Faith Without Easter is Futile

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached April 5, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: 1 Corinthians 15:3-20 0:27
3For what I received I passed on to you as of first importance: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, 4that He was buried, that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, 5and that He appeared to Cephas and then to the Twelve. 6After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still living, though some have fallen asleep. 7Then He appeared to James, then to all the apostles. 8And last of all He appeared to me also, as to one of untimely birth. 9For I am the least of the apostles and am unworthy to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God. 10But by the grace of God I am what I am, and His grace to me was not in vain. No, I worked harder than all of them—yet not I, but the grace of God that was with me. 11Whether, then, it was I or they, this is what we preach, and this is what you believed. 12But if it is preached that Christ has been raised from the dead, how can some of you say that there is no resurrection of the dead? 13If there is no resurrection of the dead, then not even Christ has been raised. 14And if Christ has not been raised, our preaching is worthless, and so is your faith. 15In that case, we are also exposed as false witnesses about God. For we have testified about God that He raised Christ from the dead, but He did not raise Him if in fact the dead are not raised. 16For if the dead are not raised, then not even Christ has been raised. 17And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins. 18Then those also who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished. 19If our hope in Christ is for this life alone, we are to be pitied more than all men. 20But Christ has indeed been raised from the dead, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:51 And good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. Special welcome to you if you are new. One of our values here at our church is we value questions and those who ask them. That is why we do Q&R after every service. There's a phone number in your bulletin, both online and here in person. So you can start texting questions now. That's why in our bulletin we have on the side, we have explanations for every last element of our liturgy. It's there because we expect you to be here, so we're thankful that you're here.

2:22 In the final book of Harry Potter, there's a scene where Harry, the wizard, goes and visits the grave site of his dead parents who gave their lives to save him. As he goes to the village, snow is falling on the ground. He gets over to their gravestone. He wipes the snow off and he reads the inscription. It says, here lies James and Lily Potter. And then underneath that, it says this. It says, the last enemy that shall be destroyed is death. Great line, not original to J.K. Rowling. It's actually a quote from Paul that is not printed in your bulletin, but it came just after our text here, which is the longest treatment of the resurrection in the ancient world. Emory professor George Yancey, who's a philosophy professor, wrote a New York Times opinion piece a couple years ago on facing death.

3:26 This is what he says. He says, how great you perform on your MCATs and LSATs and GPA and all those scores, we will perish.

4:08 And that's that quote. And a lot of you're going, great, depressing quote, Michael. Thank you so much this morning. But I give it to you because his students, when he says this to them, they are completely silent. They don't know what to do, but it's, and the reason why is because it's still honest, logical, and consistent what he says. I believe every person in this room, no matter what you believe, every single one of us has to come up with some way to live knowing that death is coming. what hope do we have? How will we actually live out our lives with hope in light of death? Because you can't escape it. We try to ignore it all the time, but you look on the news and there it is. I was riding my bike to preach here today and I slipped and I have a nice big gash in my pants, death is coming for us all. It's just delayed, but it's still coming. And you need to ask therefore yourself, how will I have hope? And Paul in our text today, he has the audacity to say there was an event that was so permanent, that was so disruptive that it actually can and does give us hope. Easter is not like Christmas. Everybody loves Christmas because Christmas, again, the lights, the presents, the music, the festivities, everybody can partake of in Christmas and yet not be changed. Easter doesn't let us do that because Easter isn't based on like a feeling.

5:58 It is based on a historical event that either happened or it did not. And I think that what we need to do is we need to look at this text because Paul uses this word here, if. He says if, not once, not twice, six times he says if. If this did not happen, look at verse 17, then you are still in your sins. if this does not happen in verse 19, then we are to be pitied more than all other people. If, if, if. You see, Paul understands that so much hinges on this. And so what I wanna do just for a few moments this morning is I'd like to look at the evidence. I wanna ask just two questions. Did it happen?

6:50 And if it did, so what? Did it happen? and if it did, what does it mean? So number one, did it happen? Look at our first verse. Paul writes this in verse three. He says, for what I received, I passed on to you. as I passed on to you as of first importance. that Christ died for our sins, according to the scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day, according to the scriptures. What a lot of scholars point out is that Paul's language, it's hard to tell to us today, but Paul's language is actually highly technical terms. When he says, I received and I passed on to you, those were earmarks in the ancient culture that he was in, that what was about to be said comes from strict, formal transmission of memorized truth. And other scholars point out that when he starts saying phrases like, Christ died for our sins, he was buried, he was raised, he appeared.

7:55 Those are liturgical creedal statements from an early Christian creed. And so what's Paul doing with all this? Here's what he's trying to say. He's trying to say as carefully as possible, I didn't make this up. I didn't make this up. And this matters why, because he knew that people then and people today will try to look at this account and say, ah, this is just a legend. Right? That we know how legends form because we have data that shows how legends forms, right? If you go back to Alexander the Great, he had a miraculous birth, which sounds familiar, right? Of course, that was written about 400 years after he died. If you go to Caesar, there were divine legends about Caesar, but that also happened centuries after he died.

8:50 If you look at the life of Buddha, what you find is that the miraculous that happens around Buddha was codified generations after he died. And so what a lot of people try to say is, well, that's the same thing about Jesus, right? But myths need gaps in time and memory to work, to form. which is really important for us because Paul, this letter was written about 12 to 20 years after the events. And he's quoting creedal statements that were written about five years after Jesus' death. In other words, there is no gap. There's no gap here for a legend to form. That these documents are too early to be legend. And then look at verse five. Paul moves into what I call naming names. He starts making a list. Cephas, the 12.

9:43 After that, he appeared to more than 500 of the brothers and sisters at the same time, right? Why is he pointing that out? Because you can't all hallucinate the same thing if it's at the same time. And then my favorite phrase is, most of whom are still living. What's going on there? Again, Paul's saying, hey, you want proof? Here's my proof. Check the facts. Here's the people that you can go talk to. This is actually really important that there's a scholar named Richard Bauckham. He's a Cambridge scholar. He wrote a book called Jesus and His Eyewitnesses. And since it's come out, there's been no major debunking of his thesis. His thesis is this, that in ancient culture, nobody had the genre of fiction. We know fiction where you can write something out and it'd be fake. People didn't think that way. So if there was a document that proposed to be actually history, the reason why you see these names is these were actually lists of eyewitnesses to say you can go now verify.

10:46 You can go talk to these people. And so therefore, this list, what you see in this text is not written like mythology. It is written like a list of witnesses for you to look at. Now you might push back and say, okay, fine, it's not fiction. they didn't have that, but people lie, right? People lie. There's a really funny sort of skit that you can find online. You can sometimes if you scroll, just scroll enough and you'll find it because the algorithm will show it to you. And it's the skit, I think it was like Seth Rogen. And there are a bunch of disciples all sitting around and Peter says, I got this great idea. Let's steal Jesus' body. And all the disciples start going, yeah, that's a great idea. That's a great idea. What happens next? What do we do? He goes, well, here's what's going to happen. Afterwards, we're all going to suffer brutally terrible deaths. And all the disciples are like, what? That doesn't sound so great. That's after we get rich and famous and have all this stuff.

11:50 No, no, no, no. We're just going to be brutally murdered. And I think it's great sarcasm because Why? Because people lie when they expect to get away with something. Nobody dies for a lie that they invented themselves. You only lie if you think that you can get something out of it.

12:15 And so what happened, we know in history, is that Peter was crucified upside down. James was stoned to death. people do lie, but you always lie because you think that you're gonna be able to get away with it. But that's actually not what happens. Nobody confessed. All they had to do, if they confessed, if they said, hey, it was just a hoax, it was just a metaphor, wow, warm, fuzzies, nobody would have killed them.

12:43 But they didn't do that. Nobody recanted, which means this. And here's what we have to contend today. either what you have here is the most inexplicable conspiracy in ancient history that has formed over decades and hundreds of people had to all hold it together under torture without anybody recanting or maybe something actually happened that Sunday morning.

13:18 That's the evidence. That's what we see here. And by the way, for some of you, the evidence is the problem. But for a lot of you, you know what? The evidence is not the problem. Your problem is not, there's not a lot of evidence. You know what your problem is? It's too costly. Because here's how it's costly. If Jesus is who he says he is, that means then we are not the master and commander of our own life. It means then that we are not the architect of our own story. The early church, these people, they thought it was worth it to give up their reputations, to give up their comfort, to give up their very lives because they thought that what they were getting with this was more. And so the question I want to ask you all is this. Is it so for you? Is it worth it to you?

14:12 Can you afford it not to be worth it for you? See, a lot of things that we don't want to give up, our comfort, our reputations, our very lives, they thought it was worth it. But do you, are you willing to give those things up for this? Because the resurrection isn't asking you to trade your life for some religiosity, for some, you know, religious fuzzy wuzzies to have in the bottom of your heart. No. What the resurrection is saying is that this is the lens by which you are to look at all of life to have life. and if it's true, it changes everything.

15:21 All right, so second point, last point. What does it mean if it's true? How does it actually change everything? Go back to our text, look at verse 13. And Paul says this, he says, there's that if statement, if there is no resurrection of the dead, then not even Christ has been raised. And if Christ has not been raised, you're still in your sins. Notice what Paul's doing here. He's not giving us any wiggle room. He's saying, this is your only hope for life and death. That everything falls on this event. You can't get away from it. You can't just say Jesus was a spiritual guy and his creeds and morals are good to live. No. There's no mushy middle here. Skip down to verse 18. He says, if the resurrection is not true, right? if Christ had not been raised, that those who have fallen asleep in Christ are lost.

16:20 This is also important because here's what he's saying. He's saying, if the resurrection is false, all those graves, they have the final say. All those goodbyes that you've ever said or will ever be said to you are final. That's the weight of the if statements. And what's interesting is the very last statement here, verse 20, there's no more ifs. Paul says this, he says, in Christ, Christ has indeed been raised from the dead. And he calls them the first fruits of those who have fallen asleep. Now that word first fruits for a lot of you is not super normal. We don't use that terminology. But in an agrarian society, first fruits was a big deal. It was the most joyous occasion. Why? Because it meant this, me and mom and dad, we're not going to starve this year. Because in an agrarian society, you need the harvest to come in, but you don't know for months if it will.

17:17 But the first fruits announces, it's not the harvest, but it announces that the harvest has come. And so Paul's calling Jesus that. This is what he's saying. He's saying the resurrection that happened 2000 years ago, that's not the resurrection of all of creation, but it's the first fruits. It's the start of, it's the promise. It's the declaration that what happened on Easter back then means that's what's in store for all of creation for us today. That's what it's saying. I have a pastor friend who lost his daughter in the Nashville shootings a couple years ago. And I made, you can call it a mistake or fortuitous, I made the mistake to watch a documentary last night on it. there's on Netflix, there's a documentary called All the Empty Rooms. It actually won best Oscar for short documentary this year. And he was one of the families that was profiled there.

18:17 And it just was gutting to walk into the room that was just like it always was, but his daughter's not there anymore. what do you do with that? How do you cope with that? I remember visiting him the week after this all happened and what he said to me has stuck with me since. This is what he said. He said, Michael, as a pastor, I've always cognitively believed in the resurrection.

18:46 But now, now that I've lost my daughter, now I really believe it. And here's what he's getting at there. He's saying this, when you're not suffering, yeah, it's easy to kind of talk about, hey, your life is random. It's a dog-eat-dog world, no big deal. But when you're hurting, when it's hard, when you're like, I have no hope, where am I gonna get hope? That's when, that's when this matters. That's when the first fruits of the resurrection becomes finally sweet. What you need, if it hasn't been sweet to you, if it's never been, it means you haven't actually plunged your hurts and your cares into the resurrection because that's the time, that's the moment when it can. Pastor Donald Barnhouse lost his wife. He had to raise his 10-year-old daughter by himself. And there's this great scene where one time they were walking across the street and a massive transport truck goes by them and the shadow passes through them.

19:45 The daughter, being 10, was very scared. She flinched. And so this pastor picked up his daughter into his arms and said, hey, did that truck hit you? She said, no, daddy. No, the truck didn't hit me. Just the shadow of that truck hit me. And he goes, he said, I know you're sad about your mother. I know you think that you've lost her, but you need to know something that death never actually fully hit your mother because Jesus Christ on the cross took the true truck of death and therefore only the shadow of death has hit your mother.

20:25 The death of Jesus Christ, what Paul is saying here, he's saying that because he took the real hit, now the only thing that can hit us is the shadow of death. Now you're right to say, what do you mean? How's the death we now have, how's that just the shadow of death? Samwise Gamgee at the end of Lord of the Rings, he says this great quote, he says, is everything sad gonna become untrue? it's a wonderful question and Paul has the answer in one word you know what he says? sleep isn't it interesting that Paul in our text never calls the dead dead not once not twice three times he calls them asleep and that matters because why? sleep is temporary sleep is something that you can awake from what Paul is getting at is he's saying because the tomb is empty, because Jesus is the first fruits as a guarantee, my friend's daughter, she's not gonna wake tomorrow, but you know what?

21:26 She's gonna wake. I've lost my dad. My dad's not gonna wake tomorrow, but he's going to wake. The hurts, the pains, the things that you have lost, they're not coming back tomorrow. As the testimony said earlier, it doesn't solve the pain in the moment, but it points forward and says it doesn't have the last say and when we get back here's our problem For a long time, I just wanted my dad back. but if I got my dad back he's just going to die again don't ask back for what you've lost what you should be asking for is it to be what it was always meant to be in the first place and that's not to have these fragile lives but to have a restoration and recreation of all of life that can't die again, that we were always meant for.

22:25 And so going back to our text, if Jesus rose again, then we will rise again because the resurrection is a bodily, renewed, fixed certainty. One of the themes of Harry Potter throughout all the books is that Harry just wants to get back to be with his dead dad. over and over and over again. And there's this one scene where he's running after who he thinks is his father. He says, dad, come on, where are you? But no one came. It was time for the rescuer to appear, but no one was coming to help. I think everybody in this room were running either to someone or to something, hoping to get back what we lost, what we never got before. It could be friends. It could be beauty. It could be health.

23:16 It could be a career. It could be the thing that we think will be enough for us. Whatever that is, we want somebody to take that shadow away and tell us it's all going to be okay. But I know there's a voice inside of you because it's inside me as well. And that's this. The voice says this. Just because you want something to be true doesn't mean it's going to be true. see when my friend said I used to believe in the resurrection cognitive but now I really believe how do we know that's not just false hope One of the statements I've heard the most this year is this. the resurrection is too good to be true But you need to hear an assumption in that statement. When you hear people say the resurrection is too good to be true, the assumption that's being made is that something that can comfort us must therefore be not true. The fact that something can comfort us has no logical bearing, whether it's actually true or not.

24:15 C.S. Lewis points this out. He says, if I find in all my desires that there is nothing in this world that can satisfy, the only logical explanation is that I was made for another world. What he's getting at is this. Shouldn't it be the truth that if death is natural, it's always around us, then why do we feel so much so like it's not? Maybe it's because you weren't made for it.

24:40 That's powerful evidence that you were made for something else. I think it's very, very inconvenient, the resurrection story. Why would you invent a resurrection story that hinges on the bodily resurrection of a crucified criminal where enemies can verify ones who were still alive and they were motivated to disprove it? Why would you do that? It would be so much easier if they just said, it's metaphorical, it's spiritual.

25:09 Why would you do it with first century Greeks and Jews who were not expecting this, didn't want it, had no concept for an individual resurrection in the middle of time, and yet that's exactly what you see. The resurrection story is either the worst wish fulfillment story ever conceived, or it actually happened.

25:33 My friend's daughter, again, is not waking up tomorrow. She's not coming home. And you know what? Take your sense experience. How do you comfort him? Do you sit around and go, well, you know, it's a dog-eat-dog world. That's not going to help. If you go and say to him, well, you know, she's in a better place. That's not going to help. If you go to him and say, you know what, sorry, life stinks and then you die. That's not going to help. my friend's only hope your only hope my only hope that makes sense of our experience is that we will see her again and I'll see my father again and you will see what you lost again but the way it was always meant to be and the way that you never knew that you needed to want it that's what is in store which means guess what good news you don't have to live your best life now You hear that phrase all the time, YOLO, live your best life in Lyle?

26:29 You don't have to. And you can't. Because you have this. You can only come in the resurrection. Because of the resurrection, it's the way that you're going to be able to have life. The Christian faith lets us say this. I don't know why bad things happen. You heard it in the testimony. We don't know why bad things happen. But it can't be that God doesn't love us. Why? because he took the ultimate worst thing. What's the worst thing that's ever happened in history? The death of his own son and he turned that evil into good. And if he can do that in Jesus' life, guess what? He can do it in your life as well. Through both your death and through your life. And that means no more sadness. That means no more death. Whatever is lost will be healed. Whatever was gone will be made renewed. Notice the resurrection is not the greatest hits.

27:22 It's not just reruns. It's not like, oh, I get to finally replay what I used to have. It's better than that. It's what was always supposed to be. And if that's true, then guess what? This is the only answer that we fully have that takes seriously our pain and does something about it. It gives us an infallible hope for the future, but it also lets us have a rock solid security now. Because of that hope. The promise of the resurrection is not the end of death now. It's the healing of all of creation. And it's always the way we wanted it. What if you really believe the resurrection today? Some of you have grown up in the church. You've been around. You've thought of it. You've heard of it. But it hasn't impacted your life. What if you let it? Speak it over to your losses.

28:14 Slam it into your heart. Every other religion that I know of, if you study all the world religions, they essentially say, this life doesn't matter, just wait for the next life. Every secular view that I know says this life is all that there is. The problem with all other religions is that it means that this world is cheapened, but the problem with secular view that says this world is all that there is is that suffering always takes it away. Only Christianity says this life actually matters, and guess what? Suffering doesn't have the last word. The grave doesn't have the last say.

28:52 And folks, that makes more sense of your lived experience than any other view that I know out there. That's what we have. That's the evidence of this. Easter is Jesus putting himself in the grave so that we could come out of it. Easter gives us that. And the question is, do you believe that? Because if you lack joy this morning, it's possible that you haven't actually let this resurrection power move from your head to your heart. You haven't seen every last moment in your life through it. it's not just about the ones you've lost it's about how you live every day every hour, every moment in light of it you need to move it from your intellect into your life, into your sense experiences Jesus took the full impact of that truck folks and he walked out on the other side and here's what he's saying to you he's saying come come with your questions you don't have to have them all figured out come with your doubts come with your hurts he can handle them he can take them come with your weary heart because he is the first fruits the guarantee that the harvest is coming and that the sleepers will wake and that you will too and everything sad will become untrue rest in that hold that let's pray Heavenly Father thank you for this good news thank you for the breadcrumbs the evidence that we have to contend that we as Paul even said if this didn't actually happen we would be the most pitied but if it did if it actually happened in history in life we have the answer is everything sad going to become untrue the answer is yes everybody in this room

30:59 is coming with some form of hurt, sadness, shame, guilt, incompleteness. It's the marriage that's in shambles. It's the relationship that never happened. It's the friends that keep you at bay. It's the loves that you never get, and it's the ones that you do that aren't enough. Whatever it is, I pray that you show us that in the resurrection, we don't get back what we always wanted to have or never got or did get and lost we get in the resurrection what it was always supposed to be

31:43 I pray that this would not just be an idea. it's so easy to go to nod and hmm and then walk out let this move in us, make this beautiful let it taste good and sweet as first fruits in our lives we pray these things in your name

Machine translated from the source