Fatima Conference-The Authenticity of the Miracle of the Sun

Guest speaker · Our Lady of Good Counsel · Fatima Conference · Preached October 13, 1917 · Published October 31, 2017

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

3:13 All right, yeah, you want to keep the camera away. Everybody can see me okay? Okay, I don't have to stand on a stool. That's good.

3:33 Well, thank you very much. I'm very pleased to be here, especially with such distinguished speakers. the program that you have says that the talk I'm about to give is titled The Authenticity of the Miracle of the Sun October 13, 1917 Scientific Proof of the Defiance of All Cosmic Laws as much as I'd love to give that talk I'm actually going to give you a much more humble talk. which I would like to call Hostile Witnesses to a Miracle And the reason for it is I'm not a scientist. I don't play a scientist on TV. And quite frankly, the science in the miracle is interesting, but quite frankly, I don't know how helpful it is for bringing people to Christ and saving souls. So, what I'd like to do is look at the miracle of the sun from the level of history rather than science.

4:32 But I will have a little bit of science in it, so no one will be disappointed. it. So that was my original talk. I'm going to talk about hostile witnesses to the son. Although you might be experiencing a different talk called penance, penance, penance, which is the beautiful thing with my talks is that not only are you informed about the faith, but you have redemptive suffering that you can undergo as you listen to me speak. Okay. Now, our Lord chose to have Our Lady appear to three shepherd children in a town near Fatima, 1917. And I think it's fair for us to ask the question, why this particular time in this particular place?

5:19 Mary could have, for example, appeared to three shepherd children in Russia, say, before the Bolshevik Revolution. But instead, Our Lord wanted it here. And I think also that the time and place has certain applications for us today, 100 years after the fact. Now the historical situation, I'm sure the other speakers have already touched on, so I'll quickly review it. 1917, of course, the world found itself in the midst of the first great world war, the first of two, in which more people would be killed than any other time in human history.

6:00 Also, 1917 marked a period of the advent of Russia becoming atheistic, the Soviet Union, in which itself would murder more of its own citizens than any other country in history, with the possible exception of communist China. As for the place, Portugal had recently undergone a revolution, and the new government was extremely anti-Catholic. It sought to wipe out Catholic thought and influence in Portuguese culture, and in fact, some have speculated that they would wipe out Catholicism within a generation or two. Not only that, but there was also the problem of the mass media. The Catholic press was severely hampered in Portugal at the time, and the secular press was decidedly anti-Catholic.

6:59 In fact, the press, whenever it would report on the faith, usually did so to ridicule the devotion and the doctrines of good, faithful Catholics at the time, and it especially liked to attack the clergy as very anti-clerical. Now, I'm sure all of you are thinking to yourselves right now, thank God things have changed. Now it's true that our situation today is not the same as it was in 1917 Portugal, thanks be to God. We don't find ourselves in the midst of a worldwide conflict. And the Catholic press is alive and well, thanks be to God. And by the way, that's why it's so important for us today to please support Catholic media, WTN, Ave Maria Radio, because these are lifelines, these are beacons to a fallen world. But nevertheless, we do have something in common.

7:56 I remember, you know, back when I was younger and shorter, when I first became interested in apologetics, I went to my first Catholic conference on the New Age. And there was one line by a speaker, a very good holy priest, who started this talk, and I still remember it as clear today as it was back then. He said, we live in the age of apostasy.

8:24 And back in the early 1990s, I thought to myself, gee, Father is kind of hyperventilating a little bit, you know. I mean, after all, Father Hardin defines apostasy as the complete abandonment of the Christian religion, not merely the denial of some article of the creed. And so apostasy seemed really strong, but especially the age of apostasy. Now, it was true back then, lots of people were joining the New Age movement. Some people did apostatize. But I thought, you know, boy, that's the overstatement of the century. But now looking back on the early 1990s, from the standpoint of 100 years after the miracle of the sun, I now can see that this wonderful priest's words were prophetic. We are living in an age of apostasy. So, and this apostasy, by the way, is not merely that people have forsaken the faith and go off to live comfortable lives somewhere.

9:28 It is also a very fervent anti-Catholic apostasy where they not only deny the faith but turn against the faith. We live in a kind of hyper-skepticism where people who have abandoned Christ and his church will look extremely critical. They'd almost have an invincible skepticism about anything in favor of Catholicism, but on the other hand, they're willing to accept anything, no matter how bizarre, no matter how unlikely, to escape the obvious.

10:05 So therefore, we have a common bond with our brothers and sisters back in 1917. we too are experiencing this caustic skepticism. And it's also out of that anti-Catholicism of 1917 that we're given a great gift of hostile witnesses.

10:31 You see, this anti-Catholic press happened to have a few reporters come out and they witnessed the miracle of the sun. So their witness is a gift for us today to combat skepticism. Now, when I say hostile witness, what do I mean? Well, I'm basically coining a phrase from my book, Hostile Witnesses, How the Historic Enemies Proved Christianity. And in it, what I do is I chronicle the historic enemies of the church, starting with the New Testament, going all the way to World War II, and looking at Christ and his church through the eyes of his enemies. because these historic enemies are forced to confront the facts of Christ and his church, and they can't deny it. They have to explain it away, or they have to turn it around so it's more palatable. But all of them bear testimony to Christ and his church.

11:27 So I have Jews who attest to Jesus doing miracles in their own way. I have Muslims who explain how virtuous the Crusaders were. I have Nazis who talk about how the Pope was their enemy. So it's a very interesting book. In one chapter, I have the hostile witness of Fatima. So that's what this talk is about. The hostile witnesses of Fatima. Now.

11:58 Now, we're going to examine two hostile witnesses, both of them are newspaper accounts of the miracle, and I'm also going to throw in a friendly witness. Now, this friendly witness was a good Catholic. His name was Dr. Jose Garrett. He was a professor of natural science at Coimbra University. And what I like about him was he witnessed a miracle and he witnessed it. as a scientist. So we have two hostile witnesses and a friendly witness. And what I'm going to do is what I do in the book is I'm going to show you what they say, what they report, and then I'm going to show how what these unbelievers report actually undermine the claims of modern skeptics today. The very people you'll run to in school or at work or maybe family members. So let's continue. Okay, our first hostile witness.

12:54 Newspaper account by Oseculo Newspaper. Now this was written by the chief editor, Alvino D. Almedia. The article appeared in October 15, 1917, so two days after the miracle. Now just to give you an idea about Oseculo Newspaper, three months earlier, they wrote an article, really more of a hit piece, on these rumors about Mary appearing to three shepherd children, in which the article is titled, A Celestial Embassy? Financial Speculation?

13:29 In other words, the article claimed that this whole thing with Fatima, Mary appearing to these children, was a premeditated financial speculation that wishes to transform the Erie Mountains into a place of miracles like old lords. So this definitely is a hostile newspaper. Just a few months later, this is what they're going to report.

13:57 Before the fascinated look of those people whose attitudes would remind one of biblical times, and who, white with fear, bareheaded, looked up to the sky, the sun trembled. It performed never before brusque movements beyond the laws of nature. The sun danced, as the country people are so aptly expressed it. And then it continues, And afterwards, everyone asked everyone else if they had seen and told what they themselves had seen. A majority confessed that they had seen the shaking and dancing of the sun. Others, however, declared that they had seen the smiling face of the Virgin herself. They wrote that the sun had spun around on its own axis like something like a fireworks display,

14:48 that it had descended almost to the point of setting the earth on fire with its rays. There were those who said that they had seen it continuously changing colors. It was almost 3 p.m., the sky was cloudless, and the sun followed the course in its normal splendor, which no one dared to look at. And then it continues. It concludes, It remains for those who are qualified to give their opinion, in all fairness, on the uncanny dance of the sun, which today in Fatima caused an explosion of hosannas from the throats of the faithful, and according to the testimony of trustworthy persons, impressed the free thinkers, in other words, the atheists, as well as those who have no religious affiliation whatsoever, who had flocked to the now celebrated spot.

15:41 That's our first hostile witness. Second hostile witness is also a newspaper, Odea, who printed an article on October 17, 1917, So a few days later, it says this, quote, At one o'clock in the afternoon, midday by the sun, the rain stopped. The sky, pearly gray in color, illuminated a vast arid landscape with strange light. The sun had a transparent gauzy veil so that the eyes could easily fix upon it. The gray mother of pearl tone turned into a sheet of silver, which broke up as the clouds had been torn apart, and the silver sun enveloped in the same gauzy gray light. was seen to whirl and turn in a circle of broken clouds. A cry went out from every mouth and people fell on their knees.

16:35 And it continues, The light turned a beautiful blue as if it had come through a stained glass windows of a cathedral. and spread itself over the people who knelt with outstretched hands. The blue slowly faded and then the light seemed to pass through a yellow glass. Yellow stains fell upon white handkerchiefs against dark skirts of the women. They were repeated on the trees and on the stones and on Sierra. People wept and prayed with uncovered heads in the presence of the miracle that had awaited. Seconds seemed like hours, so vivid they were. Again, an atheistic, anti-clerical newspaper. Now, let's go to our friendly witness, and you'll see by the testimony why I kind of like him, especially if you're going to talk to someone who has problems with the faith, maybe is a skeptic themselves.

17:29 Dr. Garrett says this. He says, almost at 2 o'clock, the very moment previously, the sun had triumphantly broke through a layer of clouds that had been covering it, and was shining bright and clear. I turned to this magnet that was attracting the eyes of everyone, and I could see it clear-cut, sharp-edged, and brilliant shining disc. And it didn't hurt to look at it. In my opinion, the comparison that I've heard made in Panama to a full silver disc is not a good one.

18:08 It was much clearer, livelier, and richer in color, and the hues gave it the appearances of a pearl. And he continues, it also should not be confused with the sun as seen through fog, which incidentally there wasn't at that time since the fog is opaque, diffused and it would veil the sunlight. In Fatima it had light and heat and it was clear cut as could be.

18:39 The sky was covered with wisp of clouds with the blue breaking through the sunlight, which was not annoying. At times, these wisp of clouds, white in the beginning, seemed to turn into a pink or translucent blue as it glided past the sun. The amazing thing is that no one could look at the sun, the very source of light and heat, for a very long time without paining the eyes or dazzling the retinas to blindness. The phenomenon must have lasted about 10 minutes, during which there were two brief interruptions when the fierce sun threw out a more brilliant and flashing rays, which had forced one to look away. This pearly disk suddenly began to move, and it was not the movement of a planet in its normal course, it spun on its own axis at breakneck speed. Suddenly a cry was heard, like an anguished shout from all the people. The sun, maintaining the velocity of its rotation, dislodged itself from the firmament in full, bloodily advance on the earth, threatening to crash us with its weight of its enormous and fiery mass.

19:56 He continues, since if that had been the case, I would not have been seeing things purple.

20:35 I turned around, I rubbed my eyelids and covered them with my hands to keep the light out. Still turned around, I opened my eyes, and I saw that just as before, the landscape and the air continued to the same purple color. The impression was not that of an eclipse. I had seen an eclipse of the sun, which in Vizu, where I had been at the time, was total.

21:04 And then finally he says, continuing to look at the sun, I noticed that the air cleared. In fact, everything near and far had now changed, taking on the color of old yellow damask. Now what's interesting about Dr. Garrett is a few days later, he tried to replicate the effects like a good scientist. So, a few days later, I did a test looking directly at the sun for a few moments. Looking away, I saw, after a few moments, the forms of uneven yellow spots. You did not see everything the same color as in the air where yellow topaz was volatilized, but rather dots or spots which would follow the movements of the eyes. all these phenomena which I have cited and described were observed by me coolly and calmly without any emotion or fear now how many of you ever tried to look at the sun as kids you don't have to raise your hands you can confirm what Dr. Garrett was saying you close your eyes, what do you see? You see spots and the spots seem to follow your eye he said that was not what happened at F-Anima That was not what happened at Fatima.

22:21 All right. So now that we heard the hostile witnesses back in 1917, let's see what current hostile people say about the miracle of the sun. How did they explain this miracle? One of the most popular explanations or ways of explaining away the miracle... is mass hallucination.

22:45 Yes, religious fervor and the desire to see something supernatural, the argument goes, causes a mass hysteria where the crowd convinces itself that the sun is moving and that it's changing colors. Okay. I can tell by your reaction you don't think that's a very strong objection. but you know if you're going to talk if you're going to talk to a bible christian what do you got to use? You got to use the Bible. If you're going to talk to a non-believer, what do you got to use? Hostile witnesses, right? Now, what does our hostile witnesses tell us about this hallucination theory? Well, the funny thing is, the hostile witnesses had absolutely no desire to see a miracle happen. In fact, they had every desire not to see a miracle happened. In fact, it's said that many of the newspapers didn't even bother to send reporters to Fatima because they knew that a miracle wouldn't happen. So they actually wrote their stories the day before. So the few that actually came there were there to ridicule the crowd. So it's hard to believe that these hostile witnesses were caught up by a mass hallucination and claimed that a miracle happened when they don't even believe God exists.

24:04 Moreover, if it was a mass hallucination, you would expect it to happen during the peak where everybody expected it to happen. Right? But I don't know if you know this, but the miracle actually happened when people started leaving and many people felt despondent that there wasn't a sign.

24:25 Okay. Again, that would certainly argue against this mass hallucination, you know, religious fervor idea. Another problem, too, is that all the observations, if you take Dr. Garrett's and the other two information in the article, You find out that as they surveyed the people around... and their own accounts, they all agree on four points, or at least attest to four points. One, that the sun became a mother-of-pearl color that the people could look at without discomfort. Number two, that the sun moved and spun in never-before-brusque movements beyond the laws of nature. Three, that some claim to have a vision of Mary. Not only the three shepherd children, but if you remember in the Osseculo account, some claim they actually saw Mary smiling.

25:22 And four, changing colors. Now, you might be caught up in religious fervor. you might think that you're seeing a miracle, but what's the odds of... Now remember, we're talking somewhere between 30,000 and 70,000 people all mass hallucinate exactly in the same four points. I mean, I think it's easier to claim that that's miraculous in itself.

25:49 So if we use what's called Occam's razor, where the simplest explanation is usually the right one, the mass hallucination theory is just preposterous. Just preposterous. Yeah, okay. The second theory is the optical illusion theory. I'm curious to see what your action is to this. By prolonged staring at the sun, there started an optical illusion where the sun seemed to have been moving around when, in fact, it was merely eye damage.

26:28 Okay, so you think, I can tell by your reaction, you think this is more plausible. Very good. Well, how plausible is it? Well, let's look at the hostile witnesses and let's see what they have to say about this. These witnesses, curiously enough, if, okay, let's put it this way. If the miracle of the sun was caused by a prolonged staring at the sun, you would expect that the miracle would happen sometime, you know, you'd be looking at the sun for a few moments, and then the optical illusion would start, right? But the hostile witness claimed that the phenomenon of the sun happened, excuse me, the witnesses turned their attentions to the sun only after the phenomenon had begun to take place, not before, okay?

27:24 So, obviously, the sun starts moving, you turn your attention to it, it can't be from prolonged exposure to the sun. Amen? Okay. Moreover, and this is something I tried to check, I looked at all the testimonies and interrogations of the children. Mary never specifically explains what is the nature of the sign she was going to give on October 13th. They never say that. Now in interviews after October 13th, the children do mention the sun, so they're kind of retrojecting. But Mary never said on October 13th, I'm going to make the sun move. So everybody there in Fatima that were witnessing the children during the apparition before the miracle, were all facing where the apparition was because that would be the most logical place where the miracle would happen.

28:18 Which is why the miracle of the sun attracts people's attention. It's already happening. It isn't like everyone was standing up looking at the sun. wondering when is it going to do something interesting. So I think we could dismiss that, the prolonged staring at the sun.

28:38 So even if something like that could produce an optical illusion, it definitely didn't happen at Fatima. Also, the friendly witness. Remember, we saw Dr. Garrett try to reproduce the phenomenon after the fact. He tried looking at the sun to see what would happen. And, of course, if it is an optical illusion, we should be able to reproduce it. And all he said was, it looked like spots. Nothing like how he witnessed on October 13th. Okay, third one, the meteorological explanation. this one claims that we know in science that sometimes particles in the upper atmosphere can... can cause a distortion of sunlight and sometimes make the sun appear to change colors. And so some skeptics today say that that's basically all that happened in Fatima.

29:40 It was just upper atmosphere particles. Well even if that were true, it doesn't explain the movement of the sun, right? And it also doesn't explain how three shepherd children were able to predict months ahead of time that there would be dust particles that would produce some sort of strange effect on that particular date and time. And also there's another problem too. The dust particle problem, if you go on the internet, sometimes they'll have pictures of the phenomenon. And usually there's a heavy cloud layer and you'll see the sun with different colors. Very foggy. Well again, our hosta witnesses and our friendly witness both say that the sun was clear clouds, you could be seen directly. And notice Dr. Garrett was very specific.

30:33 He said it was clean cut, you could see clear edges. So that rules out upper atmosphere distortion, as far as dust particles or whatever. Okay. Now, there's a fourth approach. You know, if three times you fail, try, try again. I actually like this one because it's basically a layer of humidity plus all the other stuff. Right? Just throw it all in. And it's actually kind of an ingenious explanation, but it doesn't fly any better than the other ones. Now, this particular theory is this. It says a layer of very humid air caused a kind of fog that enabled the crowd to look at the sun without harm. And this combined with, you know, mass hysteria and the expectation of finding something that's going to happen and the rainbow effects caused by this humidity, basically all the things we just said, Plus, prolonged staring at the sun made the sun move, change colors, etc., etc., etc.

31:40 Now, you always have to wonder about the kitchen sink approach. You know, that's almost a confession that, you know, something is very difficult to explain away. Well, you know, what's interesting is this particular skeptic, and I've seen it a few other places, focuses in on something that not very many people who know things about of Panama, realize. But Dr. Garrett actually recognized it. The skeptic mentioned something about smoke or fog that appeared above the children, and he interpreted that as a layer of humidity. Now here's what Dr. Garrett actually witnessed this, and this is what he said. It must have been about 1.30 p.m. when there arose on the exact spot where the children were a column of smoke, thin, fine, and bluish, which extended up about two meters above their heads and evaporated at that height.

32:35 This phenomenon, perfectly visible to the naked eye, lasted for a few seconds. Not having noted how long it lasted, I cannot say whether it was more or less a minute, the smoke dissipated abruptly, and after some time, it came back to occur a second time and then a third time. I don't know how many people here knew about that.

33:00 Well, is this a layer of humidity? What's going on here? Well, for one thing, Dr. Garrett makes it very clear that it dissipated. It wasn't no more than a couple of feet above the children's head. And actually, if you look at the accounts, this same phenomenon was witnessed with the previous visions that the three children had. this odd smoke that seemed to appear in that same area. and then dissipate.

33:32 Has anybody seen the film Miracles of Fatima with Ricardo Montalban? Wonderful film, if you ever see it. They actually get it right. You see the smoke. Well, obviously, this is in a layer of humidity that covered between 30,000 and 70,000 people. Okay, let's get real. This is a thin, calm smoke. Most people who witnessed it said it was almost like incense were being offered. You know how incense is just a narrow cloud? It was like that. And of course, the kitchen sink doesn't help any better than all the other debunking things. Obviously, you don't have mass hysteria. You don't have people looking at the sun. You don't have all the other things. So that's pretty much the best that the skeptics have to offer. Now notice, thanks be to God, the hostile witnesses help us to debunk modern skeptics.

34:26 Okay, so is there any kind of tenable scientific explanation of what happened with the miracle of the sun? So let's go a little bit into science. I believe Dr. Fustigi mentioned this in his first talk. There's a theologian and a physicist named Father Stanley Yockey. Great guy, very knowledgeable. And he proposed a scientifically plausible explanation for the miracle of the sun.

34:56 Now before I begin, it's important to notice that when God works miracles, sometimes he uses secondary causes. For example, if there's a miraculous healing, sometimes God will use all the mechanisms within your body to heal the person. but only there's a supernatural agency so that what would have took months to heal completely was instantaneous. But God still uses natural means. So Father Iacchi's solution actually has some plausibility in that sense. Now what does he say? He says, for sure we can rule out that the miracle of the sun was a solar phenomenon. We know the sun actually didn't move. And we know this because observatories around the world all recorded... absolutely no difference in the sun on October 13, 1917. Okay.

35:47 So, Father Yockey says, so that we could probably understand it more as a meteorological phenomenon. Now his theory is, as you have heard, that Yockey proposes that ice crystals in the upper atmosphere... formed what he called an air lens, and that this air lens refracted various colors of the rainbow, And that combined with the mixing of warm and cold air masses. caused this air lens to rotate and also plunge down to Earth in a kind of boomerang effect, which Father Yockey claims is completely feasible given the fluid dynamics. But as Dr. Fastigi pointed out, the coordination of all these things is itself miraculous. Actually, Father Yackey says, and I quote, the careful coordinated interplay of so many physical factors would by itself be a miracle, even if one doesn't wish to see anything more than what actually happened.

36:52 Clearly the quote-unquote miracle of the sun was not merely a meteorological phenomenon, however rare. Was Father Yockey right? Well, I think his theory actually has a lot of merit. But even Father Yockey's admission of the interplay of so many physical factors, when you take into account what we heard from the hostile witnesses and the friendly witness, really kicks it up even more of a notch than Father Iacchi admits. Consider this.

37:28 The hostile witnesses, the friendly witnesses, explicitly state that the sun was clear and had a well-defined edge. Now, if such an air lens existed, that air lens would have to be in perfect proportion to the sun. as seen from the ground of Panama, so that you wouldn't be able to say, oh, there seems to be some sort of circle around the sun, right? Not only that, but it had to change size. When the air lens comes up and down, it has to expand and contract in proportion to the 30,000 to 70,000 people witnessing it.

38:03 Not only that, but as Father Yockey says, these ice crystals would refract the rainbow. Somehow they would only refract certain colors because none of the witnesses talk about a rainbow, but they do talk about blue and purple and so on. So, the miracle of the sun for us today.

38:24 Although today, 100 years after Fatima, we're not experiencing the same kind of persecution that they did back in 1917. But we do live in a world where the media is certainly not Catholic-friendly, to say the least. When I was on a national radio program and they asked me, Gary, if the miracle of the sun happens today, I bet it would be all over the press. We have massive believers. And I said, you know, I don't think so. I think the news would report it like this. Crowds report a rare... immunological phenomenon in Portugal today. Some claim it's caused by the Blessed Virgin Mary. others say otherwise. Now let's go to sports.

39:14 Today, we are affected by hypercriticism. We're affected by a militant egalitarianism. Never claim that anybody is any more special or anything is true as opposed to something being false. And I think they would flatten whatever they say. Our Lord was very wise to have have the miracle happen at this place in this time the miracle the son is really a gift for us for the new evangelization. And it also helps us to realize that the suffering, the mocking, the ridicule that these poor people in Fatima that received from the anti-Catholic press... actually produced sterling witnesses to God's work and approbation of Mary's appearance.

40:02 In other words, as it says in 1 Corinthians 3.19, God tells us that he catches the wise in their own ruses. Yes, the wise of that day didn't believe in God. They didn't believe in Marian apparitions. But they were forced to admit that a miracle did take place. And so they were on the same standing as three little shepherd children who knew that months earlier.

40:34 Thank you very much.

Machine translated from the source