Faith and Memory

Bijan Mirtolooi · Redeemer West Side · Published August 23, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

0:15 Haggai chapter 2.

On the 21st day of the seven months, the word of the Lord came through the prophet Haggai. speak to Zerubbabel, son of Sheltiel, governor of Judah, to Joshua, son of Josedach, the high priest, and to the remnant of the people. Ask them, who of you is left who saw this house in its former glory? How does it look to you now? Does it not seem to you like nothing? But now be strong, Zerubbabel, declares the Lord. Be strong, Joshua, son of Josedach, the high priest. Be strong, all you people of the land, declares the Lord. And work, for I am with you, declares the Lord Almighty. This is what I covenanted with you when you came out of Egypt, and my spirit remains among you. Do not fear. This is what the Lord Almighty says. in a little while I will once more shake the heavens and the earth, the sea and the dry land. I will shake all nations and what is desired by all nations will come. And I will fill this house with glory, says the Lord Almighty. The silver is mine, the gold is mine, declares the Lord Almighty. The glory of this present house will be greater than the glory of the former house, says the Lord Almighty. And in this place, I will grant peace, declares the Lord Almighty. And then to verse 20 of the chapter, the word of the Lord came to Haggai a second time on the 24th day of the month, tells Zerubbabel, governor of Judah, that I'm going to shake the heavens and the earth. I will overturn royal thrones and shatter the power of the foreign kingdoms. I will overthrow chariots and their drivers. Horses and their riders will fall each by the sword of his brother. And on that day, declares the Lord Almighty, I will take you, my servant Zerubbabel, son of Shaltiel, declares the Lord. And I will make you like my signet ring, for I have chosen you, declares the Lord Almighty. And that is the word of the Lord.

2:37 Thanks be to God. You may be seated. Now, if you were here last week, we looked at Haggai chapter 1, and in Haggai 1, we saw a people experiencing revival. There was joy, there was obedience to God, there was spiritual vitality. So Haggai chapter 1, revival. And those same people, now two months later, when we get to Haggai chapter 2, are deeply discouraged. Revival in chapter one, discouragement in chapter two. One of the things that I love and appreciate about the Bible... is how brutally honest it is that a person can be experiencing spiritual renewal, can be obeying God and trying to follow after God and do the things that God says, and at the same time experience deep discouragement, a kind of melancholy of soul.

3:39 In fact, in so many of the biographies I've read about great Christian leaders in the past, what always stands out to me is their courageous faith and their leadership and their commitment to God's kingdom and a seeming constant struggle with depression and melancholy and discouragement. The Bible is very honest that having faith or being a Christian and following God doesn't exempt you from the discouragements and the sufferings of life. In fact, sometimes it can make them feel even more acute. And yet, while acknowledging the reality of discouragement, this passage also shows us the astounding comfort that God brings to his people, not in sparing them from trouble, but comfort that's with them in their trouble. And so this passage can be a great help to us.

4:35 in how we navigate discouragement in life and in our spiritual journeys. So let's take a look at first, what are the sources of discouragement? And second, the promises that God gives to his people who are discouraged. And third and finally, why we can know and trust in those promises ourselves. The sources of discouragement, the promises God gives and why you can trust in his promises. So first, why were the people discouraged? If you were here last week, you'll remember that these people, the people that Haggai is preaching to, had recently come back from exile. Their people, their nation had been conquered. Many of the inhabitants of their city were taken by force to Babylon. And as the decades passed, eventually a new empire came and said to those exiles, you can go back to your city.

5:32 So the people came back to their city and they were rebuilding the city. They were rebuilding the temple. And Haggai comes to them to say, you've not prioritized your spiritual things. You've been focused on yourselves. You've been focused on your own houses. In God's house, the temple lies in ruins. So that was chapter one. Haggai challenges them. He preaches to them. He calls them to repentance and they respond. There's a revival. They commit to God. When we get to chapter two, the people who started off with enthusiasm in their spiritual journey are now discouraged. Why? Why? The first reason is because the work of building the temple was flat out difficult. It was hard work. So if you glance at the passage, for example, you'll see in verse four, three times God says to the people, be strong. Now, you don't tell somebody to be strong, especially three times, if the thing that they're doing is easy or fun.

6:34 You know, if someone is going out to a nice dinner with friends, you don't tell them, be strong. They're going to be just fine. You tell somebody to be strong when you know what they're facing is hard for them, when what they're facing is going to be scary, maybe even the outcome unknown. And so if God's coming to his people and saying, be strong, it's because what they're doing is going to be very taxing, very difficult. And it was. They were charged with building God's house, building the temple. The temple had been completely destroyed. And so what was in front of them was literally a pile of rubble, an absolute mess. And the work of clearing it up, of finding new materials to build the house would have been very difficult. And on top of that, we know from other parts of the Bible, that is in all things in life, there were naysayers. There were people who were opposing them, people who were saying, you'll never get this done. The work was difficult and there was opposition. And that contributed to the discouragement. Day after day, doing work that was hard and not seeing results, not feeling like it was adding up to much. So difficulty, it was hard work.

7:49 And there was another source of discouragement connected to that, but even deeper, not only was the work difficult, but it was also disappointing. If you look at verse 3, God, again, speaking through Haggai, says to the people, notice the three questions. Who of you has left who saw this house in its former glory? How does it look to you now? Does it not seem to you like nothing? Now, God is asking a series of penetrating questions that are meant to pull back the emotional layers of the people. And what God's saying is this, and there would have been people in the community who with their own eyes saw the old temple, Solomon's temple, which would have been an architectural wonder, spectacular to behold. And more than that, the time of Solomon's temple, at least for much of its history, when that temple stood, it was a time of peace and prosperity in the nation.

8:47 So the temple, which was architecturally beautiful, also was symbolic of a time when things were okay, when people flourished. And now God says to the people, you're trying to rebuild what was destroyed and it feels like nothing. It feels like what we can produce in the present will never match the glory that we had in the past. The people are experiencing nostalgia. They're remembering a time in their past that seems far superior to what they're experiencing in the present. And that pain, that perceived memory of their past makes the present work discouraging and disappointing. No matter how hard we work, no matter how much we do, we'll never be able to match what we used to have. So when you put that together, the difficulty...

9:42 and the disappointment, what you really have is a group of people who are homesick. a group of people who remember what it used to be like. and are discouraged that they're not able to get back. And more than that, these people had just come back from exile. And they must have thought all those years in a foreign place and difficulty and oppression, they must have thought, as soon as we can get back to our city, then we're going to be okay. Then we'll be home. and they got back to the city and it didn't feel like home. They're homesick. And this story is a microcosm of the human condition that actually all of us, if we're looking into our hearts and able to see it, are experiencing this same kind of homesickness. Martin Heidegger, who, as far as I know, is not writing from any kind of spiritual perspective, any kind of Christian or religious perspective, said that every human being carries with them a sense of unheimlich, a word translated something like unsettledness, that we move through life feeling like strangers in our own world, disrupted and disoriented, like something is off and it doesn't quite fit.

10:58 It's homesickness. Or if existentialist philosophers are not your thing, how about a Disney movie? It's hard, I challenge you, to think of any Disney movie in which at some level the basic plot is not some hero trying to save the world and at the same time to find themselves, to find a place where they belong, to find out who they really are and the place where they fit. So this is a bit dated now, but I remember years ago, the movie Hercules. Hercules is trying to save the world. And at the same time trying to figure out who he is. And in the hit song from that movie, Go the Distance, Hercules sings, I've often dreamed of a far-off place where a hero's welcome will be waiting for me, where the crowds will cheer when they see my face and a voice keeps saying, this is where I'm meant to be. I'll be there someday. I can go the distance. I'll find my way. If I can be strong, I know every mile will have been worth my while. I would go most anywhere to feel like I belong.

12:11 Heidegger, Hercules, Haggai, the whole Bible. And if you'll look in your own heart, your own story tells you that we're longing for something we haven't found yet. We're homesick. We think to ourselves like these people thought, when we just get there, if I can just have them, when I get into that school or when I get that job, when I get into that relationship, then I'll feel like I've arrive. Then I'll feel at peace. And you get the things and you still feel unheimlich. We're homesick. And that's where the people were. They were deeply discouraged. And at some level, I would contend that all the discouragement that we carry, if you trace it far enough, is a reminder that we're homesick too.

13:07 Now, it's to that homesick and discouraged people that God in verses four through nine speaks some amazing promises, breathtaking. And all we're gonna do now for a few minutes is meditate on some of these promises. They're cascading in beauty. I mean, just stunning. And they're worth meditating on much more than the time we have tonight to do so. But to a discouraged people, let's see what God says. to buoyant and make their faith even more resilient. Let's look at the promises. He says first,

13:46 it's been hard before, but I was with you then and I'm with you now. So if you look with me, first verse four and then verse five, God says to this people, I'm with you. This is what I covenanted with you when you came out of Egypt. My spirit remains among you. Do not fear. And that's interesting. The people are nostalgic. They're remembering the past and they think it was better back then. And God says, it wasn't always great. You were in Egypt. That is, you were slaves. You were in bondage. You were oppressed. But I brought you out. I was with you then. And when you came out of Egypt, it was difficult. It was scary. It was hard. The future was unknown. But I was with you. And I saw you through the Red Sea. I saw you through the wilderness. and I brought you to the promised land. And God is in effect saying to the people, all the things that you remember that was great about your past came after tremendous suffering.

14:47 And I was the one who was with you through it all. And I'm still with you today. That's why God says, my spirit remains among you. He doesn't say, I'm gonna send you my spirit. He says, I've never left. the first promise, the first assurance that God gives to a discouraged people is you're not alone. It might feel like you are. You might not feel supported, but God says, I've never left. I'm with you. The second promise that God gives, you go down to verse nine. God says, the best is yet to be. The glory of this present house will be greater than the glory of the former house, says the Lord Almighty. Now that was stunning. That was audacious for God to say, remember, the people are standing before a pile of rubble, like literally stones in a mess everywhere. They're overwhelmed by the difficulty of the task ahead of them.

15:47 And God says to them, I know you think the past was great, but let me tell you, you haven't seen anything yet. The glory of the house that right now is a mess before you is going to be even more than the glory of the former house. The best is yet to come. And so God is saying to his people, I want you with the eye of faith to see into the future and to know the best is coming.

16:18 And the most amazing thing God says by way of promises, it's been hard before, but I was with you then and I'm with you now. The best is yet to be. And if you look at the end of verse 9, God says, and in this place, I will grant peace. Now, the word peace in English, we often use that word to describe a cessation of conflict, right? The absence of hostility. But the Hebrew word for peace is shalom. And that's one of our favorite words around here at Redeemer. Because shalom doesn't merely mean the absence of conflict. Shalom means the presence of goodness in every direction. Or another way to say it is, shalom is holistic flourishing. And God says to a discouraged people who are overwhelmed and disappointed, right here where you stand, it's going to feel like home.

17:16 You're going to have shalom again. Why does that matter? Because you remember we said earlier, all human beings carry around a deep sense of homesickness. That's because when we were made, we were home. The Bible says that when God made humanity, our first parents, Adam and Eve, he put them in the Garden of Eden and that was shalom. We were home. If you think about home, home is the place that fits you. Home is the place where you're safe, where you're with those that you love, where you're seen to the bottom and your love to the sky. And we had that. In Eden, human beings were safe and in right relationship with creation. The world wasn't breaking down. It wasn't breaking down on them. and human beings were in a good relationship with other human beings.

18:09 We got along with other people. There was not conflict interpersonally and human beings were safe in their own skin. You know, there's a verse in Genesis 2 that says, Adam and Eve were naked and they felt no shame. They had nothing to hide. They could be vulnerable and loved. They were safe in their own skin. and most importantly, they had a right relationship with God. They walked with him in unbroken, unhindered fellowship. Eden was home, right with God, with ourselves, with other people, with the world. And we lost it. And human beings have been in exile and wandering ever since. And God says, I'm going to bring you home. In this place, you're going to experience peace. I'm with you. I've always been with you. The best is yet to come because you're going home.

19:08 Now, I can imagine the people hearing these amazing promises standing there in front of a pile of rocks that is an absolute mess saying, how do we know? Like, how can we trust those promises? I mean, that would be amazing if it were true, but how can we know? How can you know? because the reality is if you're a person of faith, if you're here tonight, identify as a Christian, you know at some level all the things that I'm sharing tonight. And yet the reality of our present experience makes these promises feel very distant and abstract. So how can you know? And the answer is that little word in verse five. God says, I made a covenant with you. A covenant. The reason these people could know that these promises would come true, and the reason you can too, is because God makes covenants. A covenant is an unbreakable vow. It's a promise. And God throughout the Bible makes covenants with his people. One of those covenants is the one alluded to here in verse five, the covenant with Moses. But there would have been another covenant, another promise in mind that God would have given to these people that they would have been holding on to. You see, this whole book is about rebuilding the temple, rebuilding God's house.

20:30 It was King David, their greatest king, who first had the idea of building God a temple, a place where he could dwell among his people. And God said to David, David, you're not going to build me a house, but I'm going to do you one better. I'm going to build you one. This is 2 Samuel 7, if you want to read about it. God says to David, you don't get to build the house, but I'm going to build you into a house. And in 2 Samuel 7, God makes a promise. He makes a covenant with David and he says, you're a king. And for all time, there's going to be a king sitting on your throne. There's always going to be sitting on the throne, a king from the family of David. And that was where this hope for a Messiah came from. This hope that there would be a true king who would come into the world and bring justice and bring peace and show God's love.

21:31 God made a promise to David, a covenant. There's always going to be a king from the family of David on the throne, which must have been very confusing for these people because their nation had been conquered, their city destroyed, there was no king. And so they're thinking, how in the world is God going to keep that promise? the reality of the experience that they had is often the experience we have. All these great promises, but it doesn't feel like it. In fact, David Dixon, writing about this reality in the Bible, says, the state of David's kingdom may sometimes seem to human sense. in a condition quite contrary to what is promised concerning it. It's a piercing quote. You know what he's saying? You have all these promises, but you live in the world and you say, it's not adding up. You're supposed to be a king on the throne, but our city is destroyed. We have no temple.

22:29 What's going on? Do you notice how the book of Haggai ends? It's actually kind of odd. After all this talk about building the temple, God zeroes in his focus at the very end of the book, right? Verse 23 is the last part of the story, on a man called Zerubbabel. Now, he's been mentioned multiple times throughout the book, and almost all times he's mentioned, we're told he's the son of Shelteel. In fact, in two chapters, five times we're told he's the son of Sheltiel. And you might read that and think, why do we need to keep knowing that? We get the point. He's the son of Sheltiel. Why does God keep repeating himself? Why giving us this seemingly periphery detail? Because it's not periphery at all. When God says Zerubbabel is the son of Sheltiel, what he's saying is, Zerubbabel, who's leading you right now, is from the family of David. Sheltiel is a son of David. In other words, despite appearances, God says, my promises are still unfolding.

23:31 I told you there would always be someone from David's throne, David's family leading you, and I'm keeping my promise. And in the midst of your discouragement and in the midst of your despondency, God says, the line continues, the promise endures. Zerubbabel in this moment is a symbol of God's promise, which despite appearances is unbreakable. That's why Kathleen Nielsen in her great book on Haggai says, Zerubbabel represents the surety of God's promise to bring an eternal king in David's line. And that king is the one who will accomplish this deliverance.

24:12 Now, whatever accomplishments Zerubbabel had in his life clearly he's a figure that's pointing beyond himself. Yes, he led the people. Yes, they rebuilt the temple, but Zerubbabel stands for something much bigger than happened in his lifetime. And when you get to Matthew and Luke, the beginning of the New Testament, and you read the genealogies of Jesus Christ, what you see is that Zerubbabel is one of Jesus' great, great, great, great grandfathers. That God kept his promise, because he always does. That from Zerubbabel, the one leading people in this time of discouragement and despondency, that one of Zerubbabel's great sons was none other than Jesus Christ, who is God with us. When God says, I'm with you, I've always been with you. It was hard before. I'm with you now. Jesus Christ is the ultimate embodiment of that.

25:09 When we come to the table, you hold in your hands the bread and the cup. He kept his promise. And the night before his death, Jesus looked at his friends and said, I'm not going to leave you as orphans. I'm going to give you my spirit to be with you all the way to the end. And then I'm going to come back and get you. And I'm going to bring you home. I'm going to bring you to the kingdom, to the place where there are no more tears, there's no more illness and death, where everything sad has come untrue.

25:40 How can you trust in God's promise? Because of Jesus Christ. If Jesus came in the world and did what he said he did and rose again and defeated death, then he is the embodiment of God's ability to keep every promise he's ever made. He's the fulfillment of the covenant. And so tonight, as we hold the bread and the cup in our hands, we hold the tangible reminders that God keeps his promises. Now, briefly, how do we apply this to our life? I mean, these are soaring promises. How do we connect them to our story this evening? Three things, again, briefly. First, follow your discouragements all the way up.

26:25 If you're discouraged tonight, and if you're not tonight, just give it time. When discouragement comes, follow it all the way up. What I mean is, don't ignore it, don't avoid it, and certainly don't numb yourself to it. Feel it and trace all the way up. Why? Because if you do, you're going to find yourself getting closer and closer to the reality that you were made for a world that's actually going to heal every longing in your heart. Say it this way. There's a spot in one of his books where C.S. Lewis says, does it ever strike you as odd that we're always frustrated with time? I mean, it's getting to the end of summary. Say, oh, it went by so fast. We're always feeling like there's not enough time. Time's going by too fast.

27:20 And Lewis says, as long as we've lived, time's been our natural habitat. You think we'd be used to it by now. And yet we find ourselves continually flustered and frustrated by its existence. Why? Maybe it's a clue that we are, after all, made for a timeless existence. That maybe we're made for eternity.

27:42 And Lewis goes on to say, if I find in myself a desire which no experience in this world can satisfy, the most probable explanation is that I was made for another world. So trace your discouragements all the way up. Lots of times when people get discouraged, they just think, well, that didn't work, so I'm gonna try the next thing. Go all the way up and you'll find yourself in the presence of the God who made you and who says, my kingdom is the kingdom that will heal every ache in your heart. So follow your discouragements. Second point of application, don't despise the day of small things. You see in our passage where God says to the people, work, I'm with you, work. God was saying, do the daily tasks of building the temple. Clear the rubble, get the new material, measure, cut, do the stuff, work. And it was discouraging for the people because it was very hard and they were feeling like it's not adding up to much. There's another place in the Bible where Zerubbabel, this Zerubbabel, God comes to him and says, don't despise the day of small things, which was God's way of saying, I know it doesn't seem like what you're doing right now amounts to all that much, but make no mistake, this is huge. Don't despise the day of small things. Now, I think God was saying that not only because all work can be meaningfully done and can be really rewarding and energizing and serve others, that's true. But I think God was saying, actually, you got to get a bigger perspective, Zerubbabel. You're a tiny thread in a much bigger tapestry. And to see the whole thing would knock your socks off. Nothing you're doing today is actually small. And when the veil of eternity is pulled back and you see it all, you'll say, oh my goodness, the best really was yet to be. So work and don't despise the day of small things.

29:49 All the little obediences, all the little ways of choosing to put others and to put God first amidst life's hardship, that's not a small thing because we don't serve a small God. Last point of application, keep your eyes up. God ends his promises by saying, the coming glory is going to exceed anything we had in the past. It's a call to look forward to the future.

30:17 Now, Daniel Nairi, a novelist, has a spot in one of his books where he says, what you believe about the future will change the way you live in the present. Christians are meant to be those who have a vision of the future that radically reorients how they live in the present. I've used this example before, some of you have heard it, so bear with me. But I don't really like camping. I've gone a couple of times, I don't really enjoy it. But the few times that I've gone, I've made the best of it, and I try to have fun. And the reason is, while I'm out there camping, I keep saying to myself, this is only temporary. I'm going to go home soon. And knowing that I'm going to go home soon actually does enable me to be present, to enjoy, to have a much better time than I would have if I thought this was it. there's a lot to do.

31:15 There's a lot of people to care for and to serve. There's a lot of brokenness in this world that needs attending to. There's a lot of work that's needing to be done. There's a lot of people who need hope. And we will be those who are most equipped to love and to serve in this world the more we think of the next one. The moment we stop needing this world and this city to save us is precisely the moment that we're going to be most able to enjoy it. God makes amazing promises that await his people for their future. Keep your eyes up. Look at what God has promised. Look at what he said is coming and allow that future to shape how you live in the present. Let's pray and then come to the table. Our Father, thank you for teaching us tonight from Haggai chapter two.

32:12 As we do come to this table now, we ask that you would keep our eyes up. Whatever real discouragements and sorrows we've brought with us here tonight, even whatever joys and excitements we have, help us to see those things, but to see more tonight. Help us to see Jesus Christ, the true King, David's greater Son and our Savior, who came in this world to keep every promise that you've ever made. Help us to see him and the kingdom that he's preparing for us. And may the reality of Jesus and all he's done fill us tonight with hope amid our sorrow, with joy amid our discouragement. May you feed us for the journey and renew our faith. We ask this in Jesus' name and for his glory.

Machine translated from the source