Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached November 23, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
2:07 A lot going on, but we are in the middle of a series on joy. So let me ask you a quick question. What success in your life right now do you look to to bring joy? For some of you, it would be, if you don't have it yet, it would be maybe a promotion. For others of you, success would be maybe a doctor's note that says that the cancer is in remission. For the others of you, maybe it's a very specific number. If that number was in your bank account, that would relieve you of the cares of this world. And then therefore you would be much happier. But here's the thing. For every single one of us, we have a problem. And that's this.
2:54 Somehow, sorrow, suffering, takes away our joy. And so what I want to look at today is, I think, the hardest question when it comes to joy, and that's this. How can you have really joy? How do you actually get joy in the midst of sorrow and suffering? It's probably the biggest question Christianity has to answer. Which is, if there is a good God, why does he allow suffering? and hurt still in our lives. Because the truth is, is that suffering comes for everybody. The Welsh poet, Dylan Thomas, I didn't know this until I looked it up, but when he wrote his famous poem, it was during the time when his father was actually slowly dying from throat cancer. That's when he wrote about how, do not go gentle into that good night. Rage, rage against the dying of the light. Because that's what's human. It's to resist.
3:46 It's to rage. It's instinct to fight against suffering, to not let it win. But that's the problem. Because every success that we build, suffering steals. For every time that we actually get security, that we feel like we have enough, then sorrow shatters it. And so what I want to look at today is a question that I believe, no matter where you are on the spectrum of belief, whether you're a skeptic, believer, secular, religious, everyone's going to have to make an account for suffering in this world. How do you handle it? How will you get through it? What's the answer? It hits everybody. And if you look at our text here in verse 6, it says, David says, I will never be shaken. But then look at the very next verse. He says, that's when I was dismayed. See, every word of you has to do this.
4:38 You can have everything in a moment, verse 6, and then nothing dismay the next. What do you do when the bottom falls out? What do you do when it hits? I want to see three things in this text. Number one, how our answers for suffering don't work. Number two, the surprise of the real answer. And then number three, how do you actually practice it? I'll say it again. Very simple today. How do our answers to suffering, how does it not work? Number two, what is the surprise of the real answer? And then number three, how do you actually practice it? So first, how do our answers to suffering, to sorrow, how do they not work? Look at our text here. Verse one, let's just walk through the progression. This is a Psalm of David, and David starts thanking God. Why?
5:31 First, in verse one, it's because he's thankful for how low he was, but he was lifted up out of the depths in verse one. In part, he's thankful for how you brought me away from your enemies. You healed me. This is in verse 1. Let my enemies, you did not let my enemies gloat over me. And then verse 2, you healed me. So there was some sort of physical issue that he felt delivered from as well. And so in verse 4, it says that he starts singing God's praises. But then by verse 6, he acknowledges that when life started turning good, there was this overconfidence. It's when I felt secure, I said, I'll never be shaken. Notice he felt invincible because this is what happens when a good life starts happening. When things are good, we inevitably connect. The reason why good things are happening to me is because I'm doing something good.
6:26 And I believe there's both a religious and a secular way that we get overconfident in that kind of environment. And I want to look at both. because when tragedy strikes, that's when things kind of fall apart. And so let's look at the religious version first. Here's how the religious version goes, and I hear it all the time with people in the church. It goes like this. Hey, I pray. I go to church. I showed up here on Sunday. I tithe. I give my money. But then the diagnosis comes in. Then the job falls out. Then bad things happen. And here's what happens. We start saying, where are you, God? Why are you letting this happen? Why are you letting this actually hit me the way it happens? Don't you care? Where are you?
7:19 That's what ends up happening. If you have a religious understanding of our work with God, that I give him this and I should get that, it's a very transaction. You unknowingly are living a transactional life with God. when we struggle with this idea, because this is what happens. We struggle when good people get bad things and bad people get good things. Because we see that in life. All the time, we see this all the time. People who look like they're living good lives, bad things are happening to them. And people who we know are living bad lives, good things are happening to them. It doesn't seem fair to our moral ledger. It doesn't seem fair. this is why in the movie The Sound of Music what does Maria sing? she sings this line nothing comes from nothing nothing ever could so somewhere in my youth or childhood I must have done something good see that's karma that's not grace and it reveals how deeply we really believe that the moral universe at the end of the day should work out for us.
8:23 and so when suffering hits when that diagnosis comes that's when we start going, well, maybe, you know, what did I do wrong? Where's God? Why is he not here? I held up my end of the deal. Why is he not holding up his end of the deal? And that's where a lot of religious people, their faith shatters in that moment. Now, some of you right now are saying this. You're saying, well, that's why I don't believe. Some of you are saying, well, that's why I'm not religious because I'm not going to put all my eggs in that kind of basket. but there's a secular overconfidence too. Here's how it goes. It goes like this. Hey, there's no God. There's only this world. And so I'm going to eat kale. I'm going to optimize my portfolio. I'm going to do my best to have a good life here. And even though I know that ultimately it's going to go away, I'm going to do the best I can to keep the chaos out there at bay.
9:23 I'm going to optimize my life. But then what happens? You know what happens? The very same thing happens to the religious person. Eventually, that diagnosis comes. That job falls out. The pain and the suffering of life hits. And it's in that moment you realize you had a lot less control than you thought. It's in that moment that all of a sudden, that you go, then why did I do all this? You see, if matter is just motion, If there is no larger purpose or plan of reality out there, then whenever something is wrong, you have to say, well, no, it's not technically wrong, not in the grand scheme of things. It just is. Because who's to say what right and wrong is? Annie Dillard, the author, poignantly pointed this out. She wrote a book called Pilgrim at Tinker Creek, and here's what she did.
10:17 She moved into the woods in Virginia, and she was hoping to just start recording all the beauty and the wonder and all the great things that she would see in nature. And she sat down day after day and just recorded what she saw. You know what she saw? Death and violence. She talked about how she saw frogs sucked dry by water bugs. and mass chaos and destruction everywhere. And here's what she concluded. These are her words. Evolution loves death more than it loves you or me. We value this individual. we value the individual supremely and nature values him not a wit. So either this world is a monster or I myself am a freak. So look at her dilemma. Her dilemma is this. If there's no God, then you're outraged towards suffering and evil and violence.
11:14 She would say that you're actually a freak for actually thinking that there's right and wrong out there. in a world that basically is an indifferent universe. There is no larger reality out there. She says, that means you're a freak. But if you're not a freak, if actually you're right, that violence is wrong, if that's actually true, that means the world then is a monster and broken and needs to be redeemed. It's either one or the other. And her point actually is that actually, that means no one can escape the kind of question about, is there a God or not? Everybody has to kind of go through that question. That you can't actually escape it. So go back to David in our text again. Here he is. He's pointing out whether you're religious or you're secular. If your security is built on performance, if it's built on competence, if it's built on what you offer to God, you're vulnerable for being shaken because it's when I felt secure, verse 6.
12:14 I said I will never be shaken. In other words, when you most think that you can't be shaken, that's where you're most likely to actually be shaken. Because when the sorrows show up, when the suffering hurts, whether you're sort of the calculating religious karma type person or the more secular optimizer, you know, basically protect your life with all the other things around you, both of those things don't work out in the end. And so the question asks, what will? What will provide for us? What will hold up? All right, that's point one. Point two, then, what is the real answer? What's the surprising real answer? When the bottom falls out, what will actually work? And I know what some of you are already thinking right now. Some of you go, I know what's going to happen. Michael's a pastor. He's going to get up here and say, have faith. Just love God a little bit more. That if you have faith today, the pain will go away. Yes, I made up that rhyme. Have faith today, the pain goes away.
13:13 You think that? And actually, if you read the text, it looks like that's what David is promising. Look at, go to verse 5. In verse 5, it says, sing the praises, right? Praise his holy name. That's verse 4. And then, for his anger lasts only a moment, but his favor lasts a lifetime. Ah. Or look at verse 11. You turned my willing into dancing. You removed my sackcloth and clothed me with joy. See, if you're a skeptic right now, you either think that's sort of faux sentimentality or at worst, it's some sort of propaganda.
13:47 because what it looks like it's saying is it's saying, hey, don't worry, just have faith and God's going to, it's all going to work out in the end. Now, if you're a believer, here's what you're saying right now. You're saying, okay, that's nice. It's all great. But guess what? I'm still willing right now. I'm still suffering right now God's promising all this joy and stuff but what about my life right now
14:12 That's what a lot of religious people say. Where's my dancing? Where's my joy? And so this is where I feel like I need to be very clear because there is a tendency for people to think that what Christianity is promising is that if you believe in Jesus, you won't suffer. That is not true. That is what I'm here to tell you. that Christianity does not say if you just believe in Jesus, you'll never weep. But there is this view out there. People say if you just pray to God enough, if you just love God enough, then don't worry. God's going to bring blessing into your life. that's what people say but I'm here to tell you this loved ones still die of cancer even if you pray for them I happen to know that I'm here to tell you that sometimes the job does not come back sometimes you don't get the good news about the remission sometimes the marriage never happens or if it did happen and it's not as good as you thought it was going to be.
15:24 Right? Suffering still hits. And this text is saying, sorry, this text is not saying, the Bible is not saying that if you just believed in God enough, your life will go well. As if the joy comes in the morning and some sort of magic pill. I love magic. I do, I try to do magic tricks. There's a friend of mine who doesn't live in New York. Their kids, whenever I see them, they want me to do a magic trick. They call me Magic Mike. I say, I told them, don't say that. You really shouldn't say that. I like magic. But people are like, hey, this is magic.
16:04 but in fact the truth the truth is who believed in God the most in the Bible? Moses, right? Moses, God believed, Moses believed in God. What happened to him? Wandered around for decades, wasn't called until his 80s. Daniel loved God, right? Loved God, thrown in the lion's den. Jesus perfectly loved God, perfectly prayed, perfectly obeyed, perfectly was killed and executed.
17:04 And I have to keep telling myself this. If Jesus wasn't actually spared sorrow, why do we think we will be? Let that just sink in for a second. If Jesus wasn't spared sorrow, what makes us think that we will be? And so here's the question. If verse 5 isn't promising that faith makes the pain go away, then what is it promising? I'm going to tell you a story that I think helped me with this text. in 1851 there was a missionary and people on this boat with him they were shipwrecked and the mission didn't win the mission failed his companions died one by one he was the last one to live and he eventually there was a party that went out looking for him and they found everybody dead and they found his journal the last entry in his journal was actually a scripture passage from Psalm 3410.
18:03 I'm going to read it to you. Young lions do lack and suffer hunger, but they that seek the Lord shall not lack any good thing. Now this man was dying of starvation, was dying from exposure. He watched all of his friends die as well. And yet, how did he have the presence in mind to say, though I hunger, I lack no good thing. and actually that was the last verse the last actual line just beneath that in a shaky malnourished hand wrote these final words I am overwhelmed with a sense of the goodness of God now how the heck did he write that I want to know how could he say I am overwhelmed by the goodness of God as he's dying a very painful death.
18:58 because yes, you know, when things are going good, God must be good. When circumstances of life are good, it's easy to actually say God is good, but this man had something. He had someone. He had a secret that starvation couldn't steal, that death couldn't touch, and I think it's the surprise of the real answer. It's a way to access the goodness of God, to get God and the goodness of God apart from our circumstances. And I think that's what these verses are about. Because what the verses are basically saying is rejoicing in the Lord isn't actually found in the absence of sorrow. It's actually found through its presence, through the presence of sorrow.
19:50 That rejoicing in the Lord isn't found in the absence of sorrow. Real joy is found through them. So last point, how do we become people that actually can say, I am overwhelmed by the goodness of God, despite our circumstances? That's the question I want to ask. Because I think David in our text here gives us one practice, but three parts. Repeat, recall, rejoice. Repeat, recall, rejoice. Let me quickly go through them. First, repeat. Look at, again, go back to our text here. David keeps repeating himself. Verse 1, I cried for help. Verse 2, I cried for mercy. Sorry, verse 2, he says, I cried for help. Verse 8, he says, I cried for mercy. He says that you lifted me up in verse 1, but then you brought me up in verse 3. Not once, not twice, 10 times does the word Lord show up here.
20:44 He keeps repeating, Lord, Lord, Lord. Six times the word exalted or praise shows up. Why is he repeating? he's repeating because repetition is the way to get truth deeper into your life. I'll say it again. Repetition drives truth deeper. He says, weeping stays for the night, but joy comes in the morning in verse 5. And then verse 11, he turned my wailing into dancing and clothed me in joy. He's repeating these statements to drill them down further into his heart. I watched my father do this. The last time that he was cognizant, before he died in the hospital, I sat with him. You know what he said? He said, Michael, let's say the Lord's Prayer together.
21:36 Let's say the Apostles' Creed. Let's read some Psalms together. What was he doing? At the end of his life, he was pushing further into his heart. He was repeating the truths that animated his life. Jesus did the same thing. What did he do on the cross? The last thing he said was, my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? That's actually a quote from Psalm 22. He could only have said that in his moment of agony and hardship because he had repeated that same phrase over and over and over again in his heart before. you and I will only be able to handle the agony and hurt and suffering and sorrow of this world if we've repeated before that time and during those times the truths that animate our lives. So are you repeating?
22:30 Are you actually saying what the psalmist here says? Because here's the truth. You need to study scripture. You have to live it. You have to breathe it. You have to repeat it over and over and over again into your life so that when suffering hits, what you bleed are these statements.
22:52 That's how you handle suffering. That's repeat. Now, secondly, recall. You say, well, isn't recalling repeating the same thing? Not exactly. You can repeat something rotely like a puppet, like a parrot over and over and over again. It doesn't mean anything. You have to recall it. It has to actually mean something to you. David in verse five says, his anger only lasts for a moment. he's recalling not just God's promises but actually how God actually has treated him in the past. he's going somewhere in his sense experience and saying I know that that's what he does for me I know that his anger will only be for a moment now Now, that forces us to say, well, how do we know? see David had his experiences we have something better we have the cross because what does the cross do the cross tells us that the reason that God's anger only lasts for a moment.
23:48 is because Jesus took that anger. The valid anger that you actually, you want God, by the way, to be angry at evil and suffering. The problem is when we do it ourselves, how does he not then be angry at us? And the Christian answer is that because it falls on Jesus. the only reason that we can say and recall that his anger only lasts for a moment is because his anger is poured out on Jesus not on us so go back to David right he has this overconfidence we have overconfidence we have self-centeredness that's transferred to Jesus and so David didn't slip into the pit in verse 9 because Jesus goes into that pit sister abi determined by settler Taipei Sha взовой And if you're secular, what you're going to do is, since sorrow and suffering takes away your joy, you're just going to have to run away from everything that hurts.
25:11 But Christians have this crazy ability to actually have joy through sorrow. If you go to 2 Corinthians 4, verse 17, this is what Paul says. He says, our afflictions are producing joy. Sorry, our afflictions are producing for us an eternal weight of glory. An eternal weight of glory. Now that's a huge, you go, wait, how can your suffering and afflictions produce an eternal weight of glory? We think sorrow and joy are like oil and water. They can't go together. But Paul says, actually, the sorrow and suffering brings joy. Which sounds crazy. I'm going to admit it. It sounds crazy. How is it possible? Recall, recall what happened in John chapter 2. Jesus at the wedding of Cana. What did he do there? He turned water into wine. It's his first miracle.
26:04 And in rabbinic tradition, your first miracle, your first of anything, whether it's your teaching or preaching, that actually sets the tone, the stage for the rest of your ministry. And so was Jesus' first statement, was it some teaching, was it some preaching? No, his first thing that he ever did was taking a party and making it a better party.
26:28 What Jesus was doing in that moment was saying, you know what? I've come to take what you think is a party and I've come to make it a better party. That's what I'm about. That's what I'm here for. And yet go back to that text again. And what you see is Jesus has this conversation with his mother where he says to his mom, he goes, my hour hasn't come yet. And if you study the book of John, as you repeat it in your life, you will see the word hour shows up over and over and over again in John. And the word hour is always a reference to Jesus's death. And so when he's saying my hour hasn't come, he's thinking about his death. Now, why is Jesus at a wedding thinking about death? That's a little awkward and weird. and here's the profound truth. We say this at Redeemer all the time. The reason why he was thinking about his death at a wedding was when everybody else was sipping joy.
27:28 Jesus, in the midst of all this joy, was sipping the coming sorrow so that you and I, when we're sitting in sorrow, can sip the coming joy. That's what's going on there. Jesus Christ was in this beautiful space of joy But he was sipping the coming sorrow So that we can sit in all the sorrows that we're in right now And know That joy comes in the morning It really does come in the morning In the Garden of Gethsemane He stared down the cup of God's justice And yet he drank it The Christian faith allows us to say I don't know why bad things are happening, but it can't be that God doesn't love us because the ultimate bad thing happened to Jesus and he turned the ultimate bad into good. And if he can do that in Jesus's life, then he can, guess what? He can do it in my life too. That's what we have as a resource. That's how your sorrow doesn't give, doesn't just give way to joy. It actually brings joy. So last thing, rejoice. How do we practice rejoicing? In the Lord.
28:38 how does it come? last thing I'll say just last example in Tolkien the Lord of the Rings there's this beautiful scene where Pippin looks into Gandalf's eyes and this is what he says he says at first he only saw lines of care and sorrow though as he looked more intently he perceived that under all there was this great joy a fountain of mirth enough to set a kingdom laughing were it to gush forth I love that line because I actually think that's the hope for every Christian now. is that you have lines of sorrow.
29:15 They're on our faces. Just live long enough and those lines show up. But there can be a fountain of mirth and joy. that can well up and be there because joy comes in the morning. And I know a lot of you still feel like it's 3 a.m. at night. Dawn doesn't look like it's ever coming. The grief is crashing. but if you're in Christ, this is saying joy and mirth and laughter and love is underneath all of that and will be there. and the resurrection, again, won't take away the hurt. It won't take away the deep pain. That's still going to be there, But what the resurrection shows us is that hope dwells in the depths of our hearts. because of what Jesus did for us, and now there's no obstacle to that joy. He sipped the sorrow so that you and I can drink the joy, and so if you're not a Christian here, I want you to ask, where are you going to get that joy in the midst of sorrow?
30:13 But if you are a Christian, don't have that transactional relationship that, oh, I did this and then that. No, instead, come to him and say, I don't always know why you're letting this happen, but I know that you've taken the ultimate bad and made it good in Jesus' life, and therefore you can take whatever's bad in my life and make it good too.
30:35 And we rest in that. And we know that. that hope allows us to dance even now even in the midst of our sorrow weep stays for the night but joy comes in the morning repeat, recall, rejoice let's pray Heavenly Father thank you for this good word thank you for what you're doing in our life this is hard We admit that the world doesn't have a good answer. that we could try to optimize our lives and yet sorrow still takes away and religion just tries to earn it. But Father, help us to see that you were not distant from our pain and sorrow. You entered into it. You did something about it. you're not distant from it. Help us, Father, to realize that we can have not just joy in the city as we've been talking about all the past couple months, that we can actually have joy, not just from sorrow, we can actually have joy in the midst of sorrow.
31:44 Turn us all into individuals that can say that we're overwhelmed by the goodness of God. Move in our hearts, we pray these things in your name.
Machine translated from the source