Fulton Sheen · Archdiocese of New York · Vision Video · Published May 12, 2021
0:28 Friends. I presume you noticed the elocutionary gymnastics of the announcer in projecting the particular subject of this evening. You know, it could have been a curse word. I heard of an Irish woman who went to Moscow, apropos of the subject of hell, and she met a communist over there who helped her onto a tram. She was rather surprised. And she turned to him and she said, may the good Lord find a nice cool spot in hell for you. You know, this is a subject, of course, that's bandied about by fundamentalists and modernists. I was once disturbed, oh, about two or three o'clock in the morning with the doorbell ringing frantically.
1:29 When I answered it, there was a drunk at the door and he said, he said, I want to know the difference between fundamentalism and modernism. And I said, well, you come back tomorrow morning and I will tell you. He says, tomorrow morning I'll be sober and then I won't care. Those who live in New York and have to commute to Long Island are very familiar with the place en route where on the Long Island Railroad you have to change your trains.
2:04 And it is always, of course, one of the great difficulties that commuters have to face on their way back home at night, coming in in the morning sometimes. This particular man was suffering from a heart attack which seized him just at the point of change which is Jamaica. Clergymen called on him in the station and said, don't you think you better make your peace with God? He said, you know you're going either to heaven or to hell. And he said, I don't care where I'm going as long as I don't have to change a Jamaica. Well, we're not going to talk about the eternal hell, though there is one. We're going to talk about an entirely different kind of hell, which is the psychotic hell, or the neurotic hell.
3:00 Now, the moral universe has, of course, I suppose, best been portrayed poetically by Dante. And the moral universe was one in which man is here in the center, and he's given a moment of time in which to say, I or nay to his eternal destiny. This is the choice of the moral universe.
3:29 Now, in our times... Hell has moved inward. inside of a man. Freud has done much to put man And hell on the inside, this is what is called justice consciousness. This becomes the superego for Freud. And this becomes the id down here. Now, the hell of which we're going to speak is that of not just the egotist, but of the egotist who becomes neurotic. And we're going to do this first in terms of an incident that happened in the life of our Lord, and secondly in terms of modern psychiatry and psychology.
4:30 And for our modern terms, we go to a, or rather the gospel, we go to the young man in the land of the Gerasenes. This young man was possessed, and he reveals in the gospel story the first characteristic of the agoneurotic, namely conflict, contradiction. Man is at war with himself. Now everyone, of course, is at war with himself in the sense that he feels dual were made up of body and soul. But here, the conflict is much more intense. When our blessed Lord came to this young man, he said, what is your name? The young man said, my name is Legion, for we are many.
5:21 Notice the contradiction. Personality is the mark of an, is signified by a name. Now this man says, I do not have a personality. Mine is split. Mine is like the Roman Legion. There are 6,000 men in the Roman legion. And so I say my and we and us and legion in order to indicate that inside of me are perhaps 6,000 different impulses and passions and instincts all craving for some kind of an assertion. And what this young man revealed as the conflict is also, isn't it nice, you know, for my angel to clean my board when I'm talking about hell? The conflict on the inside of modern man is something like this. Here is the real self.
6:19 What a man is. Over here is his phantom self, his shadow self, what he believes himself to be. Now, the agoneurotic always has to have this phantom self nourished, constantly seeking praise, adulation, has no reverence or respect, generally for those who will not praise him. He must be served all the time. But while he is boasting, vaunting himself, enlarging his ego all the while, he knows he's a phony because he has to live with his real self. But he tries to make his way in the world by making, as I say, everyone serve him.
7:15 Incidentally, he's preparing in a certain sense for the welfare state, for the socialistic state in which every ego is nourished not by his own responsibility and by the fulfillment of his own duty, but by a government, particularly a socialistic one. That's the first characteristic of the ego in your life. But it's not yet an inner hell.
7:44 Now, the second state is one in which there is a hatred of fellow man. This was evidenced in the gospel story by St. Luke saying that the young man lived alone in the tomb.
8:06 He was homeless. No one would pass by the road where he lived. putting that in our modern psychological language a man who cannot live at peace with himself cannot live at peace with his fellow man being at war with himself He projects that inner conflict, that civil war, that earthquake. He projects to the outside. Dr. Victor Frankel, one of the great Viennese psychiatrists who passed through Nazi and Soviet concentration camps, says that you could always tell the agoneurotic by the fact that he hoarded his cigarettes.
9:06 When a man in a concentration camp began to keep the cigarettes for himself, he had lost his hold on life and his relationship to his fellow man. He said as long as the man was normal and he saw suffering around him, men going to death and men dying, he would share his cigarettes with others. But when he began hoarding, he was manifesting that antipathy to fellow man which is the mark of that inner hell. Sue
9:46 oton 茶 茶 茶 kind of a people. Held to Sartre as an apartment house outside of Paris in the suburbs. Free people live in it. Well furnished, no flames, no fire, except only inside. But... Every ego is psychoanalyzing every other ego. No man can have a thought, a desire, a motivation that is not known by the fellow man.
10:48 The essence of personality is something which is incommunicable. But here, the neighbor is the one who destroys that personality and therefore is hated. And then developing that idea in one of his own books, he said, my neighbor is opposite me. And because he's opposite me, he is none me. Whatever is none ego is against my ego. Therefore, my neighbor is hell. Let's start. And that's the second mark of the egoneurotic.
11:48 And the third mark is given in the gospel, was when the possessed young man said, or rather the evil spirit in him said to our Lord, why dost thou meddle with us, Jesus, son of God? Art thou come to disturb us before our appointed time? Notice that he did not deny that Christ was the Son of God. The devil did not. He admitted it. But what is there? There's a hatred of God. God's a meddler to that kind of an egoneurotic. He's a disturber. And so the egoneurotic in modern psychological language has a terrific hatred and contempt for religion.
12:42 and it is not so much that he knows there is no god it is rather that he wills that there be no god and sometimes that will becomes action and when there's a corporate will that there be no god and the action is corporate then you have militant atheism then you have communism And this is the hell there is of the ego neurotic, the fugitive, the fugitive from himself, the fugitive from his neighbor, the fugitive from God. T.S. Eliot said in one of his fine lines of poetry, in a land of fugitives, when everyone, he who goes in the opposite direction seems to be going the wrong way, When everyone is throwing themselves into an abyss, the one who runs from the abyss is called a fool.
13:44 The fugitives who plunge themselves in. And our blessed Lord described this inner hell as a worm and a fire. The worm that dies not. The fire that is not extinguished. We say that even in our common language when we run up against people of that kind, we do speak of the worm, we say, what's eating you? or what's burning inside of you. This is not the end of hell, it's only the beginning. And of that fire, the poet W. Yeats has written, What flames in the night the resinous heart of man has fed. his conscience, real self is burning inside of him and Percy Byssey Shelley who certainly ought to know that kind of an inner hell spoke of it again as the serpent as our lord did and said that undying serpent that calls her venomous brood to her nocturnal tasks In other words, all the serpents come, seems to devour the soul within.
15:12 This is not the end of that kind of hell. But we are not to dilate too much on this kind of an ego neurotic, except merely to describe it in these poetic and psychological terms. More important still is how to get out of it. The world is full of these egroneurotics, who hate themselves so much and beat themselves so much that sometimes the beating can become suicide. What's the remedy? Self-help? Self-confidence? No. There is no psychological do-it-yourself kit that will ever enable a man to get out of that kind of inner worm eaten and fired of our conscience.
16:28 Nothing. In fact, those who have passed through it. say they have a peculiar kind of activity. And here, here is a strange testimony. A testimony of a man who does not believe in God, who has done everything he could to destroy decency, morality, and virtue. He prided himself in being a follower of Nietzsche to a point where he went on doing evil so that evil would become his good. this. I'm speaking of the French atheist and communist André Gide. And André Gide says of himself in his diary, if I could at least relate the drama, could depict Satan as he is when he takes possession of a man. An absurd notion, you may think, but I have lately come to understand it for the first time. You are not merely taken prisoner, but the evil, which is an active power, demands from you activity in his service.
17:43 where did the communists get the energy he tells us you are compelled to be fighting for false and perverse causes no a man cannot help himself our blessed lord said what man by taking thought can add to a stature one cubit he cannot gather figs and thorns grapes and thistles so there has to be a power that comes from the outside. If, for example, I should take a ball and throw it across this library floor, that ball would go in a straight line unless there was a superior power that diverted it in another direction. so too the agoneurotic mind is going in a certain direction.
18:45 There's nothing can stop that direction. except some power that comes from the outside, that diverts it. And that is the difference, you see, between world religions... and Christianity. In all world religions and in just psychology alone, man attempts to go to God or to happiness by lifting himself by his own bootstraps, by meditation, by self-denial, by practice of the Eightfold Way. Whereas in Christianity, this is the process. God comes down to man. In other words, a beachhead is established from the outside in the heart of man who wants to get out of that inner hell. We're open on the side of our finiteness. It's possible for something to get in us.
19:50 We are not to think that simply because external circumstances surround us and even overwhelm us, we will all act necessarily the same way in virtue of those causes. That was the great mistake of Freud. Freud said, if you put a hundred men or a thousand men into a camp and starve them all, you will find at the end that every one of them will manifest exactly the same basic instincts. They will all go in the same direction.
20:24 One man will not differ from another. That is not true. Dr. Frankel, who was in a Nazi and Soviet concentration camp, said that some men during starvation became saintly, and other men went on the side of the devils.
20:48 Look at the two men on either side of the cross. They both suffered alike. One became the good thief and the other wanted to be taken down to go on the business of stealing. An American psychiatrist speaking of the soldiers in Korea under starvation and under communist torture said that some became altruistic, and others simply became like demons. What makes the difference in each and every instance is not what has happened to them here, but whether or not they cooperated with a power that came from the outside. And I suppose if there's anything that illustrates this outer power that comes unknowingly into people even when they live together, it is the story of the editor of the London Daily Worker, the Communist Sheet. The editor was a Dr. Hyde.
21:41 Dr. Hyde and his wife, who was also a leading communist in London, were listening one night to a broadcast given by Molotov, in which Molotov was speaking of peace. Suddenly, Mrs. Hyde got up and shut off the radio. She said, I do not believe that Molotov wants peace. I think he wants war. I think his dove of peace is covered with payonets. And the only reason he's talking of peace is to deceive the rest of the world. And the husband said, you're not talking like a communist. She said, I know I'm not. But I'm talking like someone that's going to get out of this egoneurotic hell of ours. He said, if you keep on talking that way, I will report you to the party, and you will be disciplined.
22:42 She said, report me. I would give anything to get out of this. Why, he said, you're talking as if one day you might go into the church. She said, I am. She said, I am. He got up and said to her, so am I. Shake. To what took this neurotic hell except a power that came from above?
Machine translated from the source