Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published April 5, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
3:57 Thanks. Thanks, Katrina, very much for reading that for us. Let me add my welcome to Jeff's. If I haven't met you before, I'm Pete Nicholas, the senior pastor here. And we're thinking this morning, obviously, on this morning of all mornings, about the resurrection and those words from the Apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians 15. Now, it's a common view that there is when it comes to spirituality in general and Christian spirituality in particular, that it's kind of nice for you if that's your thing. A bit like some like sport, some like music, others like maybe art. And if you're particularly religiously inclined, spiritually inclined, then that's fine for you. But it's not a matter of truth and falsehood, more a matter of preference, whether you like that type of thing or not. And so people say, well, it's great for you and you seem to draw strength from it. That's wonderful. But I wonder if you noticed that when the apostle Paul is writing this letter of 1 Corinthians 15, which historians can place with great accuracy to between AD 53 and AD 55.
4:55 So we're talking only 20 years after the events of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. As Paul himself says in verse 6, many of the people who saw the resurrection are still alive today. As he writes it, he doesn't say, well, it's nice for you or it's nice for other people, but you can take it or leave it. He actually says very strongly that if this is not true, then our faith is in vain. In other words, he seems to be slightly uncomfortably black and white about that. Now, you could put that down to his personality. Maybe he was a black and white type of personality, but he won't have it. He says that the very facts of the resurrection mean it's not a take it or leave it type thing. It's a true or false. It really happened in space, time, and history type thing. Let's see why it is that he says that and the implications particularly. And he wants to flag three areas where the resurrection has a profound impact for us. He wants to talk about our faith.
5:52 He wants to talk about the prospect of forgiveness. And lastly, he wants to talk about hope. Faith, forgiveness, and hope. Let's look first of all at faith. He writes in verse 14 of chapter 15. You can follow it on the inside of your bulletins if you want to follow it. If Christ has not been raised, our preaching is useless, and so is your faith. I mean, he's really pushing the case, isn't it? He's really saying it very strongly. He's not leaving as much wiggle room. Our preaching is useless. Not that preaching is useless. I'm sorry if you don't like my preaching, but you're here for the next 20 minutes or so. But he says, the substance of the preaching is useless, that your faith is in vain. Now, why does he say that? As I said before, many people like to think that faith is kind of good for some, not for others. Some even view it as some have a particular quality of faith. Like some people are really good at believing things that aren't true.
6:49 You know, like Alice in Wonderland who believed 10 impossible things before breakfast. Some have that gift, others don't. There's actually a view out there now, which I think is particularly prevalent, that faith is psychologically helpful for some people. This is a view, really, that came about from Carl Jung. And Jordan Peterson has popularized it in the last 10 years particularly, and he's got a big following of people who buy into this. And it's for that reason he gave a bunch of lectures on the book of Genesis, not because he believes that that's historically factual, but because he thinks it's helpful. And the view goes a little bit like this. Life is chaotic. The world is difficult to navigate. And our subconsciouses feel that chaos. And that puts a real burden on us. And so one of the ways we cope for that is we try to project stories out into the world to give us a narrative to make sense of life.
7:44 We're meaning-making beings, is the idea. And so the subconscious projects these myths, these legends, these stories out onto life, things like that the world will work out in the end, that the cream always rises to the top. We codified in myths, different generations and different cultures do it in different ways, but these myths aren't absolutely true, they're just helpful. In fact, Jung uses an illustration for this in his book, Structures and Dynamics of the Psyche, where he says this, just as constellations were projected into the heavens, similar figures were projected onto legends and fairy tales. So here's what he's saying. He's saying, you know, look, you look at the night sky and it all seems dark and chaotic. And then someone says, oh, look, I think that looks a little bit like a hunter. Let's tell a story about Sagittarius. Or another person says, no, over there, it looks a bit like the twins. Let's tell a story about Gemini. And so we tell these stories to comfort us as we look at the night sky, but they're not true.
8:43 They're not real. They're myths and legends and spirituality and Christianity in particular. needs to be put into that bucket, myths and legend bucket. Is that what's going on here? I wonder if you've noticed that when the Apostle Paul is writing, he does not write in any type of way that would make this feel like a myth and a legend. You don't say to someone, hey, you observed the myth and the legend that happened just 20 years ago. You can go and ask the people, right? You don't challenge first century listeners and readers to go and look it up for themselves and speak to the people about something that happened in space, time, and history if it's just a myth. So the Apostle Paul is not treating this like a myth. In fact, he says, if this isn't really happened, if Christ has not been raised, your faith isn't useful, isn't psychologically comforting. He says it's useless. That's what the word vain means. It's literally useless. It does you no good at all. Now, let's try and explore that a little bit more. Look, I think the problem is that Jung even in his own illustration kind of gives the game away. I mean, let's imagine that I take you out into the night sky later on today, and we look up at the stars, and I say, well, there's Sagittarius up there. Now, of course, you and I both know there is no hunter actually in the night sky, right? Our children might buy into that, but we don't, because we're adults. But there is a constellation there, isn't there? I mean, we're labeling something real in the night sky. Otherwise, how do sailors navigate through the darkness? True, Gemini, the twins aren't there, but there is a constellation, and maybe you could tell me which one, that is actually true and objectively there. It doesn't change day to day. It hasn't changed in millennia. It's still going to be there.
10:23 It's fixed. So could it be that Jung's got it wrong? Could it be that the myths and legends are labeling true realities in different ways, in which case it begs the question, what's the reality? The Apostle Paul says the resurrection is the reality. It is the stars that are fixed in the night sky. The different cultures at different times and places might try and label it different ways. He says, this is the truth. Or as C.S. Lewis once came to realize, this is no myth. This is the true myth. You want to believe in something that makes sense of the world. Well, we all have that need, but underneath that need, there's a reality that there is a true story to make sense of the world. And the Apostle Paul says, it is that Jesus Christ lived, died, rose again in space, time, and history.
11:17 This is the fixed point through which you can navigate through the choppy waters of life. This is the true constellation that's in the darkness of the world that gives you light when you need hope. This is what you can base faith on, he says. Otherwise, your faith is in vain. Secondly though, he wants to draw attention to forgiveness. Verse 17, he writes, If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. Your faith is futile and you're still in your sins. Paul's saying here that if Jesus Christ really has been raised from the dead, one of the great good news elements of that is that there really is forgiveness. Forgiveness for anyone and forgiveness for anything that has been done. The God has in Jesus Christ made the possibility of forgiveness for anyone who trusts in him.
12:13 In the children's book, the BFG, the big friendly giant, Roald Dahl labels the worst dream as the troggelhomper. And the troggelhomper is described by the BFG to his friends one day as this. He says, It's a red, thrashing storm of a nightmare that makes your skin feel all creeping and crawling. And what is so bad about the troggle humper? He goes on to explain that you look on all you've done and there is no forgiveness. It's not just a children's story, that is it. I think as adults, we feel that the worst possible thing maybe in this world would be to look on what you've done and to know that there is no forgiveness. We all carry around a sense of our guilt and our shame. And of course, we need to be thoughtful here because sometimes people feel guilty and shamed for things that they haven't done wrong.
13:06 I'm not talking here, nor is Paul, about guilt feelings or other people imposing shame on you. That's wrong. But just because there are guilt feelings for things we shouldn't feel guilty about, so we should also feel guilty for things that we have really done wrong. And you and I know the difference. There are things that we have done wrong. And things that maybe other people haven't forgiven us for. Maybe there are things where other people have tried to forgive you, but you carry it around because as you say to yourself, I can't forgive myself for this. Maybe you tell yourself it was unforgivable. I wonder sometimes if part of the reason that everyone hustles so hard in this city is because the hustle is a way of keeping ourselves distracted. from the skeletons in the closet. It's as if we think if we keep ourselves busy enough and never stop moving, then we don't have to have that kind of ache in the psyche, the burden of things that have gone wrong. Maybe we hustle and, you know, work so hard because we think if I can just do enough or be enough or be good enough, then if I can put enough into this world from the wrong that I've kind of taken out of the world, then maybe I'll balance the scales. So much of our hustle, I wonder, is an overcompensation for these feelings of guilt and shame. The worst thing is this red thrashing storm of a nightmare that there is no forgiveness. But the Apostle Paul says, if Jesus Christ has been raised from the dead, then there is forgiveness. There need to be no storm that you face. There needs to be no nightmare. When you pause and slow down and your mind finally goes still in the small hours and your mind goes to those things that you've done wrong, in that moment you might feel and know and experience real relief, a conscience washed clean. Why?
14:52 Because God, whose opinion matters most, God, who is the moral arbiter in the universe, has forgiven you. You say, well, I'd love to believe that, Pete. I'd love to believe that. How is that not just a myth? It's not a myth because that's what Easter is all about. Jesus Christ really lived the perfect life, the purely innocent one, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world, as it says in Scripture. And then he died on the cross, not for anything he did wrong, but on the cross he was taking, well, the red thrashing storm of God's anger at all of the injustice in the world, all of our wrongdoing in the world, all of the guilt that we've put into the world and the shame that we carry. He was taking it on himself so that as he was rejected, we might be accepted. So as he took the storm, some of us might know peace for the first time, that our guilt might be atoned for, dealt with. And you say, how can I believe that that's true? Well, do this thought experiment with me. When a prisoner is pronounced guilty, they have to serve their time. How do they know when the sentence is done? They know because one day the doors of the prison open and they walk out a free person? How do you know for sure that Jesus Christ really paid the price for your and my sins on the cross so that forgiveness is possible? Well, you know, because after he served his sentence, the prison of death opened his doors and he walked out a free man. So you do not need to carry your guilt and your shame anymore. If you've never felt relief from that troggle hump a nightmare that pesters you in the middle of the night, if that's the reason that is driving you in your labors and you can't sit still, know this. If Jesus Christ has been risen from the dead, there is forgiveness for all and anyone, no matter what you've done wrong. Some of you need to let this argue with your conscience. You're there saying, well, Pete, I still don't feel I can forgive myself. In the nicest possible way, you're not in charge of the universe. Trust the one who is.
16:59 If God has said you're forgiven, who are you to contradict him? You are forgiven indeed because Christ has risen from the dead. Your faith is not futile. Forgiveness is possible. And lastly, hope. There is hope. Verse 18, the Apostle Paul goes on. He says, then those who have fallen asleep in Christ are lost if the resurrection hasn't happened. and he goes, if only for this life we have hope in Christ, we are of all people most to be pitied. If only for this life we have hope in Christ, we are to be pitied more of all people. Why? Because he's saying hope is not just a psychological construct. Hope is not just some Pollyanna optimistic disposition. We Brits don't have that, by the way. We just keep calm and carry on. But hope is not the kind of the American side of the Atlantic. You know, a bit more positive about life, a bit less dour, and stuck in the mud. It's not that. Hope is the sure and certain expectation that no matter how bad things get in the now, that one day all things will work out for the good. The sure and certain expectation that no matter how bad things get in the now, one day all things will work out for the good. Here's the thing, there are countless studies and psychological tests that show this is absolutely vital for the human condition, vital for us to do life well, and vital for us to face suffering and death well. We need hope. We need an anchor for hope in the storms. But where do we find it? Well, again, the Apostle Paul says, if you're just trying to make up a story, a myth, a legend, say it would be helpful to believe that some guy at some time rose from the dead. He said, you are to be pitied more than all people.
18:49 He's not saying it has psychological utility. He's saying you are pitied. But the converse is true. If Christ really did rise from the dead, then it means that hope is not only possible, but there is hope in the world. How can you know that? Well, look at what happened to Jesus. He took the worst of the world. No one else has faced what he faced. He took the mocking of the crowd. He took the scorn of the religious establishment. And then he ultimately took the rejection of his Father in heaven on the cross as he paid the price for our sins. No one has suffered like him. He took everything that's bad about this world, sin, rejection, death, and judgment. He took it all on himself. and then three days later he came out the other side. Death could not hold him. That's why Christians in the first century could sing a song that taunted death. Oh death, where is your sting?
19:52 Because they were saying that death has no power anymore. That the worst thing this world has, death, is not something to be feared anymore. It's just the doorway to the world beyond where the Lord Jesus Christ redeems all things, and his resurrection life is given to all people who trust in him. And we live for eternity knowing him and knowing everything good in this world and nothing bad. No more death. No more disease. No more despair. No more restless anxiousness, but just peace and resurrection life with our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ forever. Oh, I know that all of us inside have that part that says, I want to believe that, but I don't want to be a child about these things. I want an adult faith, a faith that can stand up to the rigors of 21st century life, a faith that can get me through the subway on a Monday morning, right? I need that type of faith, that type of hope. Well, this is this. Christ really lived. He really died. He really rose again. He's left his indelible marks all over history, and you can believe that. And if you come to believe in that objective reality of faith in Jesus Christ, then you have hope.
21:08 Let me end with these words from Josh McDowell, who spent an enormous amount of time interacting with and examining the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the grave. He says this, no matter how devastating our struggles, disappointments, and troubles are, they are only temporary. No matter what happens to you, no matter the depth of tragedy or pain you face, no matter how death stalks you or your loved ones, the resurrection promises you a future of immeasurable good. Few people seem to realize that the resurrection of Jesus is the cornerstone to a worldview that provides the perspective to all of life. The cornerstone to a worldview that provides the perspective to all of life. Do you have that perspective? Do you have a sure anchor for your faith?
22:03 Do you have the reassurance of forgiveness? And do you have that most precious of all things, hope in the face of life and death? May it be so. Let me lead us in a prayer. Heavenly Father, thank you for the Apostle Paul. He's pretty direct, Lord. He doesn't leave us many places to go, but maybe in his directness, we're confronted with the reality that the resurrection isn't nice for you if you happen to believe it or that's your thing, but it is something which happened in space, time, and history. And therefore, it has profound implications. This changed the life of the early disciples and the early church. It turned the world upside down. May it change our lives and turn our worlds upside down. that we might live life the right way up, we pray. We ask all this for Jesus.
Machine translated from the source