David Lee · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
2:22 Let me add my welcome to Gustavo. My name is David. I'm the pastor here. And it's a really exciting time to be a part of Redeemer Brooklyn. Like Gustavo mentioned, we just started a year ago. And we're going to keep saying that we are a new congregation until you finally feel like it's not a new congregation. So we're excited to celebrate our one-year anniversary next Sunday. We do hope that you'll join us for that. And it just made me think this past week of just how often over the past year I've been telling people, wow, we really want to be a missional community. We really want to be a missional community. And I was saying that so much that one time somebody finally had the courage to just flat out ask me, what are you talking about? What does it mean to be missional? And I was like, oh, right, maybe we should help define that and talk about that a little bit. And I said, you know, to be missional, it is just simply not living for yourself. That's what it means to be missional.
3:18 And from a Christian context, it is not living for yourself and instead living on mission, understanding that you are sent by God to be a part of what he is doing in the world. That is now what it means to be missional. And that is really central to understanding what Christianity is all about. and how Christianity shapes your life. Because you've got to realize that that's essentially what Jesus came to do himself. Jesus the Son is sent by God the Father on mission for the sake of the world. And so we now as Christians, as followers of him, are called to join him in all that he is doing, to be with him and also to be like him as we live missionally out on mission with him. And that's what we want to be all about here at Redeemer Brooklyn. And that is why in this season, as we're coming up on one year, this is just a great chance to talk through the kind of community that we want to be.
4:14 And so we started this new sermon series through the Gospel of Mark. Because Mark gets really clear about Jesus' missional identity. That he is this king. He is this Messiah that's come to save. But he does it not by trying to be served, but to serve the sake of others and the sake of the world. And that is the kind of church that we want to be that's founded on who Jesus is. A church that's not for ourselves, but for the good of Brooklyn, for the good of others. Now, our passage that was just read in Mark 8 is a critical, central passage that helps to bring all of the gospel of Mark together. and this particular passage that was read becomes sort of the linchpin and the turning point for this entire gospel of Mark. Because here is where Jesus most clearly identifies himself and who he is to his disciples and what he came to do.
5:14 And in our passage, Jesus then answers very important and critical questions that every single one of us, if we want to consider ourselves a Christian, every single one of us must also answer. And so we're going to look at these four critical questions that come from this text. And I'm going to just warn us now that, again, if you consider yourself a Christian, these are questions that you have to answer yourself. And what the text is going to show us is that these answers are not going to be at all comfortable for us. These are not easy answers to these critical questions, but that's how you know this is the real thing. That's how you know that you finally really understand what Christianity is, who Jesus is, and therefore who you are. So let's look at this passage, and let's look at four questions that this raises. First is who, how, why, and what. Who is Jesus?
6:08 How will he save? Why is it necessary that he saves this way? And what does it mean for us? Who is Jesus? How does he save? why is it necessary and what it means for us. So first, in the beginning of our passage, we see Jesus talking to his disciples and he asks this question to them, who do people say that I am? Now, up until this part in the gospel of Mark, there's been a lot of, this has been sort of the big question that people are asking. And there are all these rumors flying around because Jesus is doing a lot in his ministry. And so the disciples say, well, some say you are John the Baptist. Some say you are Elijah from the Old Testament reincarnated. And others just say, you are a great prophet that's come. Now, that is all really, really high praise for who Jesus is. But it's off the mark. And if you don't get who really Jesus is, then you will not fully understand his mission and why he came.
7:05 And so this is significant to get him correct, get him right, if you want to understand the full significance of his ministry. And so Jesus says, okay, that's great if other people say that. But I ask you, who do you say that I am? And the apostle, the disciple Peter, he comes out and he says, you are the Christ. You are the Messiah. Now, you may not know this, but this is a very big moment because this is the first time in the entire Gospels where now Jesus' identity as the Savior, as the Messiah, isn't just narrated, but it is said out loud by another human being. And this is the first time that a disciple is now fully confessing Jesus' true identity as the Messiah. Now, this word, the Messiah, had a lot of significance, right? If you think back, the word Messiah just basically means the anointed one. But that idea, when you think back to Jewish history, it had a lot of weight.
8:02 So people like Peter and the entire Jewish people, you realize for centuries they had now been subjugated and oppressed by foreign powers. So the kingdom of God feels like it's gotten shrunken down to this tiny little sect, and now they are this dominated subculture within the entire vast Roman Empire. And so for centuries, the Jewish people have been waiting for God to send someone that will finally liberate them, that will finally fulfill all of their hopes and all of their dreams, that there has been this savior figure that has been spoken of that will finally come to be the Messiah, the anointed one, the king above all kings, to finally fulfill all of the hopes and the dreams of the Jewish people. That is what Peter is confessing about Jesus. You were that person. And Jesus doesn't shrug it off, but he completely accepts this confession.
9:00 But he takes it a step further. He says, yes, I am the Messiah, but then he also calls himself the Son of Man. The Son of Man was a specific title that was used in the prophet Daniel, back in Daniel chapter 7. And the Son of Man was this divine, heavenly, messianic figure that was promised to come with all power, with all the angels, empowered to do God's work. It was a heavenly, divine figure. And so with Jesus now, through this confession, he is making it absolutely clear who he is. He's not just a mere prophet. He is not just a great teacher. He is not just a healer or a miracle worker. But he is the divine heavenly figure sent to save Israel, sent to save the whole world. The divine king.
9:55 And here is why this particular confession is very, very important. Because if that is actually true of him, then this confession changes everything. Because Jesus here now is saying that he is God himself that's come to save humanity. So this is a complete world-shattering truth claim where if somebody says something like that, you can't say, oh, that's nice for you. Like, what are you having for lunch later? This is a miraculous, a huge claim that requires now a response from you if it is true, which is why it is important that Jesus then presses the disciples and he asks, who do you say that I am? Who am I to you? Do you get who I am and what I came to do? You know, C.S. Lewis has this famous argument saying that because of these audacious claims that Jesus makes, and you can't really argue with what he is saying when he calls himself the son of man.
10:56 Because of these claims, he really only leaves you three basic options as to who his identity is. And you can either think that he is a liar, a lunatic, or lord. And it's a really simple syllogistic logical thinking. Either he knows he is not God himself, but he is saying that he is, which would make him what? A liar, right? Or he really believes that he is this divine Messiah and he is not, which would make him what? A crazy person, a lunatic, right? Or the only third option is what? That he is actually who he says he is. We have no other option. That is what he leaves us with. Here's what C.S. Lewis says. You must make your choice. Either this man was and is the son of God or else a madman or something worse. You can shut him up for a fool.
11:53 You can spit at him and kill him as a demon. Or you can fall at his feet and call him Lord and God. But let us not come with any patronizing nonsense about his being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us. He did not intend to. See, at some point, every single one of us here, all of us have to make our own personal decisions, personal confessions as to who Jesus really is. Not who I say Jesus is, not who others say Jesus is. But he says, but what about you? Who do you say that I am? Am I just someone that you admire? Am I just a moral compass? Am I just your insurance package for eternal life? or am I actually the Messiah that's come to fulfill all of your hopes and your dreams? And your answer to that will change everything.
12:51 Your confession of who Jesus is will either be the start of life with him, or it will be the beginning of the end with him, where you are severing a relationship with his revealed identity, and therefore his mission for the earth. He's either a liar, a lunatic, or he is the Messiah, or he actually is the Lord. That's who Jesus reveals himself to be. That's the first question. The second one is therefore how? How will he save? Look at verse 31 with me. It says, the son of man must suffer many things and be rejected by the elders, the chief priests, and the teachers of the law, and that he must be killed. And after three days rise again. How will this Messiah come? Through suffering, through rejection, and ultimately through death. Now, this was a radical idea too. Never before this moment did anyone in Israel connect the Messiah, this anointed one coming in all power to save, with suffering, right? There were other ideas and passages in the Old Testament, like you may be familiar with the suffering servant from Isaiah, from the Isaiah passages, but that was never connected directly to the Messiah, the anointed one back then.
14:09 See, the Messiah was supposed to come and defeat all evil, make all things right once and for all, to take care of injustice, to renew all things, which is why a suffering Savior made zero sense back then as well as to us now. And this isn't the kind of like noble suffering that we can kind of think of, right? like martyrdom or that's what we kind of equivocate Jesus' suffering to. See, it says that not only does he suffer and he has to die, but he is rejected. That language means that he is going to be despised. He's going to be shamed that there is no glory in this suffering and hardship.
14:46 And that is why you see in this passage, Peter, he freaks out and he rebukes Jesus. Peter rebukes Jesus here in this passage because his thinking is just like ours. How is it that you can come and save us and do everything that you've said you are to do if you are to suffer and to die? And Jesus responds, get behind me, Satan. You do not have the things of God in mind. You have the things of this world. Jesus is saying, you are living into this worldly view, Peter, much like how we typically live into today. He didn't have this particular modern progress narrative, but it was the same human fleshly idea, right? Today we live in this world that we've deeply internalized, that our lives should be up and to the right, that over time things should just continue to get better.
15:40 And in fact, that is why we work so hard, so that we can be buffered against any kind of hardship. And if any of us wrote down, what is your vision of the good life? I promise you it would be something that does not include suffering, but gaining more comfort, gaining more resources, getting more power and status. And that is why we work so hard here in this city, right? We want to gain that power, that influence, and that status because that's how we believe. That's how the world works. That's what leads to the kind of life that we want. And this is the story that's been true over all of human history. Like, think of the history of winners in this world, like the way that it's narrated. It's the strong and mighty armies that take over those who are weak, right? It's the powerful people who make things happen versus those who are weak and who are suffering that get taken advantage of.
16:38 And that's the very narrative that we live into in this city. Nice people finish last. You've got to take every single competitive advantage you can because it's brutal out there. And so it's either, you know, it's dog eat dog. Either you've got to conquer or you will be conquered. That's the kind of thinking that we live into all the time, which is what causes us to strive and grab for status and for power. Because that's how we think we will win. That's how we think we will set things right in this world. And that's the exact same thinking of Peter and the disciples. They are expecting Jesus, this powerful Messiah figure, to now go in and take over the throne. To overthrow the Roman Empire. To overpower them. To now put Israel back on top.
17:31 To get this power and this influence. Which is why it is utterly shocking when Jesus says to them, not only am I the Messiah, but I am one that must be rejected and humiliated. That yes, I am that anointed one, but I am one who has come to suffer and to die. and this is where Jesus breaks from any other Messiah figure or leader or hero that you are ever, ever looking to. Nothing, no one is like Jesus. No other king, no other leader, no other power that promises this kind of hope and change, and it's really important for us to understand that this is how Jesus comes, that he saves through suffering. He saves by giving up his power and giving up his life in order to serve, that his way, the way of Jesus, is to willingly go down in self-sacrifice and in humiliation, not up into the right, to a place of exaltation and glory, that his ultimate victory comes through the cross and death on a cross.
18:53 And here's the scariest thing that Jesus then says after he makes that clear to his disciples. Look with me on verse 34. He says, then he called the crowd to him along with his disciples and said, whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. for whoever wants to save their life will lose it, but whoever loses their life for me and my sake and for the gospel will save it.
19:21 This is not how you grow a following. I imagine people who heard this but then immediately turned away and stopped following Jesus. And he is making very clear his implications for his followers. that if this is the path for me as the Messiah, this too is the path for you as my follower.
19:46 And see, when Peter rebukes Jesus, it feels like, oh, Jesus, we want to protect you, and that's why we're going to say, no, don't do that. Do you know what Peter is really doing? Do you know what our hearts are really doing when we hear that? We are wanting to protect ourselves. We don't want this kind of a life. That's not what Peter envisions for his life as a disciple of this Messiah. Because if his Savior must suffer and die, then that means that's also the roadmap for anyone who wants to follow him. And Jesus is not shy about saying that at all. He's not trying to get influence and power through getting a larger gathering and trying to create a movement because that's what we would do. We would try to get as many people. We would try to water down the message as much as we can to get as many people as we can because that's how you change the world, right? But Jesus instead makes very clear the cost of discipleship. And that's the thing that we've got to internalize too, friends. If you think that following Jesus or if you are following Jesus because you think it will lead to a smooth sailing life, ultimately, friends, what we are doing then is we are using Jesus still to get what we want. We are using Jesus for him to accomplish our agendas. And we're not treating him or submitting to him or following him as the king, as our Lord. And our lives won't be filled with any kind of suffering or pain because we won't follow him into those places. Or if we do experience any kind of hardship or friction, When we do experience a real cost to following Jesus in our workplaces, in our communities, in our relationships, in our relationship lives, in our hopes and our desires.
21:38 And when we realize that there's a death that is to come, we will only maybe get angry or get a lot of bitterness. And we'll feel like Jesus has left and abandoned you because things are hard. When in fact, Jesus says in those moments, this is exactly where I am. And maybe now you are finally learning what it means to follow me and to not follow yourself or the ways of this world. because how I come is through suffering and death. But the third question, that's probably racing up to your mind. is why? Why is that necessary? Jesus says the son of man must be killed and after three days rise again. And if you're anything like me, when you read that, you're like, okay, If you know you're going to be raised from the dead in three days, why go through all of that suffering and that pain? Can't we just skip the suffering part of the Messiah and just get straight to the exaltation and straight to the glory?
22:42 But Jesus says this really interesting word that really controls the entire sentence. He says, the Son of Man must suffer. He must die. He is therefore saying, it is absolutely necessary for me as the Messiah to go through this in order to accomplish my salvation. And here is why. Again, the Messiah, the Savior of the world, makes you ask the question, saved from what? What are we saved from? What has he come to do to put everything right in this world? Well, the Bible teaches that the reason why the world is broken is not whatever you want to call it, ignorance or education or whatever it is, or just hate in people's hearts. Ultimately, it is sinful human nature that is constantly grabbing for power, wanting a life that is up and to the right at the expense of others.
23:42 That we don't want to take up our cross and to follow Jesus in order to serve. We want to be served. And that is why we never in our fleshly desires, we never want to give up control. We never want to give up power. We never want to give up comfort. Instead, we want to seize those things and use it for our own benefit. The Bible says that is ultimately at the heart of what is wrong with the world, why everything is broken. That is at the heart of why nations are at war. That is at the heart of injustice or evil or relational conflict that we cause to one another. That is what is wrong. That is why there is hate and evil persists in this world. You know, I was walking here this morning and you pass by all these colleges and right around the corner is NYU Tandem School of Engineering. And their slogan, I just realized this morning, their slogan is built to solve humanity's greatest challenges. Become an engineer and you will solve humanity's greatest challenges. Now that might get enrollment up because there's this powerful message behind it. But the Bible doesn't agree with that. Engineering is good if you're an engineer. I'm glad you guys are an engineer. But the Bible says that there is something so much more profound, so much more relational at the core of everything, and that working a little bit harder won't ultimately fix the problems. And what the Bible teaches is that it's not just our human nature that's curved in on ourselves, but what that ultimately is, is a relational tear principally against God himself, that instead of laying down our lives before God and having him on the throne of not only our lives but of the world, that we are constantly wanting to be on the throne ourselves, that we want to be God. And that is a simple definition of what the Bible calls sin.
25:32 And it is a complete violation of a relationship with him who made us. That is what needs to be set right. That is what is principally wrong with this world, which is why what we need is forgiveness and reconciliation with God. And how do we get it? And that's what leads us to why Jesus has to come and suffer in this way. Because you know this from any of your other relationships, when there is a violation, right, when there is a relational breaking, when there is a wounding, someone needs to pay for that. If someone has hurt you or stolen something from you or taken something from you, either you can make them pay and make them suffer and pay the debt, or you can absorb it. You can take it on. You can take on that suffering. But that's the thing. Someone has to pay. Ultimately, for true forgiveness, there is a debt and a suffering that must be endured.
26:30 and Jesus says that is why I must suffer and be rejected and die because that is the only way that you and I can be forgiven of the infinite debt that we have against an infinite God and it's either you pay or I pay and Jesus says sadly you're not qualified to pay your death can't absolve you of your sins You can't be granted the assurance of pardon if you just pay because you are sinful. You are not infinite. You and I are not worthy enough to pay the price that is due to God. But do you know who is? The Messiah. the divine heavenly figure of infinite worth that also lived the sinless life who doesn't have to atone for his own sins but comes so that you and I now might be forgiven in him.
27:32 See, that is why Jesus must come to die on a cross to fully pay for our sins so that we might know. once and for all that we are completely forgiven. And it's only if he dies that we now have true and eternal life in him. But only if he lets go, only if he comes down in all humility, in suffering, only if he lets go of all of his power and his status. He must suffer and be rejected if we are to live and be accepted by God the Father. That is why the only way we can have true life, true forgiveness, is on the other side of death. That's why he must suffer and die. It's for you and I, but it's not only to give us this true forgiveness, but he also does in order to have us experience for the first time in our lives true love, complete, unconditional love, a love that does not say you have earned it or because I like you or because you bring something to the table, but a love that is utterly sacrificial, utterly selfless for you.
28:48 You see, there's no other love in this world that is that selfless. You know, a parent might give of themselves selflessly to a child, but at the end of the day, you derive a lot of meaning and value from that child, and so you're able to do really hard, selfless things. But do you know what God is doing for us on the cross? He is dying for us while we were yet enemies of the cross, while we were the ones spitting in his face and mocking him, while we were unjustly accusing him. he says I will die I will show my love to these people so that you and I can now know that our worth is not based on the things that we have or a life that says it's up and to the right. but now we are assured of a love that can never ever be taken away that is not on the basis or on the premise of anything we have ever done and so God Jesus, he dies on the cross so that we can have this kind of unconditional love where the God of the universe lays down his life in complete selflessness to assure us of our value and our worth.
29:59 And friends, that is the thing. Not only are we looking for true forgiveness in our souls, we are also looking for true love. This kind of love is what we are ultimately looking for. And when you have it, when you have a taste of that, then we can start loving others selflessly the way that Jesus does.
30:21 That's why he comes. But then finally, that leads to the final question. Well, what does that mean for us? Verse 34, he says, whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. See, if you only see, once you see what Jesus has done for you and why he comes this way, that is the only way that a statement like this no longer becomes utterly death-defying and scary. That when you see what Jesus has done for you on the cross, you can now take up your own cross You can now look to yourself and be willing to lose yourself because you gain everything in him. And when Jesus says you have to take up your cross, what he is saying is just in the same way that I gave my whole life for you. Taking up your cross now means you are giving your entire life, all of yourself, holding nothing back to live for him. and now the way that we live, the shape of our lives is the cruciform life.
31:19 It's the life in the shape of a cross where we are willing to die to ourselves, willing now to die to our own agendas and our own passions, knowing that experiencing eternal resurrection life comes only on the other side of that, where we can give ourselves away for the sake of Jesus and for others. Because that's where true life is found. The writer Paul Miller, he calls this the J curve. He says, this is now the shape that every normal Christian life takes. It is not an up and to the right, but it is a going down, going into a death to reenact the gospel message and story in our lives. Knowing that only on the other side of that comes real life. That's what Jesus shows us, and that is now why we mimic and reenact this gospel narrative, a dying and a rising with Jesus, a dying to our comforts and to our convenience and to approval or to power, and ultimately a dying to ourselves, ourselves that want to just grasp for power, that want to be like God, and a dying to those things, and no longer finding our identity in those things, but letting go and experiencing these tiny deaths in our lives.
32:36 And at first, letting go of that thing that you think is so important is gonna feel insurmountably hard. And I don't know what's coming up for you right now. The Spirit is poking something at you, some area of your life where you say, well, no, Jesus, you can't have this, anything but this. But you realize that this becomes now, because of what Jesus has done, a chance to trust in what he says, that whoever wants to save their life will lose it. But whoever loses their life for my sake and for the gospel will save it. That now you can trust in this promise that Jesus is giving to you that on the other side of that death, my friends, but only on the other side of that death, will you and can you experience the fullness of life that only Jesus is offering? And the more that you live into this J curve, the more that you slowly start to realize and internalize, oh, I no longer am.
33:34 must have these things. Because Jesus, he said, I must suffer so that I might have everything in him. That even now, real physical death, the worst that this life could possibly do to you, can also never take you away from him, but only bring you closer to him. That is a start of real life, my friends, real resurrection life. And if we start following him, trusting him, giving ourselves away, we will start to get a taste of what Jesus promises. Let me close with this final quote from one of our commentators. From Donald English, he says, and here comes another surprise. This is the way of total freedom. If you clutch your life wholly to yourself, protecting it against all others, asserting all of your rights, your needs, and privileges, you lose it because it isn't life any longer.
34:28 If, however, you acknowledge that life is not yours by right, that all is a privilege and that it is to be lived in the love that the gospel story reveals, self-giving love, then you possess life wholly. There is now nothing to lose and everything to gain. So will you trust him? In whatever area of life where you are most afraid, where you are so afraid to give completely over to the Messiah, will you trust him and see a life that comes on the other side of death? Let me pray for us.
Machine translated from the source