How Can We Be Honest With Ourselves?

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached April 19, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: 2 Samuel 24:9-19 0:32
9And Joab reported to the king the total number of the troops. In Israel there were 800,000 men of valor who drew the sword, and in Judah there were 500,000. 10After David had numbered the troops, his conscience was stricken and he said to the LORD, “I have sinned greatly in what I have done. Now, O LORD, I beg You to take away the iniquity of Your servant, for I have acted very foolishly.” 11When David got up in the morning, the word of the LORD had come to Gad the prophet, David’s seer: 12“Go and tell David that this is what the LORD says: ‘I am offering you three options. Choose one of them, and I will carry it out against you.’” 13So Gad went and said to David, “Do you choose to endure three years of famine in your land, three months of fleeing the pursuit of your enemies, or three days of plague upon your land? Now then, think it over and decide how I should reply to Him who sent me.” 14David answered Gad, “I am deeply distressed. Please, let us fall into the hand of the LORD, for His mercies are great; but do not let me fall into the hands of men.” 15So the LORD sent a plague upon Israel from that morning until the appointed time, and seventy thousand of the people from Dan to Beersheba died. 16But when the angel stretched out his hand to destroy Jerusalem, the LORD relented from the calamity and said to the angel who was destroying the people, “Enough! Withdraw your hand now!” At that time the angel of the LORD was by the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite. 17When David saw the angel striking down the people, he said to the LORD, “Surely I, the shepherd, have sinned and acted wickedly. But these sheep, what have they done? Please, let Your hand fall upon me and my father’s house.” 18And that day Gad came to David and said to him, “Go up and build an altar to the LORD on the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite.” 19So David went up at the word of Gad, just as the LORD had commanded.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:58 we get to the last story in 2 Samuel about David's life. And it ends kind of strangely. Unlike how a lot of people would write their memoir or their biography or they would tell their biographer to write about them, you don't see the ending of David's life with some great military feat or some poem at the end that describes all his feats of lore and yesterday. No, what you see here instead, that the author of the greatest story of Israel's entire history, David's life, they end his life with a census, a headcount, an administrative spreadsheet. It would be like a biography about Lincoln ending with some sort of budgeting committee meeting.

4:01 That's what is happening here. And a lot of people are like, that's kind of a really strange way to end. But this is the thing about scripture. In scripture, what looks benign often is radioactive underneath. We live in what philosopher Byung Chul Han thinks is the achievement society. That's how he describes the world that you and I live in every day. That here in New York City, we live in this optimization space. That we try to optimize everything. We try to biohack everything. We try to test and measure and get our minds around our sleep, our diet. We take supplements and people are taking peptides and there's these biometrics. We are the most, how do I say this? We're the most life hacked and we are the most focused on self-improvement.

5:02 We're the generation that cares about that the most. We've done that the most. we've spent billions and billions of dollars on this. And yet, loneliness is at epidemic levels. Anxiety is increasing across the board in every generation, but particularly including also the most educated, the most therapized generation ever. We know so much about the surface of ourselves, and yet I think the thing that drives things, the hidden engine under our choices still remain hidden. We don't see them. And so I think this text, what this text is trying to get at, it's not about the census. It's not about the numbers. It's about the engine underneath. And so for us to do that, we need to look underneath the hood to see this engine. So I want to look at three things this morning. Let's look at what you can't see, what to do when you finally see it, and then thirdly, how do we get the freedom to even look in the first place? I'll say that again. What we need to do to look under the hood, we need to look at what you can't see, what do you do when you finally do see it, and then how do we get the freedom to even look for it in the first place? So first, what can't you see? Let's go to our text, the first verse here, verse nine, it says here, Job, he reports the numbers. And in the very next verse, it says, David was conscious stricken. And he started, and he says, I have sinned greatly in what I have done. And a lot of people are like, wait a second, can we just back up for a moment? What did David do that was so bad? Why does he talk this way? What's wrong with counting people. Like literally there's a book in the Bible titled Numbers, which is all about counting.

6:51 God, we know in the Bible, he even orders censuses as well. So why is God angry with David? Why does David even know? It's one thing if God's angry and you're like, I don't understand why he's angry. But David, he's conscious stricken. He knows he did something wrong. And we're like, but what did you do? What actually happened? Well, the text is not explicit. And I think that's our first hint, that the silence here is the point. It shows us that sometimes the most significant things about what we do never is just the action on the surface. It's not the action itself. It's the motivation underneath it all. The parallel account to this text here in 2 Samuel 24 is 1 Chronicles chapter 21, and it gives us more of the context. The context for this census is that David has had a number of amazing military victories. He's at the absolute peak of his power here, And which means there's actually no dire reason necessarily for him to have to...

7:56 make a count. Things have been going really great. And so what Israel is now actually counting, how many people do I have? Now, why would they do that? The theology for Israel's reason for warfare actually can be summarized, if you go to chapter 1 Samuel 14, it says this, nothing can hinder the Lord from saving, whether by many or by few. Translation, God doesn't need your numbers. He can actually do all things, whether with many or few. If you go to 1 Samuel chapter 17, it says this, for the battle is the Lord. The battle is the Lord. So, you know, ergo, why is David then counting? And now with that context, we can start realizing the only reason why he would do that is because... he's beginning to think like every other ancient Near East king. He's had a bunch of victories.

8:52 He's had a bunch of wins. So he's starting to count. Why? Because he's not doing defensive. He's not trying to protect. He's going to go on the offense. He's starting to look around going, who now can we take? Who can we actually conquer? In other words, David has here stopped trusting God to give him victories, and he started now trusting in his own resources, in the numbers that he can quantify for his army. So you need to hear this. The action of counting is neutral. It's the motivation underneath it that's the problem. The census isn't the sin. it's the symptom of what actually is the sin. The great 19th century preacher Charles Spurgeon has a story about this that we've used at Redeemer before but I'm going to tell it again because it's so good.

9:45 The story goes like this. There was a gardener once who made this amazing carrot. He grew a carrot. It was great. And he loved his king and so he offered his king this gift of this beautiful carrot. And the king was so moved by this gift he gave this gardener a larger plot of land to grow more carrots. Now there was a nobleman who was in the court that day, saw this happen and he started thinking, hmm, this is really amazing. If the king gives a plot of land for a carrot, what would he give for an even better gift?

10:20 And so what he did was the next day he shows up to court. for the king with his best horse, this amazing horse. And he looked at the king and said, oh great king, here is my best horse. I give it to you as a gift. And that king, discerning what was going on, seeing his heart, accepted the horse, said thank you very much and send him on his way. Now the nobleman was confused. He was like, I don't understand. And again, the king was like, okay, I'll help you here. I'll explain. Here's what happened. The gardener gave me the carrot. you gave yourself a horse and I think that's a great illustration because for us in our text the census for David that was him giving himself a horse and we do this all the time You might not have a standing army that you're counting, but there are things that we count and let me be very clear there is nothing wrong with checking in on your retirement portfolio there's nothing wrong with listing your achievements there's nothing wrong with tracking and wondering what your standing is.

11:28 But what's the motivational engine underneath those things? That's what I want to talk about. Is the reason why you do those things, is it because you're needing some sense of control? Some sense of security? Are you trying to figure out, is the reason why you make that extra text message? to the relationships that you have, is it because you're, what are you needing? What kind of security, What kind of validity are you looking for? behind even our most virtuous actions, there is still a hidden engine, desperate to secure some power, some approval, some comfort, some control. Everybody in this room has a different thing that we're looking for and hoping in to give us what we think we need. But my question to you before we move anywhere else is, what's yours?

12:20 And I'm not talking about, by the way, I'm not talking about the reason that if you did something, and you would tell someone else why you did it. And I'm not even talking about your own self-narrative that you have about who you are and your own generosity and your own ability and your own, you know, virtue. I want to get at the real reason. That's what I'm talking about.

12:43 And I think what we need to say is this. Often what we say to ourselves and others, that we're giving people carrots, I think what's happening is we're actually giving ourselves horses. And what are those horses? Some of you don't even want to start this process. You want to know why you don't start thinking about your own sort of motivational engine? It's because for, at least in this text, you can't start even doing that because you're still, you're stuck with some of the questions that you have about what's going on here. Some of you can't even look at an engine because you're like, hey, I don't understand. Look at what God does next. He lays out three punishments. Famine, military failure, and three days of plague. And 70,000 people die. And a lot of folks in this room, this is what you start doing. You start thinking, wait a second, this doesn't seem fair. This seems wildly disproportionate.

13:39 That someone had a bad motivation for a census and 70,000 people die. How is that okay? Two things, real quickly. One, this census was not a private action. Yes, when a leader actually makes decisions, it affects the culture. And the culture has now changed. Where now, the entire group of Israel, they now have moved from trusting God to trusting in their military might. They now actually have collectively changed their hearts about this. And now they're all culpable for it. When a leader's hidden heart corrupts, the surrounding culture is not left unaffected. The second thing you need to know is this. Look what God actually does. Look what he targets. Think about famine.

14:31 What does famine do? It targets economic power. Military failure targets military power. Plague targets social and cultural power. And so what's actually happening here is God is going after the very exact economic, military, and cultural idols that the census was built to serve. Which means God is actually being surgical here. He's trying to cut out the very problems. You don't go, when an oncologist decides to cut out the cancer, when an oncologist says you need radiation, you don't think that's cruelty. Cruelty would be an oncologist looking at your scans and then sending you home saying, hey, everything's fine, you're good, don't worry about it. See, God doesn't do that. God cares too much. When he cuts, he's not cutting to hurt, he's cutting to heal in this text. But here's what you need to know. You don't go to the doctor unless you know you're sick, and you don't know you're sick unless you read the scan.

15:35 And my question today, before anything else, is this. Are you willing to read the scan? Are you willing to do the work? To ask yourself, you know, you say you're giving carrots, but are you willing to realize that you're actually giving horses to yourself? What is the thing that if you lost it, what is that thing that you feel like if you lost it, you'd feel like you lost yourself?

15:59 Don't just sit around and ask, hey, what do I do wrong in the world? I mean, that's a fine exercise, but you really should be asking through all the things that the world says I do right, all the virtuous things that I do right, what is the motivational engine underneath those things? How do I discover where in those spaces there is selfishness, where there's a self-serving attitude? Because when you do that, then you'll find out what your actual God is, who your functional savior is. And that's what you often don't see. That's what you don't often see. That's number one. Okay, fine.

17:08 What do you do when you finally see it? Well, look what happens next. Look at David. The phrase here in verse 10 that's translated conscious stricken, literally it means his heart smote him. I love that old English word. It brought ruin to him. And so, hear this. This is not just feeling bad. Oh, shucks. I feel sorry. David here is doing something different and it's hard to tell, right? Because when the plagues hit Egypt what happened to Pharaoh? You know what Pharaoh did when the plagues first hit? He confessed. He said, I have sinned. Take it away. And when the plagues went away what happened? His heart was hardened. He went right back to things. He actually wasn't actually repenting. Remorse is sadness over consequences. repentance is sadness over the causes that brought on the consequences see remorse is feeling bad about what's happened after as a consequence repentance is the sorrow of the causes remorse leaves you in the same place repentance always turns you around the same hidden engine that's underneath our actions I think is also underneath and runs our sorrows.

18:31 That actually you can get, when you get beneath to the motivational level, there are actually reasons why you can grieve that are actually wrong. Because you, why? Because you can grieve because you got caught. You can grieve because of the cost. You can grieve because of how it made you look. It looks like grief. People go, oh, wow, look at them. They're really cut up by it. No. your motivational engine is off so then you push back you say, how do you know David is actually repenting here? How do you know he's not just in damage control I think you can see three things with his response. one his heart strikes him before any profit before any plague shows up this matters real repentance always starts with your own conscience not just consequence secondly he admits without excuse.

19:23 Look at what he actually says. He says, I have sinned greatly. He goes, and I beg you and I have done a very foolish thing. You know what's not here? Oh, but you don't understand the stress that I was under as a, you know, the head of a state. Oh, you don't understand what I've gone through. There's no explanation. He just owns it cleanly. Thirdly, he places himself in God's hands.

19:51 When it comes time to choosing his punishment, this is down in verse 14, he only wants to be in God's hands. He says here, he says, for his mercy is great. That's his argument. In other words, he's not just sorry. What is he doing? He's trusting. And that matters because why in the first place, we only printed part of the chapter earlier, Joab, other people were saying this is a bad idea, but he didn't listen to them. Why now? because what's happening now is he's turning. He was going in one direction and now he's going in a different direction.

20:27 If you find yourself saying sorry for the same thing over and over and over again, you probably are feeling sorry, but you haven't repented. Early on in my marriage, I had a habit when my wife would call and say, hey, how close are you? I'd always say, I'm two blocks away when I was really 10. And there's a lot of reasons for that. and of course I would always be late so then what would I do? I'd say I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

20:54 Eventually she was like that's great that you're sorry, I want change. Because that will show me that you actually have repented, that things have actually changed here. Repentance always means a directional movement away and towards. He moved away from trusting what he thought he needed. towards trusting to what he really needed in God. And the evidence of repentance isn't just how bad you feel. It's not that. It's the direction that you're going to go in. And here's what's counterintuitive about all that. The world assumes that as you spiritually grow, as you get, you know, more spiritually better, that that means you're a better and better person. So then you have less to actually repent. That's how the world thinks. But that's actually not how it works. That the more you grow, the more clearly what happens is you start seeing your own heart.

21:48 The more you see your own mixed motivations. The motivational engine underneath everything else. You actually repent more, not less. Because you see yourself better. A great musician, a great athlete doesn't end up practicing less. What happens is because they've gotten so great at their craft, they now see the gap between what they are and what they could be. And they become laser focused on that. It's the same thing with repentance. It's a practice. And the better you get at it, the more you see, the more you have to work on. And so today, if you say, hey, I believe in Jesus, but then you can't omit when you are wrong. You can't name your mixed motivations. You're not actually growing. Spiritual growth, by definition, is not needing less grace. it's knowing that you need it more.

22:47 You'll turn. You'll turn and repent to the degree that it feels safe to do so and it'll feel safe for you to do so if you know whose hands you are in. Notice David is not repenting because he's cleaned up his life first. He's not repenting because he's in his own hands. He knows he's in his hands just as he is and that's what lets him do it. Do you know that too? How do you know that you have that? To the degree that you do, to that degree, will you actually do this have you learned how to turn? It's great to feel sorry. It's great to actually have that feeling, but real repentance is always turning. Don't just look, therefore, out in the world. If you want a practical application, don't look for just accomplished friends. Don't look for the people who have their lives all put together.

23:41 Look for the people who are the most able, most willing to actually confess and repent. those people are the ones that have a higher chance to actually be running their lives on grace. And you can apply that to yourself too because you could be that friend for others. All right, last point. How is it possible? What gives us the freedom, the ability to actually go off and do this? I think in our text, what it shows us, the hints is actually in the geography. Where is all this happening? When David in verse 18 here, when he builds an altar, he's actually building it on a very specific hill and that hill is Mount Moriah it's the very same mountain where Abraham brought Isaac where God stayed Abraham's hand at the very last moment what did he say to Abraham?

24:32 he said stop, don't do it I will provide a substitute and what happens? a ram is revealed to die in Isaac's place what's amazing in this text is this is now centuries later on the very same mountain the angel of the Lord, if you look at verse 16 here it says his hand is outstretched to destroy and what does God do? God says stop he says stay your hand same mountain same state hand, same word stop and what happens is he tells God God tells David to build an altar, what? to offer a substitute and then after David on this exact location, this is actually where Solomon builds his temple where now for generations you will have on the very same ground animals being slaughtered not because God needs blood but because the people need to see what is required how justice requires wrong to be absorbed someone has to take it something has to absorb it in our text, you know what happens?

25:40 David tries to be that substitute look down here in verse 17 It's very admirable. He says, hey, I have sinned. I, the shepherd, have done wrong. These are but sheep. What have they done? Let your hand fall on me and my family. Admirable, but guess what? He couldn't do it. God couldn't even accept it. Why? Because he was guilty too. He can't pay the debt for someone else if he actually has that debt himself. That was the problem. He was guilty. And guess what? The animals that are being sacrificed by the tens of thousands on this exact site, they can't actually pay. They point though, they point forward. Every sacrifice on this hill, Abraham's ram, David's oxen, all these thousands and thousands of burnt offerings, they're all pointing forward, basically saying someone needs to come and actually make the sacrifice so this offer sticks, so that the hand really does stay.

26:48 And the Ark of the Bible is basically asking that question, and we don't get the answer until we get to the New Testament, where what do you find there? You find Jesus, the last week of his life, he goes into Jerusalem, he walks up a hill, Mount Moriah, he goes to the temple, and just a few days later, on a hill that overlooks that, he gets to see, as he's being executed, he's able to see that he's going to be the one to make the offer that David never could. He stands in not for sheep, not for oxen, but for every single one of our hidden censuses, for all of our wrong motivations, every mixed motivation, everything that you've done or that you haven't done or that you should have done or will do, all those things, he takes that sword.

27:47 that had been stopped on Moriah again and again, and finally it doesn't stop. It lands on him. I would love for us to be able to do the work to know that every census that we've ever tried to take, every manipulative act of charity, every self-serving act of service that we do, every horse that we've given to ourself, that he saw those things and yet he went anyway. That's what Paul is trying to get at when he says in 2 Corinthians, he says, God had made him who knew no sin to become sin so that we might have the righteousness of God. That translation, that's a fancy way of saying Jesus was our substitute. He ends up in our place.

28:41 He didn't just sympathize with the hidden engine. he absorbed all the hidden engines that we deserve. He absorbed the payment that we should have made for those things. In history, if you look at it over and over and over again, when a leader fails, the people suffer. Same thing happens here. Jesus reverses it. The people fail. And Jesus suffers and bears the cost. That's the gospel. He gets what you deserve. You get what he deserves. David used his power to serve himself. Jesus uses his power to serve everyone else. how do we really know that David that David actually repented I gave you some of the features I gave you the difference I gave you the terms but how do we really know that he didn't just feel sorry one of the things that we know from history is this history is always written by the victors have you heard that phrase history is always written by the victors what that means is that if you get to be the last one standing to write the history books you tend to always airbrush you tend to always be the one to kind of fudge on your failures.

29:54 and make them look a little bit better. But if that's true, and David was the greatest success ever, why do we know about Bathsheba? Why do we know about Absalom? Why do we know about this census? It's because David let his failures be in the record. Against every instinct of pride and legacy, he put it in there. Why? Because what makes a person free enough to do that? What makes a person free enough to do that? Think about Peter. Why do we know about his failures? Think about the disciples. Why do we know about how at the time when Jesus needed them to actually be there for him in the Garden of Gethsemane that they weren't? How do we know about Paul and all the things that he did wrong? we know because when you actually receive grace you no longer need to manage your image your failures are no longer stains to cover they are the marks of grace and you don't mind other people seeing those marks you can let people in when your identity is in your moral performance when it's in your vocational success when it's in your relational numbers when it's in your relationships when it's in your your reputation you must defend that image at all cost every stain is a threat to your acceptance but here's what I want you to imagine imagine everything you've ever done wrong every mixed motive every failure of love and honesty is written like in a file one of those old you know now that everything's digital I'm going to go back imagine it's in one of those like vanilla files and it's stacked big and God opens that file and he reads every single one of those things.

31:48 He sees it all and he doesn't reject you for it. He saves you from it. And then he puts a stamp on it that says paid in full in Jesus. If that's actually true, the file no longer becomes a threat. Even better, it's now actually a sign of grace. It's actually your testament to everyone else. That's why we know of David's story. That's why we know of Peter's story. That's why we know the disciples' story. My question to you is this, is do you have that story? Can you? Are you able to let other people read your file? Do you even want people to? Because now it's no longer a sign of the stains of your sin, but it's actually a testament of the grace that you've received. you will when grace stops being a concept and actually starts being a daily experience no performance review no vocational success no retirement fund balance is ever going to come close to offering you the freedom found in that file being stamped paid in full they won't the world will tell you this the world will tell you you know what real freedom is?

33:10 freedom is being able to do anything you want anywhere you want the problem with that is is that that's still in the file and you're still condemned for it real freedom is when you have done whatever you have done no longer has the power to destroy every supplement that's out there every biometric every success It's all trying to earn what can only be given in Jesus. And when you have that freedom, friends, that's when you give. You always give out of what has been given to you. you use it to care and love others. And so over the next week, this is what I want you to ask. Don't just ask. Here's how to apply this. Don't just ask, what have I done wrong in the world? That's fine.

34:01 Ask, what are the, even the things that I have done most right, what are the motivational engines under those things? And once that you've actually named them, once you bring them to God, not to be punished, but so that the file can be seen, and then stamped, paid in full. That's what I want you to be asking. Is there still something that you're hiding? Is there something out there in your hearts that you don't want other people to see, that you're worried that if it came to light, you would be rejected?

34:32 Let that be read. And the truth is this, he actually already read it before you did. He knew about it before you knew about it. He already read it and he already forgave you. He already went to Mount Moriah. He already paid for it. He was already that substitute. He did it. So your file is now clean. You are not the hero of your own story, but you know what? You're loved by the one who is.

34:57 David, his story ends not with grace, greatness. David's story ends with grace. And your story can end that way too. If you allow it, if you accept this, it starts by seeing the hidden motivational engines. it starts with turning and repenting and then knowing that the file has been paid in full. Will you let that affect you? Will you let yourself experience that and not just know it? Let's pray. Heavenly Father, this is a good word. It's a hard word because we like to look at the surface. We are the most studied generation of the surface of ourselves. We know the surface of our nature, but help us to see, pull back the hood to look at the motivational engine underneath all the things that we do.

35:51 Help us to see the mixed motivations, the inconsistencies, the way that we try to earn power, approval, comfort and control because of our insecurity, our lack of what we think we need and help us to see that the only way to actually be full and be filled is to see that you are our substitute.

36:14 that you went up on Mount Moriah after again and again others did and you stayed their hand, you finally took and paid the price. I pray that that would be something that would move us. Help it affect us. Help us to be able to give out of what's been given. Help us to love and serve out of gratitude that it comes from seeing your nature and what you've done and what you're doing and what you will continue to do. Move in our hearts, we pray these things in your name. Amen.

Machine translated from the source