David Hwang · Jubilee Church · Published August 31, 2025
2:00 Good morning, Jubilee. Great to see you out here on this beautiful Sunday together as God's people. So let's begin our time as we do every week, as we should every week, recognizing that we are here for more than just he and me, because he's making a family of us, so we are here for he and we. So can we turn to our brothers and sisters all around us? and wish each other a good morning in Jesus' name? Can we do that, please? Ecclesia, good morning. All righty then. Here we go. Starting from this week and for the next some more weeks to come as well, I'll be needing you to put on your thinking caps. to follow me through some exercises in theological thinking. Now, this is not to say that you didn't, nor that you weren't expected to do this before.
2:59 Of course not. Because any time we talk about the Lord, you hear a sermon, you're thinking about God, this is what you're doing. You're thinking theologically, right? You're being a critical thinker. But what I am saying now is that I'll particularly need you to do so for the next three or four weeks. And this, because the messages for the next three or four weeks will be a lot more theological in nature. Or to say more plainly, the messages coming up, including the one today, are those that I hope will challenge some of the theological constructs that most likely have been actually foundational to how you might have understood Christianity.
3:42 Theological constructs concerning what Jesus did for us on the cross. You think you know, but do we? Hmm. What the nature of God's salvation is. What the nature of God's judgment is. Our understanding of biblical inspiration. Wow. All of these are huge ticket items. Foundational to our faith. Foundational to each of our theological constructs of how we understand and relate to God. So indeed, I particularly need you to come ready to listen and to think carefully through the theological matters I'll be proposing and addressing today and in the weeks to come. Amen Can I get an amen? Alright, let's go Now, please, hear and know the following qualifiers before we get started for today And the first concerns the word theology The word itself, theology, as it means what?
4:43 The study of God, ology, study of Deus, Deus, God. The study of God, theology. And I start with this because on one hand, the pursuit of a theological understanding or the pursuit of theology is kind of a ridiculous endeavor. The study of God? How can, it's like, think about this. It's like an amoeba trying to study a human? Like, I don't know if that range even does what I'm trying to say justice, but how can we study God?
5:20 So in that sense, theology itself is kind of a ridiculous thing. Quite presumptuous on our end. Maybe even almost prideful. But on the other hand, and thank God there's another hand, because God is a God of revelation. The God who reveals. We can indeed study to actually get to know God accurately. because of the revelation of the word. Because of the revelation of the word become flesh. Because we have the Bible, the scriptures. Because we have the incarnate word, Jesus. The full revelation of God himself. Hallelujah and amen. But nevertheless the pursuit of theological understanding is still a matter of our limited abilities and finite capacities. And we, I'm sure, will all admit that, that we have, or we are those of limited ability and finite capacity. This is the second qualifier, by the way. So yes, since this pursuit of theological understanding is still a matter of our limits and finite capacities, we also need to always remain humble through this process, in the sense of always being willing to listen and to consider theological perspectives other than the ones that we ascribe to, knowing that we might not be fully correct in how we see things.
6:45 Where even in the cases where we do see the Lord correctly, as the Apostle Paul stated in 1 Corinthians 13, 9-12, that we are still only those who know in part. And frankly, can only know in part because we're only just a part of the body of Christ. which then reminds us that we must indeed live out our faith, as stated in Philippians 2.12, with the attitude of working out our salvation with fear and trembling, where again, humility is key to do so. Otherwise, if you think you know everything, that is the beautiful, not beautiful, but the central fodder of pride. And once you have that pride and you think you know everything, the natural result after that is a fight. When you think you know and others don't know, and they claim to know, but you think that they don't know, guess what happens? Yeah, a fight.
7:43 However, before we go down the road then of how can we be sure of anything then? You know, if I don't really know what I'm supposed to know and other people don't really know what they're supposed to know, then how do we know anything then? Before we go down this road, or at least too far, I will say that there's no need to do this. There's no need to go down that road. For we actually can know some things as much as a thing can be known by us, limited beings. And this is again because we have the witness of the Bible. And of course, we have the witness of Jesus himself, the full revelation of the Bible in the flesh concerning who God is, as well as a witness and a testimony of the people of God throughout its history engaging with scriptures. And then after Jesus came, engaging with scriptures in view of Jesus. So when you put all of this together... we certainly can have an understanding of God that is both humble yet full of conviction to then courageously live for Jesus.
8:40 Amen. Okay? Now one final qualifier that I would like to make concerns a reality that whether you know it or not whether you have ever acknowledged it or not you are a theologian and you have a theology. Now it may be deep it may not be deep or strong or well-developed. But nevertheless, still, whatever your understanding of God is, that's theology. Whatever your understanding of God, if you have an understanding of God, that's theology in your brain. And however you got to the point of understanding God, that's a matter of theological thinking and development. So, you're a theologian. And I bring this point up to make sure that you recognize that the things that I'll be sharing about, the things that are things that surely concern you and are for you, as they're things that you've actually already invested in and are interested in.
9:41 That's why you're actually even sitting here. Or to say it another way, theology is not just for seminary students. Oh, Pastor Dave's talking about theology. Time to check out. That's for just the pastors. That's just for the leadership. That's just for the missionaries. Ah, not me. No. The answer is resoundingly no, because already you're a theologian. Already you have a theology. So we're talking about things that you're already interested in and already invested in. Hallelujah. And all the more because I hope that, as you'll see clearly today, either again or anew, your theology, your understanding of God, how and why you understand and see God the way you do, dictates and will dictate everything about how you live out your faith. Your theology informs how you live. No doubt about that.
10:33 For example, if you think that God is an all-powerful God, you will probably live boldly. Or if you think God is a very distant God, you will live with a love that's cold. Or if you think God is a taskmaster God, this is how your theological construct is. Somehow he's a taskmaster. Then next thing you know, you will live your Christian life more probably dutifully, legalistically. So yes, my brothers and sisters, I hope you see more clearly now the great value making sure that we are always carefully considering how we see and understand God, and therefore the importance of each of us following along through the messages that I'll be sharing in this theological series that we're starting today, carefully, humbly, but also courageously. Amen. And by the way, don't be too intimidated by what I presented because we're not going to get like super geeky about everything, okay?
11:34 Though we will go kind of deeper. Good. Okay then, for us today, I'd like to start our foray into theology by considering the theological position that is called penal substitution. Penal substitution Anybody hear of this? Penal substitution? Okay, not many Oh, a few, okay, good So then, what is this about? Penal substitution Well, I would say that this is the theological position That most, if not all of us Are actually familiar with here As well as the theological position that most If not all of us actually ascribe to Whether we did so intentionally or not And I say this because this position, penal substitution position, is the position that has dominated the theological position of the church since the time of the Reformation. So back in the 1500s, the 16th century, this became the dominant position of the church, penal substitution.
12:36 And therefore, it has its effect to this day without a doubt, where today, in fact, it's still the dominant position of the church. Now, penal substitution's view has to do with our understanding of what Jesus did for us on the cross. Where in short, according to this view, Jesus went to the cross to take upon himself the penalty that we deserve for our sin, and this as our substitute. Penalty, substitute, penal substitution. where this act then satisfied God's holy justice, thereby making a way where sinners can now be forgiven of all their sins by grace through faith in Jesus. And this, without compromising this forgiveness of God, without compromising the holy righteousness of God because the price of sin had been paid by Jesus, the substitute.
13:34 Now the biblical basis of this view comes from passages like 2 Corinthians 5.21 that states that God made him who had no sin to become sin for us, that in him we might become the righteousness of God. Galatians 3.13, Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us. Romans 8.3, for what the law was powerless to do because it was weakened by the flesh, God did by sending his own son in the likeness of sinful flesh to be a son offering, and so he condemned sin in the flesh. I would say, doesn't this all sound familiar? It should. Because there are countless songs that we sing about this. Jesus, you died for me, paid my price of sin for me, took on my sin. He who had no sin became sin for me. And God, you forgave me. because of Jesus. Countless sermons being preached about all of this. And again, so yes, this is a familiar position I think to all of us.
14:31 And again, the reason why is because it's been the main and dominant theological understanding of Jesus' work on the cross. due to the theological influence of the Reformers, like Martin Luther and John Calvin, when they protested against the Catholic Church, and then they broke off in the Protestant Reformation, as the leaders of this Reformation, their theological thinking and influence was huge. Rightly so.
14:59 And that until this time. however however before this view there was actually another view that dominated the theological understanding of the church's understanding of why Jesus went to the cross
15:23 Did you know that? Well, now you do. Before the Reformation, there was actually another view that dominated the theological understanding of the church's understanding of why Jesus went to the cross. A different theological position that could even be argued as the church's original understanding of Jesus on the cross. For this view was the one held by all the early church fathers, starting from the second century. So when we talk about the second century, we're talking about almost just like a hundred years after Jesus literally lived himself. We're talking about early church fathers like Irenaeus and Origen. They wrote prolifically about theology. We have those writings. As well as the later early church fathers like Athanasius and Augustine, St. Augustine as we know him as, in the third and fourth centuries. Lots of writing and they all hold to this position, this theological position of Jesus on the cross called Christus Victor.
16:20 Christus Victor. Now in this position, as the name implies, the focus of Jesus' work on the cross is about the victory that it won. Thus, Christus Victor, or Christ the victor. Where the emphasis in this view is on the fact that all of humanity and the world itself is enslaved and in bondage and oppressed by the power that Satan held over us and the world due to sin. Therefore, Jesus moved to break the hold by defeating Satan through his greater power of perfect love that still wanted to save us even though we were still sinners and his enemies.
17:06 Okay? So then in this view, the cross is viewed much more as a battlefield versus the courtroom of the penal substitution view. Where in the penal substitution view, the cross is like a courtroom. Like, God is a judge. You got the sinner. Jesus said, I'll pay for the sinner. He said, fine, you're free. You, punishment, you know, and then guilty. Like, that kind of idea is a penal substitution idea. Or the view of the cross in the penal substitution idea. Where in the Christus Victor point of view, the cross is just a battlefield, cosmic battlefield. Kind of like simply said, good versus evil. Jesus versus Satan. That's the primary emphasis in this view. Now the biblical basis of this view comes from passages like Colossians 2.15. Having disarmed the powers and authorities, he, Jesus, made a public spectacle of them, triumphing over them by the cross.
18:03 1 Corinthians 15.54-57. Death has been swallowed up in victory. Where, O death, is your victory? Where, O death, is your sting? The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. But thanks be to God, he gives us victory through our Lord Jesus Christ. Hebrews 2, 14-15. Since the children have flesh and blood, he too shared in their humanity, so that by his death he might break the power of him who holds the power of death, that is, the devil, and free those who all their lives were held in slavery by their fear of death. Okay? Now, similar to the penal substitution view, I would say that this view, though you might not have known the theological term for it, Christus Victor, is still a position that you and I are probably not unfamiliar with, right? I mean, we've heard this as well. That through Jesus, he, through his love, he defeated the enemy.
18:55 He conquered the enemy. He broke the chains of sin and death through his love displayed on the cross to give us victory, right? So it's not unfamiliar as well. Now, before we go any further, let me pause again here for a moment to make another qualification. And that is to mention that we have to recognize that theology is not necessarily truth. Okay?
19:20 We have to pause and remember that theology is not necessarily truth. For theology is a construct of understanding developed by people. And of course, through their interpretation of the scriptures and in view of Jesus. So it's truthful. Theology can be truthful. It's moving towards truth.
19:45 But it's still an interpretation that's without a doubt very much influenced by both personal and societal contexts. That's why different people have different views of God. because their personhood and greater context inform them to lean one way or another. That if you are a thinker, you kind of lean towards one kind of theology. If you are a feeler, you lean towards another kind of theology of expressing and understanding God. If you are a spiritual person, again, they have another stream of theology. And then your personality is, I don't know, loud and proud or quiet and quirky, whatever it is, all that starts to affect how we see and understand God, not to mention a greater context. If you grew up in a war, you will have a different theology than someone who grew up in peacetime.
20:45 If you grew up in riches versus poverty, it'll be different. Your context will certainly influence the construct of your development of understanding concerning God. okay which is frankly why what makes theology so beautiful and worthy to study at the end of the day it's a bunch of testimonies of how different people at different times got to know God but we have to know that it is a matter of truthful, moving towards truth but interpretations constructs of understanding developed by people in their context That's why Karl Barth, famous theologian, said, you have to have the Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other. Because theology speaks of relevance.
21:38 Theology speaks of the context. Or it should be relevant to the context, rather. Okay? Where there are many times, since theological positions are matters more of interpretation, per se, than actual truth, besides those tenets of truth that have been established as core to the Christian faith. And we have that from the Apostles' Creed. Even before, like, there was a lot of heresy and false teaching, so the church leaders got together, and we have what was called the Council of Nicaea, the Council of Chalcedonia. They formalized these creeds, but even before that was the Apostles' Creed in its early forms that the church has been reciting. If you believe that, then there we go. We're good. This is what is core to Christianity, truth. So this, if you ascribe to it, whether you call yourself a Protestant Christian or even a Catholic Christian, they recite the Apostles' Creed, they believe in that, boom, that's how things are defined, right?
22:36 Those are the tenets of faith that have been established as truth in our faith. But besides these tenets of faith, I believe that most different theological views can and should be reconciled by seeing them as matters of both and rather than either or. A lot of times we want to be like right or something like that, correct. So we're like, it's either this or wrong. No, no. That's too elementary and too simplified. We're reducing too many important things. Most times, most theologies actually can be both and. For example, predestination versus free will. Predestination. God has determined everything. He knows everything, controls everything, determined everything. Undergirding that is the desire to honor God's sovereignty, by the way. The other side is free will.
23:30 Because God loves us and there's no compulsion in love. Therefore, he freely freed us to make whatever choice we want. Completely free. God determines nothing. Two different theological streams that seem opposite, but they can actually be reconciled. Why? because yes, in the cosmic view, because he's God, he probably does know everything. And in that sense, he's in control. But on the ground level, to you and I, we don't know what God's thinking, so it is free will. Did God tell me to pick up this tissue or this towel and do this? I don't think so. So, hey, hey, hey, a little bit of both and. A little bit of both and here.
24:08 But some differing theological positions actually can't be reconciled that easily, like spiritual gifts. I believe that there are denominations that believe that no more spiritual gifts, no more prophecy, no more visions, no more miracles. They ceased to be needed. Cessationists. That's what they say. Other side says, hey, man, I'm experiencing miracles every day. What are you talking about? Speaking in tongues and prophetic visions and declarations. Now, that can't really be reconciled that easily because it's like so opposite. Like how do we do? You know, how do we reconcile that one? Likewise, even women in leadership. It's pretty plain. I don't believe women should be teaching the word at church. We believe that that's not true. We believe that God made us in his image, male and female. Some churches go this way.
24:59 Some churches go that way. We obviously, we honor the image of God, male and female together here. here. But it's clear. How do you reconcile there's no real middle ground when it's unbiblical for women to preach and teach, meaning it's a sin, like murder, I don't know, or is it not? And then how do you reconcile that? There's no middle ground for that. It's really hard to, again, some theological streams are not as easy, easily both end.
25:28 Therefore, again, humility is key in the pursuit of growing in the true knowledge of God, or else you'll grow prideful and end up fighting. And how much of that do we see? in this world. Outside the core tenets of faith, that's what we kind of quote-unquote would fight for, stand up for. Outside of that, think we need to listen to each other a little bit more, more, right? However, when we exercise a humility or even when we exercise a humility needed to see our various theological positions not necessarily as truth, as well as considering the possibility of different theologies as a matter of both and, even when we are humble and everything can be both and, there's still the issue of the implications in a theological position that will affect how we live out our faith. For again, theology is not just a thought exercise, but a matter of how we ultimately discern how we are to live out our faith.
26:28 Yes, my brothers and sisters, without a doubt, theology is important because theology informs our activity. What we believe directly influences how we live. For example, if you really believe in predestination, it could be both and, free will, but I really believe in predestination. Go to the ultimate extreme. That's why those who are uber predeterminists, they don't do any missions. No missions, no outreach. They're like, why? What's the point? God already predetermined who's saved and who's not saved. Why do outreach? See? The other side, free will. It could be both and, I guess, but I lean towards free will. but you take that to the ultimate extreme that's where you ever hear the word lose your salvation because of your free will you could choose and at the end not choose God and therefore lose your salvation or at the very least, live very legalistically because your free will matters so much.
27:29 Again, same with gifts. If you believe in gifts, then you'll practice them. If you don't, you won't. You'll have women leadership. See how theology affects, informs our activity. It influences directly how we live. Therefore, it's very important that we sharpen and continue to pursue the sharpening of our understanding of God so that at the end of the day, our life will reflect the ultimate goal of all theology. And what is that? What's the ultimate goal of all theology? Well, it's simple. That our life will reflect as best as it can Jesus. For again, he's the fullest revelation of who God truly is and what the Lord is truly all about. Hallelujah. Okay? So then, how shall we apply what was just mentioned? By the way, are you guys warm? Thank you.
28:20 Can we, Amu, can you ask someone, our staff, if she can come out and just adjust? Yeah, you know, I know I have a jacket on, so I'm a little bit warmer than you, but I feel like it's heating up a little bit. Yeah, baby, I'm heating up. Hopefully, I'm on fire. Where am I here? Where was I? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So then, how can we apply all that was just mentioned about the important role that theology actually plays in our life concerning the theologies that we are talking about today, penal substitution versus Christus Victor? How can we go ahead and apply what we just said to these two things? Well, I would say that, firstly, that in a very general way, these two views can be a case of both and. as they do not have to be contradictory but they can be complementary.
29:19 For the Christus victor view can be seen as a view that explains what Jesus accomplished through a sacrifice on the cross. What is that? Victory over Satan by the power of his love. To then set free all those willing to be set free by grace through faith in him. Where the penal substitution view can be viewed as a position that complements the Christus victor view by explaining how Jesus accomplished the victory. In his love, by specifically taking on the fullness of sin himself and therefore satisfying the needed judgment of God. So again, these two views do not have to be a matter of either or, for a case can be made for these two views to be those that work together. Biblically, it's true. There's evidence of both in the Bible, both positions. rationally oh yeah it makes sense Christus victor is what Jesus did victory penal substitution is how he got the victory penal substitute right and even contextually you can understand why maybe the early church fathers as they were still going through Christian persecution under Rome would think more of victory right defeating the powers that be where for the reformers, they were just coming out of the medieval times under the Catholic Church.
30:44 The sparks of the enlightenment and reason were starting to fire up. I can understand why they thought more legally to justify their position. Right? You can see that, how it all works out. However, as it's said, you notice a key word in my sermon so far is however. However, listen. However, as it's said, the devil's in the details. And in this case, it may be true. for when you get down to some of the details of each of these views
31:21 this is where I would then start feeling the need to argue that the Christus Victor view may be the position that accurately represents Jesus as compared to the penal substitution view. And the reason for this... in short is this. It's because of the way that these two positions differ. in how they explain the judgment of God. The reason why I lean towards Christus Victor rather than penal substitution is the detail of how these two positions in the detail of explaining how the judgment of God works. For the Christus Victor view presents God's judgment purely in terms of grace, but the penal substitution view presents God's judgment more as a matter of needed retribution, of needed payment.
32:14 So let's take the next step together of pressing deeper into theological thinking. Let's keep going as I move now to explain more of what I just talked about. Now, and again, in general, these two, in general, in the general view, these two views do seem to complement each other very well. On the cross, Jesus took the fullness of sin, whereby this act of perfect love, Jesus defeated Satan, thereby breaking his hold over all humanity. We're now simply by grace through faith in him. All who believe in him and receive him as Savior and Lord can now be forgiven of all their sins and even inherit eternal life. Amen and hallelujah. So again, on this level, on this general level, stated in these terms, I would say that there's nothing really incorrect about combining these two views. on that general level stated in the terms that I just shared. However, okay, the point where the room begins to open up to cause us to start to wonder and to even start contending has to do with the following question.
33:18 Ready? When Jesus was on the cross, how was the judgment of God placed on Jesus? Or more pointedly stated, when Jesus hung on that cross, did God the Father actually himself inflict his wrath on Jesus? Is that what happened? When Jesus was on the cross, God the Father who was loving Father as soon as Jesus became sin on that cross the look in his eyes changed. I don't know. Now the wrath. Now your sin. I hate sin. And sin's on you, Jesus. So here it is, the wrath and judgment.
34:11 My wrath. how was the judgment of God placed on Jesus? It's a huge question. Again, stated frankly, did God the Father actually himself inflict wrath on Jesus as the righteous and holy one? And frankly, we must really press to come to as intentional and as informed of an understanding of this question. For of all the details in either of these theological streams and many other streams actually included, of all those details, this one, about how God's judgment was executed, will surely, surely determine how much, will determine much of how we see God.
35:07 And therefore, it will also determine much of how we live out our Christian life as a result thereof. For in or due to the penal substitution view, if we see God the Father as the one who's actually and actively inflicting himself, his judgment on Jesus, which is what that position holds to. That God the Father is the one who is actually and actively inflicting himself, his judgment. Because he's the holy one. He's the only one who can cast judgment. Therefore, he's the one doing this.
35:43 Yes, if we see God the Father as the one who does this, despite the fact that there's still the message of love and grace in this view, for sinners are set free by Jesus' love. Jesus, we did nothing. Jesus did this for us. It's a grace to us, extended to us, for the forgiveness of our sins. So, those who subscribe to this, and even they think that God's wrath is on Jesus, they still have a sense of grace and love, the grace and love of God. Nevertheless, it still becomes hard to, if you have this view, to disassociate the notion that number one, God's love is actually a little more conditional than graceful. For there was still a matter of a payment, right? Hmm, hmm, let me think about that. It's kind of a little eye for an eye, isn't it? it's like the merciful king who had a servant with a lot of debt forgiveness is just you're forgiven but no someone else came and said I'll pay that debt okay I take that debt you're forgiven but you're in trouble hmm hmm makes you wonder is that really mercy and grace number one another theological challenge then Again, because these are just theological constructs.
37:05 They're not true, so we've got to think these through, right? Also, if you ascribe to this view of God's judgment then you'll see probably that god is more a legal judge than a loving father. It can easily happen. More transactional than relational. Yeah, you wanted a relationship with me, but before we can finally come together in our relationship there had to be a transaction first. In the name of holiness, but there had to to be an exchange, a transaction. So is it really relational? You know, like, is this really graceful? Is this really relational? And perhaps worst of all implications is this, that if you see God as the one who gives wrath, then you know the unsaid implication now said is that God is the one who is capable of violence to punish.
37:58 God is the one capable of violence to punish. Because the cross was quite violent. okay where if we view the cross more from the Christus Victor view since the cross is seen as the place of a battle towards victory over Satan rather than place of a legal transaction and by the way just a quick aside those who theologians argue is that transaction was that a payment to God the Father? Was that a payment to Satan? hmm that's another little digression anyway yes but in the Christus Victor view, since the cross is seen as a place of more of a battle towards victory over Satan than a place of legal transaction, then God is seen only as a rescuer and deliverer. For the cross then is simply the display of the greater power of his perfect love greater than the power of Satan's sin and death.
38:53 There was a battle and the perfect loved one, the Lord Jesus, where God's wrath then is satisfied not by some payment, but simply through the conquering of Satan. The conquering of Satan was a retribution. The defeat of Satan was payment enough. Where then, as the victor,
39:25 God's forgiveness for us then is a forgiveness extended to us without any conditions, with no strings attached, truly all by grace. because we were a sin. No payment needed. He just came with his greater love, sacrificing, but love, broke, changed the sin of death, conquered Satan, and said, now you're free. Wow. We were locked up where we deserve to be, but now we're free. Grace.
39:56 And all the, this is all about grace. All the more in this view that the forgiveness of God being this kind of grace just mentioned without strings, without conditions, because also in this view, even God's judgment on Satan is something that God does not do himself. But it's something that Satan does to himself.
40:25 Did you get that? Because it's really all by grace because in this view, the judgment of God, the war on Satan, right? Good versus evil. It's actually not a battle or a judgment or a violent punishment on Satan that God does to him, but what Satan does to himself. So, please, keep keeping up with me as I now explain this.
40:55 For in the Christus Victor view of the judgment of God, God's judgment, is the idea that God's judgment is actually not of him ever actively moving to punish. Ever. Even Satan. but the Lord simply removing his presence. This is the Christus Victor view of the judgment of God. Not God actively moving against, but removing his presence. For simply stated, when God withdraws his presence of his gracious life and protection, his sustaining goodness and truth, all that is of corrupt and condemning sin is then free to rush in with all his destructive deathly consequences okay get that?
41:56 so we think judgment attack no God actually removes and then the judgment compounds on itself and we know that this view of God's judgment is not just some wishful theological thinking I wish God's judgment was like this so I'll make it like that that's what it is God's judgment is what I think removing no this is not true because there are many passages, many, many passages in the Bible that describe the judgment of God this way as a matter of the removal of or from his presence. In the Old Testament, the prime example is Adam and Eve. You will surely die if you disobey me. They disobeyed. And what happened? There was a removal from East of Eden, as they say, away, farther away from God. And we see that over and over again in the New Testament as well.
42:51 In Romans chapter 1, the Lord said, I pleaded with you to listen, but you would not listen. You didn't want to listen. So I gave you over to what you wanted. The shameful lust and deceits of your flesh and of this world. And then, of course, in the book of Revelation, anytime we hear about or see the metaphors of judgment, we actually see an implosion of sin. Satan devouring Satan, in a sense. evil being evil, on evil. where when Jesus shows up, there's no violence. He just shows up and everything is silenced.
43:37 Hallelujah. But I will say, herein lies the tension. For there are many other passages in the Bible that seem to depict God himself moving in violence against people. That's the tension. starting from the Israelites and their conquest, to then, of course, that's through people, but then what about the flood? What about the plagues? Hmm.
44:11 And this is why we have more messages coming up in this series, To help us to continue to grapple with this very important topic. in view of these difficult texts, frankly speaking. but for us now the reason I can confidently say that God is not at all violent and this even in his judgment that it is a matter of removal more than attack much more is because of the witness of Jesus but when we see Jesus the full revelation of God what do we see? we see one who a smoldering wick he did not snuff out a bruised reed he did not break like a sheep silent before its shearers went to sacrifice by the way this is next week's message we're going to talk about Jesus more but again for us this week at the very least, since we know that Jesus is indeed... the full revelation of God we can start to grow our confidence in what our passage we finally get to our passage for today what our passage for today has to say 1 John 1.5 God is light and in Him there is no darkness at all.
45:17 where this includes any idea idea, our idea of a holy judgment, human ideas of holy judgment where God himself moves in violence. And again, proved by Jesus himself. He was not violent at all. that's why this passage actually said this is the message we have heard from him Jesus God is light and there is no darkness in him at all and I don't know about you but do you really need theological training and understanding to know that violence is of darkness is violence of light hmm but again, all the more secured by Jesus and the life he lived. So, so it's because of this perspective that I argue that we are to understand then that what happened on the cross from the Christus Victor perspective. is how we might want to really consider how we understand the cross, which means that, first of all, we have to, again, align and understand and agree with that God's judgment is simply the natural result of being separated from God.
46:32 This is God's judgment. The natural result of being separated from God. The source of all life and truth and goodness. I've shared this many times. If God is the source of life, and we are with God, we have what God has, which is life. But if we don't reject God, we don't have what? Life. If we don't have life, what do we have left? Where there's no life, there's death. The more farther we go from the orbit of God, the farther and farther we get away from life, which is closer and closer to death. The removal of this, that's the judgment of God. We have to first align there. Where then the understanding of retribution or the payment for our sins in this view is not the payment made by Jesus on the cross. Whew. Whoa there. whoa there yeah what was just said in this understanding of Christus Victor the retribution or the payment for our sin in this view is not a payment made by Jesus on the cross but rather it's us simply paying ourselves price of our own choice to now be under the dominion of Satan's rule of destruction towards death.
47:53 That when we disobeyed, we made that payment and now we're under death and we started dying. That's why if you look at Genesis chapter 5, you have this litany of like this person married this person and they had these children and then he died. And then he died. And then he died. He died. He died. He died. Who's paying the price there? It's us. We're taking on the consequence of our sin in many places. But because of God's great love and grace, he did not fully remove humanity from his presence. Lest we would not have only physically died, we would have spiritually died in the fullest way. But because of his great love and grace, he did not fully remove humanity from his presence, sparing us from this full reality of being separated from God. For he himself committed to saving us from our bondage and death. Genesis 3.15, I will put an enmity between the serpent and the woman's child. He will crush your head, you will strike his heel. Already, the commitment was made, and therefore, because that commitment, that promise was made.
48:54 There was this holding period of the consequences of sin still being paid by us, but still the Lord sparing us the full wrath of that, the full result of that. Therefore, when Jesus, the Son of God, God the Son, went to the cross, it again, it wasn't to pay for our sins per se, but rather, though he himself had no sin, he still willingly and fully entered into all that is sin. willingly entered into the fullness of evil and all that Satan could unleash on him Satan unleashed that violence on him when he went to the cross. Satan attacked not God the full effect of sin Satan put it on Jesus not God the Father Therefore the cry of Jesus on the cross was of being forsaken. right?
49:46 not of God the Father attacking him My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? Why have you removed your presence from me? Not, Father, that hurts. You used to love me, but now you're stabbing my hands. That wasn't Jesus Christ. Why have you removed your presence from me? Yes, judgment of God. God's presence removed so that Jesus can fully take on all of sin in this way, the full effect of sin, rather, so Satan can have the fullness of his way with Jesus. where Jesus could then conquer Satan and all that is of Satan. And this, again, by the greater power of his perfect love. Satan thought he got him, but actually perfect love is greater than the perfect love to even love his enemies. Us, sinners in bondage, that only deserved our due consequences that we were already under, that in this perfect love is greater than the power of Satan.
50:45 Therefore, making the cross not a matter of any retribution or payment. but a move of restoration simply by conquering Satan where then now truly by grace through faith in Christ's victory over Satan. through the great power of his love for us we can now be set free to be restored unto God and to one another so we're under the payment we made the payment it would have been cashed out in full if it wasn't for God's grace and presence to hold us in because he made a promise that he won't leave us. so that when he came, he went on the cross to take on, God's presence was moved, so all of Satan's, everything can go upon Jesus, became no sin, who had no sin, but the power of Jesus' perfect love was greater than that of evil, breaking the hold of Satan.
51:39 Christ rises as the victor. and says all of you who deserve where you're at shackles be off come out hallelujah this is freedom. This is forgiveness. Without condition, this is grace without merit. Not to mention, the victory on the cross also marked the final and just condemnation of Satan. For in God's wisdom, the opportunity given to Satan to kill the Son of God. and there's, by the way, you know that there's parables about this when the Son is sent and the vineyard, anyway from God's wisdom, the opportunity given to Satan to kill the Son of God by just the removal of his presence, not by Jesus' guilt was an opportunity that Satan's nature of evil and death could not resist.
52:43 what a chance so he went full force on Jesus, but in doing so as it's been accurately said when death stung Jesus it stung itself for when Satan crucified Jesus Satan ended up finally and fully incriminating and condemning himself for he killed an innocent one he murdered the innocent one before then he killed but he killed the guilty Thank you. at the garden there was only a temptation no death but here the opportunity was too ripe and he jumped all over Jesus not only to have the chains of sin broken and defeated by Jesus' greater perfect love but he incriminated and condemned himself for murdering the innocent one for murdering the innocent that's why we hear in the murder of Cain and Abel I hear the blood of the innocent from the ground.
53:51 Right? I don't know if you know that story, but we already see the foreshadowing of these things. Okay. Woo! Wow. Did you get all that? I do hope so. But even if not, you have this recording that will be on YouTube and our podcast and many, many, many other sources online about the comparison between the crisis victim and the penal substitution thing that you can do research on your own. Please do so. Don't let me carry the only burden of your theological understanding. I'm happy to share it. So please study as much as you can to become as clear as you can be on this matter. For my brothers and sisters, there's no doubt that the matter of salvation and atonement is one that is still cosmically mysterious. Gosh, how can Amoeba is trying to understand humanity. What is going on in this cosmic realm of the Lord and Satan and what's going on? right? And therefore, I do not claim to say that all that I mentioned is for sure the right angle to take. 100% concerning Jesus' work on the cross, many have argued throughout the history of the church, right? But I still do hope that from what I shared, all that I shared, that all of us are at the very least challenged to think more carefully and courageously through our faith. For again, how we understand God is how we will live for God.
55:08 We're in view of our topic for today, the bottom line. here's the bottom line in non-theological terms ready? If you can be as honest as you can with yourself about God, are you or have you ever been afraid of him? here's the bottom line non-theologically in your relationship with God are you or have you ever been afraid of him?
55:34 that he will punish you That if you do wrong, he's going to come and get you with with the lightning bolt up your you know what. Your foot. What were you thinking? I'm just kidding. Well, if you answered yes, honestly, part of the reason why I did so is simply because you know you're guilty. So there's a sense of punishment any time you're guilty. But I'm also sure that mixing there somewhere is also the view that God is the one who can and does punish, guaranteed. Your understanding of God in there somewhere, you see God as the one who can and does punish.
56:18 And professionally as a pastor, I've witnessed this a lot. A lot. So many times I talk to people and they tell me, is God doing this to me? God must be giving me this kind of, God did this. I did this wrong. So many times. So often. and why have so many and do so many end up thinking and feeling this way afraid of God and his punishment and this even though they still these are people that still 100% believe that God is a God of grace and love oh I still know he loved me so much and gave me grace to forgive my sins there's still that but still the lingering cloud is the cloud of judgment and the wrath of God Jonathan Edwards sinners in the hands of an angry God right There's literally a sermon title, Puritan Preacher, like that. Well, my argument for us today is that a big part of this can be attributed to the theological understanding comes from one aspect of the penal substitution position that paints God as the one whose wrath needs to be satisfied.
57:20 before anything and all else. And more specifically, that he was the one who needed to actively inflict this judgment on Jesus. whether you thought it intentionally or not this is there however if we can see God differently and we can and this again, not because it's so convenient for us to do so, because we have biblical witness for this we have the testimony of the early church all the way up to the 1500s but especially in the witness of Jesus whereby from this theological understanding of God that's been called Christus Victor we can now separate any sense of violence away from God to see him instead as one who's only full of grace and love where strictly by this grace and love, even by just his grace and love, he was able to conquer all that is obscene. And to see all of this without compromising the gravity and the cost of sin.
58:15 A lot of people who argue against Christus Victor is like, where's the gravity of sin then? Well, the gravity of sin is that we were dead in our trespasses already. The consequence was there and Jesus had to die on the cross to have victory over Satan and sin. That's pretty grave. where then by this understanding of God we can have, I pray and trust and I hope. a present movement towards a renewed relationship and a hunger for the Lord without any fear of punishment without any dread of lightning bolts of plagues, of disease of violence to you
59:03 For we know that even in the greatest moment of God's clash with sin and Satan, he did so only with grace and love, without any violence. And in such that we will be those who are truly able to embrace and live as as stated in 1 John 4, 18 a little bit later there is no fear in love there is no fear in love but perfect love drives out fear because fear has to do with punishment
59:32 The one who fears is not made perfect in love. and we do not have to fear for as our passage states this is the message that Jesus gave to us God is light and in him there is no darkness at all hallelujah my brothers and sisters it's sad but true but there's so much violence in this world that's been done to one another and and has been done in Jesus name in the name of Jesus who died for us on the cross believe in Jesus Spanish Inquisition torture Jesus is the Lord see it he loves you what? even to this day if you feel right and convicted about your faith you will fight for it from divisions in the church to literal fights frankly again the justification to be able to do so is rooted in the understanding of a God who can be violent.
1:00:33 therefore if I'm right I can be violent if I'm right I'm going to be violent don't push me I'll give you grace until that point, and then it's on. like Donkey Kong I'll get you but I pray that through the theological perspectives and arguments shared today if we can see and accept that the Christus Victor understanding of Jesus on the cross or more specifically the Christus Victor view of God that his judgment is passive rather than active as in the penal substitution view we'll be able to start seeing that the character of our Lord is indeed of non-violence and this even in the darkest times hardest moments to then allow this understanding God to start informing how we live for God. when you realize God is not violent, he's never done no violence how are we going to live oh sorry that was loud it will change the way we live it will change the way we interact with each other, even and especially when we're right oh boy amen, now again okay thank you for being we're wrapping up literally I got a paragraph and then we're done not even a paragraph sentences there's still a lot to unpack and address here if we're to thoroughly think through this position especially the addressing of the seeming violence of God in the Old Testament okay we're going to talk about this so we have to really keep our theological thinking caps on tight strapped on alright but for us today I really do hope and pray that we have been at least challenge to rethink any sort of violence in God's name. Amen.
1:02:17 By the way, this journey that I'm calling us to is is a journey that I myself have been on I grew up in the same kind of world that you did. in the same theological understandings implied and intentional I've preached this many times this way but over the years something didn't make sense this idea of a violent judging God when you cross him and I still don't have it all figured out, because when you look at the Bible, it's hard, there's some hard passages, and I promise you, one thing I can guarantee, is that I won't know what I'm talking about, a lot of the times, when we start talking about this, because theologians have argued about this, I'm not going to give you, all right, what I'm trying to say is, I'm not going to give you a perfectly clear cut, wow, this is right now, like it's going to be muddy, it's going to be a little bit muddy,
1:03:03 so therefore, I have, I have, not the word regret I questioned whether I should move into this kind of sermon series many times because I don't think I was ready I don't think I'm ready I'm not really ready actually in like the nice fully ready way that's true but at this point I think that I I think I have garnered enough information as well as conviction to again at least get us thinking more intentionally about this most important topic of how we see God. as one capable of violence or not. For this will very much inform how we live for God. Can I get an amen? Amen. Our title for today is what you see then. Oh, yes. Yes.
1:03:56 would you not choose this if you could would you not choose this if you could in your soul come on victory without violence and we don't have to wonder but I believe Jesus has done for us and yeah I think Jesus is the model of this the proof of this and thus the conviction enough to share this with us here today. hallelujah, amen let's go before the Lord right now can we take this moment to bow our hearts bow our minds, bow our bodies even why not and realize you're a theologian. Realize that you have developed an understanding of God. Some of it deep and true.
1:04:49 Even in that place, remain humble because it's a product of our constructs of context, personal, societal. Thank the Lord for the tenets of faith that's been secured by the witness of the church that we can still have conviction, but still how you thought about God has shaped so much of how you live for God no doubt about it and one big issue is this understanding of a judging violent God so let's go before the Lord in view of Jesus and the cross and let's try to reconcile this at least one degree one step because the witness of Jesus indeed says there is victory without violence only in grace and love And in this place, if you've ever thought that God is out to get you, God is out to get me he's going to punish me I'm going to get consequences because of this leprosy is coming to me blindness is coming to me because God's not happy I pray that you can reconcile this too on the cross as they say May the lies of the enemy be silenced in this place.
1:06:00 you Satan are the one who comes to steal kill and destroy not the Lord I pray that there will be healing let's pray together church hallelujah Lord Jesus, without repeating everything because we can't repeat everything at this point I just want to say, Lord, I pray more of your presence. more of your presence in each of our lives and that will make it clear when you come closer there's going to be greater life and greater freedom greater joy, greater kindness, greater compassion greater empathy, less of hate less of division, less of violence because you are light and in you there's no darkness at all and we see this most clearly in the cross we see it most clearly in you Jesus so Lord move us to a place where we're at individually we're all in different places but move us closer to what's really of you and Lord I do pray especially for those who have ever thought of you as one violent I rebuke that thought in Jesus name because Lord, you died for us. Why would you want to punish us you took on all that attack so that we can be set free so Jesus I pray you move us to a place where we really love you and we really want to run hard towards you because we are really not afraid of you.
1:07:49 Help us, Lord Jesus. In your name we pray all these things. Your sons and daughters said together, let it be so. Amen. Church, at this time, let's continue to worship our Lord.
Machine translated from the source