Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published June 14, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
1:59 Thanks, Cedric, for reading that for us. Well, let me add my welcome to Marla's. My name is Pete Nicholas. If I haven't met you before, and if this is your first time here at Redeemer Downtown, welcome to you. We are finishing up today our sermon series. We're going through that list of the nine aspects of the fruit of the Spirit. And we've been calling this sermon series The Power of Good because we've been saying this description of the good life, this description of the life of Jesus, is also the description of the life that God is calling us all to come into and to live. And this is the truly impactful life, actually, that really makes a difference to the world, far from just being a life where we seek power and control and self-advancement. Instead, if we press into these nine aspects of the fruit of the Spirit, we live out a life in the power of good. And as we saw in the life of Jesus Christ 2,000 years ago, that was the life that changed the world. And in a similar way, in the power of the Spirit, this is the life that we are called to live into. And we're ending this week by thinking about the final virtue in the list, self-control. We're going to think about it in four ways. First of all, we're going to consider the importance of self-control. Then we're going to think about the challenge of self-control, why it's difficult, not straightforward, not easy. Thirdly, we're going to think about the freedom of self-control, why it's something we really do want to press into. And finally, we're going to understand the key to self-control, how we can become people who live lives of self-control. So the importance, the challenge, the whatever I said next, and then the key. I'll come back to my notes in a moment. All right, let's think first of all about the freedom, that was it, there we are. The importance of self-control, let's think about that. Well, look, one of the things with these nine aspects of the fruit of the Spirit is this list is very carefully constructed. It has a beautiful unity to it, careful structure to it, and a kind of symmetry to it as well. So we've been saying as we've been going through it that the significance of nine aspects is that nine can be divided into three lots of three. And so the first three aspects of the fruit of the Spirit are all about our life with God. The second three aspects are all about
4:10 our life with other people. And the third three, these final ones of which self-control is the last, are about our inner life, our inner kind of spirituality and how it impacts the others. Not only that, but within the list, we said in the very first sermon that love can be read throughout the whole of the list. The first virtue is significant, not just because it's the kind of main virtue, if you like, but actually that all of the other virtues can be summarized by love. So, for example, patience is loving another person enough to give them time. Gentleness is your posture of love towards another person. That means you don't jump on every wrongdoing that they exhibit and you don't have excessive anger or hasty or unreasonable anger towards other people when they get something wrong. And I could go on.
5:00 All of the nine virtues require love. And in the same way, all of the nine virtues require self-control. remarkable unity and beauty to it. They're both kind of bookended, framing all of these nine aspects of the fruit of the Spirit. Because it's not possible to live out any of the virtues if we don't have love. And it's not possible to live out any of the virtues if we don't have self-control. I mean, self-control is required for all of these virtues. We saw earlier in the list, in the reading, of the vices, if you like, that are contrary to the fruit of the Spirit. And self-control is vital because it's the choosing of the good over the immediate desires of the flesh. We know that being patient is the route to fruitful relationships. and to conducting ourselves well in community, but frequently we don't feel like being patient.
5:54 We instead want to fly off the handle in jealousy and anger and fits of rage. And so we have to make a choice, a self-control choice, to choose the good over the short-term desires of the flesh, as it were. And we could go through all the aspects. Faithfulness, for example, requires self-control. Committed to the truth, even when it's not popular, and doing it time after time after time over the long run. We could go through any of the virtues and show you why it's so important with self-control. Now, therefore, we get that self-control is vital and important. And one of the reasons that, therefore, we're going to be thinking about self-control is because it's so important for all of life today. We frequently realize that the immature self or immature people lack self-control. There are studies that have been done, for example, where we have children who are involved in the studies where they're placed in a room, and this has been done many times, and they're given a sweet on the table.
6:49 And they're told that if they can resist eating the sweet for some time, like five minutes, then they will get a whole bag of sweets. In other words, there's a better good, a greater good available to them. They just need to exercise self-control. And typically all of those studies show that about two-thirds of children cannot exercise the self-control required. Only about a third can, normally by kind of putting their hands under themselves and kind of shutting their eyes and, you know, trying to exercise self-control. And therefore we recognize the importance of self-control. This is part of the way our society functions. Children need to be trained in self-control because without it they're not really going to be able to achieve anything good in the long run. And so, so much of teaching and so much of parenting is about educating and helping, putting structures in place that will help people grow in self-control. Listen to this from Proverbs chapter 1 verses 8 to 10.
7:43 Listen, my son, to your father's instruction. Do not forsake your mother's teaching. They're a garland to grace your head and a chain to adorn your neck. My son, if sinful men entice you, do not give in to them. And the Proverbs go on. Right at the center or the very beginning of the book of Proverbs is this call to self-control. And it's a call for fathers and mothers and teachers in society to teach the younger generation this because it recognizes that a society is not going to be able to function well unless we have self-control individually. and corporately. This is why it's a garland to grace your head, a chain to adorn your neck. Don't just go after what seems intuitively attractive. Your desires can often leave you astray. Instead, choose the path of self-control. Self-control is vital, it's important. In the Greek, the word self-control literally means self-mastery. This is something we've all got to learn.
8:38 How do we master ourselves so that we choose the good? We choose the best. We don't just go with the immediate, the thing that we kind of feel the most pull to. Frequently, if we do that, life does not go well. the importance of self-control. But that leads us to acknowledging, therefore, the challenge of self-control. Self-control, by implication, is going to be difficult. If it's self-mastery, that's not something which is easily won or easily achieved. It has to be learned and has to be ingrained over a long period of time. This is true of all cultures and all generations, but I want to particularly highlight that I think in our culture and in our time and generation, and particularly in the West and in the United States at the moment, I think we've got particular challenges when it comes to self-control. You might say, well, what are those? Well, first of all, that we actually don't, I think, value choosing the greater good over the immediate. Now, of course, we don't think about it that way, but if you reflect on some of the messaging that we have in society at the moment, it's about you following your desires, you pursuing your desires. If you want it, you get it. You should have it because you're worth it. You deserve it. That type of mantra. The problem is, is that mantra makes no distinction between good desires and bad desires, between ignoble desires and higher desires. It just says, if you have the desire, do it.
10:02 And don't you restrain or oppress your desires. You go for it. But that acknowledges no sense that there actually might be desires that are harmful for you and for others, hurtful, that actually you might want to forego certain things in order to achieve a greater good, a better good. If we just tell everyone, you do you, and I'm not going to stand in the way, and your desires are sovereign, and you've got to follow them, then you're going to make so many bad choices. Because the reality is a moment's self-reflection tells all of us that we have a war of desires going on inside of us, and which one should we choose? How do we recognize the good over the bad? If we just go with our every impulse, that does not lead to a flourishing life and that does not lead to flourishing communities. So our kind of ethic that we have in the West at the moment, particularly around desires and the sovereignty of desires and the unwillingness to challenge anyone's desires because you do you, is deeply problematic when it comes to something as vital as self-control.
11:04 We just don't have a conceptual framework by which we can challenge that. Not only that, not only culturally, but technologically we've got a big problem as well. Because technologically, it's not just that we are working out that we can monetize things very effectively if we get people to follow their desires, but we're actually worked out, of course, that by leveraging the dopamine cycle, that if we make you go for the immediate, the short term, the kind of more fleshly, that we can hold your attention. And therefore, we are actually not just enabling a lack of self-control, but we're actually training each other in a lack of self-control. Look, the immature brain is not wired up for self-control. It has to be taught. It has to be learned. You have to learn to prioritize the front portal parts of the brain, executive functioning over the more base parts that just go first.
11:59 I want this. I'm going to get it. That's why children struggle with that test. And so part of growing up and maturing has always been a training of the self, which is really a training of the brain. We now know the brain is much more like a muscle than it is just kind of pure hardware. To be able to exercise self-control. But we're not just enabling a lack of self-control. We are training our brains in the opposite way to self-control. Because our devices are incredibly sophisticated. Frequently, the algorithms and the way the devices are set up have been actually researched and trained and structured by psychiatrists and psychologists who understand how the brain works to encourage your dopamine hit to give you the short term over the longer term good. In other words, we're training a whole generation of people in how not to have self-control. So the messaging of society culturally, and the technology of our society is challenging this whole importance of self-control.
12:59 And of course, it's not just about the fact that we end up doom-scrolling or the fact that we end up with the immediate, you know, kind of pop-up of the next video is about to come with that little bar that comes across to make you anxious if you don't click on it. By the way, that's all part of the training of the brain in dopamine. But it's not just that. But of course, if we train it in one area, the brain is trained in all areas. So we're not able to choose the good, the greater good, the longer-term good over the short-term, because we are breaking down the barriers in the brain that normally we need that stop us just choosing the immediate, choosing the ignoble, choosing the sinful. We are training ourselves out of self-control, the challenge of self-control. And therefore, we need to have some honest conversations, both about the messaging that's going on, but also about how we're engaging with technology, particularly with younger children, if we want them to be able to live the types of lives that will be lived in the power of good.
13:59 The importance of self-control, the challenge of self-control. Let's then think about the freedom of self-control. Because you might be thinking, okay, Pete, all right, so I hear you. Self-control is important according to you, but actually, I'm pretty happy. I have a bit of doom scrolling. It's not the worst thing in the world. I choose my desires. I hear you as a Christian saying that that's not the best thing in the world. I'm pretty happy with that. I'm not really fully persuaded that actually this list of nine virtues is actually that important. What would I say to that? Well, I would want to suggest to you that self-control is actually true freedom, the freedom of self-control. It's interesting to me in Galatians chapter 5 that Paul says, you were called to be free, as those who follow Christ, but do not use your freedom to indulge the flesh. In other words, what he's saying is he's saying true freedom is about making the type of choices that lead you to the greatest good. You've got to understand this. Christianity is not arbitrarily against certain things. Rather, it is because God longs for your greatest good.
15:00 To use the phrase of our culture today, he longs for the best version of you and the best version of society. He is a God who's made the world. He knows how the world works best. And you at your best and community flourishing at its best is God's greatest longing. That's what he's all about. But he recognized that's not easy. And therefore, true freedom, true freedom is about exercising self-control. Now, I'm going to use one sporting illustration from last night just to kind of make the point. You'll have to indulge with that. There's my orange socks.
15:34 I know the accent doesn't work with it, but you know, we're all New Yorkers today. Wasn't it fascinating in the post-match interview with Jalen Brunson, they asked him this question. They said, Jalen, how is it that when the chips were down, when the pressure's on, that you were so confident that you would deliver, that your clutch player, your Mr. Clutch, how is it? And you know what he said? I just thought it was fascinating. He said, because of all the hours, all the hours I've put in, he said, no one saw the hours in the gym. Every summer I was there. Every summer I was doing it. In other words, he was the most liberated player in the moment of greatest pressure on that court. And don't you think he feels free now, having won this title? But what did it require? Enormous self-control down the years. Enormous focus. And that's, okay, I mean, it's true of a star, but it's true of anything in life. How do you learn a musical instrument?
16:28 You have to learn self-control. if you merely just practice when you feel like it. Most people would never practice, right? And we wouldn't have beautiful music played for us on Sunday mornings. And it's not just true of arts and skills like music and sport. It's true of life. You want to become a person who's gentle, doesn't naturally come to us as human beings. We frequently fly off the handle. You have to have constant reinforcement. You have to be focused. It has to require making difficult choices. You have to forego your desire to exact revenge and instead to press into the good of another person, especially when you don't feel like it. We could go through all of the virtues and show you this. You want to live a life that's free in any area. A true life of freedom where you actually choose the good, where other people look at you and say, wow, they are flourishing in life. It will always require self-control. There is no easy path to the good life.
17:23 And until we learn this, the true freedom is not a life without any constraints, but true freedom is about choosing the right constraints, we're never going to learn it. Now, I think we're starting to figure this out as a society. The problem is we're not pressing into it. Think of the evolution of James Bond. You didn't know I was going to go there next, did you? Early versions of James Bond, you know, the Ian Fleming books and the early films when they came out. James Bond was the classic desire, the kind of Superman according to Nietzsche because he had a license for everything. He had a license to kill, but he never felt guilt or remorse. He had a license to drink, but you never see him drunk. He had a license to gamble, but he's the one person who always beats the house. He has a license to sleep around, but you never get the next day when the lady turns up at the door requesting alimony. And it was a life without consequences, right? And it seemed great for a period. Through the 80s and the 90s, James Bond franchise was flourishing and it was the same old James Bond always doing.
18:20 Whatever he chooses, and always coming out on top. And then the franchise got tired. Why? Because it's not real life. And so Martin Campbell came in as the director for the new version of James Bond film, starting with Casino Royale. And here's what he said. In order to revitalize the franchise, he said this, I wanted to show a bond with a journey, with an emotional stake, a Bond who would fall in love and feel the pain of his choices. Fascinating. In the culmination of those films, the line comes up, think on your sins. A James Bond with an emotional reality because his life had consequences. In Casino Royale, you may remember it, that James Bond kind of falls for Vesper, the love interest. And in one of the most poignant scenes where I think you see this complete reversal. He has to defend her against some person who's trying to kill her, and so he kills this person, but she is traumatized. She's experiencing PTSD.
19:23 And so he looks for her afterwards, and he finds her in the shower, but this time she's fully clothed. She's in the shower. She's on the floor. The shower's running, and she's weeping with the trauma of what she's just seen. She's just seen him kill a man. And Bond climbs into the shower, not to seduce her, but to comfort her. Fully clothed. a life of consequences. Bond is suddenly experiencing consequences. My friends, we are told through a thousand billboards and a hundred commercials that you can have a life without consequences. Learn a lesson from James Bond. It's not real life. In real life, if you do bad things, you experience the shame and the guilt. If you drink, you get drunk and have a heavy head in the morning and probably done something you're ashamed about. If you gamble, the house will win in the long run. If you sleep around, you will leave a trail of broken lives, and you will have people pursuing you to step up and to actually face the consequence of your decision. Real life, real consequences. You want freedom? You've got to make good choices. You've got to learn self-control. A life without consequences does not exist, not in God's good earth. And therefore, it's about understanding the implications of our actions and pressing in self-control and living a life that is the truly free life, a life full of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control. Against such a life, there is no law because this is the truly free life, but it's not an easy life to live.
20:55 The freedom of self-control, which then leads us lastly to the key to self-control. We need to recognize that the false way we often try to pursue virtues, and particularly self-control, just doesn't work, and we need to recognize the uniqueness of the Christian spiritual approach with the power of the gospel and the power of the spirit. Let me say that again. There is a way that we try to genuinely pursue virtues. It does not work. It's been going on for thousands of years, and I'm going to try and show you it doesn't work, and I'm instead going to show you why the Christian method of transformation, living in the power of the spirit and the power of the gospel, is the only way that truly works. You know the phrase, beware of Greeks bearing gifts on the back of the whole Troy thing and the Trojan horse. Well, similarly, there's a method of personal change which is hugely popular in lots of different ways in the West and which we normally try to change and try to inhabit virtues about. And it seems very popular. Lots of people talk about it, but it doesn't really work. It was first probably became popular by Plato in his book Phaedrus.
21:59 and he tells an illustration to try to make the point, where he talks about a charioteer who's riding a chariot, he's got two horses. And one of the horses represents ignoble desires, I suppose if you're talking spirituality, sinful desires, the desires that you don't want to follow. And this is the unruly horse. And then the other horse is the one that represents higher desires, good desires, the things you do want, maybe longer term desires. And the charioteer is the rational functions of our brain, so Plato says. And the rational part of our brain has to marshal the tension between those two horses. In his story, they're winged horses because the whole point is if you get it right, you're going to fly. And it seems very attractive, doesn't it? We have bad desires, we have good desires. What do we say to our children? Make better choices. In other words, the executive functioning part of our brain, the rational part, has to choose the good and then we have to follow it. Doesn't that sound so attractive, so intuitive? And that's pretty much the way the West has done virtue formation for a couple of thousand years. I think the problem is that whilst it's good, it just doesn't work. There's lots of research that now backs this up. For example, in psychology, social psychologists talk of the rebound effect, which is this. If you try to restrain a desire and say, well, I don't want to go with the ignoble horse, I instead want to follow the other horse, go with the better desires. You are able to do it in a short term, but the problem is, is that your rebound back to the ignoble desire after trying to restrain it is stronger than it ever was before. This was shown by a guy called Daniel Wegner in 1987 with a famous experiment in psychology called the White Bear Experiment, where he basically tried to get people to not think about a white bear. And he said to each of the participants, you need to not think about a white bear for the next four hours or so. And he found that the way the brain works is that the more we try not to think about something, the more we think about something, which is why repressing desires or restraining desires does not work. You say, okay, so if we're not to do it that way, what way are we to do it? Well, I wonder if you noticed in Galatians chapter
24:07 five how we don't just restrain desires, but we replace desires. All of the ungodly desires in the list of the ignoble parts of our spiritual life in verses 19 to 21 are replaced by the virtues of verses 22 to 23. So rather than jealousy, we have gentleness. Rather than giving in to a lack of self-control, we have self-control. Rather than rage, we have patience. In other words, it's not about restraining our desires, it's about replacing our desires. We need to replace every single desire, and we do that in the power of the Spirit. There's lots of warnings about this in scripture if it doesn't work. In Colossians, for example, chapter 2, verse 20, we're told, since you died with Christ to the elemental spiritual force of this world, why as though you still belong to the world do you submit to its rules? Don't handle, don't taste, don't touch.
25:03 In other words, restraint. Such regulations have an appearance of wisdom. It sounds plausible, doesn't it? With their self-imposed worship, their false humility, and their harsh treatment of the body, they lack any value in restraining sensual indulgence. In other words, it does not work. It doesn't work. So you say, okay, well, what's the alternative? Galatians 4 verse 24. Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with his passions and desires. Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. It's twofold. Number one, rather than just restraining our desires, our ungodly desires, our sinful desires have to be replaced by godly desires. Nature abhors a vacuum. You have to not just restrain but replace. Instead of pride, you pursue humility. Instead of rage, you pursue patience.
25:59 Instead of the easy path of exaggerating a story, you choose the path of faithfulness and telling the truth. I could go on. Every ignoble desire needs to be replaced by a godly desire. And it has to be done in the power of the Spirit and according to the gospel of Christ. Because only the gospel of Christ and the power of the Spirit can really change us at a deep level and can stop the rebound effect happening. One of the persons who got this in history was a man called Thomas Chalmers. He was a preacher at the turn of the 19th century up in Scotland. And he preached a sermon that's become pretty well known within kind of reformed circles. It's called the expulsive power of a new affection. Expulsive is in it pushes out. He's basically saying, new desires, godly desires, Christian desires, gospel desires, push out ungodly sinful desires. He said this, in a word, if the way to disengage the heart from the positive love of one great and ascendant object is to fasten it in a positive love to another, it's not by exposing just the worthlessness of the ungodly desires, but by addressing the mind's eye to the worth and excellence of these new desires, that all old things are to be done away and all things become new. Let me try and illustrate what he's saying there. He's saying, look, how do you grow in self-control? You need to actually see how attractive self-control is, why it's so important.
27:22 And in the power of the Spirit, according to the gospel, your lack of self-control needs to be pushed out or replaced by self-control. How do you do that? The gospel does it. You have to think about Jesus, for example, in the Garden of Gethsemane, not just as a moral example, but as the way by which he won for you in the power of the Spirit, the gift of self-control. There he is in the Garden of Gethsemane. He would do almost anything to avoid what he's about to go through the next day. He knows how horrible the cross will be. Here is Jesus who seems to be perturbed by nothing during his whole life. And then in the garden, he seems to be a shell of a man. He breaks down, falls to his knees, cries out in prayer to his Father, If there's any way, let this cup pass from me. And then in a remarkable display of self-control, what does he pray? Yet not my will, but your will be done.
28:16 In other words, he shows such self-control that he goes to the cross, even though every fiber of his being wants to run the other way. But he will not give in to his desires and want to run the other way. Instead, he gladly submits to the Father's will and pursues the journey to the cross. And he misses nothing out on the step of that journey. He drinks the dregs of the cup of God's wrath to its full, to his last on the cross. Why does he do that? For you and for me and for all of the ways that we give in to our lack of self-control. And we don't choose the good life and we choose our interests over the good of another, but not him. He chooses your interests over his interests. and when you really get that, when that sinks in in the power of the Spirit into your heart, it awakens a new desire for you. Maybe someone's wronged you and you want to get revenge and get them back and you say, hang on, he did that for me? Then I want to pursue their good and I'm going to exercise self-control by not giving in to my anger. Maybe you're trying to grow in gentleness and you find it really difficult. You just want to fly off the handle, but you say, he didn't.
29:25 He didn't run the other way. He walked steadfastly to the cross and replaces your sinful desires with godly desires. This is how the gospel works. This is how the power of the Spirit works. Or let's say you're trying to grow in goodness. You know you should pursue the good of others. The problem is, if you're blunt, most of the time you just don't want to. You just want to pursue your own good. It's much easier. And besides, you've had a tough week. You live in New York City. Things aren't straightforward. So isn't it okay just to have a bit of me time? And so a friend texts you saying, I could do with some help. Can you come around and help? And you just think, I can make an easy excuse. It would be easy. Or maybe you're married and your spouse says, could you get this for me? Could you take out the trash or whatever it is? And you think, I really don't want to. And wouldn't it be easy just to turn around and say, well, it's your turn or I don't want to or all the other things. But instead you suddenly remember that Jesus Christ did not pursue his own good, but pursued your good to the point of death, even death on a cross.
30:24 that he was prepared to sacrifice his own life and experience separation from the Father on the cross for you and for me. And the moment you get that, you think, actually, I can get off the couch. I can take out the trash. It's a low bar anyway. I can go and see my friend. I might not want to do it right now, but actually he didn't pursue his own good. He pursued my good, so I can go and do likewise. You see, the gospel replaces our sinful desires with godly desires in the power of the Spirit. This is the way we grow in the aspect of the fruit of the Spirit. This is the life of self-control, as we're going to sing in a moment. To this I hold, my hope is only Jesus, for my life is wholly bound to His. Oh, how strange and divine I can sing, all is mine. Yet not I, but through Christ in me. My friends, there is real freedom in living out this life of the Spirit, a life of love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.
31:26 Such a life might not be straightforward, but it is the truly free and liberated life, a life lived out in the power of the good. But to do it requires self-control. And unless we follow Christ and the gospel grips our hearts in the power of the Spirit, we cannot live this way. Worldly rules won't do it. Mere willpower and effort and structure won't do it. Only Christ can do it. Yet not I, but through Christ in me. Let us pray, let's pray. Heavenly Father, thank you so much for this passage and both for the life it places before us and starts to evoke in us a sense of maybe I could become this type of person in the power of the Spirit by the gospel. But also not just that it places a great vision before us, but also places the way we can grow. A life full of love, a life full of self-control, a life lived in the power of the Spirit.
32:22 Help me, help us to become more and more these people we pray. And we ask it for Jesus' sake. Amen.
Machine translated from the source