Why Does God Allow Suffering?

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published April 16, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Transcript

0:08 We are a vibrant and diverse community in the heart of New York City. Together, we seek to experience renewal by the gospel, raising up generations of disciples, and living for Jesus in the city. Today's message delivered by Pete Nicholas. I'm delighted to be able to have on stage with me Andrew Butler, and we're going to be exploring this question of suffering with Andrew. Andrew is married to Jane, got three kids, Jackson and Sage and Lulu, Lucy. And, well, we'll dive straight in, Andrew. Let's go back a little bit to 2014. And you were young, fit, and healthy. Still young, fit, and healthy now. But you got an unexpected brain cancer diagnosis in 2014. Tell us a little bit about the context around that and your story. Sure. So, good morning. My name is Andrew, as Pete said. Roll back the clock to 2014. I was in law school, finishing up my first year of law school. My now wife, Jane, and I were engaged at the time.

1:05 We were set to be married on May 25th. Late in April, I was having these terrible headaches at the end of my first year studying for finals. I'm sure people will be surprised to know that a male in his early 20s, his first thought is not to go to the doctor. It was not my first thought. Thanks to my fiancé's prodding, went to the doctor. we had an MRI done because the headaches were so severe and would not go away. And the doctors found some things that shouldn't be there. And as a result of that MRI, we ended up having surgery. I think we have a slide that shows ultimately what they found. Yeah, I think they're going to bring up on the slides now a picture of your brain. Have we got that? Maybe not.

1:53 Well, we'll carry on. Hopefully your brain is not just nothing, so there we go. Let's continue anyway. But how big was the tumor? They found some things that shouldn't be there. It was about nine centimeters across, so a little smaller than a tennis ball. So it's not a small item. It was growing, which was the cause of the headaches. It was ultimately going to put pressure on my brainstem, which would have not let this, the signals that help you breathe and your heartbeat pass through. And ultimately, it would have been fatal if they had not been able to go in and surgically remove it. So we had the surgery on May 1st in 2014. The surgery went really well, as well as we could have hoped. And recovery went really smoothly. We were actually able to be married on May 25th anyway, as a result of that surgery and the recovery. And from then, things, you know, we had a recovery period over the next couple of months. But following that surgery, I finished law school. We started our family. We, as you mentioned, we now have three kids. We moved to New York in 2018. We've been here ever since. We then in 2022, as a result of a routine scan, identified a regrowth of that tumor. And so we ended up having in the summer of 2022, just when you all were coming to the city, another surgery to remove the regrowth. And that surgery went really well. I'm still here.

3:27 Everything's okay in that sense. Like the medical prognosis, it remains positive. But we also recognize the fact that it has come back once means that it could come back again. Yeah. I mean, I'm trying to imagine and put myself in your shoes. 2014, you're engaged, you're looking ahead. As you say, young, fit, healthy, engaged. Life is laid out before you, and then you get this brain tumor diagnosis, which has got to be one of the worst things that you can ever be told. But then you get through that, and you're kind of thinking, oh, here we go, we've got the pictures up on slides now. So let's just, we can see that. Do you want to just talk us through what we're seeing there, Andrew? Sure. So your eyes go pretty straightforwardly. The photo on, or the scan on the left is top down. the scan on the right is from the back, and you can see the things that shouldn't be there. It was growing such that the normal hemispheres of the brain were kind of pushed out of true, and if you advance to the next slide, you'll see what it looks like after it was taken out.

4:27 So this is nine centimeters across, and I think if we do have the next slide, then we'll be able to see. There we go. This is after they removed it? Okay, so that gap there is obviously where it used to be. Yeah. So that hole is now in my head. I sometimes joke that I have a hole in my head. You actually have a hole in your head. So, wow, incredible. And so 2014, obviously, that was dealing with it. But I remember when we chatted beforehand and were talking about this interview, you said that in some ways, you know, there was also the impact of it coming back because you suddenly realized it's not a one-time deal. You come back. Just talk through like how that impacted you and, you know, your relationship with your wife, Jane, and things like that. Yeah. So the things that come to mind for me in response to that are two. One is, I think as a male in my early 20s and, you know, still I'm in my early 30s now, I have this sense, this rough sense of invincibility.

5:23 And that just like was a bubble that just got pricked by a pen and doesn't exist anymore for me. And that, I think it's not that I thought I walked around all day thinking about being invincible is just sort of this rough sense, and that's sort of the point. It's like, you don't examine it. It just exists in the background, and that's been done away with for us. I think now, as a male in my early 30s, you know, death and dying is something that's much more proximate to me mentally now than it probably is for your average person as a result of this experience. And then, two, I think often of, like, the things that the church fathers call the dark night of the soul. And we've had some of those as a result of these diagnoses, as a result of having, you know, a medical news that you didn't want at a time that's extremely inconvenient. And when we experienced those things, like we met with God and God met with us and we had times of amazing prayer, my wife and I, and it's not to say that we now seek out dark nights of the soul, but when they come to us, and you mentioned this in your sermon last week, the storms will come. And when they come, God is there to meet with us.

6:39 Yeah, could you just say a little bit more about that? You're a member of the church family here, so you believe in Jesus Christ, and I wonder if there might be a tendency to think that when belief in Jesus Christ, when it's suddenly shaken, as you mentioned, by storms or a cancer diagnosis or something like that, how does that kind of hold together? So say a little bit more about how belief in Him helps you navigate and has helped you navigate some of the suffering you've been through. Yeah, a couple of things come to mind for me there. I'd say three. One is, you know, the very concrete reality of the support of the church. So, you know, sitting here today in the service are like the people that drove us to the hospital, the people that ate with us before we had surgery, the people that helped to watch our kids. Just the hands and feet of the church, of Jesus is like embodied here in the church. And many of those people are here today. And that had an incredible and direct impact on me and my wife in times of challenge.

7:38 And then the second thing that I would say is the way in which these sorts of experiences, they test you. And you mentioned last week in your sermon about suffering, and you talk about it's not when it will come, or it's not if it will come, it's when. And when those trials come, the reality is that you can't build a foundation in the time of crisis. The time of crisis comes and it tests what has been built. And so when the crisis tested us, it's not to say that you can't come to faith in a time of crisis. I think the Thief on the Cross is an example of a time when someone does come to faith in a time of crisis. But these crises tested what we had been building from before. And in the midst of the storm, we didn't walk outside with a two-by-four and a hammer and nails. We walk outside and we're looking at what's tested as a result of what's been built before.

8:35 And then the final thing I would say is I have a tear-out from one of our old bulletins. This is the song, the hymn, Jesus, What a Friend for Sinners. And it ends, hallelujah, what a Savior, hallelujah, what a friend, saving, helping, keeping, loving, He is with me to the end. And part of these experiences have helped me wonder, you know, when is the end for me? I don't know when the end is. And the reality is that none of us do. And as these experiences tested us, and now, you know, it's underscored for me the fact that I don't know when the end is and when the end will come, but we rest in Jesus. in spite of the fact that we don't know when that day is. Andrew, thank you for being willing to come and share a little bit about the story, for being vulnerable and open with us and giving us plenty of food for thought.

9:28 A reading from the book of John, chapter 11, verses 17 through 27, and verses 32 through 44. You'll find this on page 871 and 872 of your Pew Bibles.

On his arrival, Jesus found that Lazarus had already been in the tomb for four days. Now, Bethany was less than two miles from Jerusalem, and many Jews had come to Martha and Mary to comfort them in the loss of their brother. When Martha heard that Jesus was coming, she went out to meet him, but Mary stayed at home. Lord, Martha said to Jesus, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. But I know that even now, God will give you whatever you ask. Jesus said to her, your brother will rise again. Martha answered, I know he will rise again in the resurrection at the last day. Jesus said to her, I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in me will live, even though they die. And whoever lives by believing in me will never die. Do you believe this? Yes, Lord, she replied. I believe that you are the Messiah, the Son of God, who has come into the world. When Mary reached the place where Jesus was and saw him, she fell at his feet and said, Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. When Jesus saw her weeping and the Jews who had come along with her also weeping, he was deeply moved in spirit and troubled. Where have you laid him, he asked. Come and see, Lord, they replied. Jesus wept. Then the Jews said, see how he loved him. But some of them said, could not he who opened the eyes of the blind man have kept this man from dying? Jesus, once more deeply moved, came to the tomb. It was a cave with a stone laid across the entrance. Take away the stone, he said. But Lord, said Martha, the sister of the dead man, by this time there is a bad odor, for he has been there four days. Then Jesus said, did I not tell you that if you believe, you will see the glory of God? So they took away the stone. Then Jesus looked up and said, Father, I thank you that you have heard me. I knew that you always hear me, but I said this for the benefit of the people standing here, that they may believe that you sent me. When he had said this, Jesus called out in a loud voice, Lazarus, come out. The dead man came out, his hands and feet wrapped with strips of linen and a cloth around his face. Jesus said to them, take off the grave clothes and let him go.

13:00 This is the word of the Lord. Thanks, Joanna, very much for reading that for us. Well, what we're going to be doing over the next 20 minutes or so is trying to explore this question of suffering. And as we do so, I think it's worth framing it that sometimes with a topic like this, of course, there's no sense in which we're going to resolve all of the questions today. So this is very much a community conversation. If you're a guest here this morning, it's wonderful that you're here, and hopefully you'll be able to involve yourself in that conversation in a couple of different ways. Firstly, we have a question and answer straight after the sermon. And so as we're going through, you'll see that there's a QR code on your bulletin, and if you want to text in a question or engage with the questions that are coming on that and upvote them, then we'll try, Jeet and I will try to engage with those for 15 minutes or so after the talk as well.

13:57 I'll also make myself available after the service so we can continue to talk about it. And of course, the person who's invited you along this morning I know wants to be able to have this conversation with you. I'm deeply grateful to Andrew for kicking off the conversation by sharing a bit about his own experience. Let me try to introduce it this way. Of course, whenever we think of suffering, our minds straightaway go to, sadly, the latest item in the news. A week ago last Friday, of course, you'll be aware of the terrible earthquake in Myanmar. and the latest kind of estimate, tragically, something like 3,000 people are presumed dead through that. And we don't just need to reference Myanmar, we could reference numerous tragedies which crowd our screens, our media feeds, our newspapers, almost on a daily basis of tragedy. And one of the things when we see suffering kind of out there in the news is it makes us acutely aware of our own suffering. It's as though it triggers something and we start to reflect on our own circumstances. And I'm very conscious in a crowd this size that a number of you will be carrying live issues of suffering you're either personally dealing with or a family member or a loved one or a friend is walking with at the moment. So this is very much not an academic question, though it does require intellectual rigor. It's very much a pastoral question.

15:17 If you'd forgive me for being anecdotal and personal for a moment, it's a very personal question to me and to our family because we've experienced a bit of a season of suffering in our family. My father died very suddenly from cancer in the summer of 2023, five weeks from being diagnosed to passing away. A couple of months later, my wife's mother, my mother-in-law, was diagnosed with stage four terminal cancer, and she's in an ongoing battle with that at the moment and has been since then. And a couple of months after that, in January of 2024, my wife's sister was diagnosed with stage four terminal cancer as well. Thankfully, she's now currently in remission. But I remember in that period, around about January, just after the diagnosis of Auntie Jo, for my children, one of our children, our youngest, over breakfast, turned to Rebecca and I and he said, Mom, Dad, does our family have cancer? And what do you say to a child in those moments?

16:14 How do you explain that? So this issue is firmly not merely intellectual, though it requires intellectual engagement. It's deeply personal for all of us in many and different ways. I approach this first and foremost as a pastor, but I do believe that pastorally we not only need to engage with the emotion and the tragedy of it, but when we're thinking about suffering, it's not only the practicalities of how am I going to get through it. What about the implications? Who's going to walk with me through it? How do I have a community who can support me? There are so many practical things that we need to engage with. But in the midst of it, what is often framed as the problem of suffering is a deeply challenging question. The philosopher and skeptic David Hume, when he was writing about the so-called problem of suffering, wrote it this way in his dialogues concerning natural religion. He said, were a stranger to drop on a sudden into this world, I would show him as a specimen of its ills, a hospital full of diseases, a prison crowded with malefactors and debtors, a field of battle strewn with carcasses, a fleet floundering in the ocean, a nation languishing under tyranny, famine, or pestilence.

17:27 And then a few paragraphs later, he concludes, the philosopher's old questions are yet unanswered. Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is impotent. Is he able but not willing? Then he's malevolent, he's bad. Is he both able and willing? Why then is there evil? You see, there's the pastoral side of it, there's the emotional side of it, but then deeply woven in is this intellectual challenge, which is if there is an all-loving, an all-powerful God, why is there evil in the world? And this why question surfaces for all of us. It's fascinating to me that David Hume is a skeptic, and yet he's framing the question against a classically biblical view of God, that God is all-loving and all-powerful, so why does God allow? And I don't just think it's intellectual for him. It's almost as though like a compass points to true north. We have this innate sense that we're not cast adrift in a world without meaning, that we're not just living in a world where random things happen and there are casualties, but there is a sense of meaning, there is a sense of order, there is a sense of purpose, and yet why? Why then is there suffering? We come up to it time and time again. Think of it this way, singer-songwriter Ed Ames in the 1960s framed it by a song, and in his song, he started the song with the chorus of Alleluia, Alleluia, and then he went from that to frame the why question this way. From the canyons of the mind we wander on and stumble blind through the often tangled maze of starless nights and sunless days.

19:09 while searching for some kind of clue, a road to lead us to the truth, but who will answer? When the soul is darkened by a fear it cannot name, when the mind is baffled and the rules don't fit the game, who will answer? Who will answer? Who will answer? It's fascinating that Ed Ames moves it from a why in a general sense to who. Who's going to answer? It's as though we want a personal audience with God to say, God, what are you doing? Why have my friends got cancer? Why is there suffering and perplexity? Why do the TV screens and music and media feeds crowd with suffering? Will you answer, Lord? And as we engage with this question as I've framed the problem, I want to suggest to you that whilst the God of the Bible and Jesus Christ does not give us a neatly packaged, all strings tied up in a neat little bow answer to suffering. Indeed, I think were there such a thing, it would not be able to engage with the gritty realities of human existence.

20:09 He does give us three pillars, I want to suggest this morning, which we saw in John chapter 11, three pillars that can sustain us when, tragically not if, when suffering comes along. So I want to look at the solution or the resolution on this by engaging in those three pillars. First of all, comfort in the midst of suffering. Secondly, meaning to make sense of suffering. And thirdly, hope that there will one day be an end to suffering. I think we need all three pillars. So let's think first of all about, first pillar, comfort in the midst of suffering. Ed Ames put it this way, who will answer? Because one of the great problems we feel when suffering comes along is that we feel very much alone. Andrew Butler talked about the way that the community gathered around Him, and we need people to support us as we engage and go through suffering. And I want you to notice in John chapter 11, the story which we had read for us from the eyewitness John, how Jesus engages and provides comfort in the midst of suffering. If you've got your bulletins, you can follow it on there, and I'm going to look at verse 33, halfway down to 36.

21:15 When Jesus saw Mary weeping and the Jews who had come along with her also weeping, he was deeply moved in spirit and troubled. Now, as context, Lazarus is known to Jesus. He's a friend of Jesus. Mary and Martha, the sisters of Lazarus, are known to Jesus. This is in Bethany. It's about two miles outside Jerusalem. He would have been at their home before, so these are family friends. And Jesus enters into this situation and sees Mary, the sister of Lazarus, weeping because her brother has died. Jesus asked, verse 34, where have you laid him? He asked. Come and see, Lord, they replied. Jesus wept. Then the Jews said, see how he loved him. Now, notice a few things here. You know the story. You've had it read already for you. Jesus is going to raise Lazarus from the dead. Indeed, some of the Jews in verse 37 do ask this question, which is, if Jesus is able to do these amazing miracles he's done, then why did he let his friend Lazarus die? Couldn't he have done something about that before death happened? Why did Jesus allow it? So there were serious questions being asked here. But in the midst of it, notice where Jesus is. He's right there in the midst of the grief. And notice his emotional posture. The Bible would have us believe that this is God himself in human form, which is why only he can heal Lazarus. And so if you often think of God as remote and distant, disconnected when suffering comes on cloud nine, you know, kind of benignly smiling or with some neutral expression on his face whilst we're down here in the Maya suffering, notice that does not square with the God of the Bible.

22:50 Because the God of the Bible, Jesus Christ, is there in the midst of the suffering, and he enters into the emotional reality of the suffering with the shortest but probably most profound verse in Scripture, verse 35, Jesus wept. And we cry out, why? We cry out, who? Who will answer? But in the midst of it, Scripture presents us with a person, God Himself, who steps into our human realities, who enters into the grief and the pain of suffering, and who is therefore able to connect with us in the midst of it. He's not distant. He's not remote. He's right there. Can I just say this to you, Pastor Lee? You may well be asking right now, where are you, God? Why aren't you doing something in my life? Why do you feel so distant? Well, God is right there with you, right there in the midst of it. You might not be able to see him right now, but he is there with you. Jesus wept.

23:45 Edward Shalito was a chaplain in the army in the First World War for the British forces. And after the First World War, he was trying to grapple with how he could believe in God and yet reconcile what he had seen on the battlefield. And he wrote a poem called Jesus of the Scars. And here's the last verse of the poem. The other gods were strong, but thou wast weak. They rode, thou didst stumble to a throne. But to our wounds, only God's wounds can speak, and not a God has wounds, but thou alone. This is the unique claim of Christianity, that God was wounded on the cross. Jesus Christ was wounded. He made Himself vulnerable and open, and He entered into the midst of our suffering. And here's the thing, the reason we have support groups often for people who've been through suffering, who have been through and come out the other side, are the ones that we want to go to when we suffer because we need someone. There's an existential need for someone to say, I know what you're going through. I see you in the midst of it, and I'm there to support you. Only a God who has suffered can say to us, I have any idea of what you're going through. Jesus Christ can say that to you and can comfort you in the midst of suffering because He is the only God with scars. Only God with wounds can empathize with our wounds. That's the first pillar, comfort in the midst of suffering offered by God with wounds.

25:12 Secondly, meaning to make some sense of suffering. We ask this why question, why? Why is this happening to me? Why is there suffering? What's going on? It feels so disorienting. And I would suggest that the very concept of suffering actually is one where it's not just mere pain we're talking about. Pain is mere stimuli. It's a mere response to certain painful stimuli that we have. But suffering is pain plus morality, pain plus injustice. It's a sense of it should not be this way, which is why, properly speaking, I don't think the animal kingdom experiences suffering. It just experiences pain, because some pain can be good, some pain can be bad. Running a marathon and is painful, some of you will still do it. It's not my distance. I better over, like, short distances, about 10 yards to the coffee shop and back. So pain doesn't mean suffering. Pain plus injustice is suffering. And so woven into the very fabric of the question is a sense that it should not be this way. And again, Jesus Christ uniquely gives us a sense of being able to make sense of suffering because when He weeps, He shows us that this is not part of His intended plan. This is not the way the world is supposed to be. And this is the Christian story that God created a good world, a wonderful world, full of good things that we enjoy, family, friends, food, maybe even for some fame and fortune. And yet, when humanity turned away from God, such is the closeness of our relationship with creation that in turning away from God and the source of all goodness, we became distorted. We became people with bad in us, and we brought evil and suffering into the world. We distorted the world, and the world should not be this way.

26:56 This is why Jesus weeps, because he validates the deepest intuition that the world should not be this way. I don't mean to philosophize, but if the world is purely material, if the world is purely natural, then there is no such thing as suffering, because there's no such thing as injustice. It's just nature doing what nature does. One person who thought a lot about this was the Pulitzer Prize winner and writer Annie Dillard in her novel Pilgrim in Tinker's Creek. And in it, she writes about how she observes in the animal kingdom horrific things happening, but the animal kingdom just kind of carries on. And she one day is sitting down by a creek and she sees a water bug crawl on top of a frog, inject its poison into it, and then suck out its insides. And she's horrified, but she sees that the rest of nature just carries on regardless. And she writes this, I realize that either this world is a monster or I'm a freak. Let's consider the former. This world runs on chance and death and power, but I cherish life and the rights of the weak versus the strong. So that must mean that I crawled out by chance of a sea of amino acids, and now I whirl around and shake my fist at the sea and cry, shame, we little blobs of soft tissue crawling around on this planet's skin are right, and we would have us believe that the whole planet is wrong?

28:16 Let's consider the alternative, she says. Nature is fine, nature is all right. It's our emotions and values that have gone amiss. We're the freaks, and the world is fine. So let's all go and have lobotomies, and then we can go back to the creek and live on its banks as untroubled as any muskrat or reed. And then she famously says, you first. which is it? You see, if we're going to say that they're suffering, we're appealing to some sense of justice. And if we appeal to justice, we have to believe that there's a God of justice, otherwise nature does not have justice ingrained into it. It's red and tooth and claw, as Alfred Lord Tennyson once said. So where do we get this problem of suffering coming from? Who are we asking why? Who is the who that we want to answer us? We believe deeply, as a compass points to north, that there is a God who needs to give us an answer. And Christianity validates that sense of meaning. Yes, world should not have suffering in it. Yes, the world is a good world. Yes, there is something wrong in the world. That's why Jesus weeps at death. It should not be this way.

29:17 But if you don't believe in God, there is no meaning. There is no suffering. It's just pain. And then Jesus goes further in verse 40 and says to Martha, Did I not tell you that if you believe, you will see the glory of God? This is the remarkable thing about Jesus Christ. Whilst suffering in the pure sense is not willed by God, God can work through suffering to bring about even good and glory. And so Jesus Christ works even through this suffering of his friend dying to bring glory. How so? Well, because we're here talking about it today. The glory of seeing Jesus Christ raise Lazarus from the dead, which gives us the hint that there can be meaning in suffering and, third pillar, that there can be hope for an end to suffering. We often think that no good can come out of a situation, but this and the suffering in the Bible shows us that if God can work through this to bring about a greater purpose, then don't think that He can't work through your life to bring about a greater purpose. If He can work even through the crucifixion of the Lord of glory, which we're going to be thinking about on Good Friday, and rise from the dead on Easter Sunday, to bring about some greater purpose, then don't think that your suffering could never have any purpose. God is in the redemption business, and He can bring meaning even in the midst of the darkest night. Let's look then thirdly and lastly at the hope for an end to suffering. Look with me at verse 25. Verse 25, Jesus says, I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in Me will live even though they die, and whoever lives by believing in Me will never die. Do you believe this? Yes, Lord, she replied. I believe you are the Messiah, the Son of God, who came into the world. You see, comfort is significant. It sustains us in the pain of suffering. Meaning is significant.

31:07 It helps us to reorient that whilst we don't have all the answers, we will one day get some answers about why suffering was allowed, and there is significance going through that. But ultimately, we long for an end to suffering. And Jesus Christ uniquely gives us the promise of an end to suffering, and therefore He gives in microcosm, in this miracle, a foretaste of how that's going to happen. Because here's the thing, here's the logic. Jesus Christ raises Lazarus from the dead, showing that He is God and that He has the power to end suffering just with a word. If He's able to call Lazarus out of the tomb, as one commentator put it, it's just as well that He named Lazarus, otherwise the tomb would have given everybody up. And that's the Christian claim, that one day the voice of Jesus Christ will raise from the dead all who trust in him to a world where there's no more death, no more disease, no more cancer diagnoses, no more despair, no more despondency for the old order of things will pass away. And I know what you're thinking because I used to think this too.

32:09 Well, that's just fairy tales. That's just wishful thinking. No. It's as sure and certain as the raising of Lazarus from the dead. And it's as sure and certain as the raising of Jesus Christ from the dead, because here's the Christian story, the true story that happened in space, time, and history. Jesus Christ really lived, and He died an excruciating death on the cross that would show you the worst of the suffering of the world. and yet that was not the final chapter. Three days later, he rose from the dead and planted a flag in history showing that suffering will not have the final word and that all who trust in Jesus Christ will one day be raised to a new world, this world made new, where death will have lost its sting. You say, I'd love to believe that. You can believe that. It's as certain and sure as the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.

33:05 Let me end with this. In 1 Corinthians 15, which is one of the oldest parts of the Bible, one of the first parts of the New Testament written, there's a hymn that we get an insight into what the early church sung. And the refrain of that hymn is, Where, O death, is your sting? It's kind of teasing death, prodding fun at death, which would be an unwise thing to do unless death had lost its power. Where, O death, is your sting? My oldest, Oliver, is scared of bees because when he was little he was stung twice in a month, poor guy. And so now whenever he sees a bee, he kind of pulls back and cowers a little bit. But imagine this. Imagine that I was able to take a bee and remove its sting and then have it in a jar and was able to show Oliver and say, look, look very carefully, son. Do you see there's no stinger left in it? It's completely gone. Do you think he would then feel afraid of it? No, because the sting is the thing that he fears.

33:58 And a bee without a sting is just a cute fluffy beetle flying around, right? So he would have no fear of it. This is the Christian claim, that when Jesus Christ dies on the cross, He draws the sting of death that we all should face for all of the ways we've tried to live independently of God, and He rises from the dead to show that it really worked, and therefore death has lost its sting. It's as powerless as a fluffy bee flying around. No one would fear that. And so that doesn't mean that Christians don't die. It just means that we walk through death into eternity, and one day we'll all rise again and live in a world where there'll be no more suffering. That's the claim, and that's the third pillar, hope for an end to suffering. You see, we will all face suffering in this life. That's inevitable. But when you put these three pillars together following Jesus Christ, comfort in the midst of suffering, meaning to make sense of suffering, and hope that one day suffering will end, then you can stand, as Andrew did and as many others have done down history.

Machine translated from the source