Bijan Mirtolooi · Redeemer West Side · Published March 1, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
1:55 Good morning. We are in a series of sermons asking the question, who is this Jesus? What is Jesus like? What does he value? And what does all that mean for our lives and for our world today? So each week we're looking at a different passage in the Gospels to help us understand more about who Jesus is. This passage today has meant a lot to me over the years, and it's a passage that introduces us to how Jesus responds to people who doubt him. Or another way to say it, when a follower of Jesus has a crisis of faith, how does Jesus engage with that person? You see John the Baptist asking to Jesus, are you the one? That means John's asking, are you the Messiah?
2:51 In the first century, there were lots of expectations and hopes for a Messiah to come, someone who would save and rescue and renew everything. And John has come to a place in his life. where he's asking Jesus, I thought that's who you were, but have I built my life on the wrong foundation? Was I wrong, John is asking, to give you all of my allegiance? He's doubting. And it's not merely an intellectual doubt. This is shaking him to his core. He's despairing. He's having a major crisis of faith. And for that reason, I think this passage is actually extraordinarily relevant for modern people because one of the features of living in modern Western culture is everyone doubts. Doubters believe. Believers doubt.
3:45 And the question for us today is, how does Jesus respond to people who doubt? How does Jesus engage with people who have a crisis of faith? This passage is a kind of case study. And so looking at it with you, I want to show you where doubt can often come from and what to do with those doubts when they arise in your heart. And finally, and most importantly, how does Jesus respond to those doubts? So where does it come from? What should you do when you have them? And how does Jesus respond to those who have doubts? Let's take a look. First, where does doubt come from? Now, many of you will have heard of John the Baptist before, but it's important for us for a moment to remind ourselves who John the Baptist is. In Matthew chapter 3, we're introduced to John the Baptist as the forerunner of Jesus Christ. Another way to say it is, John the Baptist was Jesus' advance man.
4:46 He was the one who was sent into the world, literally prophesied about, to prepare the way, to kind of pave the path for Jesus to come and for Jesus' ministry. And so John's whole life was oriented around helping people know and understand who Jesus was. And then there was a climactic moment in John's ministry, where John is preaching by the river Jordan out in the wilderness, and he's talking about Jesus, and he's saying, the one that's to come, he's so powerful and beautiful and spectacular, I can't even untie his shoes. And then John sees Jesus, and he says, behold, the Lamb of God. Like, that's the one. And then Jesus comes to John, and John is told by Jesus, you got to baptize me. And John says, no way, you have to baptize me. And Jesus says, no, we have to do it this way. And so John baptizes Jesus Christ.
5:41 And when Jesus comes out of the water, there's a voice from heaven, God himself, and the voice says, this is my son. I love him and I'm pleased with him. And we're told the dove from heaven descended and landed right on Jesus, the power of the spirit. I tell you all of that because if there was anyone who was least likely in the history of the world to doubt who Jesus was, it would have been John the Baptist. And yet here he is asking the question, are you really the one or did I get it wrong? Like, are you really the one that I should have planted the roots of my life into or did I make a mistake in following you? How does that happen? Where did those doubts come from in John's life? The passage tells us there's really two reasons, though the second is probably more fundamental than the first. So let me give you the two reasons. Where does doubt come from? First, we can call it suffering. You notice in verse 2. John's in prison. John's in prison. The reason John's in prison is because of the time in the region John lived, there was a man in power called Herod, and Herod had done something immoral and ethical, and John spoke truth to power. That was the kind of prophet he was. He was not shy about going after corruption. And so John speaks truth to power, but power takes John and puts him in prison. And so John is rotting away in prison, and at some point he must be thinking to himself, wait a second, this isn't adding up. I'm the forerunner. I'm the advanced man, and the Messiah is out there doing his work, and yet here I am rotting in prison. He's suffering. And that suffering starts to knock away at the foundations of some of his faith because he's having a hard time reconciling what he thinks he knows about Jesus with the experience of his life.
7:40 He can't fit it together. And so suffering starts to create the seedbed of doubt in his heart, which leads to what I think is probably the more fundamental reason for John's doubt, which you might call disappointment. It's not just suffering, but he's also disappointed in Jesus. Or another way to say it is, Jesus is not living up to John's expectations of what Jesus should be and do. Do you see where it says in the text in verse 2, when John was in prison, he heard about the deeds of the Messiah. And so he sends his disciples to Jesus and he says, look, are you really the one or did we get it wrong? What's that about? If you go back to Matthew 3, when you read about John's ministry, you know, he's preaching and he's telling people about Jesus coming. When you read Matthew 3, what you see is that John envisions a Messiah who's going to come in the world with strength and with power and with judgment.
8:48 So John preaches about the Messiah and John says, he's going to be like an ax coming to the root of the tree. And trees that don't bear fruit, they're going to get chopped down. And John says, he's going to be like a fire burning up the chaff. Powerful, strong, forceful language of judgment. And so in John's mind, when the Messiah comes, he's going to be a figure of power and of strength, going after injustice and going after corruption and calling people to righteousness with force and with power.
9:23 And now he's hearing about what Jesus is doing. And he says, I expected strength and power and judgment, but in Jesus, I'm seeing weakness and humility and grace. Jesus isn't railing against Herod. Jesus is hanging out with lepers. And he's going to weddings and he's making more wine so people aren't sad. And Jesus is hanging out with poor people and he's helping sick people.
9:52 The kind of Jesus that I wanted and I expected is not the kind of Jesus that I'm seeing. and that disappointment has led John to wonder, did I get it all wrong? Now, of course, the circumstances of your life will be different than John's. You're not prophets and preachers in the wilderness of Judea talking about Messiah to come, but make no mistake, John's a case study and not if, but usually when in your spiritual life, there will come a moment where you look at what you expected in your life to happen, or you look at what you thought God would do for you, or how your life would turn out. And you say, this is not at all what I was expecting. And there's deep disappointment. There's deep disillusionment and discouragement because the life that you envision and the Jesus that you thought and the things that he would bring and do for you, it's not quite working like that.
10:52 And that's why even, and I'm speaking directly to Christians here for a moment, this is why sometimes in spiritual life, you start off like John the Baptist with zeal and with passion and with energy. You're happy to talk about Jesus. Your Bible reading is rich. You're praying. You love small group. And over time, it wanes. A fire that was burning starts to feel merely like embers. Why is that? Oftentimes, it's because suffering leads to disappointment. And the life we expected and the Jesus we expected is not matching our reality. That's where John was. And that's where doubt can come from in your life and in mine too. Now, point two of our sermon. When those doubts, when that disillusionment, when those disappointments come, what should you do with them? Where should you bring them?
11:45 What should be the posture that you have as you face your doubt in your crisis of faith? A couple things. First, when, not if, but when that kind of crisis emerges, when those doubts are there, be patient and gentle with yourself and with other people.
12:08 If John the Baptist could doubt his faith, then really any of us can. You know, in fact, as I was getting ready to preach this sermon, I was doing my reading, my study, and I noticed that lots of older commentators, even the likes of a St. Augustine or a John Calvin, when they read Matthew 11, I mean, these are some of my heroes, by the way, and I'm about to disagree with them. But when they read Matthew chapter 11, they couldn't stomach the idea that John the Baptist was actually John the Doubter. And so what they said was John wasn't doubting, John's disciples were doubting. And so that's why John sends his disciples. He's like, look, you go see for yourselves. The problem with that is it doesn't square with the text. But they couldn't stomach the idea that someone who was a preacher and a prophet and the forerunner and the prophesied over paved the way for the Messiah person would get to the end of his life and wonder, was it all a sham? They couldn't stomach that idea. And so they said it wasn't really John doubting, it was his friends. But the reality is, as F.D. Brunner puts it, saints do doubt. And when you find doubts arising in your heart, when you wonder if Jesus was really the one that you should have planted the roots of your life into, remember John the Baptist. You're not alone. And learn how to be patient and gentle with yourself. That doubt is not a sign of deficiency in faith.
13:41 it's actually a sign of maturity in faith, or at least it can be. Because what doubt does is it exposes you to the realities and the complexities of life. I believe, I know my Bible, and now I'm going through something and I can't square it all. And doubt shows that at some level you're wrestling with it. And so what does it look like for us to be a community in which doubt is welcome, doubt is safe, we don't judge ourselves, and we don't judge others when the roots or the foundations of our faith seem to be giving way. How do you learn to be patient and gentle with yourself and with others in those doubts? And there's another thing to do.
14:25 John shows us that when he doubted, he brought all of his doubts to Jesus. This is the core, one of the core parts of this story. John's in prison. He's wondering, did I get it all wrong? Did I make a mistake? And he's doubting, he's disappointed. And what does he do? He runs towards Jesus. Now he couldn't get out of prison, so he sends his disciples. But he brings his questions to Jesus. And as I'll show you in a few moments, that's part of the real reason why this story is so powerful. Because John's doubts could have led him to run from Jesus, but he shows us instead the healthy way to process them. is to bring them to Jesus. And when you read the Bible, whether it's the book of Psalms or Job, some of the great lament texts in the Bible, Habakkuk be another example, one of the things that you'll discover is that crisis of faith are pretty normal for the people of God.
15:24 But when you have a crisis of faith, you can do one of two things. You can allow that crisis to be unaddressed and you can slowly drift, or you can do what Habakkuk did, which is to say, God, you're making no sense right now, and I'm not leaving until you answer me. You can do the John the Baptist way. I don't get it. What's happening? Are you the one? And he runs towards him with his heartbreak and with his pain, and he presses into the presence of God that's disappointed him. There's a great story in Mark chapter 9. I actually talk about it a lot because I think it's really important. In Mark 9, there's a father of a son, and the boy is, the son is possessed by a demon. And so the man, the father is understandably distraught, brings the boy to the disciples of Jesus, and they can't heal him. And so the father then brings his son to Jesus and says, look, your disciples couldn't do anything here, but can you help?
16:25 Can you do something? And Jesus says, anything is possible for the one who believes. And the man says, I believe, but help my unbelief. I have faith and I doubt. John the Baptist, I spent my whole life pointing people to you. Are you the one? maturing faith is doubt that runs towards Jesus. It says, this isn't adding up. This isn't squaring. I can't make sense of it. And I'm going to run towards you anyway. It's Habakkuk saying, I'm going to stand on my watchtower and wait until you speak to me.
17:10 Which leads us to point three of our sermon. How does Jesus respond to John? Or how did Jesus respond to that man in Mark 9 who says, I believe, help my unbelief. It's actually quite amazing. And again, this is a case study. It's really stunning how Jesus responds. So let me show you three things. The first thing Jesus does in his response to John, John says, are you the one? The first thing Jesus does is he says to John, look at the evidence. Look at the evidence. You see in verse 5, Jesus replies to the disciples of John and says, go tell John this. The blind receive their sight, the lame walk, those who have leprosy are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, the good news is proclaimed to the poor. Now, that is a summary of the stuff that Jesus was doing, but it's more than that. Because if you look at those phrases carefully, what you'll notice is that Jesus is quoting texts from the book of Isaiah that describe the work of the Messiah.
18:10 John knows his Bible. John knows Isaiah. In fact, John's whole life was prophesied about in Isaiah. And John is shaken to his core. John is despairing. He's doubting. And so Jesus says, go back to your Bible. Look at the evidence. You know, John, what the Messiah is supposed to do. You know that when Messiah comes into the world, lepers are going to be cleansed and the poor are going to have good news proclaimed to them. You know that blind people are going to see and deaf people are going to hear. This is what the Messiah was meant to come in the world to do. Go back to your Bible, look at the data, remember that your faith is not a blind trust. And he tells John, go back to the evidence. Now, one of the things, and I'm just going to speak personally for a moment here, As a minister, I've had doubts in my spiritual life because of suffering, because of things that didn't go the way that I thought.
19:15 I've had doubts. And one of the things that I've learned to do in my own spiritual life and spiritual journey is go back to the evidence. And specifically what that's meant for me is the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Christianity proclaims that in a body, Jesus rose from the dead three days after dying. And that's, Paul says, the core, the kernel, the heart of the Christian message. And if Jesus rose from the dead, he's worthy of all my allegiance, even when I don't understand what he's doing. But if he didn't rise from the dead, Paul says, well, what are we wasting our time for? In other words, the resurrection is the heart of the Christian faith. And when I doubt, and I do, I go back to the resurrection. I pull books off my shelf. I listen to the podcasts and the sermons again. And I remind myself that the bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ is the most historically plausible summary of all the evidence that we actually have. And it grounds my faith.
20:17 It doesn't always answer all my questions, but it grounds my faith. When you doubt, remember that Christianity is not blind trust. It's not unreasonable. And Jesus says to John, remember what the Bible says. Go to the text, do your study. This is what I'm all about. That's the first thing. And yet on the other side, Jesus does say, look at the evidence. But on the other side, Jesus says, and I need you to trust me.
20:50 I need you to have faith. Do you see in verse six where Jesus, after saying, remember the evidence, Look at the text. In verse 6, Jesus says, And blessed is anyone who does not stumble on account of me. That's a bit of a rebuke.
21:10 Jesus is saying, blessed are those who don't walk away because they don't understand. That word stumble in Greek is skandalizo. It's where we get our word scandal. The idea of scandal is something that happens that wants you to distance yourself from the thing or the person that you're connected to. And Jesus is saying, if you follow me, he says to John and he says to all of his disciples, if you follow me, there will inevitably be moments in your spiritual life where Jesus says, I will say things and I will do things that bother you, that offend you, that don't make sense to you. For example, let me just show you. You see in the text where Jesus says at the end, the good news is proclaimed to the poor? That's a quote from Isaiah 61.
22:05 The next sentence in Isaiah 61 is prophecy that the Messiah is going to proclaim the day of vengeance for our God. Now that was John the Baptist kind of stuff. The day of vengeance. And Jesus doesn't speak about it. and that's what would have bothered John. Yes, I'm fine with proclaiming good news to the poor, but how about some vengeance? John wanted that. He was a firebrand preacher, but Jesus doesn't mention it. Why? Because John doesn't understand the fullness of Jesus' work, that Jesus is going to come back one day, and that's going to be the day of vengeance of our God. But the first time was not to bring judgment. It was to bear it, but John didn't know it.
22:51 And in spiritual life, when you follow Jesus, he's going to do things and he's going to say things and you say, I don't get it, it doesn't make sense. Of course you don't. We're too finite. And so while Jesus says, look at the evidence, he also says, I need you to trust me. I need you to recognize that there are things that you can't possibly fully understand. in the fullness of my work and the fullness of my salvation? Sometimes those questions will be intellectual, but sometimes and often more so, they'll be experiential. If you're really out there and if you're really powerful, then why is this happening to me?
23:29 It's part of spiritual life. Recently, I've been rereading a series of sermons from Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and he's got a spot in one of them. Very powerfully, he says this, we are gravely mistaken to think that Christianity will protect us from the pain and the agony of mortal existence. Christianity has always insisted that the cross we bear precedes the crown that we wear. And that's where John was, facing, bearing a cross, not understanding what was coming, not understanding the fullness of what Jesus was about and what he was doing. He was only able to see in a limited, in a finite way, and that's where we are too. So Jesus says on one hand, look at the evidence, but on the other hand, I need you to trust me.
24:19 And third, finally, how does Jesus respond to John? He applies the gospel over his life. When you get to verse 6, it seems like a gentle rebuke, and it kind of is. But notice verse 7. When John's disciples start leaving, although I don't think they got far before they heard Jesus change the subject. In verses 7 through 11, Jesus starts talking about John. And he says to the crowd of people, and I think John's disciples would have been within your shot, he starts talking to them about John the Baptist. And in summary, in verses 7 through 10, he says, John the Baptist was the real deal. He was a real prophet. He was a man of integrity. He didn't run along with the establishment. He didn't change his message to fit in. He was a reed that was not swayed in the wind. He was the real thing. And then look at verse 11. Jesus Christ, the Son of God, says to that crowd of people, among those born of women, there has not arisen anyone greater than John the Baptist.
25:31 Now, those arising of women is everyone. And so Jesus is saying that John the Baptist till that point is the greatest person who's ever lived. There's a spot in the Lord of the Rings where Faramir says to Samwise Gamgee, the praise of the praiseworthy is above all rewards. Most leaders would be ashamed of followers who doubted them. Most leaders, if a follower doubts them, would dismiss them, would judge them, would shame them, would be scornful of them. Jesus Christ, after John doubts him, doesn't shame him but says, that's the greatest person who's ever lived. And he praises him.
26:27 Why? Because of the gospel. The gospel, the Christian gospel says that a person is saved, experiences salvation, not because of the strength of their faith, but because of the object of it. And in his despair and in his doubt, John looks to Jesus. It's like this final Hail Mary kind of plea. Are you the one? And that tiny act of faith elicits Jesus' praise. And Jesus says of John, there's no one like this man. What is that? That's the gospel. The tiniest act of faith in Jesus' direction is where salvation comes, because it's Jesus who saves not even the strength of your faith. And do you realize what's happening? John wanted a Messiah, a prophet, a preacher who would come with power and with strength and with judgment, and there would be the chopping down of unfruitful trees, and there'd be the burning up of the chaff. But you know what? That would have consumed John.
27:33 because here in prison, John is doubting he's becoming an unfruitful tree by human standards. If Jesus was the kind of Messiah that John thought he should have been, then Jesus would not have been the kind of Messiah that could have saved John in this moment. But precisely because Jesus is the Messiah that hangs out with the weak and the sick and the hurting and the broken, Jesus can say of John, that's the greatest man who's ever lived, Where he deserves shame, he gets praise. And the message of the gospel and the message as we come to this table, what saves you is not the strength of your faith, but the object of it. Is your faith strong this morning? Is your prayer life rich? Is your Bible reading dynamic? That's awesome. And for the rest of us,
28:28 a little faith in Jesus' direction leads to your justification. in which when you stand before the master of the universe, you get the praise and the acceptance because of what Jesus has done. Jesus applies the gospel over John's life and says, there's no one greater. And that's because John was now covered in Jesus Christ in his finished work. That's the gospel. And so do you doubt? Have you doubted? Are you in a crisis of faith? Run to Jesus with whatever faith you have. Tell him about what's disappointing you. Tell him about how he's disappointing you, but run to him and watch his salvation come into your life in new and fresh ways. Let's pray as we come to the table. Our Father, help us now in this time of response to not just have learned about, but to actually experience the gospel. To experience Jesus meeting us gently in and under and through our own doubts.
29:27 and our own spiritual crisis.
Machine translated from the source