Is It Really You, Lord?

Dave Dwyer · Busted Halo · St. Paul the Apostle Church · Published December 15, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

0:00 Today's Advent Sunday readings are for any of us who've ever said, Lord, is it, is that really you? You know, maybe you've occasionally thought, is this just me thinking this? Is God really there? Is God speaking in my prayer? Is that amazing parking space that I found right next to the handicapped one, is that really God doing that? Or is that just, you know, chance. And sometimes it's in much more of a desperate sense that we ask, is that, is that really you? Because John the Baptist, a central character throughout the Advent season, John the Baptist, who we heard about last week at the very beginning when he was baptizing at the Jordan. This week we find him in prison because he was so confident that he was preparing the way for the Messiah. The Christ is what the word that Matthew used. It means the same thing. It's the Greek word for Messiah. It's the one that Jews had been waiting for for centuries. And at this point, almost all hope was lost. It had been 400 years since God had sent any prophet.

1:20 it. Maybe they had stopped expecting, stopped listening, and the condition of their people was probably somewhat similar to the Ukrainian people today. Their country had been invaded. They were desolate. It looked like all hope was lost, and John the Baptist, since the time of his birth and feeling this calling, he went out of the desert. He was to announce to the people, he has come, finally, the guy that we're waiting for, the one who will bring back and restore the kingdom of Israel, overthrow these Romans who've been oppressing us. He's the one. In fact, he was by the Jordan River baptizing people so that they'd be ready for this Messiah, this Christ.

2:18 He was in prison because he was so bold that he told the king that he was living an immoral life. And uh king didn't take kindly to that when you speak truth to power. Sometimes you get thrown in jail. Still happens today. And there he was. But it's almost, in a way, a little sad to hear his question that begins our gospel passage today. He sends word from prison to this guy, Jesus, who had already, since our last week's reading, when Jesus hadn't even really started yet, he'd heard about Jesus. He'd been going around what we now call the Holy Land, going around preaching and healing, and in fact sitting down with people that were enemy of the Jewish people like the tax collectors. He'd been this kind of nice guy.

3:16 Maybe not really what John the Baptist was expecting. Maybe not what all of Israel had been waiting for for hundreds of years. So John the Baptist, who is so convinced, maybe, it sounds like, started to wonder, started to doubt. Is this, is this really him? So he sends word, he asks Jesus, is it you we've been waiting for or, or should we wait for another? is another to come.

3:56 In other words, Lord, is it really you? Interesting that someone who eventually was martyred for the faith, because he was only in jail for a little while before King Herod had him beheaded, that even someone like that, could ask that question. We've been waiting. Here we are, thousands of years later, and we've been waiting. We wait during this season of Advent. We wait for a lot of things these days, but waiting for the coming of the Lord. And in fact, one of the ways in which we pray during Advent is for Christ's second coming. I wonder how many of us are really anxious to have that happen. As bad or good as our life is, very few of us are probably, oh boy, I can't wait until that whole end of the world thing happens. Christ's second coming. But we've been waiting for a couple thousand years now.

5:07 Is it really you? Are you really there? Is all of this what it was promised to be? John the Baptist in prison maybe started to wonder And yet what does Jesus say of him? This person who questions whether or not he's the real deal? John the Baptist starts talking about him to the other people there and he says there is no one greater than him Jesus knew of his question. And in fact, his response to John the Baptist was still somewhat coded. He didn't say, oh yeah, sorry I was misleading or ambiguous. Go back and tell John, yes, it's definitely me.

6:03 I am the Messiah. No, he says, well, if John is wondering who this is, tell him what you've seen. And that little list is Jesus quoting from Isaiah that we heard as our first reading. That when the Messiah comes, things will start to change. The blind will see. Those who can't walk will be healed. And that was happening. That is what Jesus was going around doing. He wasn't politically overthrowing the Romans, but he was bringing about the change that was prophesied hundreds of years before. So he gently says to John, not like, well, duh, of course you nincompoop, it's me. What's wrong with you? Why are you doubting? You're no good anymore if you doubt me.

7:01 he wasn't that kind of Messiah. He says to John, just look around. If you wonder if it's me, look at what's been happening. And that's a gentle message for us in our lives of faith as well. Because if you're like me, there's been at least an occasion or two in your life when you've asked that question. Is it really you, Lord? Is it really you up there supposedly in charge of all this mess that we got going on down here? Are you there? Are you paying attention to this? That's essentially what John the Baptist was saying. Jesus, are you getting this? Don't you see the whole Romans thing and all that? Jesus is like, yeah, yeah I am. He gently says, if you're wondering if it's me, if you're wondering if I'm really in your midst, which is what we pray throughout Advent, that God comes to us, then just look at the good things that have come about because of my presence.

8:21 I would imagine as many people in this room who have had that question in their mind, And I wonder if that's really God can also think back, prayerfully reflect on times in your life when you've clearly seen the evidence of God. A little nudge, a little tap. I came here this weekend for a celebration of your pastor, Father Jimmy, this morning at the 1130 Mass. And my flight was Saturday morning, very early. I woke up in Manhattan about an hour before my flight was boarding at JFK Airport out in Queens, and there was absolutely no way on the books I was going to make that. And I just kind of said, well, all right, let's give it a shot.

9:14 The traffic parted the ways. I got dropped off right by an empty line of security. And even though on my app it said that my gate was going to be the farthest one away. You know how that is even here in Austin. If you fly on Delta, you're way down at gate three. You got to make your way all the way through the airport. Same thing in New York. And it had changed. It was closest gate. I stepped on line, one of the last people got on the flight and said, all right, I guess somebody was looking out for me today. Sometimes we have evidence of God. Sometimes it's more profound than just a parking space or making a flight. That we can look back at times and see, as Jesus pointed to, how God worked. Jesus says to John the Baptist, who he called the greatest of all human beings, he says, when you doubt if I'm there, when you wonder if it's really me, look back.

10:22 Look at your life. You know that old poem about the footsteps in the sand? Look at those footsteps when I was alongside you, and even those times when I was carrying you. Yeah, that's how we know. Many times it's much harder to see God in our present moment. John the Baptist was in prison. I would imagine there was a lot going on for him that distracted him from being able to celebrate and reflect on all he knew about Jesus and the coming Messiah. For you and I as well. There's probably more times than not in our modern lives when we're filled with chaos and distraction. At those times Jesus says just take a little look at your life. Look at the gifts that you have. Look at how you breathe and see and your heart beats.

11:19 Look at how everything manages to still hold together in a world that, let's frankly say, we've tried to destroy many times over. Look at ways in which there was a time in your life you said, yeah, I think that was, that was God calling me to that. It must have been. That's what Jesus invites us to this Advent. He doesn't wag a finger at us. when we ask that question, is it really you? He doesn't tsk-tsk, doesn't condemn us when we doubt or wonder, but what he does is invite us to look at the evidence in our own lives. and in our world, in our families, in our workplaces, and look back and say, yeah, see, when those things happen, we can be more assured that God is with us. Emmanuel, that we celebrate this Advent season. So, Lord, are you there? Jesus says, I think you know I'm there.

12:36 Take a look. Look into your heart. And of John the Baptist and of us, he says, you will be great in the kingdom of God. Be assured of my presence, Emmanuel, God with us. Even if some days doesn't really seem like that, and even if we are occasionally asking that question, is it really you? Jesus answers us simply, it is I. I am with you.

Machine translated from the source