Chris Alar · National Shrine of The Divine Mercy · Published September 22, 2026
0:03 Find anywhere in the Bible where it says Mary had other children. It doesn't. Nowhere in the Bible does it say Mary had other children. It says in the Bible that Jesus had brothers and sisters. Here we just read his brothers. The Hebrew word for brothers is ah. A-H in the Hebrew. and adelphos in the Greek, which can mean simply a near relative or a close relative or a stepbrother or a cousin. So brothers as kin is throughout in ancient Hebrew, Aramaic, the biblical Greek, and that being Adelphoi, refers again to cousins, nephews, extended kin as brothers, as was seen with Abraham and his nephew Lot, who is also referred to in another part of Genesis as his brother. Well, wait a minute. It says Jesus was Mary's firstborn, so their father it says mary had other children firstborn as we hear in luke 2 under the mosaic law you can go back to exodus 2 i'm sorry exodus 13 verse 2 firstborn denoted the child who opened the womb and carried specific legal consecration regardless if there were other siblings who came after. They were the firstborn, whether there was another or not. They opened the womb. We know the care at the cross in the Gospel of John,
2:08 where Jesus entrusts Mary to the care of the apostle John, who was, we know, not Jesus's brother. And under Jewish law and custom, this would not have occurred if Jesus had any, any living biological brothers. Now, in several places, the Bible says it, though, he had brothers. These are most likely Jesus's relatives and not the children of Mary, okay? Now, in 1 Chronicles 23, brothers is called a related cousin. In Deuteronomy 23, verse 7, a remote kinsman. in Genesis 13 verse 8 an uncle or a nephew or men bound by covenant in 2 Samuel 1 or 1 Samuel 18.
3:00 I mentioned Lot is called Abraham's brother in Genesis 14 14 but then Lot is called his nephew you in Genesis 11 27. Never ever ever are we to say that is automatic because we read something in the English and then we definitively determine what it means. It's the whole reason we have a church. Okay brother is also described of biologically unrelated people in the new covenant. Did you know this? Brothers are used for unrelated people. Romans 8 29 says, for those he foreknew, he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his son, so that he might be the firstborn among many brothers.
3:56 All right, Hebrews chapter 2 verse 11 says, he who consecrates and those who are being consecrated all have one origin. Therefore, he is not ashamed to call them brothers. Those aren't his biological siblings. Colossians chapter 1 verse 2 says, to the saints and faithful brethren in Christ at Colossae, Colossae, grace and peace. So I could go on and on. Now here, Jesus says, who are my brothers? Who is my mother? Well, those who do the will of God. So he did not undermine his mother here. Oh, she's just another one of many. She was his natural mother, but became the mother of God by doing his will.
4:54 Fiat. She is now his mother by nature and by grace, by doing the will of God. One who does the will of my father is my brother, my sister, and my mother. This means obedience to the father creates relationships greater than natural family bonds. There's no discrediting of the Blessed Virgin here. Jesus's spiritual brothers and sisters are the adopted children of God. This is why we have infant baptism. Child is a member of the family the day they are born. They don't wait for the child to become 18 to determine if they want to be a member of the family. Nobody does that. That's why we don't wait to baptize them to 18 to see if they decide they want to be baptized.
5:50 baptized baptism as an infant brings him into the family of god as that little baby born in your family became a member of your family at birth those who have been baptized enter into a new family a family of the saints you know um an early martyr said a christian's only relatives are the saints. Doesn't say siblings. Jesus changes the order of relationships and shows true kinship here is not just flesh and blood. It's not that he's again discrediting Mary. When we acknowledge God as our father, his family becomes our family. Jesus is putting the work of redemption ahead of even natural family relationships, even more than your blood. This is why Jesus said, I will come and I will, mother will be against daughter, father will be against son, mother-in-law against daughter-in-law, brother against sister. I have come to cause division. Now, it doesn't mean that you are to detest or hate them. In the original language, when Jesus says, unless you hate your mother and your brother and your father and your sister, you cannot be my disciple. Hate doesn't mean detest or despise. It means to love less. We have to love God more than even our blood.
7:19 And that's why I always say, God rest the souls of my mom and dad. But when I became a priest, my mom cried for three days. My dad said I'd never make it as a priest. The family was disowning me. my cousin removed me from Facebook. It was a huge scandal. But I said, you know, if I have to lose all of my family over this, I hope not. Please, Lord, don't let that happen. But I was willing to make that choice, that I have to choose God even ahead of my blood. And this is why people say, I don't care what the church teaches, I'm going to my cousin's same sexual marriage, even though it's not a marriage. I don't care what the church teaches. It's more important for me to be there for my second cousin twice removed.
8:18 No, it's not. And that's hard for us to understand. But this is what Christ is saying here, that the family of God is more important than even our blood brethren, those who do the will of the Father. And so the order is God first, spouse second, children third. Notice God first. All right, I finish. Well, we Catholics believe in Mary being a perpetual virgin. well that would have to mean she didn't have any other children right well no that's not what the bible says today we traditionally think catholic understanding mary's a perpetual virgin and the protestant viewpoint that this is impossible well let's look at it do you know one of the fathers of the protestant reformation zwingli he said quote i firmly believe that mary remained a virgin pure and intact in childbirth and also after the birth of Jesus for all eternity. Martin Luther believed fully in Martin, excuse me, in Mary's perpetual virginity. In fact, there was never a challenge to this before the fourth century. And then it was done by a heretic. Always was Mary called the Blessed Virgin. You can't call her the Blessed Virgin if she had relations after Jesus.
10:01 And only always up to the fourth century was Mary called the Blessed Virgin. There was never a challenge to her perpetual virginity. And then people will say, well, the church didn't even define it to centuries later, therefore it's not valid. No, there was no challenge to it for centuries. The reason the church then defined it as dogma was because there was never a challenge the first several centuries. Mary was always called the Blessed Virgin, and it wasn't until after that that a heretic in the fourth century started to say she wasn't, and then the church had to then come define the dogma. Matthew 1 25, she remained a virgin until she gave birth to a son and his name was Jesus. Well, right there, father, she couldn't have been a virgin because it says she remained a virgin until she gave birth to a son, which means she wasn't afterwards. No, the Greek and the Hebrew word that is translated until does not imply that the action began after that point. Until simply emphasizes what did not happen before rather than indicating a change afterwards. Father, that sounds crazy. Really? Go to 1 Corinthians chapter 15, verse 25.
11:34 For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet. So if you're going to use that argument about the word until, you have to say after Jesus puts his enemies under his feet, he will no longer reign. Nobody's going to say that. He must reign until he has put his enemies under his feet. Well, then that means Jesus won't reign after. That's crazy. Or what about Matthew 28 verse 20? I am with you always until the end of time. Well, it says until the end of time. That must mean at the end of time Jesus is no longer with us. No, nobody's going to say that because until doesn't mean that you do the opposite after. In the Greek and the Hebrew it says nothing like that. It does not imply that the action began after that point. It emphasizes what did not happened before rather than indicating a change afterwards. So anyway, God bless you. I'm sharing with you what I learned in seminary on this important topic. Because why is it so important?
12:52 Because the very basis of our Catholic faith is Mary being immaculately conceived and then remaining a virgin. Now, I shouldn't say the basis, meaning, of course, Christ is in the resurrection, and we're not going to argue that. But to understand Mary's role and the four Marian dogmas, we have to understand that she remained a virgin. And hopefully this brief summary of my seminary for you makes a little bit of sense. Bottom line, you don't have to run from your Catholic faith because the Bible says the word brothers or the Bible says the word until. Hopefully you now have a little better understanding of the actual words in the Greek and in the Hebrew. You can't read the Bible literally in the English and determine what you think it means. This is the whole reason we have a church. And the church explains so that we all have the truth. You can't have two truths. Mary had other children. She did not have children.
14:11 Both can't be true. So what is the truth? Go to the original language and then go to the church because the church fathers, the saints, have all explained this to us over the centuries. Centuries before there was any argument disputing it. Praise be to God.
Machine translated from the source