Do Catholics Have to be Nice? Actually, Not Entirely!

Chris Alar · National Shrine of The Divine Mercy · Published August 21, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:02 Today we have the feast day of Pius X, and one of the things he was against was modernism. And there's a lot of aspects of modernism that we could talk about, but one of the most deadly and yet hidden, inconspicuous tools of modernism is to dismantle the truth by saying it's mean. unkind and it's offending of someone. I was just reading where Nike, an American company, raised in its billions of dollars in American commerce and capitalism, refused to put an American flag on one of their shoe brands because it might offend people.

1:00 this has become sweeping of our culture today sweeping our culture that we cannot offend anyone even at the sacrifice of the truth and this is dangerous why okay being a good or a nice person is not the same as being holy. This is what our Lord's message is here today about love. What is Christian love? When Jesus says love is the first commandment, Christian love is not just about niceness. A person can be pleasant, agreeable, generous, well-liked, but still failing in true love. We see this all the time today. Christian love or kiritas, charity, means willing the good of the other. I want your salvation more than anything. Niceness and love are not the same.

2:17 This surprises people. Niceness usually means that I'm pleasant towards you. I do not offend you. I do not make you uncomfortable. I avoid conflict. I want you to like me. These are all good things. These are not bad. Courtesy, kindness, patience, gentleness, these are all virtues. But love goes deeper. It's willing the good of the other and even telling them what they don't want to hear. Imagine a physician that finds out that you have a really dangerous disease. it would be more pleasant for that doctor to say, hey, everything looks great. Don't worry about it. You're good. You're fine. The patient leaves the office feeling wonderful about the doctor. Oh, I really like that doctor. But that would not be love.

3:27 because then the patient doesn't take care of themselves, doesn't know about the danger, continues like we would get after cameraman Giuseppe for drinking. He would drink like five or six Mountain Dews a day and then we would say you can't do this. It's because we love you. He'd be like don't pick on me. No we're not picking on you. We love you. We don't want to see you get diabetes. And that's what we're trying to do, to help. And sometimes it's telling somebody something they don't want to hear. And so if that patient then doesn't take care of themselves because they don't know, they end up dying from it. The doctor has to care about the patient's good, so he must tell them the truth even when it is painful. That is true love. So when Jesus talks about love here, he's not talking about just niceness, but the truth. Christian love is the same. Jesus was perfectly loving. I don't think anybody would argue that, but was he always nice? No, he over flipped tables. He told the adulteress, I don't condemn you, but go and sin no more. There was mercy and correction. Jesus does not humiliate her or reject her, but neither does he pretend that what she's doing is okay. He calls it out.

5:09 he calls it out true mercy forgives the sinner but calls the sinner out of sin and this is what our world today tries to tell us is wrong jesus told peter get behind me satan did that sound nice he called the pharisees hypocrites does that sound nice he overturned the tables of the money changers in the temple. Does that sound nice? He warned about judgment and hell. Does that sound nice? But he never lacked love. No, he spoke strongly because he loved people enough to care about their soul. Love and truth belong together. Paul said we are living the truth in love, Ephesians 4. One error is truth without love. You're wrong, and I'm going to make sure that I beat you over the head with the Bible. Father Anthony and I were just talking about this this morning, because St. Jerome, who is good, he corrected people, but he would beat people over the head with the Bible. So that's one wrong way. And then there can be also another problem. So you can have truth without love. This can be very wrong. That's condemnation. But then you can also have love without truth. Oh, I don't want to upset you, so I won't say what you're doing is wrong. I don't want to hurt you. I don't want to offend you, so I'm not going to say anything. I'm not going to correct this. That's also wrong. So that is really love lacking, or I should say that's really, that's not love. So the Christian way is truth and love. Now here, here's

7:16 the thing. A lot of people ask me about their loved ones in same-sex marriages, not marriages, not marriage, same-sex unions, or married outside the church, and they ask, Father, what do I do? I can't offend them. I can't offend them. And yes, we understand that. This is one of the hardest things. But if we celebrate something that is actually destroying another person's relationship with God, we may be affirming them emotionally, but we are not necessarily loving them spiritually. You catch that? So if we celebrate something that is destroying their relationship with God, like living in mortal sin, you may be affirming them emotionally, but you are not loving them spiritually.

8:18 This is a hard teaching of Christ, very hard. Does love require correcting people? Yes. Catholic tradition calls this fraternal correction. Jesus says, if your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault. Now, this happens and it works both ways. We have to understand Jesus does tell us how to do this. St. James goes even further. Whoever brings back a sinner from the error of his way will save his soul from death and will cover a multitude of sins. That's James 5.20. But Proverbs is interesting. Better is an open rebuke than a love that remains hidden. That's Proverbs 27.5.

9:13 So admonishing the sinner is actually a work of mercy, okay? But fraternal correction requires prudence. Before correcting someone, we want to make sure, are we doing this out of love of the person? Are we, you know, are what they doing actually sinful and wrong, or is it just something we don't like. We have to look at that. In fact, this is sometimes important because love has to be done also for the good of the person, and getting the right relationship with God is most important. Christianity is not fundamentally a program for producing nice people. That shocks us. that really shocks us christianity is not fundamentally a program for producing nice people christ did not come merely to make bad people behave better he came to reconcile fallen mankind and to get you out of sin a person could be extremely pleasant socially but deliberately secretly rejecting God or living in sin. That's not good. Conversely, someone might have a difficult personality, like, wow, they're really strong, and still sincerely, they're struggling to be holy.

10:47 Saint Jerome. Saint Jerome was a perfect example. Everybody hated Saint Jerome. He was harsh. He told you as it was. He told you the truth. Nobody liked him for it, but he was a saint because he stood for the truth. Now, maybe there's some lessons in there for us, but anyway, someone who might have a, well, you know, God alone knows the heart, so we have to be careful in judging the person who corrects us, and the people who do the correcting have to be careful about not misjudging the heart of those they are correcting. So the greatest good we can do is will someone to heaven. That's the best thing we can do. That is why Christian love cannot simply mean, I affirm whatever makes you happy. We can't do that. If I truly love someone, I want their good, not merely their comfort. That is the message here. And the greatest possible good for another human being is God himself. And this is important. Christian love says, I want you to be happy, but even more, I want you to be holy. I want you to know Christ, to be free from sin, and I want you reconciled with God. Ultimately, I want you in heaven. And that's why sometimes it's hard for people to understand when they're corrected. And this is why corrections can sometimes be a real act of love. Okay? Parents, you need to understand this.

12:37 this is so important a parent who never says no to a child is a huge mistake a huge mistake and God will reward those who stick to that truth I laugh because you've heard me tell the story for 10 years going to the grocery store with my mom she never let me have Jiffy Pop Popcorn. And Kieran Lerano was here this last week. God bless her for the vows. And what did she do? She brought me Jiffy Pop Popcorn. Because I never got that as a child. Because my mom said, this is not good for you. This is not, no, you are not getting Jiffy Pop Popcorn. Because mom would say no. And I would just sometimes try to debate with her. Why, why, why? And finally, she got to the point, because I said so. It's good for you to not have it, so I have to laugh on that. But anyway, sometimes the loving parent has to say no, because this will hurt you. God does the same with us. Correction must begin, though, what God tells us with ourselves. Remove the wooden beam from your eye first, then you will see clearly to remove the splinter in your brother's eye.

13:57 Now notice something here. Jesus never says that you should never remove the splinter from someone else's eye. He never says that we should never do that. He says, look to your first and then do the other. He doesn't say never do the other. Never correct the other. He says, just look to your own self first. Now notice that Jesus does not say never ever help them remove their splinter. He says we must first deal with our own sins. Christian correction has to do that. And that's why going to confession regularly is good. We develop humility because we know we're sinful. And so Christian correction comes from humility. I am a sinner. I need God's mercy just as much as anyone. But because I care about you, I cannot tell you that something that is wrong is okay. And this is important. Something harmful to your soul is not good. I think of parents with children cohabitating. Or some parents have come to me that their child brings their boyfriend or girlfriend home for the weekend. And then they get very angry at the parents because they want to sleep together in the same room in the house. And I remember one mother approaching me, but father, I can't offend my son. He won't talk to me anymore. No, no, no. That is your house.

15:31 And your house follows the rules of God. Your house follows the moral law. and your son who comes over and brings his girlfriend who are not married, your rule of the house, doesn't matter if he's 30 years old. He could be 30 years old. That is your house, and you have to stand by that rule that we will not bring sin into this house. Well, he will never talk to me again. Yeah, it's difficult, but this is very important. you know, I can't tell you that something harmful to your soul is good. It's not. And that is radically different, though, from self-righteous condemnation. Well, Father, it'll make me look self-righteous. I don't want to condemn them. That's not it at all. It's out of love that you are correcting. So mercy itself requires truth. Mercy does not mean that God says sin doesn't matter. A lot of these attacks we're getting online on St. Faustina and on the Marian Fathers keep saying that we say, oh, mercy means sin doesn't matter. No, that's not the teaching.

16:51 Mercy means that sin does matter so much that Christ went to the cross for it. If sin were harmless, Calvary would make no sense. Jesus did not die so that we could remain comfortably in sin. This is the Protestant fallacy. Jesus did it all. I don't have to worry. All I have to do is say he's my Lord and Savior and I can do whatever I want. That's deadly. That's very, very, very dangerous. And so Christ didn't die so that we could remain comfortably in sin. He died to forgive us, heal us, transform us, and bring us back to the Father. And that is why Jesus had both mercy and conviction. Repent and believe in the gospel. So to finish, Catholic teaching avoids two extremes.

17:51 Condemnation without mercy is wrong, and affirmation without conviction is wrong. Christ offers something much greater, truth with mercy. correction with compassion, forgiveness with conversion, and love ordered towards eternal life. So I think the best way to summarize it is this. Niceness asks, how can I not offend you?

18:25 Christian love asks, what is truly good for you? And how can I help you reach it? see the difference it's not easy and this is why christ said unless you hate your mother your brother your father your sister you cannot be my disciple now he didn't mean despise he didn't mean detest them that would break the fourth commandment he meant to hate in the original language means to love less. Meaning I have to love everyone and every person, even children, less than God. I have to love God the most. And sometimes that is not easy. And that is why being a true disciple, Jesus said, is very difficult. And the road of those who follow it is very narrow.

19:22 but the what the road to pleasure and kindness and and niceness without any truth and just letting anything go that road is wide and it leads to destruction so if i truly love you i don't want to see you on that road and i finished by saying don't worry my brothers correct me all the time and so all the time father you said it this way or you said it this way and I'm like you know what you're right you're right and so we all have to realize what God is calling us to in being a disciple it's not easy but it's better to have us in heaven the eternal salvation is much more important than you temporarily being offended or not. Your eternal salvation is what is the most important, and true love is willing the good for you, and your ultimate good is heaven. God bless you.

Machine translated from the source