Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published April 20, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
2:08 Sarah, thank you very much for reading that for us. Let me add my welcome to Jeff White, particularly if you're a guest here. This morning, it's great to have you with us. My name's Pete Nicholas, and thank you to the wonderful orchestra for leading us. We'll have an opportunity to thank them properly later, but I do want to apologize to them that they'll be getting the back of my head throughout the majority of this sermon. I've been reliably informed, though, those who know me best, that it's my best side. So every cloud has a silver lining for you. Now, I wonder if you have used the phrase, curiosity killed the cat. I mean, we talk about that a fair bit, don't we? As an owner of a cat with our family that seems intent on proving the hypothesis by chewing electrical wires around the house, I can certainly speak to it a little bit. But I wonder if you know that the phrase doesn't just go, curiosity killed the cat. It actually continues, but satisfaction has brought it back.
3:07 And see, it's two edges to this aphorism. The first one is to warn us that an excessive curiosity and always need to try to bottom everything out to get to that elusive 100% certainty will lead to the kind of death of knowledge in a strange way. But on the other side, it's not at all encouraging ignorance, a kind of blind faith. Rather, the satisfaction of knowledge of pursuing something until you really find it out will bring curiosity back and will cultivate it. Now, why do I talk about that as we come to this passage? Well, in the passage, we get the word wonder used twice, at the beginning of the passage and at the end of the passage. And in the first use of it in verse 4, which you can find on your own Bibles on page 859 or the passages are printed on the inside of the bulletin. In verse 4, we get the first use of wonder, and it means curiosity.
4:01 While they, that is the women, were wondering about this, that is the empty tomb, suddenly two men in clothes that gleamed light lining stood beside them. There are two different words translated with the same English word wonder. This first word means curiosity. It means perplexity. The women are the curious ones. They're the ones who've gone to the tomb in the morning. The disciples have held back. They're cowering, hidden away, too afraid to get up early in the morning and to go to the tomb. but the women are there, and as the first eyewitnesses to both the empty tomb and the resurrection, their journey is one of curiosity. Their journey is one of the sincere seekers, as it were. They start out curious. But then in verse 12, we get Peter runs to the tomb. We get the word wonder in English again. Peter, however, got up and ran to the tomb. Bending over, he saw the strips of linen lying by themselves, and he went away wondering to himself what had happened.
5:00 The word there for wonder in the original is not curiosity. It's the word we get amazement from. It's awe and wonder. Of course, there's an ambiguity in English, right? But the point is, is that the passage shows us an arc from curiosity, from seeking, from asking good questions, to the landing point, the aim, if you like, the satisfying point of curiosity, which is amazement. The cultivation of awe and wonder in our lives. And notice how linked the two are. Because to put it negatively, if you are of the disposition where you are curious about nothing, then you create a disposition towards the world where nothing can ever challenge your preconceived notions. And there, secure inside the box of your own understanding, nothing will ever amaze you because nothing will ever surprise you. There is no wonder in the world.
5:52 You've figured the world out. or rather you've just made the world very, very small, as big as your box. But if, on the other hand, you resist gullibility, of course, but you enter into the world with a posture of curiosity, with an openness to the world, with a desire to experience and learn new things, with a sense that this world is truly wonderful, as G.K. Cheston said, the world will never starve for want of wonders, only a want of wonder. It's about cultivation and disposition of curiosity that asks good questions, that seeks things out. And if you enter into the world with that, who knows what marvelous things you might find, what amazement, awe, and wonder you might end with. That's really the arc of the story. That's what the resurrection, in one sense, is all about. So we're going to think about that this morning in two ways. First of all, we're going to think about three curious facts about the resurrection. So some curious facts about the resurrection, and then we're going to think about the wonderful implications for the resurrection. And because I'm feeling symmetrical this morning, we've got three of each. So three curious facts and three wonderful implications. So stick with me as we go through, and let's first of all ask some questions of the text as we think about the curious facts of the resurrection. Now, I want to put my cards on the table. It's strange to say this as a pastor, but I have not always been a Christian. I didn't grow up in a Christian home. I came to faith later on in life, about age 22. And some of these facts were the ones that really bugged me.
7:23 So I'm kind of giving you my working as I was curious myself about the biblical witness on the resurrection. And the first one that I found so curious was that it was the women who visited the tomb. Verse 1 of chapter 24. On the first day of the week, very early in the morning, the women took the spices they had prepared and went to the tomb. Now, I found that curious, not because women were early risers or not because the disciples are cowards. I actually found those things both eminently easy to believe. But I found it curious because my presupposition was that this was a fictional account. This was a kind of sophisticated myth. This was something that had been doctored maybe over the years. Maybe you believe that or sometimes think that yourself. And therefore, I was curious as to why, if you were making this up, you would have the women as being the first eyewitnesses. For example, within the Jewish law at the time, for example, in the Mishnah, which governed the Jewish religious life, in the section of the Mishnah called the Shavut, it says this, the oath of testimony applies to men, but not to women. And so it proved pretty much for 1900 years, right, until women got the vote. That was the consensus across the West, certainly in the ancient Near East.
8:40 Women did not have an oath of testimony. So why would you then have, if you're making this up, women as the first eyewitnesses to the tomb? Their testimony is not even admissible in court, so no one would believe them. I mean, was this some kind of super sophisticated, well, wait 1,900 years, and when the patriarchy finally crumbles, then people realize what a brilliant apologetic this is? That makes no sense at all. No, instead, it rings true. Often when you're trained to listen for truth, two young boys who occasionally might stretch the truth a little bit, you look for those things that don't quite add up. And they're often the things that ring true, the curious facts. This rings true. Men, I'm sorry to talk to you directly for a moment, but you know this. How often in life have you insisted on something, it's never going to happen, it's never going to happen. Trust me, I know it's never going to happen.
9:33 and then the prophetic female voice in your life has once again proven right. You know, best not look at them right now because it'll be embarrassing for you, but we know that happens, right? How often in life has the male type of courage, which can be full of bravado, full of projection, don't worry, like Peter, even if all others desert you, Jesus, I will never desert you. It fades away under the heat of circumstances and yet there are the women trembling, but taking one step in front of the other and proving what real courage looks like. Oh, this rings very true. The women were the first eyewitnesses. You would never have made it up. Second curious fact that struck me is there in verse three and verse six. Verse three, but when the women entered the tomb, they did not find the body of the Lord Jesus. Verse six, he is not here, said the angel. He is risen.
10:26 Remember how he told you while he was still with you in Galilee. The physical resurrection of Jesus Christ is a curious fact. Curious because no one was expecting it. You may think, well, surely the Jews were expecting a physical resurrection. No, they were not. It's very clear from the Old Testament and also from reading the interactions with Jesus in the New Testament. that people expected a future resurrection at the end of all time. The Jews believed in that. the raising of the just after judgment, people would be raised to new life then. No one was expecting a person to be raised physically this side of that judgment. And so when Jesus rose from the dead, no Jews were expecting it, the disciples were not expecting it, and the women were certainly not expecting it. Similarly, if you think about a Greek worldview, at the time, the Greeks thought that the physical was bad and that the spiritual or immaterial was good, a kind of Platonic ideal. And so the idea of a physical resurrection was, again, curious and strange and defied their expectations. But nonetheless, that is the resurrection that was proclaimed. Now, again, think with me. Be a cynic for a moment. If you're going to make this up, go with the easy, the non-verifiable, right? Jesus has risen in your hearts. You'll see him in the afterlife. Now believe. I mean, we can all believe that, and no one can falsify it, right?
11:55 It's so simple, it's so easy, and it fitted the Jewish paradigm and the Greek paradigm. So why not go with that? The comfortable lie is always easier than the uncomfortable truth. Unless, of course, this is curiously true. The women were the first eyewitnesses, the body of the physical resurrection, and then thirdly, the disciples. They didn't believe. Look with me at verse 11. Here are the disciples who are going to call many, many others to belief. And then in verse 11, but they did not believe the women because their words seemed to them like nonsense. I mean, it's embarrassing, isn't it? It's not exactly sugar-coated. I mean, not just they didn't quite understand. No, no, they thought it was nonsense. Again, all too familiar to men and all too familiar probably for the experience of one or two women in this group as well. The disciples who are going to be the very paradigms of this new religion are the ones who first of all show the greatest lack of faith, not a great start, not exactly engendering an enthusiasm for this new religion, is it? Unless, of course, it's true. Because the reality is that in about 40 days' time, these very same cowering disciples are going to be standing up in the very place where they are, in the region of Jerusalem, and proclaiming, despite severe persecution, and despite the fact that many of them will go to their death for this, that Jesus did indeed rise from the dead, that his body was never found, that the women were right, that they were wrong.
13:31 They're going to do a complete 180. The disciples didn't believe, but then they changed. And I wonder if, like me, you enjoy reading biographies. The one thing I notice about biographies is that unless the biographer is trying to critique the person, if the biographer has any sympathy for the person they are writing about, he or she almost always shaves the facts just a little, right? The negative side of things are downplayed, the positive side of things, a bit of historical hagiography. It's kind of, you know, what we all do. Now, if you think we do that today in the modern world, you'd read some of the ancient biographies. In an honor-shame culture, whitewashing people's faults and overstating their virtues was essential, particularly within a patriarchal structure. So again, there was nothing like this. The raw honesty, the truthfulness, the sheer curious factual nature of this account, the curious nature of the resurrection. Here's how C.S. Lewis summed it on his own journey of curiosity that led him to amazement and wonder. He wrote, I have been reading poems, romances, vision literature, legends and myths all my life.
14:45 I know what they're like. I know none of them are like this. Of this text, there are only two possible views. Either this is reportage, or else some unknown writer without known predecessors or successors suddenly anticipated the whole technique of modern novelistic realistic narrative. The reader who doesn't see this has simply not learned how to read. I mean, he was a little bit blunter than I would care to be then, right? He is English after all. The curiosity of the resurrection, curious facts. The wonder of the resurrection then. If those facts are curious, then let it lead you on an arc as you investigate it. And let me explain to you or maybe outline to you at least three implications of this that I think are truly wonderful. The first one, wherever you're coming from this morning, if these facts really are true, if they are as stubbornly historical as they claim to be, then let the facts of the resurrection argue with your doubts. This is true of us wherever we're coming from. It may be you're here this morning and this is the first time you've ever looked at this or ever heard about this. It's great you're here and please follow a path of curiosity.
15:54 It may be you're a person here this morning who, like almost every believer I've ever known, finds yourself wondering whether this is really true. Don't think that all of us won't be standing there on that last day when we see the risen Lord Jesus face-to-face, elbowing each other, rather subtly saying, I can't believe it's true. Not because we ever fully doubted, but because full certainty of faith is elusive. We don't have a perfect perspective. we can never know all the facts. And so a thoughtful person will always be able to doubt. That's why Christianity never eschews doubt, but rather encourages us to engage with our doubts. So here, let the facts of the resurrection argue with your doubts. You must not think that the disciples were kind of inherently gullible people. When I became a Christian, a number of my friends, you know, I think rather kindly would say to me things like, oh, I wish I had your faith.
16:52 And I tried to think what they kind of meant by that. And I came to the conclusion that what they meant was that faith is a kind of virtue or quality that some people have. and other people just don't have it. A bit like being taller than six foot. Some people just are taller than six foot, some people aren't. And short of, I don't know, stretching yourself out or something on a rack, you're never going to change that. And so under that view, Jesus kind of walked along the Sea of Galilee trying to choose his disciples. and he came across certain people too rationalistic, too thoughtful, too curious, too skeptical. Ah, here's a person who leaves their brain at the door. Come, follow me. You have faith. That's not what Jesus did. The disciples were not inherently gullible. We need to be careful not to engage in chronological snobbery. The disciples were people who were hard-nosed, blue-collar workers for the whole and asked tough questions. And that's initially why they didn't believe thinking it was some kind of nonsense or fairy tale. So what changed? The facts changed them. And that is always the journey of faith. Wherever you're coming from this morning, if you're asking good questions, the truth will out. Jesus loves a good seeker, whether you're seeking for the first time or whether you're seeking for the hundredth time. Ask good questions and let the facts argue with your doubts that this really happened and you can be as certain as Jesus' is resurrection in space, time, and history. As Jeff said at the beginning of the service, it's not like being Alice in Wonderland and believing 10 impossible things before breakfast.
18:27 That's not what we're about. That's not what the Christian faith has ever been about. The facts can argue with your doubts. Implication number two, the wonder of the resurrection can transform your cynicism. Difficult not to be cynical nowadays, isn't it? And I think that cynicism is the kind of thin end of the wedge of despair. And so we want wonder. We want amazement. We want joy. But then we find that that kind of devil crawls on our shoulder and says, wise up. Look around at the world. No such things exist. Don't be taken for a ride. One of my favorite writers who's written about this is Wendell Berry. He writes this. In the year 2000, I published a small book, Life is a Miracle. My friend Charlie Singh has now asked me to deal with the question, is life a miracle, inviting me to defend my title.
19:22 Did I really mean it? Yes, I did. And yes, I do. I mean it. And I mean it practically. I know that humans, including modern biologists, have learned a good deal about living things and about parts of living things. but I don't believe that anybody knows much about the life of living things. I've seen with my own eyes, felt with my own hands many times, the difference between live things and dead ones. And I do not believe that the difference can be so explained as to remove the wonder from it. What is the coherence, the integrity, the consciousness, the intelligence, the spirit, the informing form that leaves a living body when it dies. What was the green fire that old O. Leopold saw going out in the eyes of that dying wolf? When you watch the eyes of the dying, you see that they no longer see. I think a great painter can paint the difference between an eye that is dead and a living eye, but I don't think anybody can explain the difference except by infinite aggression of response to an infinitely repeated question, what was the cause of that cause. To me, he says, as a matter of principle and of belief, life is a miracle.
20:41 I want to believe that. Every fiber of my being wants to believe that. And I think if you're human, you do too. But then does truth get in the way? Cynicism kicks in and say, wow, well, there's nothing but matter. There's no supernatural. We're just human beings. Face up. Those are nice fairy tales. Tell them to the kids to help them sleep well at night, but don't believe them as an adult. Harden up. Otherwise, the city will take you in and take you over. Don't you see? if Jesus Christ really rose from the dead in space, time, and history, it means that your deepest intuition, your deepest longing for wonder, that there is something miraculous, inherently wonderful and joyful and sudden and amazing about life is validated. Because if Jesus rose from the dead, it means that all the other things that you want to believe can be true. It's like the Archimedean point from which you can move that world.
21:39 Suddenly, we know that good will win in the end, not evil. Suddenly, we know that human beings really matter, not because you tell yourself over and over again that you matter, despite evidence to the contrary, but because there's a God in heaven who shows you that you matter beyond your wildest dreams. There's a God who loves you. There's a God who's in control of your life. There's a God who will work through all things to redeem you. and the creation at the end of it all. Don't you see? If the resurrection is true, life really is wonderful. How do you explain the miracle that Wendell Berry points to? The resurrection enables you to believe that. And the third and final implication, the truth and wonder of resurrection mean everything will be all right in the end. You and I know that it's tough sometimes to look at the news in today's day and age. You see the wars, rumors of wars, Actually, we sometimes just look around our own lives and we see the conflict and the problems that we face.
22:37 I don't know where you're coming from this morning. In a crowd this size, there'll be a number who are drawing in many painful experiences. Maybe life is not working out for you the way you want it in the city. Maybe someone you care about is struggling with a sudden diagnosis. Maybe you are, and you're perplexed and full of questions. Maybe you've made some bad choices and you're estranged from those you love and you want to know that there's reconciliation, but it seems an intractable difference now remains. There can be so many problems we're facing, and in the midst of it all, that childlike desire to know that in the end it will all be made okay is there. What do we do with that? Well, don't you see? If Jesus Christ really rose from the dead, then it means you can believe that with certainty. Why? Well, because Jesus took the worst. He took the worst of the world. He took shame. He took mockery.
23:30 He took the oppression of a state over a minority. He took death. He took torture. He took it all. He took the worst that the world has to throw at him. He was crucified on Good Friday. And then three days later, he walked out of the tomb like none of it had happened. Actually wrong, not like none of it had happened, like none of it would define him because there was a true and better and greater story. that he was coming out the other side. And because he has risen from the dead, it means that mistakes don't define you. It means that there is a God in heaven who will forgive you. And it means that one day this whole world will be renewed and will be just as real and tangible as Jesus' resurrection from the dead. The thought of the afterlife to me always felt like a consolation prize. Maybe it's because I love sport. Maybe it's because I love food. I wanted a physical reality. Well, the resurrection says that the future that awaits us all is a physical resurrection.
24:28 All things made new, just like Jesus risen from the dead. And if that's true, then that means that life really is wonderful. And in the end, all will be wonderful. I need to believe that. That energizes my labors, that sustains my faith, and that gives me grace in the conflict. May it do so for you too. Let me lead us in a prayer. Heavenly Father, thank you for this message from Luke. Thank you for his care in writing down these facts and being a historian of the first degree who carefully investigates everything and then writes them down that we might have certainty of the things we believe. Lord, wherever we're coming from this morning, we need to believe this. This needs to be the fuel that energizes us, Lord, and that sends us out into the world with curiosity renewed and with wonder being fostered. Oh Lord, please help us to believe this, I pray, wherever we're coming from, for Jesus' sake.
Machine translated from the source