Why Jesus called Peter Satan · It Isn't What You Think!

Chris Alar · National Shrine of The Divine Mercy · Published August 31, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:02 Oh, we want to get to heaven. I want to get to heaven. You want to get to heaven. Well, we wouldn't be here. But there's no way to heaven if we put ourselves first. It's all about sacrificial love. That goes against our broken human nature. The commandments are not love God with all your heart, mind, soul, and strength. and love your neighbor, in other words, as yourself, without being sacrificial, because that's putting God and neighbor even above ourselves. Now, what's going on in this gospel is important because it really talks about the danger of trying to follow Christ without sacrifice. We all want to follow Christ. Many people claim they follow Christ.

1:03 We've got a governor of our state claiming she follows Christ, but yet does anything but what's contrary, everything that's contrary to the teaching of the church. Now, striking, this is really in a way striking because it comes right after Peter had his confession of faith. You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God. But Peter expects victory without defeat, glory without suffering, a kingdom without a cross. That's how the Jews expected the Messiah, a conquering hero, overthrow our enemies, put us on the top, enthrone us. There was no place for a cross. And to the Jews today, they still don't understand the cross. This is why it's hard, because we don't either. The cross is hard. So now Jesus has to explain what being a Messiah actually means. So it was good that Peter said, you are the Messiah, but now Jesus has to explain to him, do you know what that means, Peter? You just said I'm the Messiah, but do you know what that means. It's kind of like us saying, I'm a Christian, but I don't follow church teaching on the dignity of human life, the sanctity of marriage between one man and one woman.

2:28 I don't follow that, but I'm a Christian. No, you have to learn what Christ tells us is to be a follower, to follow him. And so this is what he's doing to Peter. And so basically he's saying what being a Messiah actually means. He must go to Jerusalem, suffer greatly, be killed, and then raised on the third day. And so it is possible in many ways for us as Catholics to believe doctrine about Jesus, even the Bible, and yet resist the way Jesus asks us to live.

3:07 That is what many of us do. Peter takes Jesus aside, and it uses the word rebukes him. saying, this will not happen to you. And Peter's motivation isn't bad. I mean, I think he was kind of a, I mean, could you imagine Jesus calling you Satan? I mean, it's like, whoa, I just gave my life. I just gave up house and family for you. And so his motivation, I don't think nobody would say is bad. He's basically saying, Lord, I don't want you to suffer. It's kind of like euthanasia. many people the intent is not bad I don't want them to suffer but they they don't grasp that there's a that suffering could mean their salvation and we're going to cut it off that suffering may be the way that they're able to enter into heaven because they share in the cross of Christ because Christ could only open the door to heaven through that cross and so our loved ones that are suffering, we're going to cut it off because we don't want them to suffer, but we might be cutting them off from eternal life if they don't go by the way of the cross.

4:20 So Jesus responds, get behind me, Satan, you are an obstacle to me. Now, Jesus is not declaring Peter is Satan. Rather, he's unknowingly repeating the words of Satan. Did you know that? this is interesting. Unknowingly, Peter is repeating the temptation of Satan. That's why Jesus said, get behind me, Satan. Satan tempted Jesus to accomplish his mission without suffering and without obedience to the Father. This is exactly what Peter's telling him to do. Don't suffer, and I don't know about this obedience to this Father. So Peter is effectively proposing the same thing. Yes, you're my Messiah, but there's no need for Calvary. So Jesus, therefore, says you are thinking not as God does, but as human beings do. We avoid suffering. That's how human beings. So saying you think as human beings does doesn't mean, oh, well, we can't have humans involved in the church and help to find doctrine.

5:32 That's not what Jesus means. He means the humans and our nature avoid anything of the cross. That's our nature. And the human reaction is avoid suffering, seek comfort, protect yourself, choose what is easiest. We all do that. And Christ is trying to show us to get to heaven, and we have to break ourselves of that. That's why the first thing he says is deny yourself. Pick up your cross, follow me. So God's wisdom says that suffering united to love, that's what is redemptive. So get behind me also tells Peter where he belongs. Now, Peter had gotten in front of Jesus. Now, metaphorically, trying to tell Jesus where he should go. Not there. All right, so Jesus puts him back where a disciple belongs. Get behind me.

6:34 That's where you belong as a disciple. You don't lead me. You follow me. Well, I don't accept the church teaching on this. I don't accept the church teaching on that. I believe this. That's putting yourself ahead of Jesus. And Jesus is saying, no, get behind me. And this is what we don't like to do. We struggle with that. And so, basically, he's saying, you don't lead me, you follow me. We often want Jesus to follow us. When we go to prayer, Lord, we need this, I need that, I need this. And And in a way, that's not bad. Jesus wants to hear what's on our heart. But when all we do in prayer is say, Lord, this is what I want. Don't let this happen. Make my life work according to my plan. That's not bad, but that's when it's the focus of our prayer that we lose sight. Christ reverses this relationship. You follow me. I don't follow you. You follow me. That is a disciple.

7:43 Whoever wishes to come after me must deny himself. This is so contrary. You know, I watched when I was a kid those biblical, what do you call it, televangelists, and there were some really good ones. There really was. Charles Stanley, thumbs up. Robert Shuler, thumbs up. But then you had some of these others that were clown shows, you know, that, you know, one of them said, I don't mention sin. It makes people feel bad. Seriously? This is what Jesus is telling us. And if you're out there teaching that you don't want to feel bad, and so avoid the cross at all costs, you're doing what Satan told Jesus to do, and that's why Peter was called Satan. And so self-denial doesn't mean that we want to love suffering for suffering's sake. It doesn't mean legitimate pleasures are evil, it refuses to make it the center of our existence. Some of us exist fully for comfort, the path of least resistance. And the Christian says, not my will above everything, not my comfort above everything, not my desires above everything in God's commandments. Instead, God's will be done.

9:12 And this is why Catholic spirituality has always emphasized mortification, fasting, penance, sacrifice, obedience, works of mercy, denying our sinful desires. Every other Christian religion misses that point. This is why we are Catholic. It's the message of the gospel. And when we are told we're not biblical, you got to ask that person who asked you that, what is the message of Christ in the Bible? Deny yourself, pick up your cross, and follow me. That's Christ's message. It's not easy. That's why the road is narrow, and few find it. And so these practices train us to say no to ourselves so that we can say yes to God. Because it's often not that way in our world. So take up one's cross is one of the most misunderstood teachings of Christianity.

10:16 And it really, only really is fully shown in the Catholic faith. Christianity, now there are others who understand, but they pull Christ off the cross. Christ is removed from the cross. I remember the woman in Walmart. My Lord, he ain't on that cross no more. No, but as long as we're suffering, as long as you're on the cross, Christ is with you. And as long as we give ourselves to Jesus, we're on the cross with him before we resurrect with him. Christianity does not glorify suffering just to suffer, as I said. The cross is powerful because our sufferings can be united with the sacrifice of Christ. St. Paul says, I must complete what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ. What possibly could be lacking in the sufferings of Christ. First Colossians 1.24, our suffering. Nothing is lacking in the saving value of what Christ did.

11:18 True. Rather, what's lacking is our being on the cross with him. We all want to resurrect with him, but none of us want to go to the cross with him. Well, do we have to go to the cross? He's God, and he went to the cross. The penalty for sin is death. He paid it. All he's asking us to do is share in a teeny tiny piece of it. That's all. Christ allows the members of his mystical body to participate in his suffering. You're about ready to hear the reading of St. Faustina at the end of communion, where she says if angels were capable of envy, they would only envy man for two things. That we could receive holy communion, they can't, they're spirit only, and that we can suffer. They don't. And so, this is the Catholic teaching of redemptive suffering. And I tell you, I buy it hook line and sinker That's why i'm catholic This makes such beautiful sense, but it's not easy It goes against our nature This is very difficult. Well father. How do I embrace suffering?

12:34 It doesn't mean you ask for it, but you're going to become ill sometimes offer it up You're going to have disappointments offer that up to the cross of christ. You're going to be rejected loneliness, persecution, sacrifices that are required being a parent with your children, ordinary daily frustrations, stubbing your toe, cutting your finger. Any of these little things can be offered up. I always say this, when something happens and you're waiting for something like maybe word on a promotion or good news or bad news, and we always get excited, we want the good news, here's the best way for me to do this. If something goes my way, I say, praise be to God. Praise be to God. Praise be to Jesus if it goes my way. Thank you, Lord. If it doesn't go your way, then ask the Lord to release a holy soul from purgatory. I accept this, Lord, but please release a holy soul from purgatory, or let this be towards my redemption, towards my purification.

13:35 And so we can do this. We can offer that up. Jesus, I unite this suffering to your cross. Use it for the salvation of souls. If something doesn't go your way, this suffering is powerful. The suffering that seems meaningless to this world can become the greatest redemptive tool ever. And then somebody said, well, what about love, Father? Love is measured by the amount you are willing to give of yourself. You know, we did a wedding yesterday here at the shrine. A beautiful couple. And their parents both worked with us here. And because it was after 5 o'clock on a Saturday, we had to do the readings from the day. And so it wasn't, the gospel was not proper to a wedding. It was this gospel.

14:28 So as I'm reading this gospel, I'm like, we didn't even pick it. how amazing does it apply to a marriage? Deny yourself. You're giving everything to the spouse, your whole being. You're picking up your cross. So the beautiful couple that got married yesterday, Nick and Joanna, they put their hands on a cross. You know, there's a tradition of this little town in Croatia where my family's from, and I found out it's only one village away from my family's village. They hold the cross while they take vows, because they are offering their suffering that they know is going to come in that marriage. And you know, it was great. Father Mark Barron, who's here with us, he said, you know, basically what the meaning of that is, is I'm about to accept my cross. My spouse. My spouse is my cross. And so they hold the cross. Now here's what's fascinating.

15:28 This village, since recorded history of the village, has had 50,000 marriages. Going back 1,000 years. You know how many divorces they've had? And every single one in that village holds that cross and sees it that they're receiving their way to salvation, their spouse. That spouse is being given to them as their cross. And it is your cross that will get you to heaven. Do you know how many divorces has been in this village? zero. They've never had a divorce. Why isn't the church over there promoting this? Why aren't we, where is this on the news? This is incredible. Not one divorce in the history of this village because that's what they do. This is my cross and you are my cross. So before you yell at your spouse or your children, just thank them for being your cross to heaven. Now, that's not easy.

16:34 That's how I look at cameraman Giuseppe now. You are my cross. And he looks at me, he says, you're my cross. I love you. So this is the beautiful gift that we don't see. And so this is a beautiful, beautiful connection. You know, it's also connected to the mass, the Eucharist. At every Mass, we are sacramentally brought into contact with the one sacrifice of Calvary. The sacrifice of Christ is not repeated, you know that. The one sacrifice of the cross is made sacramentally present, and we are invited to place our sacrifice on this altar. When I get up here in a second, and I'll say, pray, brethren, that my sacrifice and yours will be acceptable to God, the Almighty Father. The Christian life is therefore Eucharistic. When we bring Christ our work, our suffering, our sacrifices, our disappointments, our prayers, our acts of love, we can unite them to the perfect sacrifice. This is the sacrifice of the cross. Matthew 16, what we just read, is lived every time we come to mass with our cross and we unite them to Christ. Jesus then gives us one of the great paradoxes ever of Christianity. Whoever wishes to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake will find it. This tells us, you know, the opposite of the world. The world says, find yourself. That's why all those divorces came out of the late 60s and early 70s. I need to find myself. The world tells you, protect yourself, satisfy yourself, Give yourself comfort. Put yourself first. Jesus says something totally radically different.

18:25 Give yourself away. that's amazing. And when we give ourselves away in love, that's when you find yourself. What are you truly made of? A husband or wife finds fulfillment by sacrificing for the spouse, as I just mentioned. Parents, you sacrifice for your children. Religious priests and brothers, we surrender our possessions. We surrender the gift of marriage and beautiful relations. We give up personal autonomy, all for the kingdom. The Christian finds life precisely through this self-gift. Give it away, you will have it. This reflects Christ himself. He saves his life. Did you know that? Did you know Jesus saved his life?

19:15 How? Not by coming down from the cross. He saves his life through the resurrection. He came back to life, which only happened by first giving it away. So to finish, Jesus asks perhaps one of the most important questions ever spoken. What profit would there be for one to gain the whole world, yet forfeit his soul? Imagine possessing everything that the world values. money, property, power, fame, pleasure, success, recognition, influence. Imagine that. And then imagine hearing Christ say, but you lost your soul.

20:01 Whoa. Would any of it be worth anything? Nothing. And this is why Catholicism insists that our earthly choices have eternal consequences. Oh, it doesn't matter. Jesus did it all on the cross. Yes, he did for your redemption. Everybody's redeemed, but not everybody will be saved. Christianity is not simply about becoming nicer people and making the world a better place. Social justice has been elevated even by the church itself, many in the church, as the number one factor. It is not. Those things matter. Yes, they do. But something infinitely more greater is at stake, your salvation. The catechism says our earthly life is a time in which we freely choose our ultimate destiny. We can only, this is right quoted, what can one give in exchange for his life, Jesus asks you? The answer, nothing. Once we understand the value of a soul, your priority has to change. Jesus is basically asking us, what is your soul worth? Wow. More than your career, your reputation, your money, your popularity, your comfort, your political power, your physical life, your education, all of that. This explains the martyrs.

21:32 the martyrs could have saved their physical life by denying Christ you ever notice that almost all the martyrs were given a chance to get out of it if they denied Christ very interesting they didn't kill him just to kill him they said if you deny this Jesus we'll let you go and so they they could have saved their physical life by denying Christ but said I would rather lose this life than lose eternal life. This is the gospel. So Jesus speaks then, lastly, finally, about judgment. Oh, there will be no judgment. Jesus did it all. No, we are saved through God's grace, but we are judged by our actions. And so Jesus speaks about judgment by saying everybody will be paid according to conduct. Right here. Then he will repay all according to his conduct.

22:32 That's Catholic teaching, and only Catholic teaching, it seems. We are saved again through grace, but we are judged by our works, works of love. Works don't save us. Don't let any non-Catholic tell you you are a heathen because you think works save you. God's grace saves you, but you've got to cooperate with that grace, and those works by your conduct are works of love. Jesus says he will repay each according to his conduct. Our works matter. Works of love, that is. Not because we can purchase salvation or save ourselves with works apart from grace. No. Salvation begins and ends with God's grace through Jesus. We don't argue that, but we have to cooperate with that grace to let it transform the way we live. And this is why scripture connects judgment with our deeds. Everybody non-Catholic will tell you this is not gospel. This is the heart of the gospel.

23:34 Faith must become a living faith. Faith working through love. Galatians 5.6. James, faith without works is dead. Faith alone is never mentioned in the Bible except one time. You are not saved by faith alone. So Jesus does not tell us to carry, just carry the cross. Go do it. He carried it first. Christianity is not Jesus standing up to the side and saying, you suffer. Jesus is saying, follow me. And that's the way he went. He went ahead of us to Calvary. He went ahead of us to death and finally to the resurrection. And he wants you to follow him there too. If he asks you to follow him to the cross, he doesn't leave it at that. He also wants you to follow him to the resurrection. And so the Catholic understanding of this gospel is one of tremendous hope. There is no Christianity without the cross. But for the Christian, the cross never has the final word, the resurrection does. This is why it all ties together. Praise be to God. I'm sorry I went way too long, but what an incredible summary of our entire...

Machine translated from the source