The Politics of the Kingdom

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached November 1, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Mark 15:1-3 0:30
1Early in the morning, the chief priests, elders, scribes, and the whole Sanhedrin devised a plan. They bound Jesus, led Him away, and handed Him over to Pilate. 2So Pilate questioned Him, “Are You the King of the Jews?” “You have said so,” Jesus replied. 3And the chief priests began to accuse Him of many things.

Berean Standard Bible.

Scripture reading: Mark 15:9-15 1:37
9“Do you want me to release to you the King of the Jews?” Pilate asked. 10For he knew it was out of envy that the chief priests had handed Jesus over. 11But the chief priests stirred up the crowd to have him release Barabbas to them instead. 12So Pilate asked them again, “What then do you want me to do with the One you call the King of the Jews?” 13And they shouted back, “Crucify Him!” 14“Why?” asked Pilate. “What evil has He done?” But they shouted all the louder, “Crucify Him!” 15And wishing to satisfy the crowd, Pilate released Barabbas to them. But he had Jesus flogged, and handed Him over to be crucified.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:31 Amen. Thank you, Amaral. All right, there we go. Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. Politics is one of the main reasons that people walk away from the church. It's one of the main reasons why people stay away from the church. About half of Americans who have no religion, who've walked away, say that it's because of the positions that the church has on social and political issues. And it's one of the main things that says it's ongoing. That's why we don't even want to talk about it. or be involved. Many folks see the church as just a vehicle for power. It's a vehicle to try to claim and use and be wielded and wield power.

3:29 The irony, though, is that a lot of Americans, even though they might have left the church because it was too political, because it was about power, they thought they left religion, but they didn't actually leave faith. Because there's now a new faith, a political faith. Political scientist Shadid Hamid said this. He said this in the Atlantic. He said, as Christianity's hold has weakened, ideological intensity and fragmentation has risen. What was once religious belief has now been channeled into political belief. We've been going through a series looking at various doubts that people have about Christianity. And this is another big one that we have to talk about, about politics. but people need to realize that inside politics, there's a new type of religion that has its own heretics, its own saints, its own praise and excommunication apparatuses.

4:31 The only thing that's not there is forgiveness. But why do we care so much about politics? I think we care about politics because I think somewhere in all of us, we know the world isn't the way it's supposed to be. And we want to see change. We want to see things different. But the assumption is, is that if we're going to get that change, it's going to happen by climbing up and grabbing power. That's why it's not surprising that when Jesus, for the first time, stands before the government, Pilate is a Roman governor. When he shows up, the first thing that they want to know is what kind of power do you have? Are you here to seize political power? That's what Pilate is trying to figure out. And he's kind of asking the questions that we have that might be even though we might have more theological or intellectual questions, there's questions underneath that, which is what kind of power do you have? What can you bring to change the world?

5:32 How do we relate to politics? How do we relate to these things? So when I want to look at our text, I want to use this text to see three movements of power. The first one is seize. It's the power that we want. The second one is silence. It's the power that he refuses. And the third one is swap, the power he spends. So seize, silence, swap. So first one is seize. Go to verse 1 here. And by the way, the first letter of verse 1 is the word very. It's the, we got cut off here in our bulletin. But in verse 1, the room, you need to see three parties in this room. The room is filled with three groups. There's the religious, there's the government, and there's the people. The religious are the chief priests, the elders, and teachers. The people is the crowd, and the government is Pilate. But each one of them is reaching for power in their own way.

6:28 And I want to walk through those. The first one, the religious leaders, right before this text, this is chapter 15, the chapter right before, the religious leaders brought religious accusations to Jesus and condemn them. But here they switch away from a religious condemnation and they give Jesus a political charge. That's why Pilate says in verse 2, are you king of the Jews? They couldn't execute as religious leaders. And so what they're doing is they're going to Rome and trying to use Rome to do their dirty work. Hence, again, the king of the Jews title. In verse 10, by the way, tells us why. If you look closely, it says, knowing it was out of, Pilate knew that it was knowing it was out of self-interest that the chief priest had handed Jesus over. That word in Greek, self-interest, is actually the word envy. They were envious. Now, why were they envious? Because Jesus had the crowd.

7:26 And often the case is that when religion can't win the hearts of the people, they'll borrow swords to make it happen. That's what history has shown us. Now, if you're like, oh yeah, you know, that's exactly why I have a problem with religion, right? Down with religion. Yeah, but look what the government does. Pilate is also reaching for power too. Look what he does. He, in verse 14, knows that Jesus is innocent. Verse 14 says, why am I doing this? What crime has he actually committed?

8:00 Pilate knew that Jesus was innocent, and yet in verse 15, the satisfy the crowd, it says, he releases a known murderer and condemns an innocent man just to save his own neck, just because it was politically expedient. That's a power grab. Now you go, oh, yeah, okay, well, down with the government too. But there's a third party here, the crowd. Some of the people in this crowd, commentaries point this out, were the same people five days before that were welcoming Jesus into Jerusalem with branches shouting, you know, Hosanna, Hosanna in the highest. Basically saying, you're our king, you're our king. And now they want Barabbas, a known insurrectionist, revolutionary instead of Jesus. Why?

8:52 Because in five days, they must have figured out that Jesus is going to give them what they want. They want, ultimately they wanted to be saved from Rome. They didn't want to be saved from themselves. And if Jesus wasn't going to do it for them, maybe Barabbas would. And so everybody in this room is seizing. Look at the fact that the priests and Pilate are trying to seize power by holding on to what they have. And Barabbas and the crowd are trying to take power because they don't have it. And instead of just, you know, looking at this historical account and saying, okay, well, that's them back then. Today is no different. Every single modern political ideology is another type of counterfeit salvation story. To depict this, George Packer, he's a writer, lists out four different Americas that are currently in existence right now. and each of them takes something good but elevates it as savior and then looks at another party and deems them as the problem, as the devil.

9:57 Two of them lean right and two of them lean left. One, this is his taxonomy, one he says is free America, where the savior is the market, and therefore the demon, the devil is the big government that's trying to stop the free markets. Then you have also real America. Real America basically says the savior is the motherland, but then the demon, the devil, is the elite and the outsiders. The two that lean left are smart America where the Savior is the expert in science, but the demon, the devil, is any kind of traditional religion or view of, you know, the family. Then you also have, lastly, you have the just America where the Savior is the state and the demon is any kind of group that keeps power concentrated. where it already is.

10:56 Because the way that we're going to solve the world is down with the powerful. Notice each one of them have a Barabbas. They each have a savior, a champion, who will beat back the threat. And instead of just sort of intellectualizing, going, okay, this is sort of the makeup of America today, I want you to ask a question. Who is your Barabbas? It might not actually be who you politically vote for. It might be who you want to see lose because then, by them losing, you win.

11:30 Who do we want to see lose so then we win? Where their downfall would feel like a victory. Where their loss is our win. And it doesn't have to be political. It could be a colleague that you want to see lose. A relative. Maybe somebody who used to be a friend. Maybe somebody that you just despise. Who is that for you? And the reason why their loss feels like a gain is because then guess what? They're the evil ones, and if they get to be the evil ones, guess who we get to be? We get to be the good ones.

12:07 Tell me who you want to see lose, and I'll tell you who you're hoping to actually win. because if you can point out the evil in them, then you never have to actually deal or face with the evil in us. I think that's one of our main problems is that if you can point out their evil, then you don't have to actually ever face your own. We're so good at that. Our country is so good at trying to point out the wrong in other people so we never have to look at the wrong inside of us. But I want us to ask a deeper question. Does that actually work? Go back to our text. Let's see how it worked out for these guys. If you look at our text, the people pulling for power, let's go to the priest. The priest, they go to the sword to get rid of Jesus because they're trying to protect the temple. But if you look at the historical accounts, 40 years later, Rome burned that temple down to the ground.

13:05 The crowd, what did they want? They wanted Barabbas. They get him. And they actually get their revolution. They get their riot. but then Rome crushes it as well. Pilate kills an innocent man to keep his job, and the historical accounts say that actually within a couple years, he loses his job anyway. In other words, none of them actually worked.

13:34 Seizing power can give you a win, but it can't give you what you ultimately want. How many times have you been like, I want that promotion, and now you have more stress? How many times have you actually won the argument, but then you lost a friend? How many times have you gotten the power move that you wanted, and it actually ended up? making your life worse

14:28 What if the problem was never who holds the sword, it's how you wield it? What if the problem isn't just who has power, but how we actually hold it? Go back to our scene here, and what's so interesting, we just detailed all these other people, there is another party here. The only person not seizing power is Jesus.

14:54 Why? Why? All right, point two, silence. Pilate hands Jesus two openings to grab for power. Let's look at both of those. The first one is in verse 2. And Jesus refuses. In verse 2 he says, are you king of the Jews? He's giving him an open platform to defend himself. And just to be clear, this isn't a theological question. Again, he's trying to assess political threats. He's trying to figure out, are you going to be a problem for Rome? and Jesus' answer is so interesting you could study this phrase and think out the implications for days and days and days. Jesus' answer, it says here, is you have said so. in Greek it's actually just two Greek words it's, let me find where it is in Greek it's su leges Sue you, Legez, say, you say.

15:59 He's not saying no. He's not saying yes. It would be so easy for him to say, no, no, no, no, no. I'm not political at all. I'm just a spiritual leader. I'm here to hug and love. He doesn't say no. He also doesn't say yes. I am 100% a political leader here to take over the state. I'm coming to get you. He doesn't do that. Pilate wants him to pick one. We want him to pick one. You know why? Because a Jesus that you can peg is a Jesus you can use. And he refuses you and I that pleasure. He refuses to be pegged. Jesus actually does something very similar three chapters before this. People try to trap him with taxes. And he takes that Roman coin. And you know what he says? He says, listen, give unto Caesar, Caesar, but give what is God, God's.

16:57 Right? Give back to Caesar what is Caesar and to God what is God's. And by saying that statement, he is doing something radical. What he's doing, where people think that there's a binary, you have to pick one. Where's your allegiance going to be? He pushes back and says, no, no, no. You can be involved politically. You should pay your taxes. don't pull out of society, but render to God what is God's. Which means this, don't you dare agree with everything a government or a party actually says, because God and Caesar are going to be in conflict somewhere.

17:39 Now, a lot of people, you know what, I guess I confess this myself, a lot of people just say, well, then my answer is going to be apolitical. But you know what? Christians can't be apolitical because being apolitical is a vote for the status quo. And Christians know you can't vote for the status quo because there's always something in this world that should change. We know it's not okay. But even though we have to vote, we can't swallow the package deal that any particular ideology is pushing because there is some place Caesar and the government is going to be off. Sorry, Caesar and God's going to be off. They are not synonymous. Therefore, we should be the first to point out where our side might be wrong. We should be the first to be able to admit it. And if we can't admit it, then it's possible you're being too uncritical about the platforms that you hold. You see, the Bible is very clear that we must love and care and support the poor and the immigrant that are in our midst.

18:43 And yet it also says our bodies and morality are not subjective devices. You can't do whatever you want with them. And yet those views push against the political ideologies that are in this country right now. They cut against the fabric of what it means to be a Christian. And therefore, we need to realize that and say it. Jesus refused to be put in a political box. And I want to argue that you should too. It doesn't mean that you are apolitical. It doesn't mean there's not at any given moment in history, something that you, some platform or some policy that you feel like needs to be applied. But in your wisdom, you need to be able to also say, but this is what I don't align with. I think that's really hard for us because it's either all or nothing.

19:38 and we need to be careful. How often do we pump our fists when the Bible critiques the other side, but then when it's ours, we kind of are either blind to what Jesus is saying about our tribe, or we don't even want to acknowledge it. That's the first thing Jesus refuses. Now, the second thing he refuses, look at verse four, is the priests hurl accusations at him and Pilate says, aren't you gonna answer? aren't you going to answer? He's giving him a second opportunity, and Jesus doesn't. And it says in verse 5, that made Pilate amazed. Why was he amazed? He was amazed because Pilate only understood one type of power, the power to force you to do something that you don't want to do, a power of external compliance and force. By the way, Jesus could have.

20:33 He could have snapped his fingers. He actually says this to Peter in another passage. He says, hey, I can set my fingers and have legions of angels to do my bidding, and he doesn't do it. Why? Because political power can compel the will, but it can't change the heart.

20:54 It can compel the will, but it can't change the heart. If all problems were just external, if they were just outside, then yes, some policy or law might fix it. But let's actually test this out. Let's pretend you are a king or queen of the world. I like that. Of the whole world. And every policy that you want to enact, you can enact. Could you enact a policy against resentment?

21:23 Could you enact a policy against anxiety? No. Of course you can't. The reason why is because law can restrain you, but it can stop the results of a messed up heart, but it can't actually stop the root causes of why our hearts are messed up. We have laws against murder. That's a good thing. But those laws can't stop the root of why we want to murder.

21:52 We have laws to be able to restrain, but we can't use laws to actually stop the very reason why we do what's wrong. So go back to our text. Look at these people. The chief priests, culturally, they had the highest morals. Everybody thought they were great. And yet, it says in verse 10, their hearts were full of envy.

22:12 Pilate had the civil law, the highest moral order in civil space, and yet he was still ruled by fear of the masses. In other words, against envy and fear and anger and joylessness and pride and selfishness, politics and policies can restrain what comes out of us, but they can't stop. They can't actually stop where they come from. You have to understand this. Force can change what you do, but it can't actually change what you want. what Jesus is saying therefore here existentially is that your problems are not just external Yes, there are evil outside. Yes, there are things that we need to do out in the world, but there's also evil in you. And no political correction is going to be able to fix that. And so without Jesus, the risk is that we will use politics to try to do what only God can do.

23:12 We'll use one of those four political ideologies. and unknowingly will make one of them a God. Will make the market a God if you're a conservative. Will make the state a God if you're liberal. If, you know, plug and play, and that's what ends up happening. That's why Jesus stays silent. He could have out-argued them, and he actually does when he's in the Sanhedrin, but he doesn't do it here. He doesn't defend himself because if he had won the argument in the trial, he would have lost their hearts. So how does he actually win the heart? Last point, the swap. Mark does something I've never seen here before, but until I had to study this passage. He uses a word, peridomi. Peridomi means handed over, and he uses it over and over and over again. Look at verse 1.

24:06 He says that the council handed over Jesus to Pilate. Then in verse 10, it says, the priest handed him over. Verse 15, Pilate hands him over to be crucified. It's like Mark is trying to like shout at us, hello, see this. You need to see this, that there is an exchange happening. There is a swap happening. And it's not just, oh, interesting idea. This is core to the narrative of Jesus. and the swap is probably for Barabbas and Barabbas is an Aramaic word. It's a compound word. Bar means son and Abbas, Abba means father. So it means son of the father, which I can't believe that's a coincidence that the son of the father, Barabbas, is released because the true son of the father dies in his place.

25:06 I've tried to, in recent years, put myself in Barabbas' shoes, try to imagine what it would have been like to be him. In prison, you hear people screaming outside, crucify him. You think they're talking about you. The jailers come downstairs, they open your door, you think they're taking you out to kill you, and they cut your bonds and release you out into the daylight. And you see some other guy being put into shackles. and being led away. And I wonder if he ever wondered. I wondered if he ever said, wait a second, that guy over there, he's getting the cross that I deserve. That guy over there, those nails were for me. He's bearing my cross. He's taking my death. And that's when you realize, wait a second, that's actually what belief in Jesus really means. At the end of the day, it's to recognize the swap.

26:06 It's to say, that's my cross. That's my death. And letting that sink into who you are. And when you do, that swap changes you. I think too often people think oh okay, Michael's just telling me I need to intellectually believe that God loves me and therefore I need to try hard to live the right life folks, that's still coercive power you're trying to jury rig your heart it doesn't work you change when you see him, not in general, but very specifically, look at you and say, every fib that you've done, every lie, every spin of truth, every place where you should have and could have done what is right and good and you don't.

27:07 And by the way, you can do this with your goodness. You obviously can do it with your badness. but you can take that goodness and wield it destructively. He takes every single one of those things and dies for them. Force never melts a heart, but seeing the fact that he willingly and wanted to die for you.

27:31 When you realize that you're not just a third party looking at this text, when you realize you're a pilot, it. You're trying to save your own neck every single day. You're the crowd who's out for blood. You're the religious leaders who actually take your goodness and wield it as a weapon against other people. When you realize that's you. and yet Jesus Christ dies for that. He goes down so that we can come up out of the prison. That's when you're changed. The only way to become a Christian is to give up all pretension. that you have any kind of superiority, that you are morally better than anyone else. Salvation comes to those who admit they need it, period.

28:21 That's it. That's how it comes. That's when you get grace. That's when you get change. When you name the sins of your life and you can do it without any kind of being compelled or being crushed because you know the cross has already paid for it, that's when you're changed. A heart that already knows it's loved doesn't need anyone else to lose.

28:50 That's it. That's how we can move into these political spaces, that's how we move out into the world, because if your heart already knows it's love, then you don't need other people to lose. This is what the gospel makes in our lives. You know, last quick interesting tidbit here. Most people don't point this out, but Pilate never would have let Barabbas out if he actually thought that he was a real threat. Have you thought about that? He would not have actually put him out if he thought it was a real threat. So why wasn't Barabbas a threat? It's because what's the worst thing that you can do if you're Barabbas? You just create a riot. And if you want to solve a political fight, you just bring a bigger sword.

29:34 Barabbases are easy to deal with. But how do you stop a king whose weapon was dying for his enemies? You can't outpower Jesus. Right? He already gave it away. You can't kill him. he already gave his life voluntarily you can't outgun him and you can't outman him and that's why the power that Jesus wields is a completely revolutionary type of power because he has it by giving it away and when we make that the core of who we are we will do the same thing if he is your king does your life emulate his that if he put enemies at the core of his life and died for them, do you do the same thing? That would change how you use your politics. That would change how you use your life. And we've got to move out in a world of service and love.

30:32 Do you serve others the way he serves you? Start. You can start with anyone. The people closest to you, the people in need, the people in your family or friends, the church just outside. And there's just so many ways to do it. Maybe my favorite is being curious. Jesus asked over 300 questions. By some things, the direct questions he was asked, I think somebody counted like, he may have actually answered three directly. 300 questions over the four gospels. He didn't need the information. He knew all the information. He did it for connection. Do, one thing you could do today is, can you ask more questions? Because questions let others into your life and you into theirs. You can start with a very simple prayer.

31:25 Lord, give me a sense of your love, a deep sense. Help me to know how you love me so that I can go out and love the world. If today you find yourself sad and lonely or scared or frustrated, the cross doesn't make those feelings go away, but it does give us a powerful place to experience the love of Jesus. Don't just let it hit your heart. Let it move. Sorry, don't let it just hit your head. Let it move into your heart. Let's pray. Heavenly Father. and this is a hard topic because it takes so much effort to not be co-opted into package deals and yet to also not just be apathetic and push all the way away I confess it is easy to be either or and yet here you are saying you say help us to have the balance that you do. Help us to realize that we can do the best job that we can with what we have, that we can look around and say, here's my wisdom, here's what I think the world needs.

32:37 And yet at the same time, know and be okay with the fact that ultimately we need you to come into our life. We need a powerful outpouring of your spirit. And us personally, but in the world as a whole. Move in our lives. Give us the wisdom needed. We pray these things in your name.

Machine translated from the source