David Lee · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
2:30 Well, my favorite Christmas movie is not only Home Alone 1 and 2, it's also Elf, right? You guys know Elf? Yes, Elf is one of the best ones where Will Ferrell plays Buddy the Elf. And one of the best things about Elf is that he is just so happy and joyful all the time, kind of annoyingly so, right? It's as if he doesn't know what's really happening around him. And he's just always with a smile, always so much optimism and hope and joy. And I don't know about you, but for me, when I watch Elle for lots of other Christmas movies, sometimes I can feel a little guilty because I don't feel that way. I don't feel the way that Will Ferrell does all the time. You know, half of New York City is sick right now. You know, there's a lot about our families that make it difficult for us to always enjoy this holiday season. And yet, the movies and the lights and the decorations sort of force us to kind of think that we're supposed to have this elf-like, this buddy-like Christmas spirit and joy all of the time.
3:34 And there can be this strange dissonance in this season. I don't know if you feel it, but I certainly feel it. Because as much as I want that to be true, it's often not so. When you look out into the world and you realize the darkness and the pain and the brokenness of this world, it's hard to feel that kind of optimism and joy that we want to have in this season. When there's mass shootings happening in colleges, when there's the shooting at Bondi Beach, or there's still warfare going on in Russia and Ukraine, or the conflict that's continuing in the Middle East. When you see these kinds of things, it's hard to feel like you can be really joyful. And not just big world picture things either. Just personally. Again, the holiday season can be one that's actually filled with a lot of the holiday blues. Where your marriages are going through a lot of difficulty and there's pain there.
4:32 Or your families aren't exactly what you would love it to be. Or your job situations. Maybe you lost your job or you're looking for something else. Life doesn't feel as fulfilling. And you have all these unmet desires that are welling up within us. And so for me, I think the cultural celebration of Christmas can often just sort of feel like this welcome distraction from the real pain, from the realities of the world all around us. I think that's something that Tish Harrison Warren, who writes this piece about Christmas in the New York Times op-ed every so often, she says this and I think captures the spirit of it well. She says that American culture insists that we run at a breathless pace from sugar-laced celebration to celebration, from Thanksgiving to Christmas to the Super Bowl to Valentine's Day and on and on. We suffer from this collective consumerist mania that demands that we remain optimistic and shiny and happy and having fun, fun, fun. But life isn't a Disney cruise. The tyranny of relentless mandatory celebration leaves us exhausted and often, ironically, feeling emptier.
5:41 Many of us suffer from the holiday blues. And I wonder whether this phenomenon is made worse by the incessant demand for cheer, the collective lie that through enough work and positivity, we can perfect our lives and the world. I think she puts her finger on something that many of us might be feeling today. And the question for us is actually, is this what Christmas is really about? Because if it is, I don't want really much a part of it. And hopefully as you've been listening to the lessons, the readings, the carols, the songs, the things that we've been singing about, you can actually see that the real message of Christmas is not about just sentiment or positivity or this baseless, optimistic hope and joy that we hope will come one day. Instead, it's not meant to be just a distraction from the world, but the essence of Christmas is that it is a deep and a real hope and joy in and for this very world that we're living in today. And that's what our final reading, our reading in Luke chapter 2, gets to the heart of. Starting in verse 10, the heart of the passage, the angels come to the shepherds and they say, do not be afraid. I bring you good news that will cause great joy for all the people. For today, a Savior has been born to you. He is the Messiah and the Lord. Friends, Christmas, the real message of Christmas is actually good news of great joy, great hope, great peace for all the people for our lived realities today. And so I want to just briefly look at what we can learn about this idea, about what Christmas is really about, by asking three quick questions for us.
7:27 Let's look at first when, then we'll look at how and why. When does this happen? How does this happen? And why does Christmas actually happen? So first, let's look at when. One of the first things that we learn about Christmas... is that it is good news. It is fundamentally good news. It is a historical announcement that is made in time. Now, I don't know how much you know about the writer who is Luke, But Luke was a physician and a historian. And so earlier on in Luke chapter one, he announces, hey, I've done all that I can to capture as many eyewitness accounts to tell you exactly what has happened in the life of Jesus. And so he's reporting even in our passage that Jesus was born when? When Caesar Augustus was the emperor, right? And Caesar Augustus, if you know your Roman history, you would know that he ruled from about 30 BC to about 14 AD.
8:24 And the reason why Luke puts that in is because he's not saying, in a land far, far away, or once upon a time long ago. He starts, he roots the Christmas story in actual history. This is Luke's way of saying, this actually happened. Now, maybe for some of us, we put Jesus and the birth of Jesus in the same category as Santa and the elves and the buddy elf and the Easter bunny that kind of becomes the mascot for these Christian Christmases or the Christian religions. But what Luke is actually trying to make very, very clear to us is that he is reporting on a true fact in history. This is news of something that God has done in space, time, and in history. And you might be asking, well, why does it matter? Why are we making a big stink out of this?
9:16 Because here's the thing. Fundamentally, Christianity is about good news, not good advice. Think about the difference between those two things. Good advice is something where you're not sure what's going to happen, but I'm going to give you a lot of different options for you to consider, to take into your own hands, and you can either take this advice or not for you to have some kind of an outcome. But what is news? Good news is something that's already been done in history. You can't change it. Something has already been done, it is being reported, and now you can respond to that good news. And friends, here's the thing. Basically, every other major religion in this world is offering good advice. Here's how you need to live. Here are the rules that you need to follow if you want to live a good life. Here's how you should live in order for the prospect of having peace or joy or love or goodness in your life.
10:12 Every other religion is essentially saying that, which means there's no real difference whether Gandhi or Muhammad or Buddha was actually a historical figure or not. These leaders become symbols or inspiration for you to live on their advice. That's what good advice is. But Christianity, my friends, is completely different from that. If the birth of Jesus did not actually take place in history, if you believe that he is just this symbolic, inspirational leader and a figure that we sing about during this time, do you realize that all of Christianity falls apart? Because fundamentally, Christianity is not that Jesus is this moral example that we are meant to follow, but that Jesus actually comes in space, time, and history to be our savior, to act, to intervene, to move into this world in order to do the things that we could never do.
11:19 And that's the essential message of what Christmas as well as what Christianity is that's quite offensive because it's essentially saying that the reason you need not just a moral example to live this life is because the problems that we face, the pain, the brokenness, the darkness that we have in this world, it is way more than we could possibly handle on our own. That there is no amount of advice or motivation or strategies that you and I could come up with in humanity. to ever fix what is actually wrong, to fully heal the pain and the brokenness that we experience. And so the message of Christmas saying that you need God himself to come into space, time, and history to intervene on our behalf in order to save and rescue us, not to motivate us. And that's a fundamental difference of what Christianity is offering.
12:12 And therefore, the story, the birth of Jesus is actually God saying, I'm sending the long-awaited Messiah to come and save humanity because I've not left you on your own to figure things out. That is incredibly important and very, very hopeful, especially when you realize that you come to the end of yourself and you don't have the resources to get your life together. So that's the first thing that we can learn about Christmas. But here's the second thing, not just the when it happens, but how. Let's look at that. You know, what Luke is doing here, he is not just trying to help us to understand that the birth of Jesus actually happened in real history. What he is also doing in our passage is he is setting up this direct contrast between Jesus, whom is the savior of the world through God's eyes, and Caesar Augustus, the most powerful human being during that time and that period. You could actually, in fact, argue that Caesar Augustus during this time was quite literally the most powerful human being in the history of that time. You know, under his rule, he did a lot. He accomplished a ton. He consolidated military strength. He centralized government. Economics were through the roof, and it famously led to a period in Roman history called the Pax Romana. It was the peace of Rome. Because of all of his power and all that he did, he brought about the peace and stability of Rome. And in fact, we read that in our passage that he decrees this census, which is why everyone's shuffling around to go back home to register. The reason for that was because he was trying to implement this widespread taxation program. And the best way to do that was to know exactly who and where everyone was so that they could be taxed. Because if he taxes them, that's how you get peace. This was the payment essentially for the peace of Rome. You need loyalty. You need to follow him. You need to help pool your resources and your money together in order to have the kind of peace that you're
14:17 looking for. And so his reign, I think, very much represents the way of this world that promises us peace and joy and all of the things that we're looking for. How? Through power, through resources, through strategy, through might, through the ways of Caesar Augustus, right? Which is why I think a lot of times we often think, the reason why I think our world is so polarized and divided today is because we do look around and we see that things are falling apart, that there isn't a lot of hope. And we often think that if we could just get the right people in power, if we could just get the right policies in place, if we could just get enough education or technology or fill in the blank, then the world will be at peace. Things won't be as crazy. Things will be back to normal.
15:10 Things will be sane and we will finally flourish. that's the way of the world that's the way of Caesar Augustus and in the midst of that Luke is saying that we see God operating in a completely different paradigm from that where the angel of the Lord comes and announces that the long awaited Messiah the hope of the world the savior of all that you are looking for has come not in a palace but in a pigsty that you will find a baby, not a king or a ruler, but a baby wrapped in cloth lying in a manger. That is how God comes to save. Now, there's actually, if you walk out here in the big steps, there's this great nativity scene. And you see the different pictures of Jesus's birth being born in a manger.
16:02 And a lot of times you look at those scenes of Jesus with some animals that are like smiling and cuddling with him. and we romanticize what Jesus' birth actually was. We think that it was full of peace and it was joyous and beautiful, but you realize what a manger is, right? It's like the feeding pen of animals. Imagine how loud, how smelly, how unsanitary things would have been. That's where Jesus is born. And the reason for that, we read, is because there was no room for him, for Joseph and Mary at the inn. that means they had zero connections. Do you know what kind of person you would have to be in order for you not to be brought into another home when hospitality was very much valued in that culture? And for you to give birth in the back stall. with other pigs and animals.
16:56 They didn't come from means. Jesus is born to a poor family with no connections, basically to nobodies. Not in a palace, but in a pigsty. And here's what we learn, that the way God works, the savior of the world does not come as a war hero or a tech savant or a CEO or a strategist or a philosopher or the most resourced person in the world. That is not how he comes. Instead, we learn that the way that God brings about his salvation, real peace and joy in the world, is through the most unexpected ways, not through power, strength, and might. but through weakness, vulnerability, and utter, utter humility. That is how Jesus is born. And that is also why the message of Christianity and the message of Christmas is only really received and celebrated by the humble that's willing not to look in the places of power in the center of society, but on the outskirts.
18:03 You know, in our passage, this message is given to the shepherds. Do you know who the shepherds were culturally in that society? They were the most looked down upon. And yet, that is who God principally sends his message. That is who celebrates, who trusts God's word, and then follows the angel's instructions to go look for the Savior of the world in a manger.
18:27 See, friends, only the humble, therefore, not the proud, only the humble will celebrate and receive Jesus in this season. because only the humble are not busy trying to be a savior ourselves or looking to the places of power for real hope. If we do, if we look to the powerful kings of this world, to large crowds in the center of it all and not unto the margins, to the lowly, to those who are outcasts, then we will miss what God is doing entirely because the way that the infinite, all-powerful God chooses to come is to be lowly in a manger to a poor Jewish family in a back stable. and is how he comes. That's the second thing we learn. But then finally, let's look at why. Because the question that you might be having is, why does God come this way? And that is essentially because that is the only way that he will actually be a savior for us.
19:22 And this is what's gonna tie everything together for us. Why does he come this way? Well, I wanna start by asking the question, well, what is really wrong with the world? Why is it that you really think we experience pain or brokenness or darkness or strife. Well, we talked about it earlier on in the service. Gustavo talked about it with Genesis 3 that paints the picture ultimately of what is wrong with the world. You see, the Bible tells us that we were made to be in a relationship with our creator, that you are not a mistake. You are made wonderfully and beautifully in him, but the way that we're meant to flourish is to be in a relationship with him, him as our Lord, him as our king, him as the one that we look to to live this life. and yet what happens in Genesis 3 and inside of all of our hearts is that we choose to be our own kings. We choose to live our life apart from him. We break our relationship with God. That is the essence of what the Bible calls sin.
20:17 It is a breaking of relationship with him and that is the reason why things have gone all out of whack. That is the reason why our hearts are self-centered and prioritize now ourselves rather than looking to help and serve other people around us. That is why we look to ourselves rather than to God for direction in this life. And the hard truth that the Bible tells us and that the Christmas message tells us is that evil and darkness and brokenness is not out there somewhere, but it is in here that every single one of our hearts have evil, that we are evil, and that is what causes some of the darkness in this world. Here's another quote from Tish Harrison Warren. She says that we dwell in a world still wracked with conflict, violence, suffering, darkness. But Advent, or the Christmas season, holds space for our grief, and it reminds us that all of us, in one way or another, are not only wounded by the evil in the world, but we are also wielders of it, contributing our own moments of unkindness or impatience or selfishness.
21:26 that is what is ultimately wrong. And that is why we cannot heal or fix ourselves. because we're part of the problem. And friends, you see, the reason why Jesus comes so lowly, humble, weak, and vulnerable is because if he came as an all-powerful, mighty judge of the world to come and get rid of all evil once and for all, all judgment, do you realize that every single one of us here in this room, would be swept up in it? That none of us would be stand left righteous, standing before God saying, there is no evil in me. See, if God comes the way that we want him to come in strength, he will swift us all the way in judgment. And that is why he comes not as his powerful king and ruler, but he comes principally as a baby.
22:23 He comes as a human being, weak and mortal and vulnerable. Why? Because he comes not to bring judgment, but he first comes to bear judgment on our behalf. That is why Jesus comes much more like us in our human condition to take on our selfishness and everything that separates us from God. So he comes so that he might not bring judgment, but to be a true savior that bears the judgment of our self-centeredness and our wickedness and our sin because he promises that he will one day return again. to get rid of all evil and he will judge fully and completely and he will end it without ending us. Friends, that is the significance of why he has to actually come in history because he's not just pointing us to the way of salvation.
23:20 He is our salvation. He is how God reconciles man and God together. And that is why he alone can do the salvation that none of us could possibly do ourselves. That is why he comes in weakness and in humility. And friends, let me end with this. Him being born in a manger is just the beginning of the humility and the weakness in his life. Because what began in a wooden trough next to animals, do you know where his life ends? On a wooden cross next to criminals. In complete, utter humility, humiliation, vulnerability, woundableness, to take on our condition on his behalf. And you see, on the cross, my friends, Jesus, he gets completely rejected.
24:19 He gets rejected from the inn at the room so that now on the cross when he dies for us, you and I can now be welcomed into the Father's house for all of eternity. You see, Jesus is the one who is not accepted so that we might be accepted in him. This is the only way that the Christmas message can be good news of great joy, of great peace, of great reconciliation in the midst of the darkness in this world. And great hope and joy for you and I in this season, no matter what you might be feeling, that there is a great hope, a great light that has dawned in the darkness that you can now look to as your savior to find the hope that you need for this life.
Machine translated from the source