Life is Worth Living · The Clown is Right

Fulton Sheen · Archdiocese of New York · Vision Video · Published May 12, 2021

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:09 I was preaching in a certain church over a period of about two months. And every Sunday there was put in the collection box an envelope that had written on it, I owe you one week $35 for a sermon. Another week, I owe you $15. Another week, an envelope, I owe you $40. This went on for four or five weeks, and it was always an I owe you. One day, there was put in the collection box an envelope containing the sum of all of the IOUs,

1:01 amounting to about $220. Well, I was rather delighted that the talks were that good. But the next week, there was put in an envelope and it read, You All Me 40. You have no idea what this show is about, do you? The clown is right. It's about play. Work and play. You remember the story of the boy on an airplane that was causing a commotion running up and down the aisles, and the stewardess said to him, little boy, would you like to go outside and play?

1:46 The idea for this particular telecast came to me from an experience that I had as a boy, and many times. There was a vacant lot near where I lived, and a number of us boys used to play baseball on that lot. And maybe one or two times a week, the game would be interrupted by my mother calling me.

2:16 And she would say, I want you to go to the grocery store and buy this and this and this. And I would always say, well, mother, listen, why can't you wait until the game is over? She said, what difference does it make? whether you're running to a grocery store or running around the bases.

2:39 You know, I never could think of an answer. But later on, when I went to school, I found an answer. She probably knows the answer already because, please God, she's in heaven. But, oh no, I won't tell you where I found the answer. Later on I may tell you. But I did find the answer. And the answer was in the philosopher Thomas Aquinas. For those of you who are studying philosophy, you will know what this reference is. And you can, can look it up yourself. I'm not going to explain it. That's the reference in Aquinas. On play. What was the answer that he gave? The answer that Aquinas gave actually was... was...

3:35 The difference between work and play is that work is for a purpose. Play is not. Isn't that a wonderful answer? We do. We work for money. We work to produce a work of art. And play is the relieving of the tension. For example, there's a legend about St. John the Evangelist that he scandalized someone one day because he was seen playing with some of his disciples. And this pharisaical person said to him, why do you play? And he said, take your arrow and your bow. Now shoot the arrow into the sky. Did you enjoy it? Yes. Well, keep on doing it all day. Oh, he said, I would get tired. Well, he says that's the way it is with any kind of work.

4:29 The work has to be relieved by play, but play and work are related. Now, you find this in Scripture. In a very interesting passage, I've never seen a commentary on it, but the passage runs something like this.

4:53 I was with the workman. as he made the universe playing before him all the day. Ludens corum eo omni temporae. Notice that there were two elements. First of all, the workman. I who was I. I was wisdom, the one who becomes Christ. I was with him in the creation of the universe, playing with him all the days. Can the creation be play? We can understand how it can be work. So we speak of he labored for six days making the world. Yes, creation was work. It was something serious. There had to be tumbles, I mean, planets and universes and stars, tumbling as it were from the fingertips of God.

5:55 The blowing and the infusing of the law of gravitation into the material universe. gravitation into the material universe so that all material things were drawn to the center of the earth and then the other law in our own hearts drawing us up above all of this was work but where did the play came come in in creation we know that he rested the seventh day but here there's play playing before him Why play? Because the playing or the making of the universe was not necessary.

6:43 God was under no compulsion to tell the secrets of his being to nothingness. Love is always free. It's under no obligation. And that is why when you're not under any obligation, when it's love, there's play. That's one of the reasons, too, why Isaac was recognized to be with his wife. He was playing. So that in the divine order, these two things always go together. Now, I mentioned Scripture, but did you know that this very same idea appears in a Greek philosopher over four centuries before Christ, namely the philosopher Plato. Plato in his work Timios pictures the Logos, that is to say the divine mind. The Logos holding the universe in his hand and playing with it.

7:53 That's where the representations of the Middle Ages came from. Remember, we've often seen works of art in which the divine child is pictured as having an apple in his hand. Well, the apple stood for the world. And here is the creator, the workman, playing with his world. as a poet has put it swinging the world a trinket at his wrist One finds this idea in Cicero, the great orator. Cicero said, whenever you're giving a serious discourse, every now and then introduce play. Something light.

8:49 Let it distract, but never completely disturb the gravity of the discourse. There was an American poet, Father Tab, who, picking up this idea of Plato, of Logos, holding the universe in his hand and playing with it, and saying that the Logos, God, lost the little ball of earth, and he came down to earth to find it again. Now, this idea, too, one finds also in Shakespeare. Shakespeare in his, I think it's The Taming of the Shrew, says, haven't we any play to distract us from this terrible hour? The two, therefore, go together.

9:45 Now, when they go together, we got a perfect picture of life. I haven't mentioned anything about the clown yet, have I? Don't worry, we got 14 minutes by the clock. We'll get to the clown. I'm saving that for the end. That's the light moment, you see, that Cicero said you introduce into a discourse. So that life really is made up of these two elements.

10:08 It's made up of the tragic... and it's made up of the comic. Why does life have a serious side? You know why?

10:31 It's because we have freedom. And freedom implies responsibility. And believe me, responsibility... which is the liberty to open certain doors and close others,

10:52 produces the tragedy of life. But life also has a comic side. A lighter side. What is it? It's life. How often we say, it's great to be alive.

11:13 There's joy in living. And so from the notion of play, we get a true concept of what is... Life. The tragic and the comic. Now we're getting closer to the clown, but not yet. Who best describes this combination of life? The tragic and the comic. whom would you save? The comedians? Well, half and half. Most comedians either take the tragic or the comic. Now let us see how some great comedians of our times take this double aspect of life, work and play, the tragic and the serious.

12:17 Who would you say was a comedian who very well exemplified the tragic side of life? Jack Benny. Why? Jack Benny's always the victim. Everybody makes fun of him. He's the butt of every joke. He doesn't know what to answer, so it's... looking out into empty space. He presents a picture of himself as being tight, which indeed he isn't. But that's the comedy side of the tragic life. And so he reveals this one side of life, namely that of being a victim. I saw him on one night with Billy Graham. and he was the victim of all of Billy Graham's jokes.

13:15 Now, it could have been the other way, you know. But no, Jack Benny is the tragic character. Who's the comic? Who gets joy and thrills and sees the funny side of life? I would say Bob Hope. Isn't that right? Bob Hope is on top of everything. He's on top of the world. Political situation, find something to laugh at. Economic situation, something to laugh at. He can talk to soldiers and the seriousness of war. He's on top of that. And so he brings out the comic side of life. As very few comedians have ever brought it out. Now, who depicts both sides? Now you know the answer, don't you?

14:09 I told you. The clown, that's right. The clown. The clown. The clown is the man who combines within himself. The serious and the light.

14:33 The sad and the glad. The smile and the tears. He has both. Look at Emmett Kelly. Sad. Did you ever see anyone so sad? And he's typical of almost all clowns. But with that sadness... There's also humor in the things that he does. A clown belongs to no social class. He doesn't belong. He belongs to the rich in a certain sense sometimes because he wears a topsail cap. But he belongs to the poor. Baggy trousers and old shoes, toes out through the front.

15:32 No one group can claim him. He depicts all of the contradictions of human life. He is the butt of jokes. Someone else carries a plank across the sawdust ring, hits the clown on the side of the face. He's always being knocked over. But he does the same to others. Why do we like the clown? We like the clown because he... he's a picture of what we are. We're so dignified, and yet we can make such fools of ourselves. We are so proud and yet we can be so frustrated.

16:35 We glory in our wealth, and yet we can be so impoverished. Charlie Chaplin was the great clown for a time, a time. When he was the pilgrim, when he was the policeman, when he would pick up a pretty girl, go into a restaurant, not have enough money to pay the bill, he was funny. Here he was, cane, he belonged to the gentleman class, baggy trousers, he didn't belong there. When did Chaplin lose his influence over an American and world audience? and world audience when he began to carry the red flag of revolution when he got into modern times and became a kind of a social reformer and put himself in a certain class, he lost it all.

17:40 So what does the clown do? I think the clown is... Maybe something like the god appearing in green pastures. It makes us ridiculous. He makes us laugh at ourselves. And there's only one time in Scripture where God is said to laugh. when was that when he laughs at the atheists. when he laughs at those who say God is dead.

18:40 God laughs. The clown is laughing at finite men who try to make themselves the infinite. He's laughing at the poor to make themselves rich. He's laughing at the rich who refuse to be poor. And God himself laughs in the same way. He laughs at man who's the carbon copy and calls himself the original.

19:14 He laughs at man when he... wants to be the pendulum without the clock. And so the one person in the world that is the great poor man's theologian... is the clown. Now, because he reveals both sides... of the tragic and the comic.

19:52 Let me tell you now what's happening in the world as we lose our love of clown. We have people today dividing themselves into two classes, something like the comics. But the comics are still comics, so they have a place in the world. But there are those who take the tragic side of life. Who are they? There are many of our modern youths who are so sad with their long faces and long hair like Job's seated on the dung heap. Not much laughter. They carry a flower, but they don't smile with the flower. Flower gives perfume, so do they, but they don't laugh at it.

20:51 And so out of them comes what? Poetry of death. Songs of death. Murder. Killing. Out of it comes this side of life, the existentialists. Life has no meaning, no purpose, no goal. We cannot see the play side of the world. And these are the dramatists, to a great extent, of our modern world, who depict the sorry side and never the glad. then what do we have on the other side We have, on the play side, the playboy philosophy. There's nothing serious to life.

21:54 I want to do it. That's it. They will to do everything they please, and then they get tired of doing what they please. These are the hedonists. whose law is pleasure, these are the pessimists. and this is the story of those who cannot see life as a whole who cannot see that it involves a few tears, but also laughs. and I wonder if the right philosophy was not given The day that the Logos or Truth Incarnate said, What doth it profit a man?

22:53 If he gained the whole world... and lose his soul. Lose his soul. That is the serious side of life. That's the work side. Work while you have the light. The other side, what does it profit if you gain the world and lose your soul? The world, that's the comic side. That's the light side. We mustn't make the secular too serious. In other words...

Machine translated from the source