Teacher's Pet All-In

Dave Dwyer · Busted Halo · St. Paul the Apostle Church · Published September 13, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

0:00 How many teacher's pets do we have among us? That was a trick to see if you'd raise your hands. Some of you did. That was good. Because usually, you know, in class it's like this. It seems to me that one of our favorite characters from all the Gospels, the one who a couple of weeks ago we heard Jesus give the keys to the kingdom, Peter, was again today sort of acting in the role of teacher's pet. Because, you know, the other disciples are probably discussing some stuff, you know, well, but it's really hard to forgive. Yeah, I know. How many times do you think we should forgive? so peter goes i'll go ask

0:41 He says, how many times should we forgive? So rather than merely asking the question, you know, he does the teacher's petting. He kind of offers what he thinks is the correct answer. Watch, I'll get points for this. Seven times. What do you think, Jesus? Seven times. Pretty good. Now, he wasn't just kind of pulling this out of the air. If you've been around church, you've probably heard that in the culture of the times, they would have seen numbers as having powerful significance as symbols and even beyond that. So seven was for the Jewish people kind of a number of completion, of perfection. Obviously, if we look to Genesis and the seven days, including the rest day, in which God created the entire universe, from that, seven became an important number. But it wasn't just a cool number, it was a number that represented completion, perfection, like, this is it. So Peter does the stretch.

1:40 Because also, at the time, there would have been rabbinical teaching based on events of the Old Testament that would have said you're supposed to forgive your brother three times. So Peter, rather than going for four, he figures he's going to really impress Jesus and show off a little bit of his knowledge of, you know, biblical numbers and stuff. How about seven times, Jesus? I think he was expecting to get the little gold star, teacher's pet gold star. And yet, Jesus says no, not seven times. 77 times. So Jesus is using the very same technique of these symbolic numbers and essentially saying unlimited. Because could any of us even keep track of having to forgive somebody 77 times? Maybe some wives or husbands out there. Maybe there's a tally, a running tally, but 77. Essentially, he's saying it's not about the numbers.

2:47 Gotta stop keeping track. Not keep track and do better. Keep track and do more things. But stop keeping track. In our second reading, Paul to the Romans says, none of us lives for oneself, and none dies for oneself, for if we live, we live for the Lord. That's really radical. that's extreme to come here St. Paul's on a Sunday night to hear don't live for yourself When, you know, the rest of the week, we kind of get a different message, right? what Paul is saying and I think what Jesus is saying with this numerology is that if we're going to be believers we've got to be all in and stop counting.

3:46 So it's not even about doing more, getting more points. There was Peter trying to get the gold star. Maybe as Catholics, 2,000 years later, we still have a little bit of that score some points with God. How many things, how many corporal works of mercy, how many rosaries, and all things that we believe should indeed flow from our faith. So this isn't saying that we're all in or to stop counting. Jesus isn't saying stop doing stuff. He's not saying stop being good. He's not saying stop forgiving. He's saying keep forgiving. keep doing good things but stop keeping track Go all in. A couple days ago we celebrated, celebrated, we marked the 25th anniversary of the September 11th attacks.

4:47 And among the many memorials, recollections, and stories that were told of that day and the weeks and months and years that have passed, there was an overwhelming recurrence of people that just went all in without counting the cost. Of course we think of our first responders, and people even like Father Michael Judge, one of the chaplains to the fire department that is a very famous story by now, who was the first human body to be pulled from the wreckage, who presumably, along with his fellow first responders, didn't calculate how safe dangerous it was. If any of you live, you don't live for yourself. You live for the Lord. You're all in. We now know, sadly, that in the 25 years since 9-11, we can even point to something upwards of three times as many deaths that have occurred.

5:55 that happened on that day from various after effects, diseases and whatnot. Many people didn't count the cost and were all in. That is, that's a high bar to set for civil service. It's a high bar for Jesus to set for us as believers.

6:22 But what he's basing it in is God being all in for us. The parable that Jesus tells, and let's hit a little pause for a second and remind ourselves that parables in most cases are not actually parables. allegories. It's not a one-to-one relationship of who the character represents. We don't believe in in a God that is vengeful and would throw us to the torturers.

6:53 And yet, what we're supposed to be thinking about there is how magnanimous God was. So the master, this guy, the guy owes him a lot of money, and in the scripture scholars tell us that there's an amount given in the original Greek that wouldn't make sense to us, but it's something like 150,000 years wages. I mean, crazy amount, right?

7:21 So he just says, you don't owe me anything. He doesn't say, I'll put you on a payment plan like a mattress. You don't owe me anything. And then this seemingly unusual action or reaction of the man. that he goes and is angry with someone else who owes him $10 or $20.

7:47 We said, my goodness, that was the wrong thing to do. And yet our first reading reminds us that all of us who are sinners, and that's all of us, tend to cling to things like anger, grudges, non-forgiveness. So it's not that out of the question that you and I might act like that servant.

8:15 It seems that if he really knew and appreciated what had been done for him, we think, how could he have done that? I wonder if in some way that servant who was forgiven all that money,

8:36 somewhere in the back of his mind didn't believe it. It was too good to be true. He's probably going to come back and ask me for some. So I better make sure I've got some money to pay him. Or even I feel so guilty that he did that. I want to give him a little something, so let me extort this guy for the 20 bucks he owes me. It has to be something like that. Because if that had just happened to you, you just won the 10 million dollar lottery, would you like the next day call up the person who owes you five bucks and say, yeah, don't forget you still owe me the five bucks. You're going to Venmo me? What's going on? Guy's like, you just won 10 million dollars, the lottery. It must be, I think, it must be that he didn't appreciate what had been done for him.

9:26 And I'll just speak for myself here and wonder out loud if I really appreciate what God has done for me. and continues to do for me every day, every time I sin, all the time. God doesn't put me on a payment plan. He says, you don't owe me anything. Wow. That shouldn't make us stop forgiving. It should even push us beyond counting how many times. Seven, is that good? If I forgive this other guy seven times, is that going to make us even, Lord? God's like, nothing makes us even. You can't.

10:13 What if we really, really believed that God had done that and continues to do that for us? Give us so much love and mercy that we don't deserve and we can't earn, so it doesn't matter if it's three or or seven or 77 What if we believed that? I think maybe we'd be all in. We'd stop counting. If you do watch poker, where they say all in on occasion, you know that in the match leading up to that, the betting is very strategic. Well, if I bet like twice as much as he bet, then he thinks I've got this, and then maybe that'll fake him out. There's a lot of math, which is why I'm not very good at poker. also obviously don't have a poker face. I don't know if you've noticed that.

11:04 There's a lot of strategy. There's a lot of counting. But once you say this, once you say all in, that's it. There's no more counting. There's no more strategizing of how much. It seems like that's what God is saying to Peter and to Dave and to us.

11:34 Once you go all in, you stop counting how many times you helped somebody this week. you stop looking for points from God, maybe you even begin to loosen your grip a little bit on what Sirach called the wrath and anger we hold on to, the grudges, the non-forgiveness.

11:56 Can you and I live into that belief, assure one another of our faith as we gather together? Can, nourished by the Eucharist that we say amen to, can we really say amen to God's unbounded mercy and forgiveness so that we don't have to be threatened? to forgive somebody else, we'll just do it. Because we stop counting the cost. We don't look at how much smoke is coming out of the building. We just run inside. Because it's the right thing to do, given how much God has done for us.

12:39 So maybe we'll have a few more teacher's pets now. If I ask another time, we'll get a few more hands be raised and say, yeah, just like Peter, I want to give the right answer. But Jesus invites all of us to stop trying to win points, stop counting how good we've done the Christian life, and go all in. stop counting the cost and really believe how much he's done for us so that we then

Machine translated from the source