God Taps #9 · “Persist

Scott Black Johnston · Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church · 7 West 55th Street, New York, New York 10103 · Published November 8, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:00 Let us pray. Gracious God, open our hearts and our minds by the power of your Holy Spirit so that as your scripture is read and your word is proclaimed, we might hear with joy what it is that you are saying to us this day. This we pray in the name of Jesus Christ, our rock and our redeemer. Amen. Amen. For the past nine weeks, Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church has been studying biblical stories in which God taps someone on the shoulder, leans in, and says, Your life has purpose. There is holy work here for you to do.

1:01 Today, our attention turns to a story that sets God's call in the context of the wider culture. How does the Holy One want us to behave as people of faith and as citizens? People who live and work and go to school, who engage in commerce, who chat with their neighbors, who vote for leaders and who otherwise participate in a complicated world. Our text for this morning comes from a letter written by the Apostle Paul. It's addressed to Paul's protege, Timothy. Let's listen in as Paul describes God's challenging tap on the shoulder to faithful souls. Our reading comes from 2 Timothy chapter 4, beginning with the first verse.

2:00 In the presence of God and of Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and in view of his appearing and his kingdom, I solemnly urge you, proclaim the message. Be persistent, whether the time is favorable or unfavorable. convince, rebuke, and encourage with the utmost patience in teaching. For the time is coming when people will not put up with sound teaching, but having their ears tickled, they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own desires and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander away to myths.

2:56 As for you, be sober in everything, endure suffering, do the work of an evangelist, carry out your ministry fully. This is the word of God for you, the people of God. Thanks be to God. Since we last gathered for worship, the United States has elected a new crop of representatives, senators, governors, and other officials. I pray that God will fill each of these newly elected and re-elected leaders with wisdom and grace. I pray that they will guide this country along a sacred path, a path described in scripture in the book of Micah. I'm speaking of the moment when the prophet asks, what does God require of us? And Micah famously answers his own question, What does God require of us but to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with our Lord?

4:16 Along with prayers for a future steeped in justice, kindness, and humility, many of us today are breathing a sigh of relief. another season of acrimonious political campaigning with its vicious advertisements, ceaseless campaign solicitations, and uncommonly nasty rhetoric is behind us. At least that's our hope. In the aftermath of a national election, the op-ed pieces, the social media posts, and the political blogs start to shift in tone, don't they? After describing victory parties and delivering campaign postmortems, politicos start talking about the challenge of governing. These analysts highlight the monumental tasks that lie before us as a society.

5:18 As an old high school debater, I'm eager for this new phase, this can we figure out how to govern part of the political cycle. I say this because in recent years it feels like political campaigns have spent less and less time debating issues while devoting ever more time, energy, and ungodly amounts of money to mudslinging. This election cycle over one billion dollars was spent on political advertisements in the great state of Texas alone. CBS News categorized the overwhelming majority of these ads as attack messaging.

6:04 Our current approach to politics begs, I think, an important question. Do we know what our newly elected officials think about pressing issues like climate change, immigration, inflation, the war in Ukraine, our war with Iran, how to do AI right, you know, cures for cancer instead of killer robots, housing shortages, tariff burdens, and the soon-to-be-empty pot that's supposed to fund Social Security. Now, who is to blame for this predicament? I know that each of us can name politicians from both sides of the aisle who never miss an opportunity to choose an attack over an idea. But friends, the Calvinist in me cannot help but wonder, aren't they simply giving us what we want?

7:04 mudslinging works. Political campaigns dish up anger because we are eager to consume it. Although maybe, maybe, just maybe, the tide is turning. One of the interesting facts arising from our latest trip to the polls is that this past week, Americans more than doubled the number of clergy in the House of Representatives and the Senate. We added six new clergy and a seminarian, most from middle America, from places like Iowa and Kansas and Texas, most from the so-called mainline denominations. We elected Lutherans and Methodists, a National Baptist and a Presbyterian.

8:02 Some find our new embrace of all these ordained politicians unsettling. I find it kind of fascinating. And I have a theory about this. I think a growing number of people in this country, some of whom belong to communities of faith, many of whom are simply faith curious. I think a growing number of people in this country are looking for conversations that frame the challenges of the day in moral and spiritual language. Fed up with endless volleys of political vitriol, American citizens seem increasingly eager to talk about virtue. If the many campaign signs lifting up Jesus' command to love thy neighbor are any indication, folk are hungry to discuss the place of compassion in the public square.

9:09 In fact, at this moment in history, I'd go so far as to say that justice, kindness, and yes, the most often and easily abandoned virtue, humility, are starting to look pretty darn appealing to us. So with a nod to those who argue it's the economy, stupid, and I do acknowledge that fuel prices matter, Dr. Hubbard, my theory goes like this. We've had our fill of unrelenting political fisticuffs and the steady drip, drip, drip of toxic rhetoric on our society's fabric. We are exhausted. And in the face of it all, a lot of folk are yearning right now for a new vision, a better way. Now, what gives rise to good, healthy, draw people together vision. Well, my friends, one of life's most difficult truths, one of humankind's hardest won lessons, is that difficult circumstances can focus our attention on what matters. A rough road has the capacity to foster a clear-eyed vision. In 1819, English poet Percy Shelley wrote a letter to his friend Lee Hunt. In his letter, Shelley included a poem, and he asked that Hunt, the editor of The Examiner, a prominent London weekly newspaper, he asked that Hunt would consider publishing the piece. Hunt declined. In fact, the poem did not appear in print until Shelley's wife published it three years after her husband's death. Shelley's poem is on the cover

11:16 of your bulletin today, and you can now find this poem in any good anthology of top quality English poetry, I'd like to read it to you this morning and then talk about the events that gave rise to these verses. England in 1819. An old, mad, blind, despised, and dying king. Princes, the dregs of their dull race who flow through public scorn, mud from a muddy spring. Rulers who neither see nor feel nor know, but leech-like to their fainting country cling, till they drop blind in blood without a blow. A people starved and stabbed in the untilled field.

12:16 An army whom liberty side and pray makes as a two-edged sword to all who wield. Golden, sanguine laws which tempt and slay. Religion, Christ-less, godless, a book sealed. A Senate, time's worst, statute unrepealed. Our graves from which a glorious phantom may burst. to illumine our tempestuous day.

12:50 Having heard the poem, why do you think Shelley's friend decided to shelve it? Perhaps the editor did not appreciate the poem's political tone, although Hunt did publish other political pieces, and the examiner took a strong stand against the institution of slavery. Perhaps Hunt did not like that the poem points a finger at people in power. In the poem, Shelley calls out King George III, an old, mad, blind, despised, and dying king. When the poem was written, the king was 81. He only had a few months to live. Perhaps the paper wished to be respectful in the face of the ruler's infirmity, or maybe the examiner did not want to offend other people in power. Shelley's poem calls out the king's sons, princes, the dregs of their dull race.

13:56 As the poem unfolds, its accusatory finger steers our attention to other aspects of English society. Shelley calls out rulers who suck blood from the country like leeches while common people struggle. Shelley calls out members of the military who assault the very freedom that they're supposed to protect. And finally, Shelley calls out religious leaders who make no room for the love of Christ, no room for the justice of God in their so-called faith. He bemoans clergy who keep the good book sealed so as not to be disturbed by God's commands to care for those in need.

14:41 I'm speculating here, but I wonder if Hunt shelved this poem because it radiates so much righteous anger. The rage in these verses is palpable. What is their source? Well, the impetus for the poet's anger, historians tell us, came from a massacre that occurred outside the city of Manchester. on August 16th of 1819. On that date, an armed cavalry summoned by local magistrates charged with sabers drawn into a crowd of 60,000 women, men, and children. These peaceful demonstrators had gathered to advocate for universal suffrage. and to protest against the corn laws, tariffs on grain that raised prices and threatened to put bread out of reach for working class folk.

15:45 Thus the verse, a people starved and stabbed in the untilled field. Shelley's fury over his government's brutal treatment of its own citizens in Manchester is clear. Although anger is not how he chooses to end the poem. In its final two verses, the poem pictures society's mistakes as graves. Graves from which a spirit might burst forth to give light to our tempestuous day. what sort of spirit do you think Shelley imagines will emerge? What might a healthier vision look like coming from the graves? The best visions, I think, the ones that move the needle and bring about good for humankind, are equal parts hard-nosed realism, inspiring beauty, and bold, courageous creativity.

16:53 A good vision gathers people around a cause instead of splitting us off into factions. And here our faith begs to testify. The most powerful visions inspire people in the midst of tough circumstances, instilling us with courage and challenging us to be willing to sacrifice, to sacrifice in the face of a worthy goal. It's not a word you hear a lot in political discourse anymore, is it? Sacrifice.

17:31 The Apostle Paul gets this. In today's passage, Paul writes to his protege, Timothy. The old preacher rehearses for the young disciple. The Christian vision that emerges after a very tough time after Good Friday. The vision of Easter morn. A spirit bursting forth. from the grave. This is what the apostle writes. In the presence of God and Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and in view of his appearing and his kingdom, I solemnly urge you proclaim the message. The next few words that Paul offers to Timothy feel almost evergreen apropos to this and so many other historical moments. Listen again, listen carefully to the Apostles' Council. Be persistent. Whether the time is favorable or unfavorable, convince, rebuke, and encourage with the utmost patience in teaching.

18:41 for the time is coming when people will not put up with sound teaching, but having their ears tickled, what a great phrase, right? Having their ears tickled, they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own desires and turn away from listening to the truth and wander away to myths. Paul's words are a summons, a tap on the shoulder, a reminder for young Timothy and for the faithful of every age that we will be tempted to wander away from God's loving vision, tempted to pursue selfish desires. We are surrounded in this weary world, Paul asserts, by myths, by scary fables, by lies that masquerade as the truth.

19:39 These divisions are powerful, but they're not an excuse to throw in the towel, nor are they reason for despair, says Paul. They are simply a reminder that our job, our calling, is to persist in the face of these falsehoods. In every age, in favorable times and unfavorable times, our mission is to give voice to the vision shared with us and embodied for us by Jesus Christ. You know how it goes. You know the Sermon on the Mount. Blessed are the poor and the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of God. Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted. Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God.

20:40 On 26th Street and Nicollet Avenue South in Minneapolis, Minnesota, there's a memorial at the place where Alex Preddy was shot. Freddie was killed after he extended a hand to a woman who had been knocked down by still unnamed federal agents this past January. The memorial includes a stethoscope. Freddie was a nurse at the local Veterans Hospital. It contains pictures of a few saints, including one with Preddy having a halo. Preddy was a Catholic, an altar boy in his youth. The Kordinov space on the sidewalk there is filled with flowers, so many flowers. There's a cardboard sign stuck in the midst of the blooms that says, Love Thy Neighbor. And this past week, the lamp posts and fire hydrants next to the memorial were slowly and steadily covered by,

21:59 I voted, stickers. It was, you might say, a vision, a grave from which a glorious phantom may burst to illumine our tempestuous day. This is the heart of it, Paul says to Timothy. These are the words we need tattooed on our souls. God alone will be our judge. Christ, who revealed God's love and justice to us, will be our only judge, the only one who matters. and this news matters more than all the static this gnarly world can generate. Bind this truth to your heart, says the apostle.

22:54 Let this vision guide your steps and you will find the strength to persist. Friends, I invite you now to stand in body or in spirit and join me in praying the prayer for the day. A prayer that comes from American author, minister, and theologian Howard Thurman. It can be found printed in your bulletins and on your screen. Deep river of a God, keep alive in me the forward look, the high hope, the onward surge. Let me not be frozen, either by the past or the present. Grant me, O patient Father, thy sense of the future, without which all life would sicken and die.

Machine translated from the source