Dr. Todd Smedley | Water from the Rock

Dr. Todd Smedley · Christ Covenant Church · Published May 26, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Scripture reading: Exodus 17:1-7 0:32
1Then the whole congregation of Israel left the Desert of Sin, moving from place to place as the LORD commanded. They camped at Rephidim, but there was no water for the people to drink. 2So the people contended with Moses, “Give us water to drink.” “Why do you contend with me?” Moses replied. “Why do you test the LORD?” 3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?” 4Then Moses cried out to the LORD, “What should I do with these people? A little more and they will stone me!” 5And the LORD said to Moses, “Walk on ahead of the people and take some of the elders of Israel with you. Take along in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile, and go. 6Behold, I will stand there before you by the rock at Horeb. And when you strike the rock, water will come out of it for the people to drink.” So Moses did this in the sight of the elders of Israel. 7He named the place Massah and Meribah because the Israelites quarreled, and because they tested the LORD, saying, “Is the LORD among us or not?”

Berean Standard Bible (public domain).

Transcript

0:32 All the congregation of the people of Israel moved on from the wilderness of sin by stages, according to the commandment of the Lord, and camped at Rephidim. But there was no water for the people to drink. Therefore, the people quarreled with Moses and said, Give us water to drink. Moses said to them, Why do you quarrel with me? Why do you test the Lord? But the people thirsted there for water, and the people grumbled against Moses and said, Why did you bring us up out of Egypt to kill us and our children and our livestock with thirst? So Moses cried to the Lord, What shall I do with this people? They are almost ready to stone me. And the Lord said to Moses, Pass on before the people, taking with you some of the elders of Israel, and take in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile, and go.

1:30 Behold, I will stand before you there on the rock at Horeb. You shall strike the rock, and water shall come out of it, and the people will drink. And Moses did so in the sight of the elders of Israel, and he called the name of the place Massah and Meribah because of the quarreling of the people of Israel and because they tested the Lord by saying, Is the Lord among us or not? Let's pray together. Gracious God of light and wisdom, as we come to your word today, we pray for the light of your spirit to illumine the truth of your word today, not only to the informing of our minds, to the renewing of our minds, but the shaping and renewing of our hearts. We ask, Father, that you would take this word sown in weakness and raise it to everlasting power that those here this morning who sense your distance, those who are far from you or do not know you, that you would open their hearts wide to the marvelous love that you've offered in Christ and that those of us who do know you, you would root us deeper within Christ today.

2:52 As we seek to find him in your word today, Lord, give us the ability to do so. And in so showing us Christ in your word, you would cause our hearts to burn within us with joy and praise to your name. We ask this in Christ. Amen. Is the Lord among us or not? Now that is a loaded question, isn't it? That's how our text ends this morning. Is the Lord among us or not? Of course, the way that it's asked, the answer is obvious. He is not among us, according to the people of Israel at this point. Not only is this a question that ends our text this morning, but it might be a question that you've walked into this sanctuary this morning with. Is the Lord with me or is he not? Because there's a lot of circumstances and situations in each of our lives, of course, if you've walked with the Lord for any amount of time, where you have sensed the Lord's distance.

3:45 You have sensed a season of drought, of being parched in your soul. And you've been suspicious for long enough. You don't articulate it in church, of course. But you've been suspicious long enough to wonder, is he really with me? Is he for me? Because what I'm experiencing now is a spiritual drought. Sometimes we're in those positions and in those places because we've put ourselves there. and when we ask the question where are you God and why have you moved away from me the response back if we were to listen carefully would be guess who moved you moved because we've neglected the means of grace we've we've neglected and and forsaken the lord's day worship or we have we've not engaged in the sacraments of the lord's supper and and appreciated the wonders of of the waters of baptism or we have not drunk deeply recently of the Word of God on our own or been engaged in prayer or in loving fellowship with other brothers and sisters. Sometimes we have wandered into dry, dusty, and weary places because we have brought ourselves there. There are other times, though, that God sovereignly allows us to end up in those places. In fact, He calls us to places of of spiritual dehydration or spiritual testing. You know that the hand of the Lord deliberately and sometimes leads us to those places to test us, to stretch us. He's done that already for Israel a number of times up to this point in Exodus. He has done things and put the people of Israel in places where they have known the testing of the Lord. And these are designed not to be places where God brings us to leave us there, that we might stay there, but so that we might just, as he says here, camp there for a season, set up our tent for the moment to lead us through it.

5:41 And he puts us in these places not because he's a cruel or unkind father, because he enjoys somehow that you don't sense his presence, or that somehow he takes delight in the fact that you feel spiritually dry and parched. He brings us to those places so that our roots in Christ in particular might grow deeper, right? Just like a tree that is in a dry land would receive signals from the leaves that they are parched and send signals down to the roots to go deeper so that it might find water. So too the Lord does this for us so that we might be there for a season. And that's what he's doing to the people of Israel here as he directly commands them, our text tells us, to this dry place called Rephidim. The Lord moved them from the wilderness of sin by stages according to the commandment of the Lord. The word for commandment there actually isn't commandment, it's the word mouth. And I don't know whether or not they actually heard or perhaps Moses heard directly from the mouth of the Lord, but whatever we're to understand of that word, they were called by God directly to go to Rephidim. And on one of the rare occasions in the book of Exodus, the people of Israel do what the Lord said. Isn't it amazing? They go, and they go with Moses to Rephidim, a place that we're told is called a resting place. But they were soon to discover that although it was a resting place, it wasn't a refreshing place. It's like being on a long road trip with children. You get to the rest stop, and you find that all the vending machines are either empty or out of order. The water fountain doesn't work, and your kids are quarreling.

7:22 This is no refreshing place, although it is a resting place. And so these people, the people of Israel, although obedient in verse 1, by going to Rephidim by the mouth of the Lord, calling them to go, now, like us, can flip the switch so easily from obedience in one moment, in one breath, to sin and rebellion in verse 2. And they quarreled with Moses. Isn't it shocking how we can go from moments of obedience, of spiritual refreshment to moments and seasons of sin. It's shocking to us that the very thing sometimes we pray and ask the Lord would deliver us from, as soon as we say amen, we find ourselves falling into again. Lord, have mercy on us because this is us, Israel. Although we have, oftentimes, it's easy to point the finger at Israel. It points the finger at us too.

8:16 Consider all the things that they've been through. I know you're a church that knows your Bibles well. You're steeped in faithful teaching and preaching of the word. You know that they've already seen the Lord carry out ten plagues. They've seen the Lord deliver them from Pharaoh in Egypt. They've seen the Lord divide the waters, the Red Sea, that they might go through and then collapse the waters in judgment upon their enemies so that they might go free and worship the Lord. And in chapter 15, there's been joy and praise and worship and delight in God's presence. And then they come to the waters of Massa, and they find that it's toxic water, and the Lord changes the toxic water, the bitter water, into clean water. And then they're wondering where food is as the Lord tests them again, and he gives them manna from heaven. And in addition to that, he gives them the protein of quail. And now today they come through all their deprivation, and yet God's provision, and they're still grumbling that there is no water. Now, the word for grumbling here is a strong word. It's not the kind of grumbling your children are doing in the car on a long road trip asking whether or not we're there or how much longer till we get there.

9:29 This is a word that communicates in the original an outright rebellion. This is escalated not only with the word grumbling, but more so, even more egregious, the word quarreling with them. That word kind of ups the ante. They're striving against the Lord, and Moses here, on behalf of the Lord, with hostility, a sense of striving against God because he's at fault. Why would you lead us here to have us die of thirst and our children? Notice who they're complaining against. And Moses said to them, why do you quarrel with me? Why do you test the Lord? As if Moses is somehow able to provide them water, as if somehow Moses knew that there was going to be no supply to slake their thirst. It's like a person who works at a particular place, and they don't make the rules, they don't supply the shelves, but they just bring you up at the counter, and you rail against them, and they say, you need to talk to a higher authority here.

10:34 You need to talk to my boss. I just work here. I don't make the rules. I can go get my boss if you'd like. You know those kind of people that rail against folks, especially in airports when the weather's bad. And all the flights are canceled and tempers are flaring and people are raging and raising their voice and the poor woman or man behind the counter is thinking, you need to appeal to a higher authority. I don't control the weather. I didn't cancel the flight. I'm just here trying to get you on another flight. And it's clear that you're upset, and it's clear that there's nothing I can do about it, and it's clear that you think you are a very important person that needs to get somewhere very important. Reminds me of a story of my sister-in-law, who was in the airport at one point, on such an occasion where many of the flights were canceled, and people were upset, of course, and this one guy goes up to the counter of the woman behind the counter at the gate, and he begins to slam on the counter, and he says, do you know who I am? Don't you know who I am? And after enough of this and people beginning to be embarrassed for him, he's the only one who wasn't embarrassed, the woman cleverly picks up the microphone and clicks over the loudspeaker and says, excuse me, I'm sorry to interrupt, but does anyone know who this man is? Because apparently he's forgotten.

11:49 It's like Israel here is saying to them, do you know who we are? We're God's people. Why would he bring us here? And we might pick up the words from the apostle Peter if we were to hear God answer. He'd say, yeah, you were once a people. You were once not a people, but you're now my people. You were once a people who did not know mercy, but now you know mercy. and of all times and occasions when you needed mercy, it's today at Rephidim. You're grumbling and arrogance against me.

12:26 I'm going to supply with water. I want to highlight the word to test here. Why do you test the Lord? Remember, the Lord is the one who does the testing. As we said, when there was no bread in chapter 16, verse 4, we're told that God was testing the people, that their roots might go deeper. and he tests them here. But now the unthinkable happens. They flip the tables on the Lord and they test the Lord according to Moses. Their audacity and the arrogance here is chilling. It's, as it were, to put God on trial, to put him on the witness stand, to take him off the judge's seat, to put themselves on the judge's seat, and to put him on the witness stand. More is happening here than we might at first appreciate in the 21st century in America. God here is clearly being brought into a courtroom in a criminal case, and he's the guilty party. And they're the ones that are quarreling, contending, and testing the Lord. That's why he calls these places Massa and Meribah. These are legal terms.

13:36 It's their terms for quarreling. It's terms often used in a lawsuit in bringing someone under prosecution. The covenant-making God with Israel, who were once not a people, who are now a people, are now being prosecuted by his people who he has redeemed, who he called out from their enslavement in Israel or in Egypt to go into the wilderness to worship him, are now prosecuting him.

14:06 Why would God bring us out here to kill us? This isn't just a civil case. This is a criminal case. This is a capital offense. This is the essence of your sin and mine, isn't it? The tyranny of sin that so often we take too lightly. I know I do, and I'm sure when you're honest with yourself, you do as well. But our sin in the face of God, in particular, our grumbling, even in the place of God's provision, is treasonous. It's a high hand of tyrannical sin against the Almighty God. This is the picture of what I do and you do when I say yes to myself, when I know better than the Lord, when I wonder where he is and call him into question, and I subpoena him to my court. And he's the one who has to answer my questions, to call his wisdom, his timing, his goodness, his presence into question. So they're here at Massa and Meribah, legal names of places of proceeding to take place here.

15:00 Here's the subpoena to God. The first one is this. Here's the charge. Give us water to drink. since it was you who led us here, O Lord. The second charge, why did you bring us here to die? The third charge, is God among us or not? They are doubting and questioning God's provision, his protection, and his presence. His provision, though, has already been given by the manna and the quail and about to be by the water. His protection has already been proven in guiding them out of Egypt and through the waters of judgment in the Red Sea. and his presence has already been proven and confirmed by the pillar of fire and cloud in the wilderness. They're visible before them. Of course God is with you. But they charge him of this capital offense. You brought us out here and our children to die of thirst. You brought us out here to kill us. And that's why they begin to look for rocks, for stones to pick up to stone Moses because you only stone someone when it's a capital offense.

16:03 picking up rocks to throw at God. C.S. Lewis, you might know, wrote a book called God in the Dock, and he says this, the ancient man approached God as the accused person approaches his judge, but the modern man, the roles are quite reversed. He is the judge, and God is in the dock. He is quite a kindly judge. If God should have a reasonable defense for being the God who permits war, poverty, and disease, he's ready to listen to it. The trial may even end in God's acquittal, but the important thing is that man is on the bench, and God is in the dock. This is what they're doing, putting God on the witness chair, demanding that He justify Himself.

16:46 Now, let me say for a moment here to people who've walked in today, who do feel the distance of the Lord. if you're in a period of dryness spiritually, I want to say you're not alone. A lot of people walked in here this morning. It's not wrong to ask God where he's gone. When your motivation is not to call him into question, but to genuinely want to know his intimacy again. To experience his presence afresh again. It's not wrong when our motivation is to draw near to him. It's wrong when our motivation is to put him on trial, to call into question his wisdom. Lord, why are you so distant to me? Isn't a wrong question when asked appropriately. Do you think he's up in heaven with his arms folded thinking, well, I just wondered and waited for you to ask this question.

17:46 No, of course, he's a kind father. He wants you to know his presence and his nearness. Think about a child. Many of you who have had children when they were toddlers go through periods of time where they struggle with separation and anxiety from their parents. You can imagine a scenario where a toddler is in a grocery store and rounds the corner ahead of mom or dad and goes into the next aisle literally just a few feet away and panic strikes the child. And dad, the father, walks around the corner and the child looks up, tears, screaming, flailing, why did you leave me? Why did you, where have you been? And the father doesn't look down at the child and say, and reason with them, I didn't leave you, you actually wandered away from me. You do that all the time and look at the result. No, the father doesn't reason with the child who's unreasonable, who feels the distance and is anxious because the father was not seen and known and experienced, but the father just silently picks up the child and holds.

18:50 So if that's where you are today, let me ask you to allow the Father to pick you up and to hold you. And if you're feeling thirsty, weary, and worn, let him hold you. but here Israel is not like that. To further clarify that this is a courtroom, their elders are present. Why do you bring elders? You bring elders to serve as the jury here, and that's why they're there, and so Moses cries out to the Lord for help. Lord, you need to help me deal with these people because they are about to pick up stones to kill me, and then here's how the Lord responds to their unjust accusations, to their crimes of high treason, to their quarreling against him, to their wondering whether or not yet God will provide, again, he puts himself in the dock. He's not held in contempt of court. He doesn't say what he had every reason to say.

19:51 Let me judge you all. Let me put you to the test. I will put you on trial. He voluntarily puts himself on the stand. He willingly submits himself, not to their judgment ultimately, but to his judgment for their judgment. verses 5 and 6 saying the Lord said to Moses pass on before the people taking with you some of the elders of Israel and take in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile and go behold and here's where he shows up I will stand before you there on the rock at Horeb and you shall strike the rock and water shall come out of it and the people will drink and Moses did so in the sight of the elders of Israel. Now think about the rod. Now here's where the people of Israel should have been nervous. As soon as the rod shows up, because whoever's on the other end of that rod, bad things happen, isn't it? This is the rod with which he struck the Nile to turn the water into blood. This is the rod with which he struck the dust of the desert to turn into gnats. This is the rod he used for the frogs. This is the rod he used for the hail, for the locust, on and on. This is the rod of judgment of the Lord. This staff of judgment now is not pointed at their enemy, not pointed at them, but pointed at the rock, at God who stands before on the rock. Behold, I stand before the rock at Horeb. The word before there is a word that clearly in the ancient world would have sent the message to them that God is there. He is the one who stands before them, not as the judge but as the one who is condemned because of their sin.

21:31 Zechariah 13.7 says, Awake, O sword, against my shepherd, against the man who stands next to me, declares the Lord of hosts. Strike the shepherd and the sheep will be scattered. I will turn my hand against the little ones. This text from Zechariah 13 is quoted by the Lord Jesus when he says to them right before he dies, all of you are going to abandon me when this shepherd is struck.

21:54 Isaiah 53, 5 says, He was pierced for our transgressions. He was crushed for our iniquities. Upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed. This rock is going to produce water, but not until it's struck with the rod of judgment. And God here stands before the rock to be judged.

22:23 For a people that test him, quarrel against him with hostility and arrogance. There's another story later in the Pentateuch in Numbers chapter 20, very, very similar to this one, where in that occasion, Moses is told, when you come to the rock, speak to the rock, and the rock will pour out abundant waters for your people. And Moses thinks to himself, I know better than the Lord. You know, last time he told me to strike the rock, so this time I'm not just going to speak to the rock. For good measure, I'm going to strike the rock twice. The very reason why Moses is not admitted into the promised land. Because Moses didn't need to strike the rock again because judgment and justice had already been served to God on that rock once. No longer needing to be struck because judgment was meted out in full by God himself. Who and what is this rock? You already know because the point was given away in our New Testament reading.

23:19 That Christ is the rock. but they didn't need 1 Corinthians 10 because Deuteronomy 32 already said multiple times that God is their rock. Psalm 78, as well as many other places, Psalm 78 says he splits rocks in the wilderness and gave them drink abundantly from the deep. He made streams come out of the rock and cause waters to flow down like rivers. Verse 20, Psalm 78, he struck the rock so that water gushed out and streams overflowed. Verse 35, they remembered that God was their rock, the most high God, their redeemer. that rock was their savior and ours. And so here he shows us through this visual image of what he would do in flesh and blood through his son.

24:04 They all drank the same spiritual drink and they drank from the same spiritual rock that followed them and the rock was Christ. This is a glorious picture, my friends, of the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ where on the cross of Calvary he receives capital punishment for capital crimes that he didn't commit. And because he struck there on the cross and flowing from his side is blood and water, as we'll sing in a moment, let the water and the blood from his riven side which flowed be of sin, a double cure, cleanse me from its guilt and power. Because he was struck and because he took the judgment and the wrath of God, he is the water of life John 7 if anyone thirsts let him come to me and drink whoever believes in me as scripture has said out of his heart will flow rivers of living water this same Lord Jesus Christ is the one too who was sovereignly thrust into a weary dry wilderness to be tempted by Satan with no food and no water there to be tested and there the devil and all of his evil tempted Jesus to throw himself down from the temple saying that God would save him and Jesus says you shall not put the Lord your God to the test and yet the Lord Jesus took on that test as he hung on the cross for you and for me Israel here is putting God to the test and rarely does God respond to us in our behavior like that proportionately to our grumbling, to our sin, to our wandering to our high treasonous offense but he responds proportionately as the wrath and rod of judgment strikes the sun the rock, Jesus Christ where his wrath is in direct proportion against sin towards the sinless one.

26:12 Christ never tested God, but he obeyed God and was crucified. We tested and got water. life-giving water. He was tested and he got judgment, struck by the wrath of God. He went before God's holy tribunal, the court of heaven, and he was punished. And the rod of God's just wrath struck him on the cross. And what we get in return is life-giving water. John Newton puts this text to poetry to hymns and his only hymns and here's what he says when Israel's tribes were parched with thirst forth from the rock the waters burst and all their future journey through yielded them drink and gospel too in Moses' rod a type they saw of his severe and fiery law the smitten rock prefigured him from whose pure side all blessings stream.

27:17 But ah, the types were all too faint. His sorrows were his worth to paint. Slight was the stroke of Moses' rod, but he endured the wrath of God. Their outward rock could feel no pain, but Christ was wounded, torn and slain. The rock gave but a watery flood, but Jesus poured forth streams of blood. The earth is like their wilderness, a land of drought and sore distress. without one stream from pole to pole to satisfy a thirsty soul. But let the Savior's praise resound. In him refreshing streams are found, which pardon, strength, and comfort give, and thirsty sinners drink and live. Let's pray together. Gracious God, our Heavenly Father, we thank you for your word.

28:13 We thank you, Father, for feeding us according to your word. I pray for any in here this morning who have felt your distance, who have either wandered from you or you in your mysterious providence have placed in a time of testing. And ask that you would cause their roots to sink deeper down into this wonderful gospel, this loving Christ who has endured the affliction, the abandonment that we'll never know so that we might know your nearest presence. Father, we pray that you would satisfy our thirsty and parched souls with Christ. You would give us the streams of water that flow from him and ask that your Holy Spirit would take all that is Christ's, all that he is to us, all that he has done for us, and that he would pour it directly into our hearts, that we might be overcome by this marvelous love, by this wondrous grace in which we stand, and that you might draw us nearer to yourself, and that we might never doubt your presence.

29:22 For truly in Christ, you are God with us. we give you the praise in Jesus name Amen

Machine translated from the source