Blue Christmas

Rev. Werner Ramirez · Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church · 7 West 55th Street, New York, New York 10103 · Preached December 17, 2025

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

16:26 Friends, I invite you to still your hearts, quiet your minds, and also silence your cell phones as we prepare to worship God. Some of you may remember a powerful moment from Sesame Street back in 1983, when the show chose to address the death of Mr. Hooper with honesty and tenderness. Big Bird burst onto the scene holding drawings he made for Mr. Hooper, excited, expectant, ready to hand him to their friend. He's there and then the adults gather around Big Bird and you can see immediately that they are grieving, not just on the show, but in real life. Their eyes are puffy, their voices are tight, and a few of them are visibly fighting back tears as they prepare to tell Big Bird the truth. They gently say to Big Bird, Big Bird, Mr. Hooper died.

17:30 Big Bird, confused and hopeful, asks, Well, when is he coming back? There's this long, heartbreaking pause before the answer. And they say, He's not coming back. Big Bird protests and says, This makes me sad. And one of the adults replies with such compassion and says, we are all sad, Big Bird. Then Big Bird asks the question every grieving heart eventually asks, but why? Why does it have to be this way? And then one of the most honest moments ever aired on children's television, Thank you. someone says, Big Bird, we don't know. We just don't know.

18:21 Big Bird's question echoes the ones we all ask at some point. Questions with no neat answers, no explanations that make the ache disappear. And it's precisely in that moment when the why cannot be answered. that the adults do the most important thing. They stand beside the big yellow bird. They hold the space with them. They let them know that they are not alone. It's such a simple scene, but to name something profoundly true. Grief is confusing, disorienting, and often lonely. And yet healing can begin when someone stands beside us and says, you are not alone. And that's why we gather tonight. We come because each of us in our own way, in our own time, have known loss. We're not here to offer easy answers or to say that everything happens for a reason. And we're certainly not here to shame anyone for not feeling merry and bright this season.

19:30 We are here to proclaim that the God who loves you also grieves with you. The God who created you holds your sorrow tenderly. And in this sacred hour, we make space for God's comfort, God's compassion, and God's healing presence. Tonight, we bring the fullness of who we are, our joys and our sorrows, successes and failures, gratitude and guilt, blessings and losses, hopes and fears, and we lay everything before our Lord and Savior, asking for God's sustaining presence in our places of deepest need. During tonight's service, we will have time for meditation, prayer, and candle lighting. Isabel, Natalie, and Chris will light the four large candles in front of us during a responsive prayer. And after that, anyone who would like to come forward and light a candle, you can do that in either in memory of a loved one or to lift up a particular joy or concern. You may do so at that time. And if anyone would like a time of additional prayer, Isabel, Chris, and I will be available here in the front. For our online community joining on Zoom, we recommend that you open the Zoom link right now and you'll be admitted during the prayer part of our service with Reverend Natalie. Tonight's service will end with silence. You're invited to remain for a time of silent meditation if you choose to do so. But before we enter our call to worship, hear this poem from Jan Richardson from A Circle of Grace.

21:12 Look, the world is always ending somewhere. Somewhere the sun has come crashing down. Somewhere it has gone completely dark. Somewhere it has ended with the gun, the knife, the fist. Somewhere it has ended with the slammed door, the shattered hope. Somewhere it has ended with the utter quiet that follows the news from the phone, the television, the hospital room. somewhere it has ended with a tenderness that will break your heart. But listen, this blessing means to be anything but morose. It has not come to cause despair.

22:10 It is simply here because there is nothing a blessing is better suited for than an ending. Nothing that cries out more for a blessing than when a world is falling apart. This blessing will not fix you, it will not mend you, it will not give you false comfort, it will not talk to you about one door opening when another one closes.

22:35 It will simply sit itself beside you among the shards and gently turn your face towards the direction from which the light will come, gathering itself about you as the world begins again. Friends, will you please rise in body or in spirit as God calls us into worship. Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, O Promised One, once again we come to Advent and await your presence. Give us patience to seek the meaning of these busy days. Give us the courage to wait in times of pain and trouble. Give us the compassion to wait for one another. Give us the faith to wait for the Messiah when we are threatened by the hereds of this world. Give us the hope to wait for the Savior even when we cannot hear the angels singing. Give us the love that does not wait when it meets Christ in our neighbor. Giver of all good things, we worship you, O God.

Machine translated from the source