Who Anointed Jesus' Feet? It's Not Who We Were Told...

Chris Alar · National Shrine of The Divine Mercy · Published September 17, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:04 So we're reading here from Luke chapter 7 about the woman anointing the feet. Now who is this woman? Okay. Luke does not give her name. He simply calls her a woman who was a sinner in the city. Now she is often identified as Mary Magdalene. this has been common but now scholars and theologians are saying it's not catholic theologians and scholars because the biblical text does not say that she was mary magdalene let's look a little deeper mary magdalene is identified up in the next coming in the next chapter luke 8 verse 2 as the woman whom jesus cast out seven demons there's also another anointing of Jesus that happened in Bethany involving Mary, Martha, and Lazarus, right?

1:04 And so these different gospel accounts were sometimes blended together in Christian art, tradition, and the gospel texts themselves, though now scholars are looking at it, present it as different accounts, different distinct episodes. But what do we know? Okay, well, we know that Jesus lets a sinful woman approach him. Okay, this is radical, looking at the social and kind of religious context of the times, because Simon sees her pass includes and concludes about Jesus that he must not be a prophet, because if he knew who she was, he wouldn't let her touch him. But Jesus turns this around and knows exactly who she is, and yet he still receives her. This is what mercy is, and all the attacks that are coming on mercy haven't read this passage, obviously, because what is mercy? Okay, Christ doesn't pretend the sin isn't real. He didn't tell her what you did is okay. He didn't confirm her or affirm her in her lifestyle. No, he didn't do any of that, and neither does mercy.

2:43 he does not pretend the sin isn't real rather his mercy is precisely what is needed to get her out of that sin it is precisely what enables the sinner to return to god so repentance is required this is what we marians have been teaching about mercy this is what we have been showing about divine mercy and yet it's attacked definitely diabolical repentance is required we have always said that even saying jesus i trust in you is a form of repentance because it's i need your mercy i've done wrong only way i would need your mercy is if i know i did something wrong and that's a form of repentance I did something wrong and I acknowledge that I need help to break away from it it's not like saying oh you know I did that I know that was wrong but I don't care I hope you burn no it's not that at all repentance is required and she did this well father how do you know she repented her tears they washed Jesus's feet all right next her love did she love because Jesus forgave her or did Jesus forgive her because she loved much?

4:10 In other words, did he forgive her because she loved much or did she love much because he forgave much? Very important distinction here. Jesus says her sins, though they are many, are forgiven. in, all right, let's look at this, is Jesus saying that her loving actions earned forgiveness.

4:34 Catholic interpretation basically says this is faith, repentance, and grace that were what she did to get Christ's forgiveness. Then once Christ forgave her, than she was loving because she realized how much I've been forgiven. I need to love my brethren. I need to love others like that. So this is very clear when Jesus says your faith has saved you. Okay. And so her extravagant love demonstrates the reality of her repentance and faith. So with God's grace, her repentance and faith were displayed. God's grace kicks in, forgives her, and then she loves much. You see that? It's kind of a long process.

5:32 But she repents. She knows she did wrong or she wouldn't be there. She has faith. This is the man who can heal me. God's grace kicks in she is forgiven then the result is she turns around and loves much beautiful chain of events now basically she wasn't forgiven because she loved she loved because she was forgiven much we should too now Simon here though has a problem with the woman the woman knows she needs mercy but Simon apparently doesn't think he does no at least not as much in Catholic terms this is closely connected with conversion and contrition what do I mean the person who recognizes the depths of God's mercy and trusts and has faith that he's the one who can heal they become grateful you know in my morning meditation today i always meditate on the passage and this is where i form my homilies and so as i was here in the chapel this morning praying doing the holy hour because that's i think the best way to start a day if you get a chance start your day with the holy hour and i know all of you can't always do that um but it was the realization how much god has forgiven me how many times I've been to confession for sometimes the same stupid things.

7:14 Sometimes I'm like, Lord, just cut off my tongue. Just slice it off because it's what gets me in trouble. And it came to me that, no, I'm not going to stop forgiving you every time you come to confession. You just have to realize how much you've been loved and forgiven more or less. So you just have to realize how much you've been forgiven so that you can love others in the same way I've loved you. And then this whole passage made sense. Like, wow, Lord, you have forgiven me so much. and you have given me so much in that confessional of forgiveness, have I gone and loved others how much you've loved me in the way, in the same way? No, I have not.

8:16 And this whole passage just kind of seemed to make sense. So I came back to my office after the holy hour and started writing these notes. Now, Jesus forgives himself. All right, this is very important. Jesus doesn't merely announce God has forgiven you. He says, I forgive you. He himself declares her sins forgiven. So then they all at the table ask the question, who is this guy? Who is Jesus that he can do this? Now, this connects very importantly with the church's understanding of Christ's authority to forgive sins. And with our sacrament of confession that were given to the apostles and their successors, the priests. Jesus had ultimate authority to forgive sin.

9:15 nobody on earth christ had all the authority to forgive sin and when you have ultimate authority you have the authority to delegate that authority hence you've heard me say many times John 20 23 Matthew 16 19 Matthew 18 18 who sins you forgive in heaven or excuse me who sins you forgive are forgiven in heaven who sins you retain are retained in heaven the grace doesn't come from the priests and those were the first priests and then it was handed down the grace comes from God but it's through the priest the tool and christ gave that authority to his apostles he wasn't looking in the mirror when he said whose sins you forgive are forgiven he wasn't talking to himself and so jesus forgives them personally and then he delegated that authority now the woman is now expressing physically what is really happening spiritually.

10:36 Have you ever had a conversion? Her tears started flowing. She started kissing his feet. She wiped the tears with her hair and the perfume that she used to wipe his feet. These are not just dramatic details to make a story nice. They communicate her humility, her repentance, her gratitude, and her love. We should do the same. Now there's a reversal because Simon thinks that the woman contacting Jesus or touching him will make Jesus unclean, but instead Jesus's holiness transforms the sinner who comes to him. yes, this is, you know, I did a homily a couple weeks ago, and one of our IT persons made a little short out of it, you know, that's the danger of those YouTube shorts, because you only take one small part of it, and if you don't listen to the whole context, this thing has gotten already 300,000 views, and I am getting absolutely crucified, lambasted um just attacked because the part that was shown on the thing talked about the difference in understanding between catholic understanding of grace and what was later summarized to be martin luther's understanding and i talked about god's grace doesn't just we're not like a pile of dung i said this is what this was the summary of martin luther's teaching i explained the whole thing. He didn't maybe use that word, but many theologians afterwards said basically this is what he was saying. It's a summary of his teaching, and it's like God's grace is like snow that covers it. And so, no, that's not Catholic understanding. Catholic understanding is that this pile of dung that maybe sin has led us to become, we are completely transformed by God's grace, not just

12:45 covered by it, transformed by it. We are the ugly duckling. We are this ugly duckling full of sin, and then God's grace transforms us into this beautiful swan. That is Catholic church teaching. And comment after comment after comment, the last one I just read says, this is ridiculous, the second grade education that this priest is trying to spew upon you. No, this is Catholic church teaching of 2,000 years. Why? Well, you really have to listen to that whole homily. That's, again, the danger of those YouTube shorts. But what am I trying to say? This is what's important, okay? This is what's important. Yes, we are saved by grace. this is very important okay we are saved through the saving grace of christ's passion death and resurrection we are only saved through grace we are saved through the cross and through christ's work of redemption but the bible is clear that we have to cooperate with that grace okay we are saved by grace but if we don't cooperate with that grace we are lost our part according to the gospel is to do just what this woman did to repent to believe that Jesus is the one she went to him to have faith and to work with God in doing the right thing cooperate with his grace and we did that she did it with love what was the right thing she anointed his feet. And that came from her faith and God's grace. But she did it with love.

14:46 And this is what Catholics mean by faith and works, which is what was so attacked in that video I did. Works, we do not mean works of the law. Everybody kept saying that. Father, you're trying to say works are new in heaven. You think that you're going to go and recite some prayer and you're going to go to heaven. Well, that's kind of what the Protestants do when they say, Lord Jesus Christ, my personal Lord and Savior, have mercy on me, a person. Yes, that's a powerful prayer. But they're the ones in stating that just declare Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior, and you will be saved. So actually, they were attacking me for that. I love the Jesus prayer. Now, faith and works, we do not mean works of the law. We mean works of love. Matthew 25, the sheep and the goat, the whole book of James. If you're not doing works of love, you're casting yourself out with the knit wheeling and grinding of teeth.

15:48 And James says, faith without works is dead. James 2 24. Again, this is works of love, which come from your faith. This one gospel passage lays all out in front of us, the entire Catholic teaching. No one's past is beyond God's mercy. That's the good news. But receiving it requires recognizing our need for it. I need God's mercy. The woman comes to Jesus without defending herself or demanding anything. She goes and throws herself at his feet of mercy. Jesus doesn't humiliate her or focus on her past. He restores her dignity and then sends her away. Really, like the adulterous woman, go but sin no more. You can be outwardly respectable and look like you're following all the rules, but fail to recognize your own need for mercy. Oh, I'm really good. I'm not a sinner.

16:52 No, we need God's mercy. And so for Catholic spirituality, that's one reason this passage fits so beautifully well with the Catholic church teaching. Confession, but you need contrition, and then you're healed through God's mercy. Then you have gratitude. Then you go out and love. That's a conversion. That's the entire Catholic faith summarized right here. and so Catholics do not say that a work that you volunteered an hour at the soup kitchen is going to save you. No, but if you drew truly a work of love, not a work of the law, or I should say even a work of the law, that you don't eat this food, or you fast on this day, that work of the law is not automatically going to save us, but we're told you Catholics believe because you fast on a Friday during Lent that you're going to go to heaven. No, that is not Catholic Church teaching.

18:01 Catholic Church teaching is we need faith and works, not works of the law, works of love. But the way that we get to that love are things like fasting on Friday. We deny ourself so we can love others more. We come to Christ and his feet and we beg for mercy. So then we are forgiven. Then we can go love more. So hopefully this passage makes sense and we can understand a little bit better what the meaning of this woman is, even though she's not even named. And that's, I think, by purpose, because it can be...

Machine translated from the source