Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached March 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
3:16 one of those passages that most people don't think they need until their life has fallen apart. But I believe that you need this every day. And often we don't know we need it. And by the time we do think we need it, it's too late if we haven't been looking at it. Because most of us spend our lives polishing our everyday lives. We are building our resumes. We focus on the positive things because our culture says to us, don't look at the negative things that you do. That's bad self-esteem. That's problematic. So just dwell on the positive things. Avoid the self-examination, the introspection. But there are times in our life when you have no choice. and what do you do when that happens? I think it's too late by then. And I think what this text has given us, though, is there is a secret here about how you can actually change.
4:11 There's a secret here about how you can be different. And my worry, though, is the minute I tell you what the secret is, you're going to tune me out. And you're going to tune me out because you're going to think it's too easy or it's not that important or it's just one of those religious words that are thrown around in churches at times. But I'm here to tell you that actually that the way that you're going to be able to change, the way that you're going to be able to survive your own brokenness, the way you're going to be able to survive other people's brokenness that is done to you is going to be to the degree that you know how to repent. And see, I threw out that word and before you start tuning me out, let me just say, just give me 10 more seconds. I think that people who only think that, that people who don't think they have anything to repent of, people who think they've never done anything wrong, we have a word for those people in culture.
5:06 You know what they're called? Sociopaths. We all know that we have done things. We all know that we have, there's things that we are not, there are things that we are upset about that we have done out there. And the problem is that when we wish that we haven't done something, most of us don't know what to do when we have. And so I think that's why we need to talk about this. Think about all the times that you wanted to change, but you couldn't. Think about all the times when you said, okay, now I'm gonna be different. Starting tomorrow, you know, there's gonna be a new person in town. And then you do it over again, and then again, and again. And we try to fix it and we can't fix it. You can't change, why? Because I would argue you haven't actually dealt with the root issue. You can change the surface stuff, you can change the symptoms, but you haven't got at the root.
6:00 And culture, why is there a problem? Because culture tells us don't look at it. Culture says, just stay on the surface. It's not going to be good for you to go down into that. But I think that's exactly what we need to do. And this psalm, what we have here in Psalm 51, is what David does when he takes a look. This is what he wrote after Nathan confronts him. David had become king. He had been on the run from Saul. He was hiding in and out of caves. And he had these mighty men around him. and these mighty men protected him. They were the guys who saved him and one of those guys' names, his name was Uriah the Hittite and he had a wife named Bathsheba and David slept with her, got her pregnant and then to cover it up, he had him killed at the front lines of a war. and then he tried to look like to all of the nation, look how benevolent he is because he's going to take this war hero's wife for his own so that she's not a widow anymore.
7:04 And Nathan confronts him. And what does he do as he writes Psalm 51? So here's three things I want to look at today. What repentance is not, what repentance is, and then how do you have the courage to actually do it? What is it not? What is it? How do you have the courage to do it? And so number one, what is it not? I have to do this because I actually think a lot of us in this room, we think we know what it is. But let's actually go through what it's not first so that we can really tell. Number one, there's I think at least three things that it's not. Number one, that are counterfeit repentance. It is not just emotional feelings without heart change. What do I mean by that? It's not remorse or regret. Here's what remorse is. I feel bad.
7:51 Remorse is I feel sorry. Tears. weeping, oh my gosh. You have no idea how many people that I've met that are full of tears. They're so sorry. And then they get up to, you know, a couple days later and do the same thing over again. When you mess up, feeling bad, by the way, is better than feeling nothing. I'll give you that. But it's not actually repentance. And here's the difference between remorse and regret. Remorse is you're sorry about the thing itself. Regret is you're actually sorry about the fact that it happened in the first place. You're sorry about the consequences, not the reason why you did it. So I regret that you were upset. I regret that I did this thing. But that's just about how it started, not actually how it ended or why you did it in the first place. If you go to Matthew 27, it says there that Judas was seized with remorse.
8:47 A lot of people don't know this. That actually meant Judas felt bad. He was sorry. He gave his money back with regret. He was like, I don't want this. So whatever repentance is, it can't be just remorse and regret. I think a lot of people think, okay, I felt bad about this. That's repentance. No, it's not. Whatever it is, it's not just remorse or regret. All right, number one counterfeit thing. Number two, trying to pay for it yourself. About 500 years ago, Martin Luther climbed, actually it happened twice. He climbed steps in Rome on his knees trying to earn God's favor. He would fast for so long that he would make himself ill. He would beat himself up physically, but also mentally and spiritually. And by the way, we still do this, right? We don't maybe do it physically as much. But we emotionally and psychologically beat ourselves up.
9:43 When we do something wrong, we shame ourselves. When we say, oh, I'm unworthy. I feel bad. and you're trying to pay for it. But that's counterfeit because you can't pay for what you've done. There's not enough that you can do. Let's just even say you could actually pay for what you've done. You'll just go out and do it again. So it's never enough. You can't pay for your sin by just hating yourself more, by feeling bad about it. We already established that. It's not about, we think if I just hate myself enough, if I suffer enough, if I beat myself up, maybe God or fate or whatever you want to believe in, maybe then, you know, I've done my time and now I'll be okay. That's not how it works. It's counterfeit. Counterfeit number three, blame shifting. This is what you see a lot of celebrities do this. When things have happened, they put out a very heartfelt, lots of great words.
10:41 they put out an official statement, they say mistakes were made. What is that? That's actually not taking any ownership. Another version of that is this, I'm sorry you feel that way. Have you ever used that phrase? I'm sorry you feel that way. When you do that, you should just take out the word sorry, because that's really what's happening. You're just saying you feel this way. It's actually a way for you to not apologize by telling someone else how they're actually feeling. If you think about it, it's actually kind of messed up if you think about it. There's a 2.0 version of this that we do now where we talk about my childhood trauma. The reason why I did this is because of the fact that I got triggered. And my family of origin, the reason I did this is because this is what my family did to me. And we try to be very careful. There is trauma.
11:34 There is family of origin. There is your personal experiences. those things actually do matter. They do have an effect on who you are. But when you use those things as a means to not take ownership, you are blame shifting. You're not actually repenting. And we do something called Q&R after every service. You can text in questions now, but I can already tell you what someone, every couple of weeks we get this question. Usually when there's a sermon like this, people go, well, where's the line? Like, where am I allowed to talk about my trauma? And where am I allowed to talk about my feeling of origin? And where am I actually doing it to blame shift and actually not take ownership? And I'll already tell you the answer. The answer is, it depends. It's always about your heart motivation. It always is. But if you're apologizing or making excuses, in the sense, if you're blame shifting, it prevents repentance.
12:28 That's how you know it's when it's not working. Look at David here in Psalm 51. It's full of these personal pronouns. Have mercy on me, oh God, according to your unfailing love. Right? Then he says, my iniquity, wash my iniquity, cleanse me from my sin. For I know my transgressions. My sin is always before me. See, it's all these personal pronouns. That's not blame shifting. That's taking responsibility. that's taking and not allowing any, you know how there's always more than one side of things, there's always other reasons? He could have gone to those things, but he doesn't. He doesn't say, you know what, hey, there's other kings out there, I'm not as bad as those kings. He could have said, you know,
13:21 I was the youngest of my entire family, and my father forgot about me when he was reporting about who are all his sons. And so of course I found my comfort in women. But he didn't do that. He ends up fully taking responsibility. And not only that, if you look very closely in verse 4, David says, against you and only you I have sinned. Let me be very clear here. He doesn't just say against you I have sinned. He says against you and you alone. It's a Hebrew idiom. when you have the you, you right next to each other, that is called a double emphatic. It is an intensification. David is so cut up about this.
14:09 One of the problems with all the other things that I just talked about, remorse, regret, it's you're thinking about you still. One of the ways you know you're starting to repent is actually you're not so much cut up about how it affects you. You're cut up about how it affects anyone else. David, in this moment, is not thinking about his own heart. He's thinking about how he's grieved God's heart. That's actually what he cares about more. That's actually what he's focused on. And I think that's actually one of the ways that you know. He's not thinking just about himself. He's thinking about God. So repentance, let me recap. Not remorse, regret, self-flagellation, or blame shifting. But before we go on to see what it actually is, this is what I want us to do. where in your life have you used those counterfeits? Where have you thought you've repented, but actually you haven't?
15:03 I would argue the reason why we go to those counterfeits. is because at some level, we don't feel like we're that bad. We don't have to go that deep because we can stay up here with these feelings. Why? Because at the end of the day, we look at David and we go, well, listen, David was a murderer. David was an adulterer. You know, I'm not that bad. That's what we do. On the surface, we're like, hey, I didn't do that much. But sometimes this is what I have to do to myself. I have to say, well, what if everybody in the world knew exactly how I felt and what I thought? If that was broadcast to the whole world, just try to imagine that. Would the whole world think that you were okay? No, that's not true. The world would be appalled. Of course they would be. And so a lot of us sit around, we wonder, why do I feel so lonely? Is it possible that you and I feel lonely because we're terrified at some level that if we were fully known, if everybody knew all of our thoughts, we would be rejected.
16:01 To be loved, you have to be known. But to be known, people have to actually know it all. And we don't want people to know it all because we're terrified that they will reject us. Why are you so tired today? Is it possible at some level, there's this incessant need to do, do, do. I have to earn. I have to go because there's this deep sense of shame. There's a sense of, I need to do more. I got to cover up what I've done.
16:28 For those of you who come to church, if you're like worship, I just feel like I'm going through the motions. Michael's blah, blah, blah, I ain't up there right now. If you're like, well, I don't understand why, why doesn't, what's going on. The answer is you can't taste what isn't real to you. We could talk up here all day long. If it's not, if it's just ideas, if it doesn't move from your head into your heart, it's not going to matter. You have to experience it. You can't change if you don't get to the root issue. And so where are the counterfeits in your life right now?
17:35 What are the things that, again, I'm trying to break down to the elemental issues. That word repentance is one of those big spiritual words that are thrown out there. I just gave you three, four reasons, four counterfeits that it's not. It's not those things. Fine. Then what is it? Point two. I'll give you two ways that you know that it's real repentance. Number one, it's honesty and ownership. When confronted, David doesn't say all those other things. He owns it himself. And instead, what does he say? He says, I have sinned. And to really do that, you have to get at the root. And I don't want to get all philosophical for too long, but real quick, are humans essentially good or essentially bad? This is a big philosophical question, but people have debated this for a while. Are people good, but they do bad things?
18:28 Or are they bad and they happen to do good things? The problem with if you think people are essentially good, but they happen to do bad things, the problem with that is then the reason why you did a bad thing at some level, if you're essentially good, is that you just didn't have enough education. You were put in the wrong family. It was the circumstances that are around you. But if you just, you know, tried hard enough, if you are in other places, since I'm essentially good, it'll work out for me. See, the problem with that view... is you, at the end of the day, it gives you all the excuses and possibility to say, well, there's something else out there. But look at David. What does David do here? David in Psalm 51 says in verse three, for I know my transgressions and my sin is always before me. And look at verse five.
19:20 Surely I was sinful at birth. All right, David's coming out on the side of, he's saying, no, humans, me, essentially bad. Now some of you are like, oh, that's so depressing. As a New Yorker, I find that refreshingly honest. I find it authentic. I find it honorable to actually say, I am not going to make those excuses. I'm going to start with myself. It starts with me. And you live with yourself long enough and you live with other people long enough. If you live with kids long enough, you're like, nope, essentially bad. and I'll show you in a little bit why that's actually not as depressing as you might think. but the benefit of saying that is here's the reason why it's good because it helps you get to the root you can't kill the habits that are killing you unless you first are honest about what's killing you And unless you're able to get at the root of it, you'll never get there real repentance starts with honesty and ownership are you being honest and are you owning with your role, with what you've done.
20:29 See, David goes deeper. And I want that for you and I want that for me. All right, that's the first aspect of real repentance. Secondly, repentance is remembering what you forgot. In verse four, David says, against you and you alone I've sinned. And some people go, wait a second, that's kind of messed up. Didn't he sin against Bathsheba? Didn't he sin against Uriah? It sounds like this guy's gaslighting these guys. He's saying, no, no, no. but you're missing the point. David, what he's trying to get at here is he's trying to say, no, no, no. I know where this ends. That before David stole Uriah's wife, he had already dethroned God in his heart. That's what he's getting at.
21:15 And again, we have to deprogram one of these religious words. This word sin that David used right here, surely I was sinful at birth. It's thrown around in spiritual spaces and I don't think we define it well enough. It's not just bad things. It's not just breaking the rules. Sin is anything, often, usually it's good things that you make ultimate in your life that you need more than God. That you get your identity from, that you get your hope from, that you get your happiness from, that you get your joy from. And so what David is saying here is he's saying, I didn't just break rules. I actually have made something good, ultimate in my life. And then if you look closely, what he says here in verse 12, he says, restore to me the joy of my salvation.
22:13 What's so interesting about that phrase is he's getting at this. When you make something in this world a joy to you, by definition it means you're not getting joy from God you're not getting joy from salvation and what David is saying there is going hey I lost the joy I forgot God that you saved me you saved me from myself you saved me from Saul you saved me from all these other things he needed joy from Bathsheba because he was not getting joy from God he wouldn't have needed the smile from Bathsheba if he understood the smile that he had from God. 거야
22:55 gleichzeitig the horizontal movement of our of our injury that we do to other folks you first have to betray God You don't commit adultery without some level in your heart saying, God you're not enough for me
23:17 You would never lie unless at some level you're like, you know what, God, your truth won't protect me. I have to spin. I have to shade things to be really accepted so when David actually says between you before you God and you alone what he's trying to get at is I've first done this this is where it starts David shows us that horizontal hurt towards others only happens because of vertical loss of joy first against you and you alone folks what are you trusting in right now who is the someone or something that you are trusting, that you're trying to get your joy from because your joy is not in God? What do you think it can offer you? What is it promising in your life that you think you can only get from that that you can't get from Him?
24:13 Real repentance starts when we remember, when we remember what we're doing and we remember that we've forgotten our first love, We've forgotten our joy in God. We sin against God first. What do you think you need because you have forgotten your need of him? That's what I want us to get at. What joy are you seeking because he's not your joy? David's darkness, our darkness, all these things come out because you've made some other thing a joy other than him. And that means to really repent, you have to remember what you've forgotten. So there's ownership. and remembrance. Ownership and remembrance. All right, last point. Great, Mike. Nice lecture. How do we have the courage to actually do this? Yes, we put it in our liturgy. Yes, we try to, you know, but again, you just go through the motions. Where do you, I was actually, I was sitting over there during confession going, man, I preach about this stuff, but do I do it, do I go deep enough? Do I just keep it on the surface? In verse one, David prays this. He says, have mercy yomio God, according to your unfailing love.
25:28 That phrase, unfailing love, we just, it's pretty benign to us, but you don't understand in Hebrew, that is a huge theological term. It's the Hebrew word chesed, which I've been trying to meditate on this word. It means unconquerable love. Covenantal love, again, that was one of those words, like what does that mean? It means that it's unbreakable, it's unshakable, it won't stop.
25:53 David begins, he can only do the rest of this because he starts with... God's unconquerable commitment that he had of David. That he was, David was so sure of that. And so if that's true, then here's what you can do. If I've manipulated someone and I'm worried, chesed is still on you. If you lied, if I cheated, chesed is still there. What if I did something I'm so ashamed of that I don't want anybody to know about.
26:27 Chesed is still there. The confidence David had, it's actually pretty mind-boggling because David had such astounding confidence in God's unfailing, unconquerable love. Do you have that kind of confidence? Could you have that kind of confidence? Because I would argue that we have even more reason. than David. Why? Because David, what does he say here? He appeals to God's general mercy. He says, blot out my sin. Here at the very end, right, in verse 9. Hide your face, blot out my iniquity. That word blot means undue, unalive, right? Or undead, what I did. But he's asking for that. He's hoping. He doesn't know. In fact, later on, he talks about you don't want sacrifices. The sacrificial system that he had, he's like I know God that's actually not enough
27:25 But he didn't know what was going to be enough. see as much as David had this confidence I don't think he has the resources that we have today. that David was hopeful, but he didn't know what we knew. And this is what we know, that centuries later, Jesus Christ on the cross, first thing we find there is this, that he proves that we are essentially not good. Because if all you need is a little bit of education, a little bit of different circumstances, then you'll be all right. No, no, it took the son of God to die on the cross to pay for what you've done. When I say you, you and me. but on that cross, what we find is Jesus saying, I will pay, I will fix, I will save. Repenting, folks, just so you know, it doesn't fix what we did.
28:18 It can't make Uriah be alive again. It doesn't do that, but Jesus can do what David can't do. When David prayed in verse 11, go to verse 11 here real quickly. What does he say? Do not cast me from your presence. why did God not cast him from his presence? Because Jesus Christ on the cross, what does he say? My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
28:44 That's Jesus saying, my God, my God, why have you cast me from your presence? The reason why David was not cast out of his presence, the reason why you and I will not be is because Jesus was. That's what this is saying. he got what David, he got what you and I deserve. He took our place. Every bit of selfishness, every little bit of fakeness, that smugness you have, that self-righteousness, the things that you don't want the world to see, every thought that we think is not that bad, it's not that bad, but actually what it does is it does incalculable harm. as it creates barriers and hurt and injury between each other. Jesus Christ took it all. and when you see him do that if you really not just intellectualize it but if you make it your reality something inside you will shift where you will not all of a sudden when the temptation comes again not to say you're not always going to do the right thing.
29:48 but there's a part of you that says I don't want to do it as much when you see that your sin cost them everything you just don't confess you just don't do it as much over time. Not because you're trying harder, but because what's happening in those moments is you're tasting something better. His joy is now your joy.
30:09 You can't, friends, you can't and you won't repent if you're terrified of wondering if he's going to accept you. But what the cross is showing us is God saw you at your very worst and he loved you enough to die for you. And even what's amazing on this side of the cross in history, if you have that tendency to say, well, he can't love me, there's no way. He died before you were even born for you to be able to say that statement for what you are going to do and what you've done and what you will do. That's amazing. How beautiful, how wonderful that before you could protest that God can't love you, he already died for you. So you're not risking anything when you repent. In fact, the biggest risk is when you don't repent. Why? Because when you confess, friends, that's when you're honest. And when you're honest, that's when you can be known. And when you're known, that's when you can finally be loved.
31:10 Because you can't be loved unless you're known. That's why these things go together. To be fully loved, you have to be fully known. But to be fully known, you have to honestly confess. and that's why this is actually not depressing. When people are like, oh, it's, no, it's not. It's actually the entry point to God's grace. I distinctly remember when I was in college, I was working through what I believe, how do I believe it, and I actually, I remember when I became a Christian for the first time, or for, like I owned it for myself in college And I had such a sense of God's cosmic love. that it was never gonna leave. I was able to just, I picked up the phone and I was, I'm going to call my parents and tell them everything I've ever done. And I did. And I had no idea what they were going to do. And they kind of responded like you would think, kind of awkwardly. They were like, we're glad that things didn't go as bad as they could have for you. And they awkwardly knew me and loved me.
32:12 But even better was I already knew that I had that cosmically. That's why I could do that locally. and I want that for you as well. I think only Christianity offers that. Every other religion does this. Clean yourself up, then maybe God will love you. By the way, our world does this too. Be good, do good things in the world and then maybe you'll get love. Only Christianity says, actually, the more you admit, the more you show that you're not so good, at least you're honest about it, then you'll actually feel and experience and know God's love even more.
32:51 Only Christianity says that. Admit that you're not clean and then you'll know how much more he loves you because he paid for that too. He paid for that too. He paid for it even before you knew that you needed it. Admitting you're sinful is death for everyone else, friends, but it's life because it's just an entry point for you to understand his grace even more and even more and even more. That's why it's not depressing to know that there's nothing that you can do, that you are in need because he said that even though you have these faults and these flaws, I will cover those as well. Remember Martin Luther? The change happened for him 500 years ago. One day he heard Romans 1 verse 17. It just says this, the righteous will live by faith. He's going up stairs on bloody knees he's desperate and then he heard the righteous will live by faith that phrase by faith just means trust he's like wait it's only by trust it's not by climbing it's not by bleeding it's not by earning and this is what he wrote when I heard those words such power came over me that my great burden fell off and it was an instant what happened?
34:04 when he realized all he needed was his need that's when he tasted the goodness not just heard it you might be sitting here and for a thousand times you might have heard Christ died for you, he loved you but that's very different than actually tasting and experiencing it and actually saying there is now nothing more I have to do one of my favorite parts in Harry Potter is when Dobby who by the way the CGI in the movies made Dobby look like an idiot but Dobby was this house elf who was a servant He was enslaved. He was trapped. He was beaten. He had no freedom. And Harry Potter offers him a very simple gift, an article of clothing that frees him. And Dobby says this one phrase. He says, Dobby has heard of your greatness, Harry Potter, but your goodness Dobby never knew. And I love that phrase because I think so many of us, me included, we know God is great, but I don't know if we've really let ourselves experience his goodness.
35:06 accept the free gift take in and if you do you'll be able to admit you don't have to climb you don't have to earn the work is finished Jesus is not just great he is good and it's already done the work is finished and if you can redeem David he can redeem you and if he does redeem you folks then it's not remorse it's not regret it's not blame shifting it's ownership and it's remembrance let's do this now and always let's pray Heavenly Father thank you for this great work move in our hearts change us remake us this is hard information because it's just in our head move it into our lives we're not equipped to do this our culture doesn't teach us to look inside and we're afraid to.
36:07 Help us to know that we have nothing to fear. because you've already cleaned. Even before we knew what it was. Pray all these things in your name.
Machine translated from the source