:04 Secondly, great sin starts small. Notice where it all starts for David, just with a look. So he's on the roof of the palace, he's looking out, and we're told what goes on in verse 2.
13:39 We're not to think here at all that Bathsheba is indulging in any type of seduction. David is on the roof. She's not on the roof. She's well within the compounds of her own home. She's having a bath just as would be totally normal within all of Israelite society. In fact, in Hebrew narrative, the first thing we're told about a person is very significant. And we're told in verse 4 that she's a law keeper. She was purifying herself from her monthly uncleanness. So she's portrayed as righteous. Now all of the animus, all of the activity, all of the intent and the movement is with David. He sees, he desires, he calls, he takes. And we're intended to see in this narrative an echoing of the Genesis narrative. Remember those words from Genesis chapter three where we see in the Garden of Eden that Eve saw the fruit of the tree was good for food and pleasing to the eye and she took and she ate.
14:35 Well, in the same way, David sees a woman bathing. She's pleasing to him. He desires and he takes. He will have it his way. We intend to see that a great sin started with just a small look. Sin always starts this way. You know, I've sat pastorally with many, many people picking up the pieces of a broken life when sin has gripped hold of their lives. And in every single instance, bar none, it is always traceable. to small incremental steps in the path of their own sin which they fail to heed. There is no such thing as one great big sin that comes out of nowhere. It's always in the small details. As we turn away from God in the small things, a look indulged leads to a lust in the heart, leads to a desire nursed and a fantasy played out, leads to adultery, leads to a broken home, leads to devastation. Great sin starts small. A nursing grudge about someone who's wronged you that then starts to become full-fledged hatred, and then the character assassination starts, and the friendships break down, and a whole friendship group and small community is torn apart by the conflict.
15:51 Great sin starts small, all the time. You know, Japanese knotweed is a horrible invasive plant, and if ever you have seen it, then it just pops up with first with a little leaf just above ground, and you see it, and it's very distinctive. And at that moment, if you were naive, you could just leave it and think, Well, it's just a small plant. It won't do anything. But it's coming from under the ground. There's a rhizome, a kind of a root ball that it comes from. And left unchecked, left unpooled out, that rhizome starts to grow and spread underneath the ground. such that it then starts to pop up all over your property. And that Japanese knotweed can start to divide between bricks and mortar and foundations and can render a whole house, a whole building unoccupiable. but it starts small. How it is with sin, the moment it pops up in your life, you can say, ah, don't worry, God will forgive me. That's what he does, right? I don't need to worry about it.
16:50 It's not that bad. I've had a tough week. I'll just say sorry the next day. And you give yourself a hall pass on that particular sin. You start to excuse it and you hide it. You push it beneath the ground. And what you can't see at that moment is that it is growing. The network of that poisonous root system is growing. And soon it will be popping up in all areas of your life. And at that point, it's almost too late. Great sin starts small. Just to look for David, that was all it was. Indulged, it became great sin. And finally, sin makes us monstrous. What is so shocking is that David becomes so far from the man that he was in his youth, so far from the man that he used to be. And in so doing, he becomes the very warning that Samuel, the great prophet, had warned Israel about that kings would become. See, this is what Samuel says in 1 Samuel 8 when the people first asked for a king.
17:45 He says, the king will take your sons and make them serve with his chariots and horses. He will take your daughters to be perfumers and cooks and bakers. He will take the best of your fields and vineyards. He will take a tenth of your grain. He will take your male and female servants for his own use. He will take a tenth of your flocks. Six times in 1 Samuel 8, we get the disposition of the king. He takes. He just takes. And yet David was so different. David gave. He gave the people victory. He gave them protection from their enemies. He gave them justice that they longed for. He gave them hope of a better kingdom.
18:32 And here we're told, when Nathan confronts him, we're told the blunt truth of what David has become. Chapter 12, verse 4, Nathan says to him, Now a traveler came to the rich man, but the rich man refrained from taking one of his own sheep or cattle. to prepare a meal for the traveler who had come to him. Instead, he took the ewe lamb. David took Bathsheba she was not his she was not his to take the giver has become the taker and in so doing David has become a monstrous distortion of what he should be of what at his best he was and my friends this is what sin does to all of us sin distorts us it morphs us it changes us like some hideous distortion from being everything good into everything bad.
19:29 It distorts love, which should lead to flourishing in a marriage, in relationships, into selfish lust. It distorts a good pursuit of happiness into an immoral pursuit of pleasure. It distorts power, which is given to a few or to all of us in different ways to serve and to bring about life and goodness into a way to manipulate and control and to bring death. It distorts truth into my truth as I distort the lies to avoid accountability. Sin makes us monstrous. I wonder if some of the reasons that we so love in Halloween, the kind of monster stories, because they enable us to realize, to believe, sorry, that the monsters are out there so that when we look in the mirror, and we see the monstrous reality of what we've become, we're no longer horrified by what we see. You know, in those films, we love to talk about the hero who comes to slay the monster.
20:25 But can any of us slay the monster within of sin and its great distortion, all that it does to us? David has become so different to all that he longed to be to all that we hoped he would be now let me just pause into a sidebar for a moment and speak about David's relationship to Bathsheba here because I know that many of you as you're reading this passage will be wondering, well, is this David's sin or is it David and Bathsheba? And actually, does David commit some? abuse of power here with Bathsheba? Some of you will be asking does David rape Bathsheba? I just want to say a few comments about that. First of all let me just say consent and power dynamics are enormously complex and evolving and this is a 3,000 year old text and we're not given all the information. So we can't make a full assessment just by reading one narrative and we need to be thoughtful about that. Secondly, though, I do want to say there is an intentional contrast throughout the whole passage between David and Bathsheba. David is the active one in the whole passage.
21:27 Bathsheba, the only thing she's described as doing are things that are righteous and good, washing herself in her beans with the Torah. Notice the deliberate use of the verb take when describing David's actions. Notice in the parable told by Nathan that she is portrayed as a ewe lamb, whilst David is the rich man. All of the power is with him. Notice the godly actions of Bathsheba at the beginning of the account. Importantly, notice that Bathsheba is never condemned in Scripture for this, but David is frequently condemned in Scripture, and she doesn't have to repent, and David does. Specific question, though, of whether or not she's raped, I think is very, very challenging, and I think I'd like to leave you to make up your own minds on that. The Hebrew does have a specific word or two words that it could use for that. that is used in 2 Samuel 13 with the rape of Tamar. It's not used here.
22:21 And if David does rape Bathsheba, then the resolution at the end whereby he actually marries her and they have a child who is Solomon, with his name meaning peace, could potentially be very problematic. because it could mean that she's being put into an abusive relationship there, which doesn't seem to be what the passage is trying to get at. So certainly all of the accountability is with David, not with Bathsheba. And the power dynamics here are very much in his court, not with her. But about that specific question, I leave it with you. But whatever you conclude about that, what I want to be very clear about, this is David's sin. And the point is not that we should point at him only and roll our eyes and shake our heads. But the point is that actually we should recognize from this account, from this incredible honesty of the account, that actually, whilst we might not have committed sins like this, the potential for great sin exists within all of us.
23:15 The enemy is within. Great sin starts small, and sin makes us monstrous. I mean, isn't that what's so awful about sin? The way it distorts and corrupts all of our lives. I know that many of you here this morning bearing the scars of it. And some of you are here this morning aware that you've inflicted some of those wounds on other people. David's sin.
23:38 Secondly, though, God's judgment. Throughout the whole of chapter 11, we haven't heard from God at all, but God has been present. Look at chapter 11, verse 27. After the time of mourning was over, David had brought to his house, and she became his wife, and bore him a son. but the thing David had done displeased the Lord. David may have been the active one in sin and the enormous and detailed cover-up that he perpetuated. But God will now act as judge and bring it to light. First of all, notice God confronts. God sends Nathan to David. It is God's initiative. The honest truth is David would have got away with this. David's cover-up was successful, if that's the right word. David had managed to weave a web of lies to protect himself from accountability, but God steps in. God confronts through Nathan. And secondly, God judges. Twice we are told in verse 7 and verse 11, this is what the Lord says. And please notice that God's judgment is perfect. David took Uriah's wife, so David's wives will be taken from him. David did this in secret, so God will make sure that this is done, his judgment is in broad daylight. David's actions led to the death of Uriah and some of his men, David will grieve the death of his son conceived with Bathsheba. Now look, I know that talk of God's judgment is far from popular and stings in the context of this. But I wonder if you can see that judgment here is a good thing for a number of reasons. First of all, David would have got away with it. How many times in history have powerful people got away with sin? How many times have the sin and the cover-up gone unchecked, unpunished? You see, we're left with either one of two conclusions. Either there is no God, in which case power is might and might is right, and you just get to do what you want, and if you can get away with it, then good for you. In which case, there is no judgment, there is no justice. The marginalized go, and their cries are unaccounted
25:46 for. I don't want to live in a world like that, and I don't think you do too. At best, even with all the advances of the Western judicial system, at best our justice is partial and fleeting. There is not an honest full accounting. Rarely are people held to account. No matter the executive committees or the reports or the investigations or the investigative journalism, most people go unpunished. But God will not have it that way. These things displease the Lord, and God will be sure that one day there is an accounting. And that's important because it says that you matter, that I matter, that this world matters, that the cries of the vulnerable matter. Will not the judge of all the earth do what is right? He will. He will. We're told in Acts chapter 17 that God has set a day when he will judge the world with justice. by the man he has appointed, Jesus Christ. He has given proof of this to everyone by raising him from the dead.
26:44 Justice will be done. but if that's the case, then notice how the prospect of judgment impacts David. It brings him to repentance. We are so good at hiding, at reframing, at deflecting, at being defensive, at deferring, at running away, at avoiding accountability for our sin. We're so good at it. We've been doing it since little children. So much of our great gifts and our intellect is invested in that task of not being accountable. And David manages to do that until what? Until he realizes that God sees his sin. That the one person he hasn't reckoned with is the one person he's going to be held accountable to, God. And at that moment, for the first time, he does the only good thing he does in all of this narrative. He repents.
27:35 He drops to his knees and he cries out for forgiveness. Now this is the reality for many of us. It's only when we see the judgment of God that we realize that we will be held accountable and that can bring us to repentance. It certainly was the case for me. When I was looking into Christianity, I could theorize it, I could intellectualize it, but the reality of my sin and that one day it would be brought into the light, suddenly made me realize I need a savior, Jesus Christ. David here repents in the face of God's judgment. May it be so for us. And lastly, that brings us to God's grace. Chapter 12, verse 13 is not a straightforward verse at all. I wonder how it impacts you when it's read. Then David said to Nathan, I have sinned against the Lord. Nathan replied, too late. You will face God's judgment. No, that's what you would expect. But Nathan replies, the Lord has taken away your sin.
28:35 You are not going to die. But because by doing this, you've shown utter contempt for the Lord, the son born to you will die. Notice a couple of things. First of all, the social consequences of David's sin do rumble on, even though he repents. He is forgiven by the Lord. We'll come to that in a moment, but that doesn't mean that there are no implications, no consequences for his life. So it will be for all of us. God may give us forgiveness if we repent. He will, sorry, give us forgiveness if we repent, but we might have to walk out the consequences of our decisions in our lives. But please notice here what this is trying to urge us to. David has sinned greatly. It's difficult to imagine a greater fall from grace. And yet in repentance, God, even with David, even with such a great sin, shows him grace. Because under the Torah, the punishment for what David did was death under the Levitical law. But amazingly, David does not die. He will not die.
29:36 And I want you to, in your minds, do a compare and contrast with Saul. I'd suggest to you that Saul's sin is nowhere near as egregious as David's sin. And yet, Saul lost the kingdom. Saul did die under God's judgment. What's the difference between the two men? It is not the size of their sin that matters, but it is ultimately receiving the enormity of God's grace that matters. That's what defines David. The only reason he's forgiven is because he repents, which is what Saul refuses to do in his pride. He will not give in, but David gives in. And it doesn't matter if it takes you one week or 10 years. If you will throw yourself on the mercy of God and appeal to his grace, he will forgive you. There is no sin so egregious that God won't forgive you. There is no unforgivable sin apart from the unforgivable sin of not going to God for grace, which is what Saul does.
30:33 David goes, and he's forgiven. As he says, a broken and contrite heart, O God, you will not despise. But you've got to read this and think, how? How is that just? I mean, what about all the consequences? What about what David's done? Who's going to pay for this? There's one of these many passages in the Old Testament that makes no sense without the New Testament. Without the New Testament, then the God who forgives David is just sweeping sin under the carpet. I don't want to worship a God like that. and I don't think you do either. But God is not sweeping sin under the carpet. This God who forgives David here will make sure that there is a full accounting for sin. You say, well, how can you be sure? Because he does it in the person of Jesus Christ. At the cross, God, who David acknowledges here when he says, I have sinned against the Lord, he acknowledges that his primary offense is against God.
31:27 He's not saying it's not against Bathsheba, it's not against Uriah, it's not against the nation. He's saying primarily since God is the source of all good, then my sin is against you, Lord. And since I've wronged you, you're the one I need to seek forgiveness from above all. I'm sure there was also a moral accounting, seeking forgiveness from Bathsheba, seeking forgiveness from the people he'd let down and betrayed, seeking forgiveness from the nation. But primarily it starts with God. And since God is the offended party, primarily, then God is the one who can forgive. because at the cross, God, the offended party, takes on himself all of the weight of the wrongdoing, all of the monstrous ugliness of sin, all of the distortion of sin, and all of its necessary judgment, God takes it on himself in the person of Jesus Christ. so that as he dies, David and any of us can be forgiven.
32:21 You know, my children have been reading over the last couple of years The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe and the Narnia Chronicles, And many of you will be familiar with the story, but there's a quick catch up. Edmund betrays his siblings, lying and deceiving and gives them up to the White Witch who's the evil person in the land of Narnia and Aslan, who's the great lion who rules over Narnia with goodness and justice and truth. is the one that Edmund betrays as well as betraying his siblings. And the White Witch comes to Aslan and says this. She says, Edmund's life is forfeit to me. His blood is my property. unless I have blood as the law says all Narnia will be overturned and perish in fire and water Lucy Edmund's sister who knows how sad and contrite he is says to Aslan is there anything that can be done? Aslan says all must be done and so in the story of Narnia he the great lion gives himself up to the white witch he is killed so that Edmund can go free He is forsaken so that Edmund can be forgiven.
33:28 You see, the price has to be paid. As the witch says, if the price is not paid, then all Narnia will be overturned and perish in fire and water. But because Aslan pays the price, the sacrifice, so Edmund is free. At the end, Aslan says this, if the witch knew the true meaning of sacrifice, she might have interpreted the deep magic a little differently, for she would know that if a willing victim who had committed no treachery dies in a traitor's stead, the stone table would crack and death itself would begin to unwind. How can we unwind what we've done wrong and the implications of it? How can we experience grace and not judgment? How can we experience life and not death? Only through Jesus Christ. Only if we come to him and repent as David did. The one thing that David did right in this passage is the one thing I want to leave you with.
34:22 turn to God, repent maybe for the first time maybe for the first time this week That's the best way to check sin in your life. as soon as you see it weed it out by repentance Lord I'm sorry I don't want to live this way protect me and the Lord will send grace and the power of the Spirit in your life and he will keep you in his love you're never going to be perfect and you're never going to be sinless but in the power of the Spirit and by repentance you can sin less So learn the lesson of David. See the hideousness and the distortion of the enemy within. Fight that battle in the power of the Spirit by repentance and faith and trusting in the forgiveness of Jesus Christ. To him be the glory. Let me pray for us. Heavenly Father, thank you for this passage. Though it's certainly far from easy to read and to grapple with. Lord, may we learn from David's mistakes so that we might not be destined to repeat them or to commit them.
35:21 and may we learn from the one thing that David does in this passage, which is to repent, to turn to you, the God of all grace, that you might forgive us and restore us. We ask it for Jesus.
Machine translated from the source