Deconstructing the Myth of Human Autonomy

Rev. Marc Choi · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached May 24, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Romans 5:6-8 1:09
6For at just the right time, while we were still powerless, Christ died for the ungodly. 7Very rarely will anyone die for a righteous man, though for a good man someone might possibly dare to die. 8But God proves His love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:33 Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer LSQ. My name is Mark and I'm one of the pastors here and it's my privilege to bring to you what I hope is a good word. We've been walking as a church community through the Apostles' Creed, which is one of the oldest and simplest summaries of the Christian faith. It is very simple, but it's not simplistic. The reality is that the Creed contains multitudes. So if you're a Christian and you're wondering how can you grow in your faith, how can you understand and experience more and more of your faith, then returning to the Apostles' Creed over and over again is a good thing to do. And if you have no idea or little idea of what Christians believe and you're curious, then the Apostles' Creed is one of your best starting points.

2:37 Last week, we considered how the Creed invites us to consider the mystery of the Incarnation, which is how, in Jesus Christ, God became like one of us to live among us. Today, we're considering the death of Jesus on the cross, what it means to believe that Jesus Christ suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried. And we're also considering what it means to believe in the forgiveness of sins. So before we press on, will you join me in a prayer so we can ask God for some help? Please join me. God, we come to you with joy, with hope. Some of us come sad and burdened and anxious. God, no matter how we come, we remember that you welcome us as we are and that you have a good word for each and every one of us.

3:38 God, we ask now that you would help us to hear, you would help us to receive, you would help us to believe. We thank you that you are with us now as you have always been. And we pray this in the name of Jesus. Amen. So thanks to the wonders of streaming, I've been slowly re-watching the hit drama ER. If you're not familiar with the drama, it ran from 1994 to 2009. And it chronicled the day-to-day happenings of an emergency room of an ER in Chicago. True admission, I probably have watched enough episodes now to work in the ER, but I'm not going to try that. As one would expect, there are a lot of dramatic and heroic moments in this show. There are so many amazing saves.

4:34 And there are also a lot of unlucky moments. And my ears always perk up when the dying person on the gurney manages to eke out a final few words. And my ears perk up because final words mean so much. We learn so much about the person in the final words. We learn what they loved, what they truly loved, what they truly valued. And as it happens when there is a loved one, a friend in the room to hear those final words, We also learn so much from the reactions. We learn so much about these friends and the way they react, the way they respond to these final words. Whether in a drama or in real life, final words are significant. Final words reveal the truth about the speaker and about the people who are listening. So this morning, we have two passages.

5:30 I want to focus on the one from the Gospel of John, which is one of the four accounts in the Bible about the life and death of Jesus Christ. Our passage from John brings us to the very last moments of Jesus's life. They bring us to the moment of his death on a cross, and this passage also shares with us his final words. So should we pay attention to Jesus's final words, we'll learn so much about who he is. We'll learn so much about the cross itself. We'll learn why the ancient words from the creed are still relevant and worth our belief. We'll also learn so much about who we are. So let's look at Jesus' final words. There are two statements.

6:25 Jesus' penultimate statement is I thirst he says I thirst that he's thirsty really isn't surprising given the circumstances Jesus has endured an unfair trial at the hands of Pontius Pilate he suffered and has endured rounds of beating and flogging he's been hanging on a cross for several hours slowly dying So naturally, he's thirsty. But this isn't just about physical thirst. This statement isn't just about something that is happening physically. All throughout the Bible, physical thirst is often used as a metaphor for our spiritual thirst for wholeness, for meaning, for purpose, for identity. The Bible tells us that we can find wholeness only in God because God is our creator.

7:26 Only God is the source of life. So trying to find wholeness, all those other things, meaning, purpose, identity, trying to find that outside of our relationship with God is what Christians call sin. We often hear this word and we often think it just means breaking rules or some moral failure. Sin includes that, but it's not just that. Sin is fundamentally trying to satisfy our spiritual thirst with anyone or anything other than our creator. With anything other than the true source of life. So whether or not you agree, whether or not you acknowledge it or not, we all know, I'm going to contend that we all know the reality and the power of sin. No matter who we are, no matter what we believe, we all understand and experience the power of sin.

8:29 Isn't it true that each of us is chasing after something? Isn't it true that each of us are thirsting after something to make us whole, to give us a sense that we are enough? Maybe it's the next promotion. Maybe it's finally getting respect or esteem or affection. Maybe it's finding the right parenting technique so you can secure your child's success. Maybe it's optimizing your health.

9:01 In our current culture, so many of us are trying to find enough authenticity, are we not? Whatever we long for, whatever we're thirsting for to give us a sense of wholeness generally falls into four broad categories of comfort, approval, control, or power. And we think if we have just enough of any one of those things or any combination of those things, then we'll be okay. We'll be enough. For me, it often comes down to comfort and approval. I spend so much of my time, I structure my days seeking comfort and approval. And so the question for you is, what's driving you? What are you thirsty for?

9:57 And the truth is, no matter how much comfort, approval, control, or power we acquire, it's never enough, is it? It's never enough. As I was thinking about all of this, different actors, musicians, and athletes came to mind who have talked about achieving so much fame and fortune and everything they desired, only to realize that they needed more. One person I thought about was Alex Honnold. You might know him from a documentary called Free Solo. Back in 2017, he free soloed the face of El Capitan in Yosemite, which means he climbed 3,000 vertical feet of granite without any safety equipment. It's nuts. And this feat was actually one of Alex Honnold's lifetime dreams. And it wasn't just one of his lifelong, lifetime dreams.

10:54 it's arguably one of the craziest and greatest athletic accomplishments of all time. In reflecting about this accomplishment this is what he had to say. People think that achieving a lifelong dream changes you but the horizon just moves. You're still the same guy looking at the same world, just wondering what the next challenge is.

11:24 One of those next horizons from Alex Honnold was Scaling Taipei 101, which is one of the tallest buildings on the globe. And he also did it free solo. And in interviews afterwards, he expressed a lot of the same things. He was happy he did it, but he was looking for the next great thing.

11:46 Alex Honnold does the most amazing things, but he's still thirsty. And he's not unique, is he? He's maybe just a little bit more honest. And this is the point. This is what we all know. No matter what you gain, you're still the same person with the same thirst, with the same sin.

12:10 We know this, but we keep on going back to the same well, don't we? And what are the consequences of going back? What are the consequences of our sin, of consuming people and experiences for our own sense of wholeness? The consequences are what we know. Our bodies break down. Our relationships break down. We hurt ourselves and those around us. We end up lonely, isolated. the consequence of our sin is truly death. sin might not be something you agree with or you can conceptualize as a truth but we all know its consequences

13:32 Now you might be wondering about Jesus on the cross and asking, is Jesus really spiritually thirsty on the cross? And this is a really good question. Jesus has a perfect relationship with God the Father. He is one with God and is God. He is the source of life. So how can he be spiritually thirsty? And this is where our passage from Romans helps us. Romans 5, chapter 5, verse 6 tells us that Jesus died for the ungodly, for the sinner, for the thirsty. So what's happening on the cross is an exchange, a great exchange. In dying for us, for those who are thirsty, Jesus takes on all of our spiritual thirst.

14:28 and he gives us his life and his perfect relationship with God. so that we can be satisfied. This exchange is symbolized in his drinking of vinegar with hyssop. Hyssop is poison. So do you see what's happening? Jesus drinks what neither quenches our thirst nor gives life. so that we don't have to in our day-to-day lives.

15:02 not only is Jesus drinking what we're trying to drink and saying you don't have to anymore, he's also taking on all the consequences of that. He's taking on all the consequences of our sin, all the hurt, all the suffering, all the death. He drinks our cup for us and he looks at us and he says, I forgive you. I forgive you, and I want you to take my life. There's a curious phrase in the Apostles' Creed about Jesus descending to hell. A lot can be said about this. So I'll simply say one way to understand hell is that it is complete and utter separation from God. So do you see what the creed is inviting us to hear? The one who had never known a moment apart from the Father willingly went into the wilderness of utter desolation.

16:04 He did it so we didn't have to. In exchange, what Jesus did wasn't partial. It's total. Jesus doesn't just give us a little bit of his fullness. or a little bit of forgiveness, a little bit of his relationship with God, but he gives all of it. The exchange costs Jesus everything so that we could have everything.

16:33 Jesus takes on our thirst on the cross. Jesus not only takes on our thirst, but he also enters our shame. Jesus not only takes on our thirst, but he also enters our shame. And we hear this in the final three words, it is finished.

16:56 We all have things about us we don't want anyone to see, right? There are parts of us we do not want anyone to see. And we spend a lot of time covering those things from view. We hide those things because those things make us feel unworthy. unworthy of acceptance, unworthy of belonging, unworthy of love. At the end of the day, we want to be seen and judged worthy instead of unworthy. We want to be judged as good, above reproach, above any reason for exclusion. And going back to our spiritual thirst, isn't it true that shame is almost always involved? We desire the right neighborhoods, the right schools, the right jobs, the right amount of authenticity, the right kinds of experiences to cover our shame.

18:02 We want people to see those things and judge us as worthy. We use all these things to cover ourselves. We spend so much of our time and freedom doing just that. And the fear beneath all of this, the fear beneath all of this is being found out as imposters, of being seen and then rejected. One of the terms that has been part of our contemporary language is imposter syndrome. According to the stats, most people experience imposter syndrome at one point or another. But guess which groups tend to report the highest amounts of imposter syndrome? High achievers and those in competitive environments, which means the typical New Yorker, right?

19:00 I read a Reddit thread the other day about someone who just moved to New York, and one of the first statements was, has anyone else just moved and experienced a skyrocket in imposter syndrome? again, we do all these things to hide this, to not be an imposter, to hide our shame. But guess what makes imposter syndrome only increase? Ironically, it's more achievement. Getting more comfort, more approval, more power, more control actually only increases the fear of our shame being revealed.

19:39 Some words from the late Maya Angelou came to mind as I was thinking about this. Maya Angelou was a celebrated and award-winning author. But listen again to what she had to say after publishing her 11th book. I've written 11 books, but each time I think, uh-oh, they're going to find out now. I've run a game on everybody, and they're going to find me out. Again, doesn't she express our own fear? No matter how much we cover ourselves, we can't cover our shame enough. But we try anyway, and it's exhausting. Ask any New Yorker, how are you? And you'll often hear the following two responses. You'll most likely hear, I'm busy, and I'm tired. Those don't sound like spiritual answers, but they are deeply spiritual answers.

20:38 And so when we look at Jesus on the cross, we see Jesus entering our shame. We need to remember that death by crucifixion wasn't just physically painful. It was emotionally and psychologically devastating. Everything about it was meant to not only destroy the body, but to destroy a person's dignity, to strip away a person's humanity and worth. And earlier in John 19, we're told how Jesus was literally stripped of his clothes, which means he would have been naked on the cross for all the public to see while he died. Can you imagine being utterly vulnerable, utterly exposed and humiliated in that way? So do you see on the cross, Jesus enters our very fear.

21:38 Jesus enters our shame. And in doing so, there's another exchange. He takes that shame from us and he gives us his clothing instead. and since he's one with God, since he's the source of life, since he is God, this means that his clothing, the clothing he gives us, the covering he gives us is as good as it gets. Jesus gives us his identity as the son of God. Jesus gives us all of his beauty, all of his goodness, all of who he is and he covers us with that. what he covers us with is more beautiful, more wonderful than anything we can do on our own.

22:33 And here's more good news. We don't have to worry about losing this covering. We don't have to worry about losing this covering. We don't have to keep striving for it or working for it. Listen to Jesus' his last words again. He says, it is finished. It is finished. He is saying he has done all the work to cover us. He's saying we can now rest. We can now stop trying to prove ourselves. We can stop because he has covered us once and for all.

23:23 So would you take the next few moments to imagine God looking at you? Can you imagine God looking at you right now where you are in your seats? What do you think God sees? in reality, God sees everything. God sees you from head to toe. He sees into the deepest recesses of your hearts and of your minds. He sees everything, including your sin, including the consequences, including everything you're doing to hide. it's terrifying to think that God sees as much as God does. But what our passage is telling us, what our creed is telling us, instead of turning away from us, instead of telling us do better or become more,

24:31 God comes close. Instead of turning away, God comes close. And he offers you the clothing of Jesus Christ. And he says, please, take it. It is finished. this is good news. This is love. This is what Christians believe.

25:00 Truth be told, I don't have a lot of application. So what I want to do is return to the beginning. I want to return to where I started. If you're a Christian, keep on returning to the basics. Keep on returning to the cross, to the good news of Jesus' final words. And if you're unsure of the Christian faith, do the same thing. Keep returning to the basics and look closely at the cross of Jesus. The cross might offend you. The cross might spur you to ask more questions. But that's okay. Jesus, the cross, has a way of meeting us where we are and surprising us. So no matter who you are, will you look at the cross?

25:57 Will you contend with it? Will you be surprised? Will you pray with me? Jesus, I pray, I acknowledge again that we all have different stories. We all have different experiences. And so as we look to you, as we look to the cross, would you take all of our experiences, all of our stories, all of who we are, and would you give us a new one? Would you give us a new story that is full of your life? and in moments of doubt in moments of joy would we hear you say over and over again it is finished We thank you for being the God who died for us.

26:55 we pray all this in your name

Machine translated from the source