When the Algorithm Knows You Better Than You Do

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached September 27, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Psalms 139:2-18 0:32
2You know when I sit and when I rise; You understand my thoughts from afar. 3You search out my path and my lying down; You are aware of all my ways. 4Even before a word is on my tongue, You know all about it, O LORD. 5You hem me in behind and before; You have laid Your hand upon me. 6Such knowledge is too wonderful for me, too lofty for me to attain. 7Where can I go to escape Your Spirit? Where can I flee from Your presence? 8If I ascend to the heavens, You are there; if I make my bed in Sheol, You are there. 9If I rise on the wings of the dawn, if I settle by the farthest sea, 10even there Your hand will guide me; Your right hand will hold me fast. 11If I say, “Surely the darkness will hide me, and the light become night around me”— 12even the darkness is not dark to You, but the night shines like the day, for darkness is as light to You. 13For You formed my inmost being; You knit me together in my mother’s womb. 14I praise You, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Marvelous are Your works, and I know this very well. 15My frame was not hidden from You when I was made in secret, when I was woven together in the depths of the earth. 16Your eyes saw my unformed body; all my days were written in Your book and ordained for me before one of them came to be. 17How precious to me are Your thoughts, O God, how vast is their sum! 18If I were to count them, they would outnumber the grains of sand; and when I awake, I am still with You.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:18 Amen. All right. Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. Today we get to a topic that I did my PhD on. I did stuff on computational linguistics, so it was sort of the stuff before AI became AI. And it's sort of the thing everyone's talking about, and it's making us ask questions. Like, for instance, for all you here, are you anti-AI or are you pro-AI? Which one are you? Right now, everybody's somewhere on that spectrum. More than a quarter of Americans right now, online, have a personal and emotional conversation. every day with an AI chatbot. A third of them call that chatbot a friend, and 40% of them answer this question positively. They say, AI understands me better than most. 40%.

3:22 AI understands me better than most. The Harvard Business Review that's been tracking how we use AI for the past couple years, for two years in a row, the number one way that we use AI is for therapy and companionship, which means we are not just using this technology to help us complete our work faster. We're actually asking it to help us complete us. We've always used technology, by the way, to outsource, to offload labor, right? We've done that with the wheel. We've done that with the calculator. We do that. But with AI, we've started to outsource what we think, what we want, what we feel, and who we are. Now, I'm a history nerd. That's what I studied in college.

4:16 And I love trying to figure out how did people live back then? Where did they go? What did they do? And it's sort of a mystery because there's so little evidence about what people were like. What you need to know is everybody in this room, you are actually the most tracked person in the world. Like our generation, we are the most tracked, documented human ever. Because why? Because every click, every search, your phone, your location is being stored forever and ever and ever. and it's feeding a profile of precisely who you are. Everything is known about you. And yet what's so interesting is that we live in a culture where people are reporting that we're knowing ourselves less and less.

5:10 We're known about us, but we don't know ourselves. And so some folks are like, well, don't, this isn't an issue for me. I'm anti-AI. I've opted out of all that stuff. But the statistics say that actually you might not have the problem with the AI, but you do have a very similar problem. Statistically, Americans as a whole are more and more lonely. Most Americans report they have three or fewer friends, and every year that number is decreasing more. Most of us, yeah, they say they're lonely. But not just that. The office might know part of you. Your friends might know part of you. Nobody knows all of you. In fact, there's a lot of things about you that you don't want known by anyone. And the problem with that, again, no matter where you are on that spectrum of anti-AI or pro-AI, the problem with that is that everyone needs to be both fully known and fully loved.

6:10 And yet no one has that. No one has both. One or the other, not both. And so the real question, I believe, under all the sort of AI anxiety is how will we be fully known and how will we be fully loved at the same time when machines are knowing us more and more and other people are knowing us less and less? That's the environment, that's the world that we're living in right now. And so I want to look at our text today and see how it might help us. Let's look at it through three lenses and look at the problem, the promise, and the price. Today we're going to look at the problem, the promise, and the price. So first, the problem. The problem, and I'm going to just come out and say it from the very beginning, the problem isn't technology in and of itself. It's how we use technology. And we're using it to get one of two things. We're using it to either be known or loved.

7:03 Everything we've ever built to cure loneliness gives us one or the other. And let me show you what I mean by that. Let's first look at love but not known. How do we get love but not known? Well, in New York City, the way you get loved is what you produce. There's a reason why in this town, the first question that's asked of every single one of you is almost always, what do you do? That's one of the questions we almost always say to each other. What do you do? Why? Because in this town, you are what you do. You are what you produce. and so if you want to get applause what the world, what this city has told you the way to get an applause is through your output but there's a sneaking suspicion I believe all of us actually have and that's this, they're not actually applauding you they're applauding what you're putting out right, they're not actually they applaud, you think that they're actually saying they might know your name, but they don't actually know you.

8:02 they're applauding what you do but it's not necessarily all of who you are. But that's what we still do. We still put ourselves in that. And yet, they might know your name, but they don't really know you. Even the people who do love us, I would argue that they don't actually know all of us. They know a version of us. You can be married to somebody or you can have a best friend and you know deep down, you know that they know the version of you, but they know the fun person of you, but they don't know the sad, the depressed, the like fallen apart version because you haven't let them see that because you know that if you do, they wouldn't be able to handle it.

8:49 They wouldn't be able to handle it. and so you lock down, this is what we do, we lock down being loved but not known, but here's the problem with that, when you're loved and not known, that's actually not real love, it's superficial love, it's thin, it's lovely, it's feeling-ly, but it's not actually real love, so that's what happens when you are loved but not known, the other one is known but not loved, What's that? Your phone knows you, right? AI knows you. And we let it, why? Because sometimes it actually really does help. It does work. It sees everything and demands nothing. What do I mean by that? It will never demand for you to repent and apologize to it. Right? It has omniscience without lordship. It knows everything, but it actually can love nothing. Researchers in British Columbia, this is just a couple months ago, I think in April, 2026, they, what they did was, is they took lonely freshmen, and they said to these lonely freshmen, half of them, we want you to message an empathy bot. We want you to message a bot that you can message them as long, as much as you want for, for two weeks. And then the other group, their goal was to message just a complete stranger on campus and text with that stranger. And what they found was actually the bot showed and gave more empathy than the human stranger. It actually gave more empathy, but the stranger helped loneliness more. And the reason why is because students didn't just need to feel and receive empathy, they needed the chance to be able to give it to not feel lonely. And I find that endlessly fascinating.

10:39 Because this is what it means. It means there's something about personhood. It's not just about you receiving and you getting. It's not just having no demands on your life. It's actually having a demand actually makes you feel more alive. So to get loneliness, you just don't need to be affirmed and stuff. You actually need to be given the opportunity to love and serve someone else. And guess what? You can't do that with a bot. You can't do that with a predictive algorithmic text string because it doesn't need you and it doesn't actually know you. So here's what happens that you can't be loved by something that you can't hurt. You can't be loved by something you can't hurt. You can be known, it can know you, It can even affirm you.

11:32 We have data on that. But not loved. Being known but not loved by a person. For everybody in this room is actually our biggest, scariest fear. And I think what we've done with this technology is we've built something that can't. That won't ever walk away. And by the way, if you think this is a problem with technology, again, I don't think it is. I think it's something about the human condition. This is where a lot of folks will say, oh, I know what the pastor is going to say. The pastor is up here and he's going to say, ah, turn to God, go to religion, and that's going to be the thing that's going to like fix you. But this is why I want to go to our text here. Because in our text, King David is not comforted by God. He's not comforted. He's actually overwhelmed by it. Look at verse 1. He says, you have searched me, God, and you know me. There it is.

12:24 You know me. And let's go down to verse 6. Such knowledge is too wonderful for me. Too lofty for me. Now a lot of folks read that and go, oh, he's saying, isn't it wonderful? Isn't it wonderful? Actually, in the Hebrew, that phrase, too wonderful, is the word overwhelmed. It's the word shattering. It's the word terrifying.

12:49 In other words, he's saying, you know everything and I can't actually take it. It's too much. I can't bear it. the gaze of God, the idea that for a lot of folks, that there is a God out there who sees and knows everything is really difficult for us. That's why he moves on in verse 7. He says, where can I flee? Where can I go from your spirit? And then go down to verse 11 and 12. He's like, I wish surely the darkness will hide me. He's hoping for something to cover him. You say, well, what's wrong with being fully known? Think about it. every dirty thought, every bit of selfishness, every bit of self-centeredness, every meanness. Also, by the way, everything that the world might categorize as actually good, but deep down, you know you did that to center yourself. Call it pride. Call it self-service. You're so good at it that you've convinced other people that it's actually good when it's really not.

13:47 A fully known being can see that too. That information, if the world actually knew, would ruin us. That power, that has power over you. And so this isn't a technology problem because even before God, David doesn't want that. He doesn't want what we, he's just like us. So what does he do? He wants to turn, he wants to hide. So before we move on, ask yourself this. Today, where might you be running and hiding?

14:23 You're like, I'm not running and hiding. I'm sitting right here. Yeah, but where might you be running and hiding? How? Why do you overwork? Have you ever asked yourself that question? Why is it that you don't put the right boundaries around things so that you sleep enough, so that you have community enough, so that you have relationships?

14:44 Why is that? Why is it that you can never say no? I think at some deep level is we're still trying to be loved without being fully known. through what we do, through our career, through being mom, through being dad, through some success out there. Or, all right, next question then.

15:05 Why are some of you so afraid of commitment? Why are you so afraid of being honest with yourself that you don't wanna ask those deeper questions? Why are you so afraid of letting other people know those things? I'll tell you why. It's because you don't wanna be known because you're afraid of not being loved. I wish we'd be honest with ourselves New Yorkers is so funny We always say we're so honest We tell the truth Many times over my life Growing up in this town I thought that's who I was and then I realized I'm just a person who hides like everyone else. Because we're terrified of being known and not loved And so what happens is If we settle for being predicted It feels better At least this context With all these 70 billion parameters lets me be able to kind of get things done and it makes me more efficient. But folks, you were not made to be predicted. You were made to be loved and known.

16:33 So, where can we get both? All right, that's the problem. The promise. David is afraid. Being known by God, right, in the early verses. But then, if you keep going, something interesting happens. Look at verse 8 through 10. 8 through 10, David tries going where? He tries to go up to heaven, like the heavens, metaphorically. He tries to go down into the depths. Look what he says in verse 9. He says, if I rise on the wings of the dawn, if I settle on the far side of the sea, what does he find there? Does he say, oh, I see God is like the eye of Sauron staring down at me. Is that what he says? No. Look at verse 10. In verse 10 it says, even there your hand will guide me. Your right hand will hold me fast.

17:22 I hope you can see this. David's tone has changed. Not the knowledge of God. The knowledge that God has in verse 1 is the same knowledge God has in verse 10. But what's changed is what David sees God doing with that knowledge. Our greatest fear, right, is that God would see everything and then use it to exploit us. Right? That's our greatest fear. Why is that our fear? Because that's what companies do. I was told once that if something is free on the internet, it means you're the product. That means Gmail is not free, folks. It's not. Because that data is what makes companies billions and billions of dollars. They know you and they sell you. And so we know that's actually how the world works. But what if, folks, what if God uses all that knowledge not to exploit you, but to take care of you? See, I think David, he gets there.

18:22 And the key place where he finally gets there is verse 13. Go to the verse 13 for a second. The most important word in the entire text is actually the first word here, for. Because he's summarizing, for, because, verses 1 through 12, for, you created my innermost being. You knit me together in my mother's womb. And folks, we don't have time to go into the theological implications of this verse and what it means in regards to the sanctity of life. and abortion and all that. If you wanna ask those questions, that's why we have Q&R after the service, please do so. But let me say this for now. God's knowledge isn't a threat because it's not surveillance, it's authorship. That's what David's getting at. When he says, you knew me, right? You knit me in my mother's womb for you created my innermost being.

19:17 An algorithm, what can it do? It can only know you by your trail, what you do. God didn't learn you. He made you. That's what this is saying. He knitted you before there was a trail, before there was a first breath. You know, I've never really knitted, but when I've seen people do it, they are touching every stitch. And those knitters, when they see a snag, when they see something, you know, where it's not working out, when something starts to unravel, you know what they do? They don't throw it away. they hold on to it. The algorithm knows you to sell you. The maker knows you to keep you. And this is what happens in the womb. For this is to happen in the womb. What do I mean by that? Because it happens in the womb before you can know him.

20:10 what's beautiful is it says that you're known before you can know. You're loved before you can love. It was always by grace. It was always that way. through your createdness. Right now, the conversation that I hear in the internet is, what's going to be our worth if AI can do our work? Right? Everybody's talking about that. And the reason why is because culturally here's what's happened. We've defined ourselves by our work. So of course, if something else can do our work, then what does it mean to be you? Everybody's asking that question. And yes, folks, if you are only your output and a machine can do that better than you, then you lose your worth. But look at verse 14. If verse 14 is true, I praise you. Why? Because I am fearfully and wonderfully made. You could do a whole sermon on just that phrase. What does it mean to be fearfully and wonderfully made? It means at least this. Look at how you were knit. Look at it.

21:17 The wonder of just who you are is amazing. Did you know that right now your body is producing two million blood cells every second? That the makeup of who you are, if you were to count every atom, it is 7 billion, billion, billion atoms that make you who you are. The length of your blood vessels, if we were to take those out and string them along from end to end, they would go around the earth two and a half times what's inside of one of you. If we were to take every strand of DNA that's in every cell of your body, and if we were to actually string those out, you know how long that would be? 10 billion miles. Further than Pluto. Literally, what's inside every single one of you could leave the cosmos. That's you. That's how you were made. Every mile, every stitch. And guess what? He was there all along. And so no, you are not, I'm going to look everybody in the eye if I could, you are not the sum total of what you produce.

22:27 You're not. You are made in the image of God, which means you are not just a pattern to be predicted. You are a person to be redeemed. That's the promise. That's the promise that we see here. Let's skip down to verse 18, the last verse. David tries to count God's thoughts and he starts running out of numbers. Where I'd account them, they would outnumber the grains of sand.

22:56 You know, you've done this, hopefully. If you haven't, you should someday. Pick up as much sand as you can. Every single one of those grains that slips through your fingers, God's mindful love is towards you. And it outnumbers every single shore on earth.

23:17 Dwell on that for a while. An algorithm can have a file a mile long, but it's never thought about you. It's never wept over you. It's never delighted in you. only the actual person of God does. And David is feeling that as fully known and fully loved. And he doesn't use the word love. What does he use? He used the word knitted and guided and held by his hand. And the reason why is, and this is a whole other sermon which we don't have time for, love in the Bible is not a feeling. It's not a feeling.

23:55 It's what God does when he knows, not just about you, but he knows you. That's love. That's why it's always action, forming and knitting and guiding and holding and beholding. Of course, all this begs the question, I think, it should. Because the skeptic in this room is probably going to say, yeah, okay, well, if he's the knitter, can't he unknit you? Right? If he's the one who is the maker, he can still unmake you. How is David so secure that the thoughts of God are love and not condemnation?

24:30 And we know David's life was not the cleanest. So last point, the price. David saw another man's wife. And what did he do? He took her. He had her husband killed. He did that to try to cover it all up. Because he didn't want to be known, right? He didn't want to be known. If anybody had reasons to dread being searched and discarded, it would be this man. So how can he, in verse 17, say, how precious to me are your thoughts, Lord? somehow, it has to be through divine revelation, David had a general sense of God's goodness towards him. But I want to argue today that you and I have something much, much greater, a better resource than even he had. And that's that we know the cost. My mother, when she was 12, she wrote a mystery story.

25:25 A lot of people don't know this. She wrote a mystery story and had it published in her school paper. Of course, the editor decided to delete the last paragraph because it was too long, which actually had the solution. So everybody thought that my mother had no idea what she was writing. And she was furious. So you know what she did at 12? She wrote her pen pal. The person that she could reveal her thoughts to, you know who her pen pal was? C.S. Lewis.

25:54 She wrote C.S. Lewis multiple times, four times. about, one time it was about this and he wrote back this phrase, the same sort of thing has happened to me more than once. and there's just not much to do, to be done about it. Because here there's like this old English, you know, gentleman going, yep, sorry, that's what happens, it's happened to me too. But what he's doing in that is he's entering, he's suffering along with her. And biographers have actually pointed this out. C.S. Lewis hated writing letters. If you want to read these, there's a book called Letters to Children by C.S. Lewis. And the last four, Kathy's or my mom, so you can read those letters if you want. He hated writing it, writing these letters. But he did it anyway. And the last letter that he wrote to my mom was actually 11 days before he died. As I think about that this morning, it moves me to know that such a great man would spend his final days taking the time to know and console.

26:55 an obscure 12-year-old girl in America. But if that's so moving, why doesn't it undo me that the Son of God would, at great expense, at the cost of his life, love us. Why doesn't that move us in the same way?

27:18 Some of you are like, well, why did it cost his life? Because when God searches and sees what's in you and me, there's a cost. That's what Romans 5 says, right? While we were sinners, Christ died for us. What does that mean? It's not when we were improving. It's not when we were apologizing. it was when we were actually actively running away to live our own lives because translation, sin is not bad things only. Sin can be anything. Often it's good things that where we prioritize and make those things more important to us than God. And we do that every single day. and if we don't want God, you know what happens? The penalty is that we don't get God, and that's exactly what Jesus got on the cross, is the absence of God.

28:12 To keep from being known, you know what David did? David had an innocent man killed. Uriah died so that David's secret would be kept buried. On the cross, another innocent man died. but he died so that your secrets could be brought to light and forgiven. David covered his sin with the blood of another man. the God of the universe uncovers your sin with the blood of Jesus.

28:45 That's what we have. On the cross, he was fully known and fully rejected so that you and I could be fully known and never fully rejected. Instead, fully loved. So folks see this. The cross is not a symbol of just love. It's the cost of the love. We tend to use technology, including AI, to outsource the risk of being human, to make things more frictionless. The God of the universe did not become less human. He became human in the incarnation. Stop and look at him. The God that you and I cannot flee. is the same God who would not flee from you even at your worst. and folks when you experience that not just in your head but in your heart on a Sunday morning like today when you really really experience that that Jesus lost the presence of God so that if we believe in him we never lose the presence of God if you really get that and you rest in that that's when you know that your outputs or your inputs or your production that that's all who you are that's when you know that whether AI brings prosperity or brings the opposite, which by the way, probably it'll do both.

30:09 That's when you still know that you're known and loved by God. And that changes everything. Real quickly, how? Two things. One, it will change how you value things. Remember when we asked, are the desires that you have right now, are they just, are they actually yours? Are they something that's been sold to you through a predictive algorithm text? How do you know? There's this Disney movie called Ratatouille where at the very end, the food critic Anton Ego spent his life judging food. And when he took a bite of Ratatouille, he's transported back to a moment when he was a child, when his mom, when he was hurt, whenever he needed something, his mom would make this dish. Because there was a way for her to say, I know you and I love you. And he felt that. And when he felt that, he was transformed. If the beauty and bite and experience of a great piece of food can bring warmth and delight, how much more can the love of God, the wonder of God, infinitely bring you more delight and wonder?

31:14 We don't read the Bible and pray to get the love of God. Right? That's not how Christianity works. you read and pray because you already have the love of God and it's found in the person of Jesus and the receipt is the cross. Read and pray to experience and taste the goodness and love of God. Because why? Because we need to remember, we constantly forget over and over and over again. Folks, if today you're like, I don't feel like praying, guess what you can do? Pray about that. You can still go to God about that. The chief end of man is to glorify God and enjoy him forever. and you can't enjoy someone you never sit with. will you do that? Experience this beauty and wonder and it'll change what we value. Now, last thing, stop hiding. When C.S. Lewis answered a 12-year-old girl's letter with immense respect, it made my mother feel seen and known and it reprogrammed the value the world might've had on her because she knew there was someone there who actually saw her.

32:21 When someone sees your smallness and treats you with dignity and respect, it brings you that value. If that's true, and there is one so much greater than C.S. Lewis looking at you, and he's not looking at your resume, he's not looking. at what you produce, what he's looking at is the whole you that he knitted. And he's saying, I knew you in your mother's womb. I formed you.

32:51 So folks, if you're tired, a lot of us are tired this morning, trying to fake the strength, trying to fake what we have, stop hiding. Put down your performances. Put down the disguises. you're safe. If the God of the universe and the person of Jesus is willing to give up everything for you and that actually moves you, do you really have to have that self-pity bout that you had this morning? Do you really have to be mad at that person who didn't give you what you deserve and need? No. That's why you can stop hiding.

33:28 Right? The algorithms can predict your patterns and religion can demand your performance. but only Jesus saw it all, loved you all, and paid it all. the gospel of doom of AI says basically it's going to end everything. And so you show us a despair. And the gospel of the utopia of AI says it's going to fix everything and worship it. one preaches an apocalypse without redemption. The other preaches redemption without needing a redeemer. Both of them are actually vying for your attention. And ironically, you're being sold something through it, through your anxiety, through your hurt. What you need to see. is that the future is not written by a machine. I don't care what anyone else says.

34:24 It's written by the Redeemer. And that means our future is sure, no matter what ends up happening. And so I just implore you, come. The Lord has searched you and seen everything and stayed and loved you. You're not gonna find that anywhere else, not in any human, not in any technology, not in any supplement stack, not in any kind of thing that can be sold to you.

34:53 And today, if you're struggling, I just want you to go back to verse 14. You are fearfully and wonderfully made. How are you feeling today? I am fearfully and wonderfully made. You have anxiety? I am fearfully and wonderfully made. I'm hurting? I am fearfully and wonderfully made. When you sleep, when you wake, he's still there, fully known, fully loved. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, it's a huge topic. We have questions. I'm thankful that the questions are here because for too long we've just gone along with whatever we've been told. Help us to use this cultural moment to ask the deeper question of what does it mean to be human? What is my purpose? what is my who am I if we are fearfully and wonderfully made if you knew us in our mother's womb there is a plan and purpose greater than we can know is it scary yes do we know the direction no but we are allowed to pray like David in the psalm, both scared at times, but also deeply, fully feeling held in your hand.

36:08 Move in our hearts in profound ways. Let us know that we can have something David didn't have, which is knowing the cost, and that this moves us to love you more with gratitude and service and wonder.

Machine translated from the source