Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached December 21, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
1:02 We've been going through an Advent series looking at the various songs that we have, the earliest songs we have, the hymns of Christmas. And today we get to the angel song. And here's how I want to set it up. I don't know about you, but what I love about living in New York City, I've been here for decades and decades, is often I'll get so used to a certain walk from my home. that for years I'll think I'll know where everything is, and all of a sudden I realize something I hadn't ever seen before, a block, a building. I think all of us here can do that. if I asked you about a particular building that you see every single day, and I say, can you actually, now I'm really low. Can anybody hear me now?
1:53 Be careful what you wish for. If, how do I say, oh, so you can walk around the same block, and I tell you, hey, can you tell me about that building? And you can say, you'll actually say, well, I can't, you can't actually describe it. Researchers actually call that the landmark effect. It's where your brain registers something enough where you can navigate around it, but really functionally it's invisible to you. They found the same thing that actually happens with museum guards. Museum guards will actually sit and watch a Rembrandt or a Monet for years and researchers ask them to explain or describe it, and they can't. Because it's been rendered functionally invisible to them because they see it so much. I believe this passage that's before you, it's just two verses, and we did that on purpose, is we are so familiar with it, we no longer see it.
2:54 We're kind of blind to them, like a guard blind to masterpieces or you on your walk around the building. We don't see it. When we see the phrase here, peace on earth, or, you know, on earth peace, a lot of us go, ah, that's a nice sentimental greeting card. We see it on greeting cards all the time. And we kind of walk on by. And yet, I think it's important for us to know that this night, whatever it was, it was anything but sweet and sentimental. In other passages, it says the shepherds were terrified. And so whether you're a Christian or a skeptic here this morning, I just want to say this. I think we both have the same problem. And that's that we don't really actually believe. And because we don't believe, we don't have peace. So let's see three things today.
3:46 Let's look at the peace we want, the peace we need, and the peace we get. We're going to have the peace that we want, the peace that we need, and the peace that we get. So first, the peace that we want. Everybody wants peace. Everybody does. but we look for it in the wrong places because we fundamentally don't understand what peace is really about. And so first, let's see the peace that we think we want, but actually doesn't work. Number one, it isn't political or circumstantial peace. We think that's what we want. If verse one, which we didn't print in your bulletin, verse one, Luke tells us that all this happened during the reign of Caesar Augustus. That's the Roman Empire. This is during the Pax Romana, which is Latin for the peace of Rome. In other words, there was great peace in the Roman Empire at this time, which I find very ironic that the angels come with their announcement of peace during the peace of Rome. Why? How did Rome get peace? They squashed everybody else.
4:54 They made sure everybody else didn't have peace so that they had peace. And we do the same thing. See, we think this. We want political peace. The way we're going to get that is our party wins and that other party we don't like loses. Our side wins and the other side loses. It's a zero-sum game. We do this circumstantial as well, right? I'll have peace if I get that job. I'll get peace if I get that pay raise, if I get that retirement package. If I finally get to that place that I want to live, I've always wanted to live. See, that's circumstantial peace that we want. But here's the problem with that. Circumstantial peace is based on our control, if we can actually just get what we finally want. The problem with that is that there's so little in this world. that we can actually control. It's fragile because of that. And so we're constantly looking for it politically and circumstantially, and it doesn't work.
5:52 Secondly, another type of peace we look for is we look for inner peace, inner psychological peace. All you have to do is go on some of those Instagram feeds or self-help books, and they all say the same thing. You need to look on the inside, and you need to get in touch with yourself, find that inner calm, focus on yourself. That functions like anesthesia. Anesthesia eliminates the sensation of pain, but it's really a distraction from the fact that the pain is actually still there. Whatever is causing the problem is still there. You might say, therefore, in this case, that real peace is not the absence of just the feeling of pain. Real peace would actually have the antidote. So just focusing on sort of that inner psychological peace often, it's like staring in the mirror saying, okay, I'm okay, I'm okay, I'm okay.
6:54 It doesn't, it ultimately won't work. If ever, if the whole world is falling apart around us, you can say that as much as you want. It doesn't stop. The fact that the problem still exists. Now, some of you might push back and say, well, wait a second, wait a second. You're a pastor. Doesn't Christianity offer you inner peace? Doesn't, don't you ask people to invite Jesus into my heart? Doesn't Jesus bring inner peace? Well, then how do you, how do you square that with Luke 12, verse 51? Just a couple chapters after this one. Here's what Jesus says. Do you think that I came to bring peace on earth? No. I tell you, I've come to bring division. And so, wait a second. The angels say they've come to bring peace on earth, but Jesus says, I've not come to bring peace on earth. Ha ha. We've got a contradiction, right? or Jesus is actually defining peace for us.
7:52 Jesus is saying that real peace is going to, if you let it into your life, it's going to disrupt your life. It's going to bring division. It's going to bring you at odds with culture to some degree. Jesus goes on and says, it's going to bring division between fathers and mothers and brothers and sisters. In other words, this peace is not a sedative. it's a new allegiance. So go back to the peace we crave. Political peace, circumstantial peace, inner peace. Ultimately we want those things because we think they will be enough. The non-Christian at some level is saying I have to create my own peace because life isn't secure. It's a dog-eat-dog world out there and so I'm going to cultivate it through my career and my money and my circumstances and my comfort.
8:46 Because nobody else is going to actually do it for me. I have to get it for myself. The problem is that you're never going to get peace that way because you're literally fighting for survival. It's literally the opposite of what peace is, to fight for survival. By the way, many Christians, or folks who call themselves Christians, at the end of the day, this is your story. You say, listen, I believe in God, but I don't really trust him. I believe in him. I think he's real. I just don't think he's going to be really good to me. Because look at how he's operated in my life in the past. And so you know what you do? You worry. Not only do you worry, what you do is you say, okay, well, maybe I need to perform more. Maybe I need to do good works. Maybe I need to try harder and be good. But here's the problem with that. Why don't you have pieces?
9:39 because you never know, have I been good enough? By the way, if you ever feel like you have been good enough, you end up kind of looking down at everybody else. because I'm good and you're not. And then ironically, then you're not good anymore. Or you feel like you're not good enough and you walk around with shame and guilt going, oh, I could be better, I'm not good enough.
10:00 Feeling guilty and ashamed. And so both places, whether you're a Christian or not a Christian, we're walking a tightrope of performance we're terrified of falling and because of that we have no peace and the first step of understanding of actually getting peace is to admit that you don't have it and the reason why you don't have it is because you're actually at war you're at war with yourself with the world with God but you're at war because everything that you're going for circumstances, politics, inner psychological peace, everything you're grabbing for is not going to work until you realize you're at war.
10:44 So if this piece grabbing doesn't work, then what does? All right, second point, the piece you need. It's not something that you can grab. It's not something that you can create. The piece that you need, I think, comes in two parts. I'm going to define it this way, history and army. First, this piece is historical. Remember we said in verse 1 that Luke does this sort of name dropping. He drops the name of Caesar Augustus. He drops the name of the governor of Syria. He drops the name that they had a census at this time. What's he doing? Here's what Luke is doing. He knew people were going to say about this event that this was all just a legend. It was all made up. And so what he's doing is he's fact-checking. There's a book by Richard Baucom called Jesus and His Eyewitnesses, and it has yet to be refuted where he makes the argument that the gospel writers put in people's names because you could actually now go and fact-check and say, hey, don't believe me, go to these people. That this actually happened.
11:52 there was a specific time place and people and it happened c.s lewis was a professor of myths He studied myths his whole life. And he said this, he said, I've looked at all of them. Whatever the gospels are, they're not myths because they're too specific. They have too many details for them to be sort of general mythic, the genre of myth. Because myths don't cite tax decrees and censuses. It's reportage. It's fact. Okay, you say, why does that matter? It matters this way. A metaphorical baby, if Jesus was just a metaphorical baby, it can give you warm, fuzzy feelings on a Christmas morning, but it can't help you when you're dying. A metaphorical manger gives you no comfort, gives you no peace in a cancer ward.
12:52 It doesn't. Only a real God who really actually entered into history, into creation. can actually do something that has the power to do something in your life. If this is just metaphor, folks, guys, if this is just a nice bedtime story to placate and make us feel better about ourselves, it doesn't work. It only works if it's history. And if it is history, if it actually happened, then that's when everything changes. That's the first step of actually getting this peace. Now, secondly,
13:54 back to this week's sermon. It's not just historical that this peace comes through an army. Look at verse 13 here, and it talks about this great heavenly host. This word host in Greek is the word stratia, which means army. It's a military term. In fact, this army is, it's just here, it's a great company. The word great company is the word plethos, which shows up in Revelation 5 to describe angels as well, where it says there's 10,000 by 10,000, which is a poetical way of saying there was millions and millions and millions of these.
14:37 And so this army, this military term means what you've been sold about whatever angels are, a sort of like white robe wearing, halo, harp strumming, you know, beatific, smiley face cherubs, that's not actually what an angel was. An angel was a warrior figure. So go back here in verse 13, and this word suddenly just pops. Suddenly, this army appears.
15:10 And so try to put yourself in the shoes of the shepherds at the time. They're sitting around. It's pitch black. There's no electricity, right? And suddenly the sky tears open. And they're blinded with the power and might of millions of swirling angelic beings. I mean, the fear, your heart's hammering, you can't breathe. You're like, this is how I die.
15:38 Because the skies have been ripped open. Power enough to unmake the world. and when this army comes, by the way, when any army ever invades, it's always war and judgment and death, and yet the craziest thing happens in this text.
15:59 Instead of that, what you find instead is this army doesn't attack. It's the only time in history an army invades to declare peace. It doesn't draw swords. It draws breath. to sing. What do they say? Glory to God in the highest heaven. Over and over and over again. In other words, God looks at the world. He sees all the brokenness. He sees all the darkness. He sees a world with no peace. He sees us grabbing and striving and not working. What does he do? He doesn't send a tank. he sends a song. He sends a baby. in 1992 during the Bosnian war, there was a mortar shell that hit a bread line in Sarajevo, killing 22 civilians.
16:54 It was horrible. It was horrific. Blood, rubble, everything. The next day, the principal cellist of the opera there went out into that mortar shell. he wore his tuxedo he took his cello he took a chair and he started playing and he played amidst the snipers and the rubble for 22 days, each day for each person who died. Why? Did it bring anybody back from the dead? No. Did it stop the war? No. No. So, it was an assertion to say that the beauty of song is more powerful than the brokenness around. it was a way to say that light one day will actually defeat darkness this angel song right here that's the cello in the ruins that is God inserting himself but not with swords but with songs into the darkness as Mark said earlier this is the darkest day of the year for us.
18:08 into this darkness God is saying it does not ultimately win. He inserts beauty into brokenness to tell us that it does not have the last word. That's the peace that you need. That's what you need. All right, last point then, fine. How do we get it? How do you get it? We have the history of it. We have the army behind it. But how do you actually get it personally?
18:36 1 Peter 1 verse 12 says that angels long to look at these things. Which if you think about it for just a second, angels live forever and ever and ever, and yet they witness all of history and they can't get enough of it. They long to look at the news of what's happening here, at the gospel, which is a bit convicting because the uncomfortable question we have to ask ourselves is if they can never get enough of it, why do we feel like we can? Why do we feel like it's not that big of a deal?
19:15 And I think the answer is this, is that we don't actually know what's being offered to us. The reason why we look for peace in all the other ways, in all the other places, is because we don't think the peace offered to us in this passage, in this text right here, is going to be enough.
19:36 And this is what I want to say to you. Folks, you can't just believe in Jesus. You need to believe into Jesus. Believe in Jesus is a cognitive, theoretical idea. But you have to actually believe into Jesus with your whole self. What do I mean by that? In the 1800s, there was a very famous tightrope walker who actually walked over the Niagara Falls back and forth multiple times. And this was so amazing. The crowds would gather and they would clap and they would praise him. He would carry weights, huge amounts of weights on his back. And they'd be like, wow, look at that guy. Look at him. Wow, that's amazing. One time, and this is apparent because I looked it up.
20:29 The story's there, but it's hard to know if this actually happened. But this is how the story goes. Apparently, one time, he looked at a man. After everybody was praising him, he says, hey, do you, sir, do you think that I could carry you on my back, back and forth across the Niagara Falls? And the man said, yes, of course I do. I just saw you carry twice my weight.
20:54 You know what he said? He said, hop on. And you know what the guy said? No way. Why? The reason why is this. because he believed in the tightrope walker, but he didn't believe into him. He believed about him, but he didn't believe into him. It's one thing to believe in Jesus. It's another thing to actually believe into him. You say, okay, what's the difference? You don't just watch Jesus. You hop onto his back. you don't just say that's great what you're doing out there wow wonderful you say carry me you don't live your life around him you live your life through him you actually step on his back ask yourself when was the last time you have done things that were scary there's long you're doing them because you're on the back of Jesus.
22:02 and no other reason. when's the last time you've actually looked at that To believe into him is more than just your mind. it's with your life every other religion, every modern belief out there. There's even secular versions of trust. Everybody says this, you're going to get peace through performance. You're going to get it by you walking on that tightrope. Don't fall off that way. Don't fall off this way. Just make it. Just do enough. Sleep enough. Eat enough. Work out. Do the job. Get the resume. Get the wife. Get the kids. Get the husband. get the relationship, whatever it is, get it. And then you'll get peace.
22:49 And the gospel says this, you can't get on that wire. If you get on that wire, you're gonna fall. Peace is not achieved, it's received. And you're not on that wire, Jesus is. So you go back to our text here in verse 14. It says, peace comes to who? To those whom his favor rests. favor. That means it's not you. It's what he gives. You don't go up to him. He comes down to you. the entire Christian story starts in a wooden manger it ends on a wooden cross it starts by Jesus finding no place to be born and it ends when he's taken to a place to die it starts in swaddling cloths it ends in burial clothes it starts with being rejected by the inn but it ends with being rejected by everybody else it starts Thank you.
23:46 by him coming to you, not you coming to him. He didn't come to you to show you how to walk on the wire. He came to walk on that wire for you. And he maintained that balance and he got that favor. And on that cross, he fell. And he fell so that when you and I fall, we don't fall into destruction, we fall into grace.
24:12 If you're on his back. if you let him actually carry you. That's why the angels are singing. They saw the whole story and they couldn't stay silent. And friends, you would sing like them too if you saw the whole story as well. If you don't just believe in Jesus, if you believe into Jesus, have you received this peace? Only if you realize that he walked on the wire for you Can you get off the tightrope of performance? Stop trying to live for peace. How do you do this? Let me just give you a couple applications. Number one, let Christmas be more than what you're letting it be in your life right now. Christmas at least means this. It means light breaking into darkness, giving you hope, which means a happy ending to our sad state. You can apply it to anything in your life right now.
25:06 Lost a job? Christmas. Lost your health? Christmas. lost hope, Christmas. In every possible problem, you can inject Christmas in there as the answer. Take your whole life in time. Your past no longer condemns you because your debt's been paid. Your future doesn't end in nothingness because death has been defeated too. and you're present now.
25:44 Your present doesn't overwhelm you because guess what? You have his favor. That's real peace, folks. That's it right there. Secondly, you can go tell others. You know why we have this account right now? Because the shepherds didn't just that night, let's not tell anybody. No, they told somebody. They must have told other people because we have it recorded here. When... this truth breaks into your life. You end up telling others. I think the problem with New Yorkers, as New Yorkers, a lot of times we work in expert culture. We think we have to be experts to tell other people. because that's what it means to know everything about it. But guess what? Shepherds did not know everything about everything. Shepherds, the reason why God reveals the most important moment in human history to shepherds is by doing so, he's showing us that we don't have to know everything about everything as well to tell other people.
26:45 We don't. who does God pick over and over and over in history? It's not the people who figured it all out. And that means you don't have to have it all figured out too. And by the way, this is how God always works. He always picks who people least expect. Sarah, right, was too old to have a son. David was too young to be king.
27:12 Moses denied God. Jonah ran away from God. Jacob wrestled with God. Those are all ways of saying it's not about knowing enough. And he picks those people because if he can use them, guess what? He can use you. no matter where you are on this. Because when you receive this peace, it's a sign. out in the world, you start singing.
27:40 Now, and by the way, no, I'm not saying, when I say you tell others, I'm not saying go be annoying about it. You know who people play their music on the subway all the time? I really wish they wouldn't. They're telling me their music. I don't want to know it. I want you to tell others, but I want you to tell others in the way. that they can hear it as song. So are you curious? do you care? The incarnation means at very least that salvation is physical. God cares about this world, so he's going to fix and remake it. Do you offer that to other people?
28:17 Will you be part of it? The purpose of salvation is not to escape this world. What you see with the incarnation the purpose of salvation is to recreate it and remake it. Which means the goal of life folks is not to escape and go to someplace nice and get away from it. If the purpose of salvation is redemption and renewal, then we should be going into the places that need it the most. Last time I checked, New York City has the most people per square mile in America, which means it has the most people, it has the most needs. This is where we should be. This is where we should be to love and serve. And so ask yourself, am I living this life out? Am I going and telling, like the song we just sang? All right, lastly, last thing to say is this. Those shepherds, they went back to shepherding. Their circumstances didn't change.
29:12 They still were cold. They still were poor. But they were different. How do I know that? Because I'm positive anytime they saw a bright star, after this moment, they saw those bright stars and they would be like, hey, that's bright. But not as bright as that night. no future, bad or good, will ever outshine for them now because they had a song in the dark. For the rest of their lives, whenever they saw anything else, they would not be enamored by it or disheartened by it. And they never got over it. The angels didn't get over it. The shepherds didn't get over it. what you need most in your life is not a change in your circumstances. You need a change of your heart and you can have that if you will let yourself be filled by the wonder.
30:06 and the awe and the peace of this moment. If you receive this peace, you move out. If you haven't yet, it's not too late. You can still get it. Let the wonder of Christmas fill your heart today. Let's pray. Heavenly Father,
30:30 thank you for, thank you for this small little snippet of the angel song, glory to God in the highest, on earth, peace. to those whom his favor rests. Father, this is the darkest part of our year. I pray that we will see that you've entered into it.
30:56 You bring beauty into the brokenness, the cello in the ruins. Help us to see that as good as these other things are, that we strive for, there is goodness in them. They're not good enough to give us peace, but we get peace through you. you bring ultimate real peace historically and through with an army not of swords but of song. move our hearts Help us to believe not just in you, but into you.
Machine translated from the source