Life is Worth Living · False Compassion

Fulton Sheen · Archdiocese of New York · Vision Video · Published May 12, 2021

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:19 Friends, Perhaps the best way to introduce this story, or this subject of false compassion, is to tell you about a little girl who hurt her finger, began to bleed slightly, and she went in to see her mother, and her mother bounded up, and then she went up to see her daddy, who was working. And she came down crying. The mother said, why are you crying? Well, she said, I told daddy that I hurt my finger and he didn't even say, oh. That was just a want of compassion. Compassion is a sympathy, a pity, an ability to be wounded when others are wounded, and to feel the sores of others as one's own. That is compassion. There's There's always been compassion in the world and the right kind.

1:37 We will distinguish later on between the right and wrong kind. Even the old Greek historian Herodotus, who lived several centuries before Christ, tells that he was shipwrecked once on an island and the people came out and cared for him, built fires, and fed him. We know of the compassion, kindness and sympathy of the Muslims. They will even kill sometimes their last lamb for a visitor. Then there was the story, it's only a legend, I suppose, about Abraham. One day a visitor came to Abraham's tent, and Abraham killed a lamb, gave him the best bed, showed him every courtesy and kindness, and yet nothing pleased the visitor.

2:34 He didn't like the food. He didn't like the lamb. He didn't like his bed. He didn't like the tent. And finally Abraham threw him out. And God said to Abraham, listen, Abraham, I've been putting up with that man for 40 years. Can't you put up with him for three days? Of course, the classic story of all compassion is the parable of the Good Samaritan.

3:06 And it is interesting how that parable began and how it was occasioned. A very clever lawyer came to visit our blessed Lord and said, what must I do to inherit eternal life? Now, the lawyer wanted an argument. Lawyers like arguments. And our blessed Lord, in answer to his question, asked a question.

3:37 Sometimes it's well not always to be put on the defensive with a question. Ask another. and so when our blessed lord was asked the question he said well what do you read in the law And he quoted the law, love God with your whole mind and heart and soul, and love thy neighbors thyself. And our blessed Lord said to him, well, do this and you will live. Well, he didn't want that kind of an answer. And so he introduced a rather technical question. It seems practical, but he meant it to be technical. Namely, who is my neighbor? How do you define him? And then our blessed Lord told the story of a man who went down from Jerusalem to Jericho.

4:36 And you do go down. As a matter of fact, the distance between the two places is about 2,400 feet. I mean the descent. And he was waylaid by robbers and beaten. And a priest and a Levite passed by.

4:57 They had no compassion for the wounded man. That was not too great a tribute for the priest and the Levite. One explanation that is given is that they found the man already robbed.

5:18 Maybe, who knows? It could happen. And then a man who was a stranger and an alien, namely the Good Samaritan, passed by and brought him to the inn and then offered to return and pay all expenses.

5:38 And so our blessed Lord said, now who's the neighbor? Well, the lawyer said it's the one who showed compassion. And our Lord said, that's right. Now, do this and you will live. So, there's always been a right kind of compassion, and it manifests itself in various ways. It can be physical, it can be financial, it can be moral. financial compassion would be helping the poor. This really happened to me the other day going to my office. Some tramp came up to him and he said, Would you give me $31 for a cup of coffee? And I gave him a dollar, and then it suddenly dawned on me, $31. I said, why do you want $31?

6:34 I said, a coffee or breakfast will only cost you a dollar. Why do you want the $30? You know what he told me? He said, you wouldn't want me to go into a restaurant rest in this suit, would you? Well, at that point, the priest passed him by. Then there's also a physical compassion, too. You probably have often seen the picture of a boy that's carrying another boy on his back, and someone said, isn't he too heavy? No. He said, he's my brother.

7:10 Then there's moral compassion. Suppose a judge sentences a man to death and then says to the criminal, I will take the sentence. I will be hanged for you. Well, that in some way typifies the great moral compassion of God coming down to this earth and taking upon himself our sins and dying for us.

7:39 Now, compassion always implies what? It always implies a moral order. Namely, a distinction between right and wrong. between the man who was waylaid on the road and the robbers and the thieves who beat him up. And compassion also implies that there's a distinction between a man destroying himself through his own fault and being destroyed by others. That's true compassion. Now what is false? And this is what we're in today. False compassion. False compassion, which is gradually growing in this country, is a pity that is shown not to the mugged, but to the mugger.

8:35 Not to the family of the murdered, but to the murderer. Not to the woman who was raped. But to the rapist. Not to the poor girl who's given a shot of dope. But to the rich boy who happens to come from a fine family, there are some judges, some in some of our courts. There are some social workers, not all. There are sob sisters. There are the social slobberers who insist on compassion being shown to the muggers, to the dope fiends, to the throat slashers, to the beatniks, to the prostitutes, to the homosexuals, to the punks.

9:34 So that today the decent man is practically off the reservation. This is the false compassion. How did it start? He started in literature. In the novels of William Saroyan, John Steinbeck. where pity was extended through the novel to the good-natured slob. Then the novels of Mandel, James Jones, and others In which pity is shown to every kind of pervert and degenerate As one character says in the novel The girl said, he called me a tramp Imagine that, he called me a tramp And the other girl says, I don't understand it Just because you go out and do all the things that a tramp does and steal and so forth doesn't mean that you're really not a nice fine girl.

10:48 Now with what result? With the result that crime is increasing... The clemency of a false kind is shown to criminals. And we have this crime picture in the United States. There is a robbery in the United States. Every 30 seconds. There is an auto stolen. Every minute.

11:43 There is a rape. Every three minutes. There is a murder in the United States every 60 minutes. 43% of those who have been arrested for robbery and larceny have already received clemency in courts. through false compassion.

12:38 In New York City alone, there are 60,000 narcotic addicts. I do not know how many there are in the United States. But here's the national figure. Of all of those that are arrested for dope pushing, selling, taking narcotics. 37% are released. They are not guilty. They're just sick. the sick. And most of those are brought back then for more crime, because they've committed greater crimes.

13:32 40% of the property damage in the United States. is committed by use between the age of 10 and 17 years. What happens to policemen who are trying to defend justice? Twelve out of every 100 policemen in the United States are assaulted in the line of duty. Why assault it? Is there respect for authority?

14:30 Or is there pity for the dope pusher, for the thief, for the young mugger who murders an 80-year-old woman for 15 cents? Part of the blame for this crime picture has to be laid at the door of all of those who have committed and shown false compassion. Here, for example, a young married woman with two children. goes on a kind of binge and lives with five different men for five different months. She's brought before a judge. who finds that her good husband, a science teacher, was not sufficiently humanistic because he taught science. I never knew before that that destroyed human nature.

15:40 But he was considered by the judge not sufficiently humanistic. So the judge ordered that the house in which they lived should be given to this mother, that the two children should be cared for by the state, the husband should pay her $200 a month until she was emotionally restored because she was more to be pitied than censured. This is the false compassion. There was a professor in one of our universities here in the United States who had just finished a lecture on the fact that there's no such thing as right and wrong. We are only, only sick.

16:37 And the great clemency must always be shown to every kind of criminal. On his way home from giving that lecture, he was mugged, robbed, and badly beaten. He insisted on being taken to the police station. before he was taken to the hospital in order to complain against the police. That was the hard way to learn. But why this false compassion? Well, we say simply because we've broken down the standards of right and wrong. reduced everything to a malady and a disease. That after all, if I say that the time, let us say, is 10 minutes to 8, and you say, no, it's 10 minutes to 12, well, all right, who's going to decide?

17:44 You mean to say we've got to have something outside of our clocks to decide what is the right time? Suppose you go into a store and say that a yard means 23 inches. Someone else says no, it's 24. Another is 36. There's no standard outside of all of you? Who's going to decide what is right? As the great Russian thinker of the last century said, a day is coming when people will say there's no longer any right, no longer any wrong, there's only hunger, and men will come crying and fawning at our feet, saying give us bread. In other words, it's just the economic that matters.

18:31 Nothing else. Even youth is saying, many who are arrested today will say, well, no, I gave up alcohol because there was no kick in it. I went in for dope. Because there was more kick. What will be the next step? What will it be? Because remember that our reactions, emotional reactions, always decrease. For example, if I did this all the time I was talking to you, you would notice it, but if I did it for 25 minutes, you'd get used to it. In order to make it noticeable, I would have to do that. So it is with sensations. We always have to increase the stimulus in order to get a similar reaction. Now, if we're going to give up, if you're going to give up, say, alcohol because there's no kick in it, then go in for dope.

19:31 What's next? There is latent in our society grave danger. that we may go in for a kind of masochism and cruelty. In the distant future there could be such a thing even as persecution of some social or religious class. But I think there will be a step before that. I think that we in America will revive bullfighting. And I think we'll get new kicks out of mugging bulls. That will be the next step. What's to be done to stop this false compassion? Well, one thing that might be done is we might institute kind of conservation corps for the hardened, hardened youths and put them under a tough marine sergeant.

20:36 where they will be paid for learning a craft. and then afterwards, when they have been reformed through some kind of discipline, and also through education, put out into industry. Another is by establishing throughout the country serious volunteer workers. That is to say, those who will take care of the youths, who are brought into court, have an interest in them. This is already working out all over the world. It's worked out in Vienna. So much so that in Vienna, where they have houses, 24 boys living in each house and a volunteer worker at the head of each house. one boy had reformed himself from alcoholism and then when he was out he went to his father who was an alcoholic and his father said to him said to the volunteer worker who rejuvenated this delinquent he said you've ruined my son he's no longer an alcoholic The volunteer workers who take this job seriously have had great success.

21:57 In one state in our union, only 37 out of 379 cases failed to restore youth. And in another, in Vienna, 92% of the cases were successful, simply because they were given a mission, a job, something to do. We have perhaps even ought to reform our child labor law. Young people are not allowed to work on account of the law. They're old enough to work. They're old enough to commit crime. They do not want to go to school. We assume in the United States that everybody must go to school. I mean, even go to college so that college today is, instead of an intellectual privilege, it's becoming a kind of a social necessity.

22:51 You have to go. But some of them were not made for books. Let them learn crafts. When, for example, there was a newspaper strike in one city, a number of boys who were delinquents began selling newspapers. It was a delivery strike, and they sold newspapers. Crime dropped. The time of the blackout in New York, some time ago. The youths went out and directed traffic, proved themselves worthwhile, why they had a job, they had a mission. And this is what we have to do to recognize responsibility. Give them a mission, a scope, a plan in life, and restore into our society true compassion, where we make a distinction between the sin and the sinner, as did the good Lord. we will hate the sin, condemn it.

23:54 and love the sinner. And with this compassion, we can hear once again the words, do this and you will live.

Machine translated from the source