Exodus 17:1-7

Guest speaker · Redeemer East Side · Redeemer East Side · Published December 28, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Exodus 17:3-7 0:35
3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?” 4Then Moses cried out to the LORD, “What should I do with these people? A little more and they will stone me!” 5And the LORD said to Moses, “Walk on ahead of the people and take some of the elders of Israel with you. Take along in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile, and go. 6Behold, I will stand there before you by the rock at Horeb. And when you strike the rock, water will come out of it for the people to drink.” So Moses did this in the sight of the elders of Israel. 7He named the place Massah and Meribah because the Israelites quarreled, and because they tested the LORD, saying, “Is the LORD among us or not?”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:22 Friends, it's good to be with you here last week of the year. Before we begin, let me begin with just a word of prayer for us. Father, may the words of my mouth and meditations of my heart be acceptable and pleasing in your sight. Oh, Lord, my rock and my redeemer. Amen. So you may have seen this Broadway show, but the Broadway show called Maybe Happy Ending, it follows two helper robots, Oliver and Claire. who discover one another and they develop this sort of connection with one another. as they discover and they explore life together. And so they spend their days living the same routines, remembering life with their former owners. And while at the same time, they're also longing for something more, some sort of deeper sense of connection ahead of them, some deeper purpose. And so the moment that they're living in right now, they're living in this sort of in-between space, no longer what they once were, but not yet what they hoped to be.

2:20 And so throughout the show, there's limited time and this in-between space that they find themselves in intensifies a quiet but also persistent question of, is anyone here with us? And so that question is actually not very far off from the one that Israel asked in the wilderness. They remember the miracles that God did to perform and liberate them from Egypt, and they've been promised in the future a better land than they could ever imagine. But right now, they're wandering. And so the days stretch on and the provision of food and water. it feels uncertain. And the wilderness has a way of shrinking memory and also magnifying need. And so for the Israelites, their freedom, it's achieved decisively. But learning how to live as free people is proving to be much harder. In other words, leaving Egypt happened quickly, but leaving Egypt behind is taking much longer. And so in Exodus 17, their question sharpens into this accusation that we read in verse seven, is the Lord among us or not? That question doesn't come out of nowhere, but this question actually grows out of weariness. And as we'll see, weariness in the wilderness, it doesn't remain neutral. It actually hardens into an accusation and then it actually provokes a response from God. And yet the very fact that they asked this question, it still matters. There's still hope left underneath that question. Similarly, many of us may have reached year end, prompted to reflect back on this past year. And yet at the same time, we kind of look forward to the following year, hopeful of what next year can look like. And so today you might be sitting here asking that same question of, is the Lord among us or not?

4:09 And so today we're going to walk through three realities that we see in the wilderness. First, weariness in the wilderness, judgment in the wilderness, and then finally God in the wilderness. So first, we're going to take a look at weariness in the wilderness to understand why this question even gets asked in the first place. We need to remember why we and where we are in the story. And so we've been making our way through the book of Exodus. And so today's passage that we just read is actually in, comes as a part of a series of tests. So in the span of three months, Israel faces three major trials. In chapter 15, they grumble for water, and then God makes bitter water sweet again. And then chapter 16, they grumble for bread, and then God gives manna and bread from heaven. And then now in chapter 17, they find themselves once again without water, grumbling and quarreling as they wander through the desert. And I think it's easy for us as readers to kind of look at these chapters back to back and think, these Israelites, they just don't get it, right? When are they going to learn? And how many more miracles does God need to perform in order for them to get it through to their heads? Maybe some of you have thought this before. Maybe you've said, if I saw God split the Red Sea, if I saw any of these miracles, I would definitely believe. I would have no doubts. But I think for us as readers, the test is always easier when you have the answers in front of you. And there's a reason why these stories are placed one after another after another. They're not just showing us Israel's stubbornness. They're exposing a deeper issue that Israel struggles with. And it's also a mirror for what we struggle with as well, weariness and forgetfulness. And so this passage is showing us that weariness, it's not neutral, but weariness slowly reshapes how we see God. And on a very real level, dehydration in a climate like this, in a Sinai desert, can become very life-threatening, not just in a matter of days, but in a matter of hours. And if you've ever gone without water for

6:16 a significant period of time, you know how quickly this can affect your body, your thinking, your emotions. But there's a deeper level to this as well. Verse one tells us that they arrived at this place according to the commandment of the Lord. So they're in this situation because they followed God. So imagine this with me. The Israelites grabbed what they could. They fled Egypt, crossed the Red Sea, and now they've been wandering the desert, trusting that God will continue to provide. It's one trial after another, and they are exhausted.

6:50 And maybe what they're feeling is something like, God, we just got through the last one. Can you just give it a break? And I wonder how many of us know what that feeling is like, that we just got over this difficult season, but there's another exam, There's another diagnosis, another bill, another complication. You're tired. It's your end. You're weary.

7:12 And maybe some of you are in a particular situation right now because you were honestly trying to follow what you believed God was calling you to do. And instead of clarity, it feels like you've been brought to a dead end, a place with no water. But when we zoom out and we read the Bible story, it's incredibly clear that at every test, every trial, God has proven himself to be the rescuer, their provider. But the thing is, when you are weary, you don't live zoomed out. You live zoomed in and zoomed in. We have this tunnel vision where the only thing that matters right now is the problem or the pain or the trial that's right in front of you. And it's because weariness makes the heart forget. And it's when we're weary that past evidence, it feels irrelevant. Future feels abstract. And the only thing that feels real amidst real difficulty is the present moment. And I think this is the issue with our hearts. One pastor, he put it this way, God might've answered a hundred of your prayers, but we only remember the one time that he didn't answer. People might've complimented you a hundred times, but we remember only the one time that someone offended you. And I think this is the problem with our hearts, our spiritual memory, it forgets all the time. And so if God answered your prayer, maybe just three days ago in weariness, it feels like the last time God spoke to you was 30 years ago. And to understand how weariness distorts us before we ever even accuse God, it helps to think about what's happening also inside of our hearts. Because weariness, it doesn't just drain our bodies, it scrambles our inner world. And so when we're exhausted, we start treating certain emotions as problems to eliminate rather than signals to pay attention to. So if you're an elementary school student, you're here with us today. You probably know and have seen the movie Inside Out, and you get to see the inner world of a preteen through the embodiment of five different emotions. And throughout the movie, there's this one emotion

9:18 called joy that's convinced that sadness, another emotion, is the one that keeps messing everything up, the one that's getting in the way, the one that's useless. And we get to the moment in the movie where there's this imaginary elephant named Bing Bong that's crying candy. And Joy immediately gets into fix it mode. Just think happy thoughts, just think positive. But the more joy tries to manufacture joy and bypass the sadness, the worse actually things get. And it's at this moment where sadness comes along this crying elephant and is finally allowed to do what she was meant to do. Not fix everything, not explain everything away, but simply sit in his pain long enough for healing to begin. And this is how the wilderness works in the same way. Weariness isn't something to bypass or to fix, but something that we go through.

10:15 But when weariness does go unaddressed, it never stays internal. I want us to look here, in our passage, notice how quickly things escalate. In verse one, it's we're thirsty. In verse three, it becomes an accusation. Did you bring us out of Egypt so that we would die? Right? They're saying that the present moment feels so overwhelming that slavery starts to look preferable. And then verse seven, the question sharpens even further. Is the Lord even among us? Can we even trust this God? And it's not like the people have forgotten altogether that God exists. No, they know he's there, but rather they forget what God is like. And this is what we forget. Weariness doesn't erase belief, but it begins to distort our memory. It makes us not forget that God exists, but it makes us forget what God is like. And what Israel forgets is that God is faithful, God is patient, and that God is committed to their good and it's when their hearts forget who God is, fear begins to fill in the blanks.

11:23 And that's when forgetfulness turns provision into coincidence, delay into abandonment, and suffering into betrayal. And this is where weariness becomes dangerous because forgetfulness doesn't stay internal. It comes out. What begins as exhaustion turns into accusation. when what begins as thirst turns into quarreling. And in this passage, quarreling, it's not just complaining, but it's putting God on trial.

11:53 And when weariness goes unchecked, it moves into something heavier because how we speak to God in our weariness, it does matter. And that brings us to our second reality here in the wilderness, which is judgment in the wilderness. The first two tests that I referenced in chapter 15 and 16. the passage talks about how God was testing Israel. But in our passage today, it says that Israel is testing God. And it comes up in this world, quarreling. And Ed Clowney, he shares some insights on this passage, many of which you're going to hear in today's message. He notes that the word quarreling in the Hebrew actually carries a much stronger meaning. Quarreling, it's not just this complaining or this bickering, like I didn't like your meatloaf or I didn't like the curtains, but quarreling here refers to filing a complaint or pursuing a lawsuit against someone. And in this case, they charge God's representative Moses with cosmic treason, but they're really after God.

12:55 They're treating God, not as their rescuer, but as a criminal who's failed them. And this is a capital offense that's punishable by death. And we know that they're serious because in verse four, they say, what shall I, Moses says, what shall I do with these people? they are almost ready to stone me. And though they quarrel against Moses, again, who they're really after is God. Moses says, why do you test the Lord? But if they're going to die here, they might as well take out the closest person that they're angry to and stone Moses. And I think what makes this scene so unsettling is that Israel owed everything to God from Egypt to the sea, to the wilderness. But now they're saying, right? We don't like the way that you're running things, God. Or I wouldn't do it that way. Or God, you're just not cutting it anymore. And so actually Israel, the people, they're guilty of the very treason that they're charging God with.

13:55 And I think we do the same thing more than we like to realize, or I'd like to admit. In our own wilderness, we subtly sue God in our hearts. We don't say this out loud, but we often think, God, I did what you asked. I did the right thing so why am I still here? Why has nothing changed? Sometimes we grumble about why God is late or why God could be so unfair and so indifferent. right? is not where I should be in my career right now. or God why am I alone or alone again? We do the same thing with our posture our attitude we pull back from prayer giving God the silent treatment we disengage from our community so on the outside we may look put together, but on the inside, we're slowly keeping a record of wrongs. So we may still believe that God exists, but we've slowly and quietly decided what God must be like. And we become more like prosecutors towards God rather than children towards God.

14:57 And then God finally speaks for the first time in our passage and says in verse five, for Moses to pass on before the people and to take some elders and the staff with him. And so now the people are watching this and they know what's about to happen. A trial is about to take place because the elders that are going with him, they make up a court of witnesses for this trial. But the other thing that Moses is commanded to take with him is his staff. And if you've been tracking with us in Exodus, you've seen the staff make multiple appearances now. It's the same staff that God used to strike Egypt with 10 plagues. When Moses struck the Nile, the Nile turned to blood, right? This staff, it's a symbol of judicial authority. It represented the very judgment of God himself. And so they would do something very similar in Rome. Roman lictors would carry around bundles of rods and these rods would symbolize unity and authority to reinforce this idea of collective power.

15:59 And so all the people, they know, they see this, they see this happening. they see the rod in Moses' hand. And that's significant because Moses goes not as the criminal, not as the accused, but as the judge. And it begs the question of what judgment would come if Moses lifted the rod against the people. And so the lawsuit is given by Israel. God cannot be trusted. Moses has become a judge and a trial will take place. where Moses will raise the rod of judgment for sentencing and execution. But the question is, is on whom? We're going to take a look at that last together in our last point, God in the wilderness. In verse six, God says, I will stand before you on the rock. Now, this is startling because in the Old Testament, God did not stand before man. Men stood before God, right?

16:54 Kings are not summoned before their servants. Servants are summoned before their king. And yet God says, I will stand before you. But Israel thinks that God is on trial. And so they accuse him of injustice. They demand a verdict. But what they don't realize is something both terrifying and gracious at the same time. They are the ones, Israel is the one that is on trial. But instead of condemning them, God steps in to the judgment seat in their place. God tells Moses to raise the staff, the staff that punishes God's enemies, the staff that judges Egypt, the staff that executes justice. And when it comes down, God doesn't say, let them have it. He says, strike the rock. Let me have it.

17:49 And so we have these grumbling and quarreling people here that say, we're done. Moses himself Moses is done but every turn and corner these people doubt God they reject him they rebel against him God doesn't respond with a lecture he doesn't abandon them he doesn't explain himself God absorbs the blow the people don't know what they're even asking for but neither did the crowd centuries later when they cried crucify him when Jesus speaks these words on the cross as he struck He says, Father, forgive them for they do not know what they do. The rock that was struck was always pointing forward to Christ.

18:34 And so how does God respond to Israel's quarreling for water? How does God respond when weary people put him on trial? God actually gives the people what they ask for. He gives them the water that they desperately need. He gives them the judgment they demand. but God, he pays for it himself as their substitute. He gives them more than answers. He gives them himself. And if we return to our Broadway show, the title, Happy, Maybe Happy Ending, the title sort of suggests a theology of weariness. It's not happily ever after. It's not tragic ending. It's just maybe. And this is the language of the people who have learned what it means to hope in a guarded way, in a cautious way. Let's lower our expectations to sort of protect ourselves or we're not used to over-promising or we don't want to trust in too much permanence.

19:36 But yet, maybe there's hope. But our God offers something much better than maybe. If a God like that is a God that defends you, pays for you, stands in your place, who gives everything for you, then what does it matter? We have something far better than maybe, far better than an explanation, than an answer or proofs. He gives us his very self and at great cost. Paul will talk about this in 1 Corinthians 10, 4. He says, For they drank from the spiritual rock that followed them, and the rock was Christ.

20:18 The rock that struck foreshadows Jesus Christ, who was struck on the cross for you. Not just to provide for your material needs, but to provide for you this living water that you might experience in something so satisfying in your life that nothing in the world can take that away. And so I want us to see, when we look at the life of Jesus, see Jesus who walked on this earth, who began his ministry actually in wilderness for 40 days, fasting, weary, in obscurity. You can see Jesus. He stood silently on the platform with Pilate. Pilate said that he was innocent, but the people condemned him anyways. And you can see Jesus struck on the cross, leaving heaven to enter into our wilderness and bear our judgment for us. This is God in the wilderness.

21:10 And so the journey for Israel, it was never directly from Egypt to the promised land, but always through the wilderness. the freedom that they already have, it still needs to get worked into their lives, but it doesn't get worked in until they go through some sort of wilderness sort of experiences, disappointments, heartaches, dead ends. And so notice how God, he doesn't remove the wilderness, but rather he provides the water in it. And if the rock has already been struck for you, if the sun has already been judged in your place, that you and I, we have this freedom to be able to build our life upon this rock. Not because the wilderness is gone, because God is with you in that wilderness.

22:01 And so is the Lord among us? Yes, he is. The Lord is on the rock and he's among them in ways that they couldn't even imagine. But not only among them, but also among us and also in our place. Let's pray together. Father, Lord, we thank you for, Lord, this word, Lord, that you are the rock that was struck. That, Lord, in many times, in many places, Lord, we do things that, Lord, we are not aware of, Lord, that we do things that, Lord, we regret. But, God, Lord, I pray that as we are faced with wilderness wandering, Lord, I pray that as any of us, Lord, here are confused or at a loss of purpose, Lord, help us to look to the rock, the rock that's given himself over to us, Lord, the rock that was struck for us.

23:01 And God, Lord, I pray that, Lord, that freedom, Lord, would release us from anything that's tying us down. But Lord, it would make us all the more, Lord, want to really live for your kingdom. We pray for these things in your son's name.

Machine translated from the source