DNA: What Rules Your Heart?

David Lee · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 21, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Romans 1:18-25 0:08
18The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of men who suppress the truth by their wickedness. 19For what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. 20For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood from His workmanship, so that men are without excuse. 21For although they knew God, they neither glorified Him as God nor gave thanks to Him, but they became futile in their thinking and darkened in their foolish hearts. 22Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools, 23and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images of mortal man and birds and animals and reptiles. 24Therefore God gave them over in the desires of their hearts to impurity for the dishonoring of their bodies with one another. 25They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is forever worthy of praise! Amen.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:49 Do you know what controls and motivates your life today? Now, that might be a question that you think about a lot. You have a very purpose-driven life, and you know exactly why you do what you do or why you want to build the kind of life that you want. But I would venture to say that for a lot of us, this is not only a super important question, but it's a really hard question for us to answer, to really know what motivates and what controls our lives. If you're anything like me, I often feel like I'm a mystery to myself, that I'm discovering myself over and over again. Here's a quote from Becky Pippert that I want to start with. She says this, Whatever controls us is our Lord. The person who seeks power is controlled by power. The person who seeks acceptance is controlled by the people he or she wants to please. We do not control ourselves. We are controlled by the Lord of our life.

2:46 Now what she is saying is that whatever is ruling your heart is the thing that is controlling you. We're in this series where we're looking at sort of our gospel DNA, the kind of church that we want to be. Because it's been about a year since we've launched and so it's a good time to reintroduce to everyone what is our gospel vision for the city. And so we've been in this series called For the Good of Brooklyn because we've been seeing how the gospel not only comes in and transforms your individual personal life, but then it goes out into community and out into the world and our shared lives together in order for the renewal of all things. But over the past two weeks, including this week, we're first starting by looking at our hearts. What the gospel does and what it says in our very first hearts, which is why last week we looked at the prodigal son, the parable of the prodigal son. And in that passage, we actually saw how Jesus really redefines what religion is, right?

3:42 He's a really surprising person in what he says and how you are now supposed to connect with God. And what he's doing there is really drastically changing our view of what we consider sin, the thing that separates us from God. And in the prodigal son, we learn that it's not so much rule-breaking or about your moral behaviors. It's much more about relationship-breaking. And today, sort of in a part two of the heart, we're going to look at sin as idolatry. Sin as idolatry that's going to help us to understand our hearts and what might rule and what might control our hearts. Now, if you've been at Redeemer for any amount of time, you know that idolatry is one of the key ideas and concepts that we really talk about a lot here. And so, again, in our Gospel DNA series, we're kind of hitting sort of the greatest hits. because we want us to all be on the same page. as we talk about these key critical ideas of what the gospel has to say in all of these important areas of our lives.

4:39 And so Ruth just read for us Romans chapter one. That is the classic New Testament text in what Paul talks about in Idolatry. He says this, that though we knew God and we were meant to worship him, we exchanged the truth about God for a lie and we worshiped the created things rather than the creator himself. Now what Paul is talking about here is that he is saying we are all made to worship. And therefore we all, no matter who we are, no matter what we believe, we all worship something. Either God, the true and living God, or something else. And whatever it is that we worship, that is the thing that rules and controls us, that motivates our actions. That is what makes us respond in a certain way. and whatever it is that we worship has the power to shape who it is that we are becoming. Now here's the problem that we're gonna look at today is that most of us are very unaware of what it is that we truly worship in our hearts.

5:40 Therefore, we don't really see what has control over our lives. We're not that aware of the maybe idols of our hearts, if that's a new term for you, what it is that our hearts might be worshiping or being ruled by. and therefore we wonder why our lives might always feel stuck, why we're always in conflict, or if you consider yourself a Christian, why you're not growing and experiencing the fullness of the life that Jesus promises in him. And Romans 1 is telling us that that is what leads, not understanding that and not rooting those things out, leads to not life but ultimately death. So the question that we're going to look at today is what is it that is ruling your heart today? What is ruling your heart? To help us to unpack that, we're gonna look at sort of three diagnostic tools. First, let's just help us to understand our hearts a little bit better.

6:32 Then we'll go a little bit deeper by giving a deeper diagnosis. And then finally, let's look at how you root out those idols. So let's understand, let's diagnose, and let's root it out. First, let's understand our hearts a little bit more. On Netflix, I just finished up this show that was obviously a very, very popular book called The Lord of the Flies. You guys know The Lord of the Flies. It's a classic book. Netflix did a great remake of it and I watched it in like one day. And it's probably one of those things that you were assigned to read in high school but you didn't actually read it. So Netflix is a great way to sort of understand the concepts of it. But if you know anything about the Lord of the Flies, It's basically these like elementary school boys who get, there's a plane crash, they get stranded on an island without any adult supervision. And it's sort of this innocence of all of these kids. that now have to learn to survive and to start creating a society relating with one another, to thinking about how they are now supposed to live together on this stranded island until somebody can come and rescue them.

7:36 And of course, in the story, it goes from starting this society to that society very quickly unraveling. There's a lot of chaos. There's violence. There is even death that's in the book. And when that starts to happen, it's intentionally making the author's point, right? The author who is William Golding, who wrote this back sort of in World War II, because he was trying to make the point that what is wrong with the world is not just corrupt systems or a bad upbringing or bad education or these external factors that a lot of people like to blame. as to what is ultimately wrong with the world. But he was trying to make the point, and this show in the book makes the point, that the problem is ultimately not out there, but it is in here. It is inside every single human heart, even in the most innocent-looking children stranded on an island.

8:29 And I read a little bit more about this idea, in William Golding. He said that he was basically trying to write this novel to push back against the prevailing thought at the time. of this naive human nature view that we are all essentially just good people. And that if we just had the right forces or factors happening around us, then we could thrive. And therefore, all the problems of this world are external to us. But in the book, he shows that it's these external circumstances that only bring out what was ultimately and always within us, in every single one of our hearts. That when you remove these restraints, the restraints of society, you see every single heart's bent toward domination, toward approval, toward violence, or toward self-preservation. So it's a really fascinating story as well as a greatly made show, so I would encourage it to you. But for us today, I would say while the Bible has much more of a holistic and a hopeful view and an understanding of a human being and their hearts, it is also not naive about the nature of a human heart.

9:38 The Bible is absolutely not naive to the nature of the heart. Jeremiah 17, 9 says, the heart is deceitful above all things. Who can understand it? The Bible is saying that all of the behaviors that we have in our hearts, we don't even know why we do what we do because there's a lot of factors that's going on in our hearts that we're not even conscious of. And Romans 1, our passage, is sort of taking that idea even further and helping us to understand why our hearts are the way that they are. Our passage says it's because we suppress the truth and exchange the truth about God for a lie by worshiping the created things rather than the creator himself. So the Apostle Paul, he is going now deeper into revealing this foundational truth about our hearts that we all have to understand. And if you don't understand this, you will always be a mystery to yourself. And that is, we are prone to worshiping.

10:34 We are always going to worship something. That is what is really wrong with us if we worship the wrong thing, and that thing takes control over our lives and our behaviors. And again, this is the classic text on idolatry, because it's essentially saying if you don't worship God, you're worshiping any other thing that's not him that is created in order. And idolatry doesn't look like weird temple worship. None of us have idolatry like that. But idolatry, therefore, because it is stemming from the heart, is simply an inordinate desire for something, anything. An over-desire for anything in your life that is not God. Which is why oftentimes we say that idolatry is looking to anything else other than God for only what God can ultimately give to you. and therefore, in our idolatry, we can turn good things, really, really good things, and we can turn them into ultimate things, loving good things in the wrong order, and that is when all the things go awry within our hearts, in our communities, and in our world.

11:46 Because now you have to have this one thing that you have this inordinate desire for, and you will do anything to get it. Now, again, we talk a lot about idolatry. You might say, okay, well, I know in concept what that idolatry is. But again, the risk for us is not understanding or not seeing what it is that we have an idolatry over. And so here's a test in order to help to show or maybe start to unpack some of the layers of our hearts as to what it is that you and I might be over-desiring in our lives. and one way to do that is to ask the daydreaming and nightmare test, which is why in our five minutes of fellowship we ask, what is it that you daydream about? See, the daydream test is really, really simple. It is, what does your mind and your heart most easily think about when you don't have to think about anything? What is it that you so deeply desire to want to happen, a good thing that your mind just starts to drift into, easily is always captured by?

12:47 I always think about when I, before I was a pastor, I worked in finance here in New York City, and I used to have this coworker who got this big bonus, and he would sort of confess to me at the water cooler. He would say, David, I just like looking at my bank account every day. I just like staring at it. He was just sort of, in some ways, lusting over what that number was providing him. Safety, security, satisfaction, approval, lots of things. His mind was just day drift into that number and what he had. That's the daydream test. For us, it might be, you know, five-bedroom brownstones, right? Or whatever it is, a perfect family, perfect kids, whatever that might be for you. What do you naturally dream about? But here's the flip side of that to sort of identify what your idols might be. That's the nightmare test. What is it that if it happened, what is that worst-case scenario that if it happened, you would almost lose the will to live to continue on in life what is the worst case scenario that you want to avoid at all costs?

13:59 A ruined relationship, a ruined reputation, your family not turning out the way that you've always imagined it to be? What is the thing that you would say, I'd rather die than for that to actually happen? See, now you're starting to think a little bit more about what is it in my own heart that I might be holding as an idol. And I want us to just understand that these are not bad things, right? These are all probably really, really good things, but idolatry is essentially finding and seeking your ultimate satisfaction and your ultimate meaning in those created things. That's simply what idolatry is, which makes us all idolaters, right? And the reason, therefore, we create idols, what Romans is telling us, is because, again, we're made to worship something. We cannot eliminate God in our lives without creating God's substitutes. And so worshiping an idol, giving your ultimate satisfaction and meaning to some other thing is always a way for us to try to control our own lives and get what we really want apart from God.

15:05 Sounds really similar to the prodigal son from last week, right? Both sons are doing whatever they wanted to to try to get what they really wanted apart from relationship with God. That is essentially what idolatry is. And in our passage in verses 21 and 22, Paul calls idolatry ultimately foolishness. In foolishness, our hearts and our minds are darkened because when we worship an idol and not God, we are ultimately choosing death and not life, which is really subversive because idols always seem to promise us life at first. Here's a well-worn quote from Andy Crouch that I use all the time. You probably memorized it by now, but let me read it for you again. Annie Crouch says this. All idols begin by offering great things for a very small price. All idols then fail more and more consistently to deliver on their original promises. while ratcheting up their demands, which initially seemed so reasonable for worship and sacrifice.

16:04 In the end, they fail completely, even as they make categorical demands. Idols ask for more and more while giving less and less. until they eventually demand everything and give nothing. you need to understand that all of our hearts are wired toward this idolatry. John Calvin, the reformer, says that we are idol-making factories. This is the first thing that you need to first understand. about what is controlling your life. But I want us to go a little bit deeper here in the second point. See, when you read Lord of the Flies or when you watch Lord of the Flies, one of the astounding things in that show is that you see that sin is not random, and it's not that some people were just born good and others were born bad, But all of the boys' behaviors, you start to see, are ultimately driven by these deeper desires that they each have. desires to want to dominate another person or a desire to want to belong.

17:02 or a desire to want to keep order, right? So it's not just about who gets to say what. There is this controlling principle that motivates every single one of their behaviors. In other words, we have these surface idols. Fine, call it career, call it family, call it relationships, call it whatever, call it your resume. There are these surface level idols, but what we really need to get to, a deeper diagnosis, is to understand what are the deeper idols underneath it that's truly controlling what it is I live for and how. And there are typically four dominant, deeper idols that I want to walk us through. It might have already been pretty painful with your nightmare test, but we're actually going to get a little bit more. It's going to be a little bit more painful. Just stay with me here for a second. But we're going to go through four deeper idols that people are typically prone toward, which is power, approval, comfort, or control.

17:59 First, let's look at power. Power is the over-desire for significance, and it comes through success or winning and competing or having influence. And so if you're prone to this deeper idol of power, the defining characteristics are usually that you always want to be right, you always like to be the best, and you love being the winner at all costs. Therefore, you don't shy away from competition. You bring competition all around to you, and you're usually driven by a lot of status. But therefore, the thing that you fear the most, ultimately, is humiliation, right? Or having any sense of meaninglessness. And therefore, you want to avoid at all costs feeling significant. And how you know if this is an idol for you is that the people around you tend to feel very used by you. And you'll have a lot of anger as one of your dominant emotions that come up.

18:59 Because you're so demanding and you're condescending to the people around you and you're critical of others. because that's how you start to feel superior over other people. That is a powered idol that is coming up. Well, here's a second one, and that is approval. That is the over-desire to please and to receive affirmation and acceptance through relationships. So now this is someone who is always actively seeking out situations where they feel particularly needed because they are looking for praise and positive feedback from their relationships. And therefore, as you can probably tell, the worst case scenario, the fear in this sense, is having rejection and displeasing other people. And therefore, people who struggle with this particular idol will usually contort themselves in all different sorts of ways in order to give other people what they want, in order to be accepted.

19:52 and therefore obviously people will be wanting to avoid conflict in their lives and therefore people around them, these are people that are really caring, really, really loving, but people around them might often feel smothered by them. And these are also people that might always feel like they are a chameleon, but then therefore there is no real vulnerability and no real intimacy in a relationship with other people. And one of the signs, the emotions that might be coming up if this is something that you struggle with is cowardice. And so oftentimes people don't know what their true preferences are, what their likes and dislikes are because they never share it because they might think that if they share it, they're gonna displease people. And so they cower from sharing those thoughts and those feelings. So that's the approval idol. I told you, it's gonna be painful for a little bit. The third one, comfort.

20:47 Comfort is the over-desire for avoiding pain and stress by seeking lots of freedom from responsibility and expectations. So what might typically come up in someone who struggles with comfort is that you need immediate gratification or instant pain relief, usually through compulsive or addictive behaviors. So this is someone who might be very disconnected from their emotions, someone who zones out a lot or is always seeking to escape whatever the situation is through Netflix or golf or anything else that you might want to do. And therefore, the great fear is that they have to take on more stress or more responsibility. Therefore, they might exude a lot of passive aggressiveness, avoidancy, and a lot of self-isolation. And how you might know that this is you is that people around you often feel neglected if this is your idol.

21:41 And the last one is control. Control is the over-desire for certainty, always by trying to do something about it. So people who struggle with control are very hard workers, very disciplined, very, very productive, and usually perfectionists. Because their greatest fears is uncertainty, not knowing what the future holds, and not being able to do anything about it. And also, therefore, criticism is something that people deeply, deeply want to avoid. because criticism makes them feel incompetent and that incompetence makes them feel like I can't fix the thing that I'm supposed to fix and stay in control. And if this is your particular idol that you struggle with, the people around you will often feel condemned because they're never good enough and you are always evaluating their performance or at least they feel like you are always evaluating their performance.

22:34 And the problem of emotion that will come up here is anxiety and worry. If I didn't do enough, then something bad is going to happen. How are we doing? Good. Here's the thing I want us to avoid here in this moment. That because we don't want to actually see our heart's desires, it's much easier to spend this time analyzing the other people around you in your life. Don't do that. Don't do it to your roommate or to your sister or to your spouse or to your kids. say, hey, you struggle with this idol. Avoid doing that. Instead, do the hard work of actually seeing what it is that you might be struggling in. And if you're anything like me, you might say, well, Pastor, what happens if you got all four of these? Do I win the bingo card? Because as I walk through this, I see in my own heart how I struggle with every single one of these as well.

23:31 And here's the thing that you got to see. This isn't like a personality type, right? There are absolutely ways that a lot of these things can overlap all the time. And you have to realize the reason for that is that this isn't just a personality type, even though you might have a dominant way in which you have a deeper controlling idol. These are ultimately heart strategies that we will use in any given moment or any given season. in order to try to save ourselves, in order to get what we really want. Remember, idols are these false gods that we can turn to, and therefore, any one of these can become false gods that we turn to in order to get whatever it is that we want and crave in that particular season. So you might find yourself pinging back and forth between all four of them, or you might see a recurring theme of a dominant one that starts to shed a little bit of light as to why you react and respond a particular way, why your relationships usually always look like this or that. Why you're not experiencing the fullness of Christ and the reality of the gospel in your own life.

24:35 And this is really helpful and important for us to understand why it is that we sin. Again, we've been saying sinning is so much more than just immoral behaviors. You've got to understand what it is that is animating why you cheat or lie or why you steal. Because idolatry is telling us that ultimately it is a heart issue, not a behavior issue. It is an inordinate desire for something. And in any given moment in which you sin or have some kind of immoral behavior, it is always because something else in that moment has become more important to you than God. You desire something else more than you desire God. That is why the great reformer, Martin Luther, when talking about the Ten Commandments, he says, there is not a single person in this world that can ever break the entire nine commandments without first and foremost breaking the first commandment.

25:29 You shall have no other gods before me. Because he understands how the heart works. That we're meant to worship him, but idolatry is worshiping anything else other than him. So examine yourself. What is it that's going on in your life? Why is it that you might struggle to have healthy relationships? What kind of conflicts do you constantly have? Do you feel like you use people? Do people feel neglected around you? Do you always feel you have to please people? Why is it that you overwork or why is it that you underwork? What is underneath that that is controlling you, moving you to act in a certain kind of way? That's why Romans 1 is so concerned with what it is that we worship, what it is that you and I worship. This is what is at stake. And that's also why we've said that the gospel needs to first come into your heart. what Jesus has done for you.

26:23 He needs to first come into your heart to do surgery at the heart level. Otherwise, you will never truly change if you're only focused on your outward behaviors. You will only grow more frustrated as to why you are not changing and why these things continue to come up in your life. You've gotta first identify what are the deep idols that you have. We gotta learn to root them out if we really wanna experience the renewing grace of what Jesus has done. Well, so then last point is this. How is it, Pastor David, that we can root these things out of our hearts? Because again, here's the other risk. Sometimes we just feel better about ourselves because we've identified it. Ah, we've done this work, I see. And if I see, then surely I will change. I know myself more, and therefore I must be able to change. That's not how true change works. And I think if you consider yourself a Christian, there are these two pitfalls that we can usually fall into.

27:20 that are not effective in rooting out idols. First is if we start moralizing the situation. When you only focus on the outward behavior and you say, hey, you gotta repent. You gotta do better. You know you're not supposed to do that. So just do better. That's behavior modification. That is moralizing. Or we can go on the other side of it and we start to psychologize things where we don't focus just on the moral behaviors but we can just focus on our feelings, our inward feelings. And we say, ah, but God loves me, so it's okay. Let us rejoice.

27:59 Both of those are not going deep enough into the heart for real change because it is not ultimately reorienting our deeply held beliefs. It is not hacking down the idols that is deeply controlling our lives. You see, under every single one of our behavioral sins is idolatry. But under every bit of our idolatry is ultimately some disbelief in the gospel and who God is and what he has done for us, which means if we really want to root it out of our lives, we have to take the gospel deep into the recesses of our hearts. and to truly rejoice in what he's done for us. And therefore, applying the gospel will always have both of those ideas of repentance, seeing the sin for what it is, seeing how idolatry is utter foolishness, that it only leads to death.

28:54 And so you want to turn away from those things. And at the same time, seeing the beauty, therefore, of what Christ has done for you so you can rejoice that he gives you something greater, more suitable, more graciously, the very thing that you are looking for in every single one of these idols. That is what gospel repentance and faith looks like. That is how you root out an idol. Because your heart will never ever change by just trying to tell it to change. You can't tell your heart to stop loving what it loves. What you need is a greater love to come in and drive that thing out. You need something more beautiful than the thing that you're looking for. to overtake and overwhelm your heart. That is what Thomas Chalmers of Puritan, he calls the expulsive power of affection. Here's a great quote from him.

29:47 He says this. He says, Idols cannot be expelled, just driven out. They have to be replaced. The human heart's desire for a particular object may be conquered, but its need to have some such object is unconquerable. The heart is so constituted that the only way to dispossess it of an old affection is by the expulsive power of a new one. It cannot be by willpower or just restraint. You cannot just drive out your idol and say, do better. It's gotta be replaced by a greater affection, truly rejoicing in what Jesus has done for you and how he gives you more beautifully the very thing that you and I are all looking for. That is how you learn to apply the gospel. And so if you or I here are struggling with this idol of power in our lives, what is it that we are ultimately looking for?

30:41 We are looking for significance in our lives. And do you know what Jesus gives to you? Do you know what Jesus does? He says, I'm going to come not in dominance even though I am the king, but I'm going to come in utter weakness, so much weakness that I'm willing to lay my life down in order to die for you, not to take over your life, but to give you life. I'm not gonna come in power and domination. I'm going to lay it down so that you can know. you have ultimate significance in me. That the God of the universe would die for you to come in that kind of weakness?

31:18 That makes you incredibly significant, more than any other thing in this world. If you're struggling with the idol of approval, what are you ultimately seeking? We're looking for love. And you gotta see how Jesus, who was utterly loved by God the Father and the Holy Spirit, comes to earth to be completely rejected. He takes on our sin, the thing that does not make us lovable or acceptable, and he pays that price. He is completely cast out. Why? So that you and I can know that there is nothing we could not only do to earn his love, but therefore nothing we can ever do to lose his love. That you are utterly loved and accepted because he was first rejected for you.

32:09 If you struggle with comfort, what is it that we are looking for? We want peace. And you gotta see Jesus, he doesn't avoid pain. He doesn't avoid stress, but yet he leaves the peace of home. And on the cross, he enters into brokenness. He enters into hardship. He enters into death. Why? So that you can have ultimate peace that no circumstance can ever take away.

32:43 And friends, for those of us who are struggling with control, what is it that we really want? We want certainty. And the cross becomes the ultimate proof to us who are struggling with control, myself included. And it becomes the ultimate answer to the question of our hearts. am I going to be okay? Is this going to turn out for my good? Am I doing enough? Am I enough? And on the cross, Jesus dies the death that you and I should have died to give us the life that we never deserved in order to secure a sure future for us. And he says you can let go of control. You can trust me because I'm willing to go to, I'm willing to move heaven and earth for you to know that I will do everything in my power. and I have done everything in my power for your ultimate good, for your ultimate peace.

33:36 Friends, this is why only Jesus gives our hearts everything that we are looking for. You cannot just be emptied of worship of something else. You've got to be redirecting that to what he has done in the gospel. This is what it means to do surgery on your heart at that deep level. And when you do, friends, you will see the foolishness of seeking comfort, peace, and security in anything else. and you will start to experience true life, real freedom, real hope, real peace, real joy, real love, real acceptance that only Jesus can give.

Machine translated from the source