DNA: Two Ways To Be Lost

David Lee · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 21, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Luke 15:11-32 0:17
11Then Jesus said, “There was a man who had two sons. 12The younger son said to him, ‘Father, give me my share of the estate.’ So he divided his property between them. 13After a few days, the younger son got everything together and journeyed to a distant country, where he squandered his wealth in wild living. 14After he had spent all he had, a severe famine swept through that country, and he began to be in need. 15So he went and hired himself out to a citizen of that country, who sent him into his fields to feed the pigs. 16He longed to fill his belly with the pods the pigs were eating, but no one would give him a thing. 17Finally he came to his senses and said, ‘How many of my father’s hired servants have plenty of food, but here I am, starving to death! 18I will get up and go back to my father and say to him, “Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. 19I am no longer worthy to be called your son. Make me like one of your hired servants.”’ 20So he got up and went to his father. But while he was still in the distance, his father saw him and was filled with compassion. He ran to his son, embraced him, and kissed him. 21The son declared, ‘Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son.’ 22But the father said to his servants, ‘Quick! Bring the best robe and put it on him. Put a ring on his finger and sandals on his feet. 23Bring the fattened calf and kill it. Let us feast and celebrate. 24For this son of mine was dead and is alive again! He was lost and is found!’ So they began to celebrate. 25Meanwhile the older son was in the field, and as he approached the house, he heard music and dancing. 26So he called one of the servants and asked what was going on. 27‘Your brother has returned,’ he said, ‘and your father has killed the fattened calf, because he has him back safe and sound.’ 28The older son became angry and refused to go in. So his father came out and pleaded with him. 29But he answered his father, ‘Look, all these years I have served you and never disobeyed a commandment of yours. Yet you never gave me even a young goat so I could celebrate with my friends. 30But when this son of yours returns from squandering your wealth with prostitutes, you kill the fattened calf for him!’ 31‘Son, you are always with me,’ the father said, ‘and all that is mine is yours. 32But it was fitting to celebrate and be glad, because this brother of yours was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found.’”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

4:06 Well, let me welcome you again to Redeemer Brooklyn. My name is David. I'm the pastor here. And if I haven't met you, we're so glad that you're here. And this is a good time for you to be joining us because we're going through a sermon series called For the Good of Brooklyn, because we're taking some time to think through what it means to be a church not for ourselves, but for the good of Brooklyn. This is a time where we're going through sort of our gospel DNA to talk through the kind of community that we want to be that lives out the gospel in every single area of our lives. Now, we've been saying that when the gospel comes into your life, it's not just a matter of your personal spiritual life that gets changed and your privatized faith. But when the gospel comes into your life, it changes everything, including your shared life and every area of your life out in the city, which is why last week to start off our sermon series, we looked at Jeremiah 29, which we said is one of the most foundational passages in all of Redeemer's history that gets at our posture here in Brooklyn, what the gospel says and how our posture is meant to be for our shared lives here in the city. So it's a foundational passage that we looked at that gets at what kind of community we want to be here now as Redeemer Brooklyn. And today, we just read Luke chapter 15, which is probably the second most influential passage in all of Redeemer's history because now it gets at the heart of the gospel message.

5:30 Our heart posture and what it means to relate to God from a heart that's been changed from the inside out. That's what we're going to look at today. Now, the context of Luke chapter 15, we didn't read it, but in verses 1 and 2, it talks about how Jesus is, to Jesus, people, two particular types of people have been gathered to him. The tax collectors and sinners, as well as these Pharisees, these religious leaders that are scoffing at the fact that these tax collectors and sinners are attracted to Jesus. And so the context of this parable that he's telling is also sort of summarized by, in general, the kind of people in the first century that were attracted to Jesus were those social moral outcasts, the irreligious people, the people that you never thought would be caught dead in sort of in a temple worship kind of a thing. Jesus always drew the irreligious people closer to himself, while on the flip side, those who are most religious, Most moral were always off put by him, were always most offended by who Jesus was.

6:32 So he was always attracting those moral outsiders while also offending the religious insiders. Now what's really ironic is that today Christianity tends to attract who? The religious, moral, conservative, religious types of people, right? You imagine what a Christian is and you maybe imagine like Ned Flanders from The Simpsons or something like that, right? Christianity seems to attract the conservative moral insiders. And the irreligious, people who don't necessarily say that they live by faith, they're the ones who feel like they're most repelled by Christianity. And that means this, or it might mean this, that we don't really get what Jesus is all about. Or certainly, us in our churches might not actually be preaching the same message that Jesus has always been preaching with his life and who he is. That's why we want to look at this passage today, because the gospel message is a revolutionary idea.

7:33 The gospel is not that there are bad people who need God, that now these good people can go tell them about Jesus. But the gospel, the revolutionary message of the gospel is essentially that every single person now needs to understand how they can now relate to God in a revolutionary way because of what Jesus has done. that there's no longer good people over here and bad people over there, but everyone comes to the Father just and only through the Son. And this was such a revolutionary idea that the early Christians, as they were following Jesus, they were called atheists because those who followed Jesus didn't look anything like standard, traditional, institutionalized religion. And so one of the best ways to get that idea across, the revolutionary message of the gospel, of Christianity across, is to look at the parable of the prodigal son that was just in Luke chapter 15. And as we look at this, we're going to see two ways to be lost and only one way to come home.

8:31 Two ways to be lost and one way to come home. Let's look at that now. Jesus is telling this parable of these two brothers that represents two ways of being lost. and two ways of breaking relationship with the father. Now, the first brother, the younger brother, the prodigal brother, he's mentioned first, and this is the most obvious way that you can break relationship with God, right? He sort of represents the irreligious kind of a person. Our passage starts off by this younger brother coming up to his father and basically saying, give me my inheritance now. Now, as Jesus is telling this story, those first century hearers would have been completely shocked that this is how the story starts. And the shame and honor patriarchal system for a younger brother to ask of their inheritance now was essentially saying, I want nothing to do with you. I certainly don't want anything to do with a relationship with you. All I want are the benefits that you will give me once you are dead.

9:27 So to say, give me my inheritance now was saying essentially to the father, I wish you were dead and the only thing I care about are the things that you can give to me, the benefit of what I can have. Now, even worse is that in order, not only does the father actually say, okay, I will give it to you, But in order for the father to give it to him, do you know what he had to do? In early ancient centuries, all of their wealth was tied to the land that they had. So the text says that the father went out and he basically liquidated and split up his property between the two brothers. Which in the Greek literally says he gave away his life's being. He was liquidating his life. Selling that so that he can give and monetize that land. so that he could give it to his younger son. So the youngest son was essentially saying, I want you to liquidate your life for me. That is an outright rejection of the relationship and saying, I don't want to live with you any longer.

10:24 I want to live on my own and for myself. Now, this younger brother is very analogous to who in the passage? These obvious rule breakers, these tax collectors and sinners, the ones that were on the outside doing morally horrific kinds of things. And maybe that's somebody that you resonate with, that character is someone that you might resonate with now and here today. You don't like living this moral, traditional life. Instead, you don't want restraints, and maybe you've lived a life or had a past, or maybe currently now where you're just living however you want, knowingly that you are living this rebellious kind of a life, apart from God, not the way that you're supposed to live. You know that you're living recklessly. And so maybe you start to resonate with this younger brother, this prodigal son. But I want us to see actually that it's not just about immoral bad behavior here.

11:21 See, the heart of a younger brother that I want us to all connect with is ultimately a heart of independence from the father and wanting to do things your own way. And the fact that we're all sitting here in this room living in New York City probably means that we have a lot of younger brothers here in this room. Because the city, New York City, attracts younger brothers. The city promises you freedom and autonomy and a chance for you to live by having control of your own life, to express yourself and not live under authority. So the city attracts younger brothers all the time. And so the character of the younger brother is not so much that you're living a morally bad life as if you are a quote-unquote sinner, but a younger brother is someone who can be busy building your own life apart from God. because you want to live into all your autonomy and self-expression. You don't have to like outwardly hate God and say give me my inheritance now.

12:20 That's not what we have to do to be a younger brother. We can just want to keep God distant enough so that he doesn't take away our freedom or takes away our joy or gives us overly restricted lives. because we want to keep control of our own lives. That's what a younger brother does. That's why younger brothers go off to a faraway country or a faraway land. like New York City to experience the life that we ultimately want to live.

12:51 But in our passage, what happens? This younger brother eventually loses everything, right? He's chasing this life that he thought would completely fulfill him, but instead there's a famine in the land, and he is at the lowest of lows. He's gone bankrupt. He's eating out of a pigsty. In Jewish culture, pigs would have been uncleanliness, right? And so it was representing the most shameful, the most dirty, the most unclean end of your life. This is a person who's now come to the end of themselves after chasing what they thought was going to be so fulfilling. and to give to them. so I think this is sort of one way to think of a picture of what the Bible calls sin, a breaking of relationship. Because sin essentially is us wanting to live on our own, thinking that we know what's best, and a lot of times, and maybe some of us here in this room have felt it, a lot of times that leads us not to the end.

13:46 that we thought we were going to get, not to the kind of fulfilling life, but instead chasing our desires, going after our own ambitions, can lead to us hurting ourselves and moving further and further from the life that we've always imagined and dreamed of until we hit rock bottom, eating literally so hungry that you're eating in a pigsty. And this is the moment starting in verse 17, look with me, where the scripture says this. And then in that moment, when he came to his senses, eating out of a pigsty, he says, how many of my father's hired servants have food to spare? And here I am starving to death. I will set out and go back to my father and say to him, Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son. Make me like one of your hired servants.

14:38 This is the very moment of like, you know, a come to Jesus moment for this younger brother. And maybe some of us have experienced this too. when we come to the end of ourselves, where we experience joylessness, only pain, despair, and darkness, where we actually come to experience that life without the most meaningful and important relationship that we are meant to have with God the Father, that without Him is no life at all. We might be chasing relationships or experiences or chasing building our careers and it's led to unhealthy and very unfulfilling habits that leave us drained and empty. And some of us might be on that very path now, even though you haven't hit the end of that path. But that's the picture of the younger brother, right? It's not just someone who is living in a debaucherous way, living out the desires only of the flesh and sinning outwardly.

15:36 But this is ultimately a picture of someone who is lost. because they've gone their own way. You see the difference there? It's not just about moral behavior, but it's about your independence and autonomy from God going your own way. And here's the thing. If the parable ended here, the message would be pretty simple. Bad people need God, right? People like that, people like you need to come back to the Father. Simple message. But that's not where it ends because that's what brings us now to the elder brother, this person that represents the religious figure. And this, my friends, interestingly, is who the parable is really about. This elder brother represents a lostness that is so much harder to see and therefore so much more spiritually dangerous for every single one of us. Look with me starting in verse 28.

16:32 The brother comes back from working the field. He's working his butt off. And he hears this loud dancing, music, feasting. And he says this. He became angry and he refused to go in. He says, look to the father, all these years I've been slaving for you and I've never disobeyed your orders. You never gave me even yet a young goat so that I could celebrate with my friends. But when this son of yours who has squandered your property with prostitutes comes home, you kill the fattened calf for him.

17:05 Now, I don't know about you, but for me when I read that, maybe because I got a little elder brother in me, that is totally an understandable reaction. I come from an immigrant Asian family, right? The place of where you're born and what you get and what you deserve is very, very strong culturally. But you understand the heart behind his reaction, right? Like, I'm the one that's been here forever slaving away, working for you. I've never disobeyed you. I've worked myself to the bone for you. So who deserves a party like this? Who deserves this kind of fellowship and love and celebration? It is not the one who squandered all of our wealth away. It should be me who gets this, the one who was loyal and hardworking and obedient. This is what I am owed and not what is owed to him. And you see, on the outside, this elder brother looks like he's such a good son because he's done everything right.

18:04 Because he wasn't as rebellious as a younger brother, but it is in this moment that his true heart is revealed. Because what is he ultimately saying to his father? He's saying, I've been keeping score. And my score is a lot higher than his. If anyone is to be celebrated, it should be me. I have earned the right to have a say over what the Father, what you do with your resources. I have the right to the things of you, Father, not him. And that is why this elder brother is fuming. He is so, so angry, which shows that ultimately his relationship with the father is just as broken as the younger brother is. The elder brother wants exactly what the younger brother wants. They both want the things of the father, the thing that they can give to them. But he doesn't get it through outright rebellion.

19:02 He tries to get that kind of control over the father, not through rebellion, but through what? His moral performance, his resume, the things that he has done. See, the younger brother is trying to get control through independence, but this elder brother is trying to still get control through his moral conformity through his being good

19:25 Here's the thing that means for us. You could be here in this room thinking you're a pretty good person because you go to church every single week. In fact, you come early on time. You sit exactly where the ushers tell you to sit. You sing loud. You go to community group every week. Maybe you read your Bible. You've never done drugs. You never live sexually promiscuously. You've done all the right kinds of things. And yet, what this is telling us is that you can still have a broken relationship with God if you are looking to your moral performance as your savior, as the thing that's going to save you and give you life. Because following the rules and obeying God can just be another way to get control over him so that you get what you really want out of him. Not doing those things out of a love for him. And here's how you know that that's happening in your own heart. Is that if things don't turn out the way that you want or expected or you feel like you deserve, you get angry, you get bitter, you've got judgmentalism all up in you, you're self-righteous. There's something brewing inside of you that is, that doesn't match the outward life because at the end of the day you are doing all of that for yourself and not for God. All of your good works, your morality, your performance was all so that God would ultimately have to give you the things that you want, would owe you something. You see that? You know, a great way to illustrate this is through a parable that I think Edmund Clowney told this, but Tim Keller has told this multiple times as well. And he says it like this. He says, there's this gardener in this land that grew this incredible carrot. And he brings it over to the king of the land and he gives it to him and he says, because I love and respect you king so much, I want you to have this beautiful, the best carrot I've ever grown. I want to give it to you. And the king is just so like, oh my goodness, thank you for that. And as the gardener is leaving, he says, you know what?

21:33 I can just tell that you are such a good steward of things that I'm going to give you this plot of land for you to garden. And so the gardener goes away like just excited. Oh my goodness, I wasn't expecting that. Thank you so much. All the while, while that's happening, a nobleman that's listening in in that courtroom listens. He says, my man got land for a carrot? I breed horses. What will I get if I give him a horse? So the next day, he comes and he says, king, I breed horses, and this is the best stallion horse that I've ever bred, and I want to give it to you because of my love and adoration for you. And the king says, thank you. And the guy's confused and he's walking out and the king says, ah, I see that you're confused. You see, the gardener was giving me the carrot, but you are giving yourself that horse.

22:28 See, your good works can be as damning as any bad behavior if you're doing it for yourself, if your motivations are wrong, if your motivation is ultimately to keep God away from your life so that you can control your own life. See, both the elder brother and the younger brother, both of them want what the father could give to them, not a relationship with the father himself. The younger brother did it by being very bad. But the older brother is doing it in the exact same way, by trying to be very, very good. They both have the same heart. both of these sons were lost because they're both using the father for their own self-centered ends, wanting to live apart from him rather than enjoying the relationship with him, rather than loving and serving him for his own sake. You see that? And here's the, I think, the part I want to press further for us is that this particular parable that Jesus is saying is directed particularly to the Pharisees, who he's calling the elder brothers. Why?

23:35 Because younger brothers know that they're lost. When you're living that way, it's not hard to see that your life is living recklessly. But older brothers don't know that we are. We are blind to our very own goodness and our heart motives, which makes it much more dangerous for us. See, because you look good on the outside, but on the inside, again, you're growing in anger and bitterness, and you don't have any kind of intimacy or relationship with the Father. That's why any kind of obedience is not full of joy, but it's just counting a scoreboard. And so because this is so spiritually dangerous for every single one of us, I want to kind of give us an elder brother test. How do you know if you're growing a spirit of being an elder brother.

24:24 Do you get angry when God doesn't give you the thing that you feel like you deserve because you've lived such a good life? Or do you get anxious and upset over that? That might be because we feel like we are entitled to a particular kind of outcome because of what we've done. Or, I can how quickly do we judge other people who are not living a morally great life? How much do we feel like we are morally superior to them? Adding things to our scoreboard. And here is one that I know creeps up in my life all the time. Does it bother you when someone receives grace and not what you think that they deserve? Just because it's not fair. Do you get upset when others receive grace? All of that might be signs that you are emotionally and mentally keeping a kind of scoreboard of yourself as well as through others. Because you're trying to control things through your performance.

25:28 This is a radical message, friends. This is why Jesus, the real Jesus, and the truth of Christianity was so revolutionary. Because religion would just say, you've got to repent of the bad things that you're doing. In Christianity, Jesus says through this, you don't have to just repent of the bad things that you're doing. You've got to actually see even deeper than that and see the self-righteous heart and motivations that might even cause you to do those good things. Don't just repent of your good things, or sorry, of your bad things, but the wrong motivations of even when you do the good things and the right things. See, pride in your good works can be what separates us from God even more than our bad deeds.

26:11 And that is why, friends, the goal of Christianity, the reason why Jesus came is not to turn bad people into religious people. But it is to bring everyone who is lost. home, back into a relationship with God the Father. In the way that we come home, we've got to see at least two things, but there's only one way to come home that you've got to see through two things. First, One of the most surprising reactions in this entire parable is not what the elder brother asks of, not the response of the elder brother, but it's actually the response of the father. Again, this father, in a very patriarchal, shame and honor culture, had every right to disown both of his sons. Both of them treated him with complete disrespect.

27:06 They totally shamed him in public. And yet, what do we see in the father? He goes out, he moves towards both of them out of love for them. He moves towards them initiatingly in love. To the younger brother, starting in verse 20. When the younger brother has rehearsed this in the pigsty, and he's like imagining how he's going to have to win his father back over just so he can be a slave in the house. Not even a son, but just a slave. And our passage says this, starting in verse 20. That as the son was coming, the father sees him from afar, which means he's been waiting for him every single day. And then he doesn't wait to reprimand him and says, what took you so long? I knew you'd be back. Now get on your knees and grovel in front of everybody else so that I can be brought back to honor again. He doesn't do that, but what does he do?

27:59 He runs toward the son. this lost son. He is undignified. He's picking up his clothes and he's running as fast as he can. And before the younger son can even start his apology, here's what he says. Quick, bring the best robe and put it on him. Put a ring on his finger and sandals on his feet. Bring the fattened calf and kill it. Let's have a feed and celebrate for this son of mine was dead and is alive again. He was lost and is found. Full love, complete forgiveness, utter acceptance, regardless of what he had done. That is how the father moves out to the younger son. But it's not just that. The father also moves out toward the elder brother. That when he comes back and he is angry at the feast that's happening, he comes out again after being disrespected and he pleads with him and says, come back into the family, have the feast with us, celebrate for your brother is home.

29:01 And he says, what do I have that is not yours? What the father is saying to the son there is saying, you have always had my love. You never had to earn it. It was always yours. You see that the tenderness and the compassion and the love of the father here in this passage. And I want us to pause on that for a moment because I think this is one of the clearest passages. of what the character of God is like toward anyone who is lost. Like when you imagine God, do you just imagine him this stern, angry, always disappointed authority figure? That's not the image of God that the Bible is giving to us. It is a God that is always ready to welcome any one of us who are lost home. with arms wide open that will do anything to bring his sons and daughters back into a relationship with him.

29:56 That is the God of Scripture. But how is it that all who are lost can come home? There's only one way, and it comes at a great cost. The only way to come home is through the costly love of our true elder brother. You know, Luke 15, like I said, it starts with Jesus telling these parables to these tax collectors and sinners and these Pharisees. And this prodigal son parable is one of three parables that he tells in Luke 15. All things being lost and then being found. So he talks about the lost sheep, the lost coins, and now this one is the lost sons. And in each of those short parables that come before this, two of the three of them, there is a lostness, and then there's this great search, and then after it is found, there is great rejoicing. But this third parable of the lost son, there isn't that quite yet. See, there isn't a search that goes out and the rejoicing that happens when the son is found.

30:57 Why? Well, it makes you think, who should have been the one that went out toward that younger brother in order to bring him back home? It should have been the elder brother. The elder brother should have had his heart broken, seeing the losses of his younger son, of his younger brother, spent everything that was his to go out back onto the far out land, to bring him back home, to say, hey, I know what you're looking for. It's not found there. Come back into the relationship of the family. We'll receive you again. We'll reinstate you no matter what the cost is. That's the kind of brother that's meant to be here in this passage. But that's not what we get, right? We get this really ugly elder brother that is hardened, that won't even celebrate the fact that his lost brother that might have been dead is now found. And commentators, as well as Tim Keller, says the reason why there is such a flawed elder brother here in this passage is to make every single one of us that hears this yearn for, look for a true elder brother.

32:07 And that is what we have in Jesus. The one who is telling this parable is pointing to himself. Because ultimately what Jesus does is he sees us alienated from God the Father in our sin, going our own way, lost. Eating out of a pigsty, thinking it's a great feast. Chasing things that will never fulfill us. He sees us going out further and further from God. and at great cost to himself, he leaves heaven. He leaves home. He leaves his relationship with the Father and the Holy Spirit to come after us, lost younger brothers.

32:47 And he does it by laying down his life to pay for everything to reinstate us back into God's family. Friends, we rightly deserve the wrath and judgment of broken relationship with God for going our own way. And yet Jesus, our true elder brother, says, I will take that on. I will pay that debt. I will die the debt that you and I deserve to die so that my lost son, my lost brother and sister can come back home and be with the Father. And he does that on the cross, friends, where he is, Jesus Christ, he is stripped naked, completely humiliated, worse than eating out of a pig trough. Why does he do that? so that he can now robe us with his righteousness, give us something that we never deserved and that was only his to give. He gives that up so that we might be then brought back and reinstated into the family of God.

33:47 Friends, there is no other way for anyone who is lost to be brought back into the family of God apart from the costly love of Jesus Christ, our true elder brother. And when you see that, when you receive that, it changes your heart from the inside out. It's not like any other kind of religion that you might be thinking about. See, it changes the motivations of why it is now that we do good works and love God and love one another. Because if you identify as a younger brother, you see what Christ has done to give you an unconditional love that no matter what your history might be, no matter how far you might have failed, no matter how bad things might have been or is right now, that nothing is big enough to separate you from the love of God, that Jesus has assured your forgiveness. Friends, receive that.

34:38 Come back home from what the Son has done for you. And if we are elder brothers, the path toward real joy, real joy, is for us to not just repent of our bad things, but also to go deeper and repent of our good things. And you can only do that if you see that Jesus has given you a love that you never could earn, but therefore a love that you can never lose. And if you can never lose that, it's okay if you look deep into your heart and see the ways in which you failed. You're not looking to your performance because Christ is your performance.

35:18 When you have that, when you live out the gospel, when that internalizes deeply in your heart, you and I and we as a community will go out to love and serve, to give of ourselves, not to get anything, but to give in a beautiful way.

35:39 Stop running. Stop trying to control things. Lay it all down. And friends, Jesus now invites every single one of us to just come back.

Machine translated from the source